ESSAY : "Reel Life"

profileBobo
CasablancaandtheRomanceofPropaganda.pdf

2/21/2014 Bright Lights Film Journal :: Casablanca

http://brightlightsfilm.com/55/casablanca.php#.Uwenf_RdVod 1/10

60

TANFER EMIN TUNC

Casablanca The Romance of Propaganda

"Casablanca provides twenty-first-century Americans with an oasis of hope in a desert of arbitrary cruelty and senseless violence."

As  we  approach  the  sixty-­fifth anniversary  of  Casablanca  (1942),  it  is clear  that  the  elements  that  made  the film  an  enduring  international  classic —  an  A-­list  cast  in  a  riveting  love

story;;  an  exotic,  glamorous  setting;;  melodramatic  and  heroic  sacrifices;;  sharp,  noir dialogue;;  and  the  triumph  of  idealism  over  cynicism  in  a  "world  gone  mad"  —  are  still capturing  our  imagination.  It  is  one  of  those  rare  films  from  Hollywood's  Golden  Age which  has  managed  to  transcend  its  era  to  entertain  generations  of  moviegoers  for  nearly three-­quarters  of  a  century.  However,  if  we  look  beyond  the  nostalgia  and  the  sentimental theme  of  lost  love  and  redemption,  we  see  that  Casablanca  actually  presents  a  complex and  intricate  political  and  social  commentary  on  the  early  days  of  World  War  II.  The product  of  a  decade  when  studios  were  routinely  producing  "a  movie  a  week," Casablanca  surpasses  its  humble  origins  as  "just  another  Warner  Brothers'  picture"  by exploiting  wartime  patriotism  and  the  traditional  "American  values"  of  freedom,  liberty, and  equality  to  shape  audiences'  perception  of  the  war.  In  the  most  basic  sense, Casablanca  was  an  anti-­fascist  propaganda  vehicle  which  was  designed  to  support  U.S. participation  in  the  Allied  Forces'  struggle  for  global  justice  and  democracy  at  a  time when  most  Americans  believed  that  U.S.  foreign  policy  should  have  promoted isolationism  and  neutrality.

Hollywood  and  the  Home  Front

Although  World  War  II  began  on  September  1,  1939,  as  late  as  the  beginning  of December  1941,  the  time  at  which  Casablanca  is  set,  most  Americans  believed  that  the United  States  "should  stay  out  of  that  phony  war  in  Europe."  In  fact,  a  Gallup  Poll  taken during  the  first  year  of  the  war  indicated  that  an  overwhelming  ninety-­six  percent  of  all Americans  wanted  the  country  to  remain  neutral. 1  However,  by  the  time  Casablanca premiered  in  November  1942,  the  bombing  of  Pearl  Harbor  had  already  occurred,  and  the United  States  had  been  at  war  for  almost  a  year.  Nevertheless,  many  Americans continued  to  support  an  isolationist  foreign  policy,  and  were  uneasy  about  U.S. participation  in  a  war  that  was  thousands  of  miles  away.  To  counteract  this  negative public  sentiment  towards  American  military  participation  in  WWII,  the  Department  of War  established  a  "War  Films"  division,  and  hired  filmmakers  John  Ford,  Frank  Capra, and  Casablanca's  screenwriters,  Julius  and  Philip  Epstein,  to  travel  to  Washington,  D.C. to  create  a  series  of  seven  American  war  propaganda  films,  grouped  under  the  umbrella title  of  Why  We  Fight.  Warner  Brothers  also  produced  some  six  hundred  training  and propaganda  films  under  the  supervision  of  Owen  Crump,  a  member  of  the  studio's  shorts department. 2

Between  1942  and  1945,  Hollywood  released  1,700  features,  500  of  which  dealt  directly with  war-­related  material.  The  U.S.  government  took  an  active  roll  in  the  screening  (and

2/21/2014 Bright Lights Film Journal :: Casablanca

http://brightlightsfilm.com/55/casablanca.php#.Uwenf_RdVod 2/10

of  course  the  censorship)  of  these  films  through  its  Office  of  War  Information,  and  went as  far  as  creating  a  production  rubric  which  the  studios  were  compelled  to  follow.  This rubric  included  a  "suggested"  list  of  six  feature  film  themes  which  would  "benefit American  morale."  Washington  suggested  producing  films  that  would:  glorify  the "American  way  of  life;;"  "depict  the  enemy  and  their  philosophy;;"  "reflect  well  on  our allies;;"  "portray  the  industrial  war  effort  at  home;;"  "illustrate  what  individuals  could  do on  the  home  front  to  support  the  war  effort,"  and  show  "our  fighting  forces  at  work."3  As intended,  the  films  produced  under  these  guidelines  (Casablanca  included)  not  only provided  the  masses  with  popular  entertainment  but  also  reinforced  the  nation's  support for  the  Allied  war  effort.

