Case Presentation

Case Presentation Scoring Guide

Criteria

Non-performance

Basic

Proficient

Distinguished

Identify a professional ethical code used to examine ethical issues in human services case studies. 16%

Does not identify a professional ethical code used to examine ethical issues in human services case studies.

Identifies a professional ethical code used to examine ethical issues in human services case studies, but the code is inappropriate or is inadequately identified.

Identifies a professional ethical code used to examine ethical issues in human services case studies.

Identifies a professional ethical code used to examine ethical issues in human services case studies. Cites the code using APA style and formatting.

Introduce the situations described in human services case studies involving ethical issues. 14%

Does not introduce the situations described in human services case studies involving ethical issues.

Introduces the situations described in human services case studies involving ethical issues, but the introduction is incomplete or otherwise flawed.

Introduces the situations described in human services case studies involving ethical issues.

Introduces the situations described in human services case studies involving ethical issues. Explains the ethical issues involved.

Describe the organizations and human services populations involved in case studies involving ethical issues. 14%

Does not describe the organizations and human services populations involved in case studies involving ethical issues.

Describes the organizations and human services populations involved in case studies involving ethical issues, but the description is incomplete or otherwise flawed.

Describes the organizations and human services populations involved in case studies involving ethical issues.

Describes the organizations and human services populations involved in case studies involving ethical issues. Specifies cultural issues related to the populations.

Analyze the ethical issues involved in human services case studies at both the macro and micro levels. 14%

Does not analyze the ethical issues involved in human services case studies at both the macro and micro levels.

Analyzes the ethical issues involved in human services case studies at either the macro level or the micro level but not at both, or the analyses are incomplete or otherwise flawed.

Analyzes the ethical issues involved in human services case studies at both the macro and micro levels.

Analyzes the ethical issues involved in human services case studies at both the macro and micro levels. Identifies how the macro and micro levels influence one another.

Analyze the policies, laws, and ethical guidelines that influenced decision making in human services case studies. 14%

Does not analyze the policies, laws, and ethical guidelines that influenced decision making in human services case studies.

Analyzes the policies, laws, and ethical guidelines that influenced decision making in human services case studies, but the analysis is incomplete, inaccurate, or otherwise flawed.

Analyzes the policies, laws, and ethical guidelines that influenced decision making in human services case studies.

Analyzes the policies, laws, and ethical guidelines that influenced decision making in human services case studies. Cites the policies, laws, and guidelines using APA style and formatting.

Analyze the ethical decision-making process in a human services case study, considering how personal desire and feelings intersect with ethical obligations. 14%

Does not analyze the ethical decision-making process in a human services case study, considering how personal desire and feelings intersect with ethical obligations.

Analyzes the ethical decision-making process in a human services case study, considering how personal desire and feelings intersect with ethical obligations. The analysis is incomplete or otherwise flawed.

Analyzes the ethical decision-making process in a human services case study, considering how personal desire and feelings intersect with ethical obligations.

Analyzes the ethical decision-making process in a human services case study, considering how personal desire and feelings intersect with ethical obligations. Identifies a model used for the decision-making process.

Write in a manner consistent with the expectations of the human services profession. 14%

Does not write in a manner consistent with the expectations of the human services profession.

Writes in a manner consistent with the expectations of the human services profession but with frequent errors and lapses.

Writes in a manner consistent with the expectations of the human services profession.

Writes in a manner consistent with the expectations of the human services profession. Uses APA style and formatting for all in-text citations and references.