dd
aakoto
CaseStuRubrics.docxCase Study on Moral Status - Rubric
Rubric Criteria
Collapse All Rubric CriteriaCollapse All
Christian View of the Nature of Human Persons and Compatible Theory of Moral Status
60 points
Criteria Description
Christian View of the Nature of Human Persons and Compatible Theory of Moral Status
5. Excellent
60 points
Explanation of the Christian view of the nature of human persons and the theory of moral status that it is compatible with is clear, thorough, and explained with a deep understanding of the relationship to intrinsic human value and dignity. Explanation is supported by topic study materials.
Determination of Moral Status
40 points
Criteria Description
Determination of Moral Status
5. Excellent
40 points
The theory or theories that are used by each person to determine the moral status of the fetus is explained clearly and draws insightful relevant conclusions. Rationale for choices made is clearly supported by topic study materials and case study examples.
Recommendation for Action
40 points
Criteria Description
Recommendation for Action
5. Excellent
40 points
Explanation of how the theory determines or influences each of their recommendations for action is clear, insightful, and demonstrates a deep understanding of the theory and its impact on recommendation for action. Explanation is supported by topic study materials.
Personal Response to Case Study
40 points
Criteria Description
Personal Response to Case Study
5. Excellent
40 points
Evaluation of which theory is preferable within personal practice along with how that theory would influence personal recommendations for action is clear, relevant, and insightful.
Organization, Effectiveness, and Format
10 points
Criteria Description
Organization, Effectiveness, and Format
5. Excellent
10 points
Writer is clearly in command of standard, written, academic English.
Documentation of Sources
10 points
Criteria Description
Documentation of Sources (citations, footnotes, references, bibliography, etc., as appropriate to assignment and style)
5. Excellent
10 points
Sources are completely and correctly documented, as appropriate to assignment and style, and format is free of error.