The  United  Nations  on  the  Silver  Screen

In  an  attempt  to  ensure  its  successful  approval  by  the  Hollywood  censorship  system  (i.e., the  Bureau  of  Motion  Pictures),  producer  Hal  Wallis,  who  was  hired  by  Warner  Brothers to  oversee  the  project,  assigned  Casablanca  one  of  these  prescribed  themes:  "III  B (United  Nations  —  Conquered  Nations)  Drama."  The  secondary,  or  "minor,"  theme  was officially  declared  "II  C  3  (Enemy  —  Military)  Drama."  Specifically,  Casablanca  was designed  to  illustrate  "that  personal  desires  must  be  subordinated  to  the  task  of  defeating fascism"  (this  theme,  of  course,  was  embodied  in  the  character  of  Richard,  or  "Rick" Blaine,  which  was  played  by  Humphrey  Bogart).  With  the  assistance  of  Howard  Koch, the  Epstein  brothers  translated  this  patriotic  duty  onto  the  screen  by  "graphically illustrating  the  chaos  and  misery  which  fascism  and  the  war  had  brought."4  The  United States  served  as  a  foil  to  the  evils  of  fascism,  and  was  portrayed  as  a  virtuous  "safe  haven for  the  oppressed  and  homeless"  —  a  nation  of  fearless  refuge  that  anti-­Nazi  Germans, such  as  Casablanca's  Leuchtegs,  could  honor  with  a  champagne  toast.

Casablanca's  casting  reflected  the  Warner  Brothers'  sensitivity  to  the  social  and  political landscape  of  the  war  (after  all,  Jack  Warner  was  a  colonel  in  the  U.S.  Army).  The  cast was  a  utopia  of  international  understanding  (or  perhaps  a  microcosm  of  the  "United Nations")  within  a  modest  budget.  The  actors  represented  a  wide-­range  of  nations  —  all of  which,  not  so  surprisingly  —  were  major  players  in  the  war:  Humphrey  Bogart  was American,  Ingrid  Bergman  was  Swedish,  Conrad  Veidt  was  German,  Paul  Heinreid  was Austrian,  and  Claude  Rains  and  Sydney  Greenstreet  were  British.  The  minor  roles  were also  played  by  a  who's  who  of  international  stars.  Yvonne,  Rick's  rejected  lover,  was portrayed  by  Madeleine  LeBeau,  a  nineteen-­year-­old  French  refugee.  She  was  one  of  a number  of  French  characters  who  won  the  hearts  of  the  viewing  audience  in  the  patriotic Marseillaise  scene.  The  pickpocket,  also  known  as  the  "Dark  European"  was appropriately  portrayed  by  the  "sinister"  German,  Curt  Bois.  Canadian  John  Qualen depicted  Berger,  Victor  Laszlo's  Resistance  contact  in  Casablanca.  His  role  was especially  important  since  it  personified  the  cooperation  between  the  Allies  and  Nazi Refugees. 5

The  staff  at  Rick's  café  was  not  immune  to  the  international  spell  cast  by  the  Epstein Brothers.  The  cabaret  singer,  played  by  Corinna  Mura,  represented  one  of  the  many "Latin"  characters  featured  in  Hollywood's  wartime  vehicles,  which  were  designed  to appeal  to  the  foreign  markets  opening  up  south  of  the  border.  The  role  of  Carl,  the  waiter, was  played  by  another  refugee  from  Hitler's  Europe,  S.  Z.  Sakall.  Sascha,  Carl's  comedic bartender-­sidekick,  was  Leonid  Kinsky,  a  refugee  from  the  Russian  Revolution.  Rick's doorman  and  bodyguard  Abdul  was  played  by  Dan  Seymour,  who  was  an  Arab.  For  Jan

2/21/2014 Bright Lights Film Journal :: Casablanca

http://brightlightsfilm.com/55/casablanca.php#.Uwenf_RdVod 3/10

and  Annina  Brandel,  the  young  Bulgarian  couple  whose  plight  spurred  Rick  into  heroic action,  producer  Hal  Wallis  chose  Helmut  Dantine  and  Joy  Page.  Dantine,  an  Austrian, was  yet  another  Nazi  refugee,  while  Page  was  Jack  Warner's  stepdaughter.  The  one  (and unfortunately  only)  Black  actor  in  the  film  was  Dooley  Wilson,  who  performed  the  role of  Sam  the  piano  player  (above).  A  one-­dimensional  character  who  was  never  fully developed,  his  main  purpose  was  to  entertain  the  café  patrons,  and  serve  as  Rick's confidante. 6

Casablanca  as  Diasporic  Purgatory Stylistically,  Casablanca  employed  many  of  the  elements  that  characterized  the  genre  of film  noir,  or  "black  film."  This  cinematic  approach,  which  ironically  originated  in Weimar,  Germany  in  the  1930s,  was  not  employed  in  the  United  States  on  a  mainstream basis  until  the  early  1940s  (Bogart's  most  famous  film  noir  is,  arguably,  The  Maltese Falcon,  which  was  released  in  1941).  Concentrating  on  human  depravity,  perversion, manipulative/omnipotent  heterosexuality,  failure,  despair,  disillusionment,  and  the "forbidden,"  film  noir  also  implied  a  certain  cinematic  style:  the  use  of  light  and  shadow, nervous,  rapid  pacing,  nightmare  sequences,  flashbacks,  unwavering,  hard-­boiled authority  figures,  and  "a  seedy,  urban  landscape  [to  portray]  a  world  gone  wrong." 7  By opening  Casablanca  with  a  map  of  the  "Dark  Continent"  of  Africa,  director  Michael Curtiz  (who  himself  was  in  the  process  of  smuggling  family  members  out  of  Hungary) established  the  physical  and  psychological  noir  setting  of  the  entire  film  —  a  chaotic  and dangerous  locale  inhabited  by  a  people  without  hope  —  a  generation  of  refugees  who were  forced  by  the  Nazis  onto  a  trail  of  despair. 8  This  treacherous  journey,  as  we  are  told, usually  began  in  Paris.  The  next  stop  (via  train)  was  Marseilles,  then  across  the Mediterranean  to  Oran,  Algeria,  where  the  unfortunate  refugees  could  travel  by  train, plane  or  foot  to  Casablanca.  There,  they  would  wait  in  tenuous  limbo,  until  the  day  came when  they  finally  secured  the  exit  visas  necessary  for  travel  to  Lisbon.  Once  in  Portugal, these  refugees,  like  so  many  other  immigrants  before  them,  could  venture  to  the "democracy  and  freedom  of  the  Americas"  (i.e.,  the  United  States)  —  a  haven,  and  a heaven,  from  the  cruelty  and  death  of  fascist  Europe.

