CASE STUDY CRITIQUES INSTRUCTIONS

Criteria

Levels of Achievement

Content

(70%)

Advanced

92-100%

Proficient

84-91%

Developing

1-83%

Not present

Total

Answer Specificity

23 to 25 points:

All key components of the topic are thoroughly discussed in the paper

21 to 22.5 points:

All key components of the topic are largely answered in the paper with few exceptions

1 to 20.5 points:

Key portions of assigned questions are left unanswered

0 points

Not present

Logic & Clarity

23 to 25 points:

Clear, logical flow to paper; major points are stated clearly

21 to 22.5 points:

Clear logical flow to paper; major points are stated clearly for the most part

1 to 20.5 points:

Lack of clarity and failure to logically explain and communicate answers is the norm

0 points

Not present

Research & Support

18.5 to 20 points:

Major points are thoroughly supported by the following: 1. Lecture material or Scripture 2. Good examples (pertinent conceptual or personal examples) 3. Thoughtful analysis (considering assumptions, analysis implications, comparing/ contrasting concept) 4. Quality of research

16.5 to 18 points:

Major points are largely supported by the following: 1. Lecture material or Scripture 2. Good examples (pertinent conceptual or personal examples) 3. Thoughtful analysis (considering assumptions, analysis implications, comparing/ contrasting concept) 4. Quality of research

1 to 16 points:

Major points are lacking substantial support by the following: 1. Lecture material or Scripture 2. Good examples (pertinent conceptual or personal examples) 3. Thoughtful analysis (considering assumptions, analysis implications, comparing/ contrasting concept) 4. Quality of research

0 points

Not present

Structure (30%)

Advanced

92-100%

Proficient

84-91%

Developing

1-83%

Not present

Total

Spelling, Grammar & APA

18.5 to 20 points:

Little to no errors in spelling, grammar and APA

16.5 to 18 points:

Some errors in spelling, grammar and APA

1 to 16 points:

Numerous errors in spelling, grammar and APA

0 points

Not present

Sufficient Length

9.25 to 10 points:

Title page, abstract page, 3 pages of minimum content and reference page (if needed)

8.5 to 9 points:

Paper runs a bit long or a bit short of page requirements

1 to 8.25 points:

Paper is more than five pages or less than three pages

0 points

Not present

Professor Comments:

Total:

/100