Help with HW

Rubric for Case Study Presentation

100 points

Criteria Full Credit Partial Credit No Credit

Presentation Organization & Introduction 5 pts

5 points Clear title, complete author information, and concise introduction that establishes relevance of the case

3 points Title and author information present but introduction lacks clarity or fails to establish relevance of the case

0 points No clear title, missing author information, and no introduction; relevance of the case is not established

Surgical Procedure & Description 5 pts

5 points Accurate and thorough description of the procedure including purpose and key anatomical considerations

3 points Procedure described but lacks accuracy or omits purpose or key anatomical considerations

0 points Procedure is not described or description is inaccurate; purpose and anatomical considerations omitted

Coexisting Disease & Pathophysiology 10 pts

10 points In-depth, accurate explanation of disease process and relevance to anesthesia care

5 points Describes the coexisting disease process but lacks depth, accuracy, or clear relevance to anesthesia care

0 points Presentation does not describe the coexisting disease process or relevance to anesthesia care

Preoperative Assessment 10 pts

10 points Includes focused history, physical exam, ASA classification, and disease-specific considerations

5 points Preoperative assessment present but lacks focused history, physical exam, ASA classification, or disease-specific considerations

0 points No preoperative assessment provided or critical components missing

Medications & Anesthetic Implications 10 pts

10 points Common medications discussed with clear anesthetic implications and perioperative relevance

5 points Common medications discussed but anesthetic implications and perioperative relevance lack clarity or detail

0 points Medications not addressed or anesthetic implications not discussed

Labs & Diagnostic Testing 5 pts

5 points Appropriate labs and diagnostics identified with rationale

3 points Labs and diagnostics identified but rationale is unclear or incomplete

0 points Labs and diagnostics not identified or rationale not provided

Anesthetic Plan 15 pts 15 points 8 points 0 points

Criteria Full Credit Partial Credit No Credit

Detailed and appropriate plan including anesthesia type, induction, maintenance, emergence, airway plan with backup, medication selection with doses, and PONV/awareness considerations. Include an anesthetic Plan B.

Plan addresses some components but lacks detail or omits one to two key elements such as anesthesia type, induction, maintenance, emergence, airway plan with backup, medication selection with doses, or PONV/awareness considerations. Failed to include an anesthetic Plan B.

Plan is missing or omits multiple critical components such as anesthesia type, induction, maintenance, emergence, airway plan with backup, medication selection with doses, or PONV/awareness considerations

Intraoperative Management 10 pts

10 points Includes monitoring and equipment, fluid management, ventilation strategy, positioning with risks and mitigation, and anticipated intraoperative events

5 points Intraoperative management addressed but lacks detail in monitoring and equipment, fluid management, ventilation strategy, positioning with risks and mitigation, or anticipated intraoperative events

0 points Intraoperative management not addressed or major components missing

Emergence & Extubation Plan 5 pts

5 points Clear, patient-specific plan with appropriate criteria and considerations

3 points Emergence and extubation plan present but not patient-specific or lacks appropriate criteria and considerations

0 points No emergence or extubation plan provided

Postoperative Management 5 pts

5 points Appropriate PACU/ICU plan including monitoring, pain management, and complications

3 points PACU/ICU plan present but lacks appropriate monitoring, pain management, or attention to complications

0 points Postoperative plan not addressed

Integration of Anesthetic Implications 5 pts

5 points Demonstrates connection between pathophysiology, surgical procedure, and anesthesia management using evidence-based reasoning

3 points Some connection demonstrated between pathophysiology, surgical procedure, and anesthesia management but lacks evidence- based reasoning

0 points No connection demonstrated between pathophysiology, surgical procedure, and anesthesia management

Presentation Quality 5 pts

5 points 3 points Some slides have visual aids or some slides are overloaded with

0 points

Criteria Full Credit Partial Credit No Credit

Clear, organized slides with effective visuals and professional delivery, 10 slide minimum met.

wording; delivery is partially professional

No visual aids or slides overloaded with words; delivery is unprofessional

Summary & Conclusion 5 pts

5 points Concise and relevant synthesis of key learning points

3 points Presentation summarizes discussion but lacks sufficient detail or relevance to key learning points

0 points Presentation does not provide a summary or conclusion

References 5 pts 5 points Correct AMA formatting with appropriate and current sources; images cited appropriately

3 points Insufficient citations in presentation, improper AMA formatting, outdated sources, or images not cited

0 points No reference slide