Unfortunately,  for  every  refugee  who  reached  the  shores  of  America,  there  were countless  others  stranded  in  Casablanca:  a  city  of  Nazi-­Vichy  intimidation,  corruption, and  control.  French  North  Africa  was  clearly  a  part  of  the  world  where  justice  was arbitrary,  and  the  "American  Dream"  was  the  stuff  of  fairy  tales.  In  Casablanca,  innocent bystanders  frequently  became  the  victims  of  senseless  crimes.  Random  German  raids always  concluded  with  a  "round  up  of  the  usual  suspects;;"  human  vultures  routinely  pick-­ pocketed  refugees  right  after  warning  them  of  the  high  incidence  of  crime.  In  this  desert city,  human  trafficking  was  a  way  of  life,  and  Rick's  Café  Américain,  with  its  tense  and smoky  atmosphere,  was  the  marketplace  where  individuals  could  be  bought  and  sold through  this  lucrative  refugee  trade.  In  Casablanca,  men  and  women  were  commodities —  unwilling  participants  in  a  perverse  form  of  physical  and  spiritual  slavery.  It  was  a locale  where  the  reversal  of  fortune  was  the  norm,  a  "Twilight  Zone"  of  morality  where normally  decent  people  routinely  accepted  menial  positions  and  sold  their  most  treasured belongings  (including  their  bodies)  just  to  survive.  In  this  metropole  of  absurdity,  con artists,  such  as  Ugarte,  lived  in  luxury,  while  Amsterdam's  leading  banker  was  forced  to wash  dishes  at  Rick's  café.

All  Is  Fair  in  Love  and  War

2/21/2014 Bright Lights Film Journal :: Casablanca

http://brightlightsfilm.com/55/casablanca.php#.Uwenf_RdVod 4/10

One  of  the  major  attributes  of  film  noir  is  that  it  reflected  the  cynical  social  trends  of  its era,  including  the  influence  of  psychoanalysis  on  popular  culture,  and  isolationism/ neutrality  on  both  the  personal  and  political  fronts. 9  Our  first  encounter  with  the proprietor  of  Rick's  Café  Américain  was  during  a  chess  match.  The  strategic  game,  which was  symbolic  of  the  competition  and  out-­maneuvering  that  dominated  World  War  II,  was like  a  psychoanalytic  therapy  session  in  that  it  exposed  the  complex  facets  of  Rick's personality.  His  attitude  towards  his  opponent  elucidated  that  Rick  was  far  more complicated  than  the  non-­partisan  image  he  tried  to  maintain.  In  fact,  his  position  was essentially  a  personification  of  the  United  States'  foreign  policy  before  Pearl  Harbor.  Like the  U.S.  government,  Rick  seemed  neutral:

Rick:  "I  stick  my  neck  out  for  nobody."

Captain  Renault:  "Wise  foreign  policy."

However,  as  we  soon  discover,  Rick,  was  also  secretly  committed  to  the  restoration  of democratic  idealism  and  justice.

Although  Rick  attempted  to  conceal  his  political  views,  his  sympathy  for  the  underdog eventually  surfaced.  We  discover  that  Rick  was  on  the  Gestapo  "Roll  of  Honor"  because he  ran  guns  to  the  Ethiopians  after  their  country  was  invaded  by  Mussolini  in  1935.  In 1936,  he  fought  on  the  side  of  the  Loyalists  in  the  Spanish  Civil  War,  against  the  fascist Franco-­led  rebels.  Even  though  Rick  made  the  point  that  he  was  well  paid  on  both occasions,  this  was  a  poor  attempt  at  concealing  his  contributions  to  the  democratic cause.  The  fact  that  he  fought  against  the  Axis  powers  of  Italy  and  Germany  in  Spain  was particularly  significant  because  it  made  the  audience  "understand  that  [World  War  II]  did not  commence  with  Pearl  Harbor."  Rather,  "the  roots  of  aggression  had  a  deeper origin."10

Rick's  cynicism  and  mysterious  exile  from  the  United  States  added  to  his  image  as  a romantic  figure  who  was  a  "sucker  for  a  lost  cause."  His  noir  appearance  became  an effective  facade,  concealing  his  political  views  and  allowing  him  to  cross  social  and cultural  boundaries  without  suspicion.  However,  from  time  to  time,  Rick's  protective armor  cracked,  exposing  his  true  sympathies.  In  one  scene,  Rick  refused  to  serve  a German  patron,  tearing  up  his  invitation,  which  would  have  presumably  allowed  him  to receive  "special  treatment."  While  there  was  no  specific  reason  given  for  Rick's  action  in the  film,  there  was  a  cryptic  conversation  that  indicated  that  Rick's  behavior  was  perhaps a  little  more  politically  motivated  than  he  would  have  liked  to  admit:

Rick:  "Your  cash  is  good  at  the  bar."

