Media Analysis Repot

Labels

Expectations

Points

Visual Aid

· Visual aids are well-formatted and informative enough to facilitate presentation of the study. (5) 5

· Visual aids supplement verbal delivery, that the two align well with each other and are not distractive of each other. (5) 5

10

· Good work! The visual aids can be more vivid with inclusion of more pictures and illustrations.

Verbal Delivery and presentational style

· Verbal delivery has satisfactory level of diction, volume, and vocal variety. Verbal delivery is extemporaneous and engaging with complete sentence structure. (5) 5

· Students dress in presentable attire and present in professional manner with confidence and composure. Students engage in good posture, effective hand gestures, and frequent and even eye contact to the audience. (5) 0 no video

10

· You are very articulate!

· The delivery is very extemporaneous with great vocal energy!

Study design, analytical effort, and clarity

· All parts of the study are reviewed in the presentation (i.e. introduction, method, findings, and discussions). (5) 4

· The study design reflects clear understanding of the purpose and application of media content analysis. (5) 4

· The presentation has great logical flow, which facilitates easy understanding of and navigation through various sections and main points. (5) 3

· Presentation of findings and discussions are meaningful and purposeful, leave the audience with something to think about the reviewed media content. (5) 4

20

· You need to make stronger connection between the findings and your methodological effort. Right now, it is a bit hard for the audience to know the coding process you go through to extract the themes and patterns.

· The TV shows are reviewed, yet it is hard to say that they have been systematically analyzed. Try to walk the readers through the analytical effort you took to get to your conclusions.

· The findings are actually very interesting, layered, and meaningful. It would be nice if they are backed up with actual coding evidences.

Organization, Flow, and Transitions

· Preview and signposts are present and are further corresponded by subsequent slides. (5) 4

· Transitions and connective phrases are used between points and sections to enhance overall flow of the presentation. (5) 4

10

· A nice preview can be included in the beginning lay out the structure of the presentation and the study.