German:  "Do  you  know  who  I  am?"

Rick:  "I  do.  You're  lucky  the  bar's  open  to  you."

Another  conversation,  this  time  between  Rick  and  Ferrari,  the  orchestrator  of  the  local black  market,  also  exposed  Rick's  liberal  political  leanings.  The  owner  of  the  rival  café, "The  Blue  Parrot,"  Ferrari  offered  to  buy  Sam's  contract,  to  which  Rick  replied:  "I  don't buy  or  sell  human  beings."  Not  only  did  this  refusal  reinforce  the  respect  that  Rick  and Sam  had  for  each  other  (which  was  particularly  bold  given  the  tenuous  race  relations  of the  1940s),  but  it  also  conveyed  the  point  that  Rick  —  the  American  —  was  above  the fascist  practice  of  trading  human  beings.

2/21/2014 Bright Lights Film Journal :: Casablanca

http://brightlightsfilm.com/55/casablanca.php#.Uwenf_RdVod 5/10

The  film  reaches  a  political  turning  point  when  Ilsa  and  Victor  Laszlo  arrive  in

Casablanca.  Their  simple  clothing  suggests  that  they  were,  like  the  other  inhabitants  of

the  town,  refugees,  running  from  country  to  country  to  escape  capture  by  the  Gestapo.

The  fact  that  Rick  broke  his  isolationist  rule  of  "never  drinking  with  a  customer,"  and  sat

down  with  the  Laszlos,  indicated  that  they  were  not  a  typical  couple.  Rick's  emotional

reaction  to  Ilsa  signified  that  "isolationism  [would]  no  longer  be  a  practical  policy."  At

that  moment,  it  became  clear  that  Rick's  rule  of  "never  sticking  his  neck  out  for  no  one"

would  be  reversed.  Like  Franklin  Delano  Roosevelt,  Rick  would  be  persuaded  by  an  ally

to  enter  the  war.  His  self-­preserving  mantra  —  "I'm  the  only  cause  I'm  interested  in"  —

would  never  again  be  recited  in  Casablanca.

Ugarte's  letters  of  transit,  which  caused  his  death,  as  well  as  the  death  of  two  German

couriers,  compelled  the  Laszlos  to  seek  Rick's  assistance.  The  visas  were  especially

valuable  because  they  were  signed  by  Charles  de  Gaulle.  This  was  a  change  from  the  first

version  of  the  film,  when  the  letters  were  signed  by  Maxim  Weygand,  the  commander  of

the  Vichy  forces  in  Africa.  This  alteration  was  clearly  a  stroke  of  U.S.  propaganda,  for  by

1941,  de  Gaulle  had  become  the  world-­famous  leader  of  "Free  France."  The  irony  of  this

political  maneuver  was  that  de  Gaulle  did  not  have  any  official  authority  in  North  Africa.

In  fact,  by  the  time  Casablanca  premiered  in  1942,  he  was  considered  a  war  criminal  and would  have  been  captured  and  tried  for  treason  (and  most  likely  executed)  if  he  dared  set

foot  in  Vichy  territory.  De  Gaulle  had  as  much  authority  to  sign  letters  of  transit  which

could  never  have  been  "rescinded  or  even  questioned"  as  an  ordinary  American  did  of

ordering  a  nuclear  war. 11  Perhaps  this  message  of  "equality"  between  de  Gaulle  and  the

average  American  was  precisely  the  message  that  Warner  Brothers  wished  to  convey.

Casablanca  and  the  Third  Reich In  order  to  place  the  Nazi  threat  close  to  home,  Koch  and  the  Epsteins  saturated

Casablanca  with  powerful  assertions  of  German  dominance.  Nazi  solders  were  given  the best  tables  at  Rick's  café  because  they  were  "German  and  would  take  [them]  anyway,"

just  like  they  annexed  most  of  Europe.  Major  Heinrich  Strasser's  duty  was  to  expand  the

domain  of  the  Third  Reich  (i.e.,  through  the  German  social  and  political  policy  of

Lebensraum).  Strasser,  Casablanca's  most  potent  villain,  made  his  intentions  clear through  his  first  statement  in  the  film:  "We  [the  Germans]  have  to  become  accustomed  to

all  climates  —  from  Russia  to  the  Sahara."  This  sense  of  foreboding  Nazi  control  was

brought  to  the  shores  of  the  United  States  when  Strasser  explained  to  Rick  that  the

Germans  planned  on  invading  London  and  New  York. 12  Rick,  the  defensive  American,

refused  to  appease  the  Germans  as  most  of  Europe  had  done,  and  warned  the  autocratic

Strasser  that  even  the  Nazis  could  not  handle  certain  sections  of  New  York. 13  Rick's

response  not  only  reaffirmed  Allied  strength,  but  also  helped  boost  American  morale  by

proclaiming  that  even  the  arrogant  Nazis  could  never  defeat  the  idealism,  patriotism  and

spirit  of  the  democratic  United  States.

The  noir  theme  of  foreboding  Nazi  domination  was  once  again  echoed  by  Rick  when  he inquired:  "If  it  is  December  1941  in  Casablanca,  what  time  is  it  in  New  York."  Although

Sam  replied  that  his  watch  had  stopped  a  long  time  ago,  Rick  proceeded  to  answer  his

own  question:  "I  bet  they're  asleep  in  New  York.  I  bet  they're  asleep  all  across  America."

Clearly,  Rick  did  not  mean  "asleep"  in  the  literal  sense;;  he  meant  it  in  the  political  sense.

While  this  might  have  been  true  on  December  6,  1941,  by  the  evening  of  December  7,  it

was  clear  that  Americans  could  no  longer  afford  turn  a  blind  eye  to  the  "phony  war  in

2/21/2014 Bright Lights Film Journal :: Casablanca

http://brightlightsfilm.com/55/casablanca.php#.Uwenf_RdVod 6/10

Europe."  Pearl  Harbor  had  been  bombed  the  morning  of  December  7,  and  scores  of American  casualties  served  as  a  rude  awakening  to  the  anger  and  violence  that  was  raging half  way  around  the  world.  The  fact  that  Rick  chose  to  focus  on  New  York,  the  most powerful  city  in  the  world,  only  heightened  the  vulnerability  of  the  United  States.  It implied  that  if  Americans  did  not  begin  to  take  the  war  effort  seriously,  they  could become  the  denizens  of  Casablanca:  prisoners  in  a  German-­Vichy  protectorate, surrounded  by  an  omni-­present  Nazi  search  light.  This  horrifying  image  was  probably enough  to  scare  many  Americans  into  increasing  their  support  of  the  war  effort.

Casablanca's  Paris  flashback  scenes  reinforced  the  frightening,  encroaching  image  of Nazi  domination  and  destruction.  Prior  to  the  Nazi  invasion  of  France,  Paris  was peaceful,  beautiful  and  carefree.  However,  after  the  invasion,  the  capital  became  a  center of  chaos,  death,  fear  and  French  military  abandonment.  The  Nazis  also  destroyed  Ilsa  and Rick's  romance:  their  laughter  and  joy  suddenly  became  replaced  by  tension,  tears  and muffled  Gestapo  voices.  "A  crazy  world  where  anything  [could]  happen"  forced  them  to part,  leaving  Rick  with  nothing  but  an  awkward  apology  and  a  broken  heart.  The flashback  scenes  clearly  illustrated  that  the  war  was  brutal;;  it  shattered  a  nation,  a romance,  and  the  lives  of  millions  of  innocent  people.  It  had  to  end,  and  according  to Casablanca,  the  United  States  was  the  perfect  candidate  for  this  difficult  task.

Despite  Ilsa's  repeated  rejections  and  the  absurdity  of  the  world  around  him,  Rick  does not  abandon  his  altruism  and  romantic  sentimentality.  One  of  Rick's  finest  moments  came when  Annina  Brandel,  a  Bulgarian  refugee,  asked  for  his  assistance  in  escaping  her tortuous  existence  in  Casablanca.  She  and  her  husband  Jan  were  desperately  searching  for visas  to  the  United  States,  when  they  were  approached  by  the  corrupt  Chief  of  Police, Captain  Louis  Renault.  Rather  than  allowing  Annina  to  obtain  the  visas  by  selling  her body  to  Renault,  Rick  rigged  the  roulette  wheel  so  the  couple  could  win  the  money  to buy  their  passage  to  the  U.S.  Rick's  actions,  which  represented  the  power  than  American virtue  had  over  Vichy  corruption,  were  questioned  by  another  patron,  who  asked  Carl about  the  honesty  of  the  roulette  table.  Carl's  reply  —  "As  honest  as  the  day  is  long"  — was  probably  one  of  the  film's  most  insightful  statements.  Like  the  days  in  Casablanca, the  roulette  table's  honesty  was  also  short-­lived.  In  this  German-­occupied  desert  town,  the nights  seemed  to  last  forever.

Resistance  and  Resurrection

Rick's  sympathy  for  the  Allies,  and  his  blatant  resistance  of  Nazi  authority,  was  once again  conveyed  in  the  famous  Marseillaise  scene.  This  scene,  which  was  a  symbolic battle  between  the  Allied  Free  French  and  the  Axis  Germans,  began  when  Major Strasser's  troops  started  singing  the  patriotic  Die  Wacht  am  Rheim,  a  song  that  was brought  over  to  the  United  States  by  German  immigrants,  and  thus  conveniently  in  the American  public  domain. 14  Soon  after  the  Germans  began  to  sing,  Rick  gave  the orchestra  permission  to  play  the  French  national  anthem,  La  Marseillaise.  The  Allied supporters,  led  by  Victor  Laszlo  and  Yvonne,  Rick's  rejected  lover  (who,  out  of  spite,  in true  Vichy  form,  defected  to  the  Axis  side  and  began  to  date  a  Nazi  officer),  began  to sing  in  cannon  with  the  Germans  soldiers.  The  singers  of  La  Marseillaise  eventually managed  to  drown  out  the  German  voices;;  thus,  they  secured  a  small,  but  emotionally and  politically  significant,  victory  for  the  righteous  Allies,  which  was  fittingly  rounded out  by  Yvonne's  teary-­eyed  exclamation  "Vive  La  France."

2/21/2014 Bright Lights Film Journal :: Casablanca

http://brightlightsfilm.com/55/casablanca.php#.Uwenf_RdVod 7/10

Rick's  Café  Américain  was  condemned  as  a  center  of  pro-­Ally  sympathy  after  the Marseillaise  scene.  The  closing  of  the  popular  meeting  place  was  just  another  example  of the  type  of  exacting  revenge  that  the  Nazi  regime  used  to  control,  dominate  and  terrorize Casablanca.  The  corruption  and  greed  of  the  Axis  powers  was  further  exemplified through  Captain  Renault's  actions  during  this  scene.  A  stooge  of  the  Vichy  and  Nazi governments,  the  unscrupulous  Chief  of  Police  willingly  did  the  bidding  of  his  bosses  and closed  the  café  under  the  pretense  of  "illegal  gambling."  In  the  same  breath,  he  graciously received  his  share  of  this  "illegal"  activity  —  his  winnings  from  the  roulette  table.

The  corruption,  inhumane  behavior,  and  arbitrary  punishment  exacted  by  the  colonizers of  Casablanca  stood  in  stark  contrast  to  the  selflessness  and  altruism  of  characters  such  as Victor  Laszlo,  Ilsa's  husband  and  one  of  the  key  figures  in  the  Resistance  movement. Victor  was,  like  Rick,  a  troubled  figure  with  a  dark  and  mysterious  soul.  Charismatic  and broody  in  turns,  he  had  a  torrid  past  that  involved  torture  in  a  Third  Reich  concentration camp  for  printing  anti-­Nazi  handbills  in  his  native  Prague. 15  When  he  finally  managed  to escape  from  the  concentration  camp,  he  was  so  ill  that  Ilsa  was  forced  to  cancel  her  plans to  leave  Paris  with  Rick  so  that  she  could  help  her  husband  (whom  she  thought  had perished  in  the  camps)  to  regain  his  health.  For  the  next  two  years,  the  Laszlos  were forced  to  move  from  country  to  country,  trying  desperately  to  elude  capture  by  the Gestapo,  which  sought  to  curtail  their  anti-­Nazi  rallies  and  publications  permanently.

The  couple's  burdensome  existence  did  not  ease  upon  their  arrival  in  Casablanca. Although  the  city  was  technically  still  a  part  of  Unoccupied  (or  Free)  France,  it  was nevertheless  under  heavy  Axis  (i.e.,  German,  Vichy  and  Italian)  influence.  One  misstep could  have  prevented  the  Laszlos  from  reaching  the  United  States,  where  Victor  hoped  he could  continue  his  political  activism  by  raising  money  and  support  for  his  underground fighters.  He  was  already  under  the  relentless  watch  of  the  Nazis,  who  had  forbidden  the sale  of  exit  visas  to  the  Laszlos.  Thus,  refusing  to  allow  Strasser  to  sit  at  his  table  could have  cost  Victor  his  freedom;;  leading  the  orchestra  in  La  Marseillaise  was  virtually  an act  of  revolution. 16  However,  the  audience  is  always  aware  of  the  power  that  Rick continues  to  have  over  Laszlo.  While  it  is  true  that  Ilsa  had  a  profound  admiration  for  the man  she  married  —  she  was  not  singing  in  either  of  her  close-­ups;;  rather,  she  was  staring at  her  husband  in  awe  —  her  romantic  affection  and  passion  was  for  Rick.  Moreover, even  during  Victor's  strongest  moment  in  the  film,  the  orchestra  still  required  Rick's permission  to  respond  to  Laszlo's  request  for  the  French  national  anthem.  Thus  for  all  the passion  that  Victor  contributed  to  the  scene,  it  was  Rick,  the  American,  who  ultimately became  the  romantic  and  political  hero  of  the  film.

The  Nazis'  brutal  and  inhumane  treatment  of  Victor  was  the  perfect  vehicle  to  portray  the enemy  in  an  unfavorable  light.  The  hatred  that  the  Nazis  had  for  Laszlo  was  first illustrated  by  the  warning  that  Major  Strasser  gave  Rick  and  the  rest  of  Casablanca:  he threatened  that  he  would  personally  punish  anyone  who  provided  the  Laszlos  with  exit visas  to  the  United  States.  With  this  one  statement,  Strasser  made  sure  that  "it  would  take a  miracle  to  get  [the  Laszlos]  out  of  Casablanca."  By  that  time,  the  "Germans  [had already]  outlawed  miracles."  Once  Victor  and  Strasser  met  face  to  face,  their  mutual hatred  intensified.  Strasser  attempted  to  make  a  deal  with  Victor:  he  would  give  him  the exit  visas  in  exchange  for  the  names  of  the  Resistance  leaders.  Laszlo's  distain  for  Nazi coercion  was  conveyed  through  his  sharp  remark:  "If  I  didn't  tell  you  when  I  was  in  a concentration  camp,  where  you  had  more  persuasive  measures  [i.e.,  torture],  why  would

2/21/2014 Bright Lights Film Journal :: Casablanca

http://brightlightsfilm.com/55/casablanca.php#.Uwenf_RdVod 8/10

I  tell  you  now?" 17  Victor's  dedication  to  the  Cause  was  evident:  fighting  the  Nazis  was

like  breathing;;  without  it,  he  would  die:  "If  we  stop  fighting  our  enemies,  the  world

would  die."  No  German  threat  could  make  him  forsake  his  comrades,  especially  since

there  would  be  thousands  to  replace  him  if  he  were  killed.  By  Laszlo's  estimation,  "even

the  Nazis  couldn't  kill  that  fast."

Throughout  the  film,  Renault  (right)  reveals  the  danger  inherent  in  the  unstable  road  he

chose  for  himself,  with  the  Nazis  on  one  side  and  his  friend  Rick  on  the  other.  When

Rick  first  met  Strasser,  Renault  was  suspiciously  too  quick  to  reinforce  his  friend's  image

of  neutrality.  The  captain  repeatedly  interrupted  the  conversation  with  misplaced

comments  such  as  "Ho,  Diplomat,"  as  if  to  reassure  Strasser  that  he  had  no  reason  to  be

suspicious  of  Rick,  or  to  question  Renault's  loyalty.  During  the  same  encounter,  Renault

also  awkwardly  repeats  the  term  "Third  Reich"  as  though  there  would  be  others.  This

Nazi  patronization  would  prove  to  be  a  very  tenuous  strategy  for  Renault.  While  it  clearly

undermined  German  authority,  it  also  stretched  the  boundaries  of  his  friendship  with

Rick.  Captain  Renault's  hypocrisy  came  to  a  head  after  Strasser  ordered  his  men  to  search

Rick's  office  for  the  valuable  exit  visas.  To  appease  the  Germans,  the  Captain  ordered  his

officers  to  be  "especially  destructive." 18  However,  Renault's  guilt  compelled  him  to

apologize  to  Rick  for  being  a  Nazi  goon;;  he  reassured  the  café  owner  that  his  request  was

only  uttered  to  appeal  to  the  Nazis'  violent  nature.

The  ultimate  resolution  of  Renault's  political  hedging  came  during  the  final  "Airport"

scene.  Renault  had  to  choose  between  Rick  and  his  alliance  with  the  Nazis.  Instead  of

incriminating  Rick  with  the  Laszlos'  escape  and  Major  Strasser's  murder,  he  told  his  men

to  "round  up  the  usual  suspects."  While  this  act  saved  Rick,  it  undoubtedly  —  and

disturbingly  —  led  to  the  arrest,  and  perhaps  even  the  execution,  of  an  innocent  man

(most  likely  a  local  Moroccan).  Renault's  most  profound  display  of  patriotism  (and  pro-­

Ally  propaganda)  came  as  he  opened  a  bottle  of  "Vichy  Water":

Captain  Renault:  "Rick,  you're  not  only  a  sentimentalist,  but  you've  also  become  a  patriot."

Rick:  "Maybe,  but  it  seemed  like  a  good  time  to  start."

Renault  acknowledged  that  Rick  was  right  and  also  decided  to  make  a  fresh  start.  Maybe

it  was  his  guilt,  or  the  sudden  realization  that  the  Nazis  could  lose  the  war  —  either  way,

Renault  instantaneously  dropped  the  bottle  into  the  trash,  which  he  then  kicked  over.

Renault's  action  thus  symbolized  the  "rejection  of  Vichy  France's  authority  and  his

embrace  of  the  Allied  Cause." 19  It  also  symbolized  that  start  of  Renault's  and  Rick's

"beautiful  friendship."

Propaganda  Triumphs  Over  Romance

The  "Airport"  scene  served  a  dual  purpose:  it  exorcised  Renault's  Nazi  demons  and

resurrected  the  corrupt  character,  whose  heart  was  his  "least  vulnerable  spot,"  as  a  "born

again"  Ally  who  redeemed  himself  by  sabotaging  the  enemy.  It  also  resolved  the  romance

between  Rick  and  Ilsa  by  conveying  the  idea  that  neutrality  could  no  longer  be  a  policy,

both  for  the  café  owner,  and  for  the  United  States.  Before  this  final  scene,  it  seemed  as

though  Rick  and  Ilsa  were  going  to  submit  to  their  passion  by  abandoning  Victor  and

fleeing  to  the  United  States  together.  However,  once  again,  duty  and  honor  prevent  the

star-­crossed  lovers  from  realizing  their  forbidden  romance.  When  the  audience  finally

sees  Rick  at  the  airport,  it  is  clear  from  his  dark  and  foreboding  demeanor  that  their

2/21/2014 Bright Lights Film Journal :: Casablanca

http://brightlightsfilm.com/55/casablanca.php#.Uwenf_RdVod 9/10

escape  will  not  proceed  according  to  plan.  He  would  once  again  sacrifice  his  own

happiness  for  a  greater  cause,  embodying  the  American  propagandist  theme  that

"personal  desires  must  be  subordinated  to  the  task  of  defeating  fascism."  As  he  explained

to  Ilsa:  "I'm  no  good  at  being  noble,  but  it  doesn't  take  much  to  see  that  the  problems  of

three  little  people  don't  amount  to  a  hill  of  beans  in  this  crazy  world."

Rick  knew  that  he  had  to  "think  for  all  of  us,"  and  reluctantly  forced  Ilsa  to  leave  with

Victor.  He  reminded  her  of  the  danger  that  awaited  the  café  owner:  "I  have  a  job  to  do.

Where  I'm  going  you  can't  follow.  What  I've  got  to  do  you  can't  be  any  part  of."  As  an

Allied  sympathizer,  Rick  would  most  likely  be  captured  by  the  Nazis,  and  like  Laszlo,  be

taken  to  a  concentration  camp  to  await  his  brutal  punishment.  Victor  was  aware  of  this

possibility,  and  welcomed  Rick  "to  the  fight."  He  reassured  him  that  "this  time  I  know

our  side  will  win."  Thus,  at  the  end  of  the  film,  we  are  provided  with  a  double-­dose  of

tragic  romantic  fantasy.  For  every  person  who  has  loved  and  lost,  Rick's  choice  becomes

a  moment  of  supreme  self-­vindication. 20

As  producer  Hal  Wallis  was  fighting  to  keep  Casablanca  true  to  his  vision  of  what  a  war propaganda  film  should  be,  history  intervened.  In  November  1942,  the  Allies  landed  in

North  Africa.  With  the  Battle  of  Casablanca,  they  secured  their  first  success  in  the

African  theatre.  The  impact  of  this  victory  on  the  United  States  was  tremendous.  The  city

of  Casablanca  was  mentioned  in  newspapers  and  on  the  radio  almost  daily,  sparking  so

much  interest  in  the  "exotic"  locale  that  fashion  designers  even  began  inserting  Moroccan

motifs  into  their  lines. 21  Hal  Wallis  could  not  have  bought  this  kind  of  publicity  for

Casablanca.

To  take  advantage  of  this  remarkable  historical  coincidence,  Wallis  accelerated  the

production  of  Casablanca  so  that  the  film  could  premier  on  November  26,  1942,  just eighteen  days  after  the  Allied  landing.  The  film  opened  nationwide  on  January  23,  1943,

just  as  President  Franklin  Roosevelt,  Prime  Minister  Winston  Churchill,  and  Soviet

Premier  Joseph  Stalin  were  planning  their  war  strategy.  Coincidentally  (or  perhaps  not  so

coincidentally),  their  meeting  was  held  in  Casablanca  (Roosevelt's  headquarters  was  even

code-­named  "Rick's  Place"),  which  undoubtedly  contributed  to  the  film's  profit  of  nearly

a  million  dollars  (which,  by  1943  standards,  was  an  astronomical  figure). 22

Although  there  are  more  obvious  examples  of  World  War  II  propaganda  films  than

Casablanca,  no  other  film  so  intricately  reflects  the  historical  moment  it  was  produced —  the  early  days  of  World  War  II  —  and  the  psychological  needs  of  yesterday's,  today's,

and  tomorrow's  audiences.  Not  only  does  it  capture  the  United  States'  perception  of  itself

in  the  1940s  —  cynical  yet  altruistic,  independent  yet  worldly,  idealistic  yet  naïve  —  but

it  also  provides  twenty-­first  century  Americans  with  an  oasis  of  hope  in  a  desert  of

arbitrary  cruelty  and  senseless  violence.  Like  Rick,  we  too  can  believe  that  despite  our

unyielding  surface,  we  are  moral  within  —  capable  of  personal  sacrifice  in  the  name  of

freedom  and  democracy.  For  in  Casablanca,  there  will  always  be  a  place  where  good triumphs  over  evil,  and  despite  the  "fight  for  love  and  glory,"  romance  survives  in  a

world  gone  mad.

NOTES

1. Frank Miller, Casablanca: As Time Goes By (Atlanta: Turner Publishing, Inc., 1992), 34.

2. Ibid., 36.

2/21/2014 Bright Lights Film Journal :: Casablanca

http://brightlightsfilm.com/55/casablanca.php#.Uwenf_RdVod 10/10

3. Ibid., 37.

4. Aljean Harmetz, Round Up the Usual Suspects (New York: Hyperion, 1992), 289.

5. Miller, 94.

6. Ibid., 93.

7. William Luhr, ed., The Maltese Falcon (New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press, 1995), 8.

8. Rudy Behlmer, Casablanca: Here's Looking at You — Again (Atlanta: Turner Publishing, Inc., 1992), 18.

9. Luhr, 3.

10. Miller, 289.

11. Jeff Siegel, The Casablanca Companion (Dallas: Taylor Publishing Company, 1992), 25.

12. Unbeknownst to Rick and most other Americans, the German army had already "invaded" the United States. As early as the mid

1930s, Nazi sympathizers were running a major training camp in Eastern Long Island, and were holding secret support rallies

throughout the United States. Please see here for more information.

13. Even though the Epstein Brothers were Jewish and clearly were justified in their personal hatred of the Nazi regime, no overt

references are made in Casablanca to the extermination of the Jewish people in Europe. However, a number of covert references are made, this being one of them. Another notable strategic maneuver by the Epsteins was their subtle placement of Jewish characters in

the film. Though never explicitly mentioned, three minor German characters — Carl the Waiter and the Leuchtegs — harbored a

particularly bitter hatred for the Nazis. We can infer that these characters were most likely German Jews who had fled to Casablanca to

escape the Holocaust.

14. Miller, 159.

15. Ibid., 195.

16. Ibid.

17. My emphasis.

18. Miller, 202.

19. Ibid.,199.

20. Ibid., 194.

21. Behlmer, 30.

22. Miller, 171.

February 2007 | Issue 55 Copyright © 2014 by Tanfer Emin Tunc