Leadership and Management
Student Assessment Guide
BSBHRM405 Support the Recruitment, Selection and Induction
of Staff
Intellectual Property Statement
VET Fair (ABN 44 983 956 589) is a provider of educational products and services for the vocational education and
training (VET) sector.
By purchasing the ‘BSBHRM405 Support The Recruitment, Selection and Induction of Staff’ assessment resources
(“Product”), you are entitled to use it for educational purposes only, but the intellectual property remains with VET
Fair. This Product includes the following components:
Assessor Guide
Student Assessment Guide
Student Assessment Workbook
any other material to support the implementation of the Product (e.g. policy and procedures, templates, etc.).
VET Fair owns all copyright to the Product as subject to the provisions of the Copyright Act 1968.
This purchase grants you a non-exclusive, perpetual, non-sublicensable, and non-shareable right to use and
contextualise this Product. You have the right to distribute unlimited copies of this Product to your students or internal
staff, limited to only for educational purposes; however, you must not:
a) reproduce this Product or produce other assessment resources based on this Product
b) share this Product with any other external person or entity other than your students and internal staff through
physical or electronic including online access
c) use this Product for any other purposes than education (e.g. assessing student competency, conducting validation
and moderation activities, etc.)
d) resell this Product to any party of individual
e) use this Product without affixing the following statement in each copy of a modified, adapted, customised or
contextualised version of this Product that is distributed electronically or in a physical format to your target learner
audience:
“The assessment activities and information in this guide are derived
from the BSBHRM405 Support The Recruitment, Selection and
Induction of Staff assessment resources provided by VET Fair. VET
Fair owns all copyright to this information and the intellectual
property of this resource remains with VET Fair.”
Breaches of this copyright will result in VET Fair claiming for loss of sales.
Table of Contents Intellectual Property Statement 2
Assessment Information 1
Assessment Event 1 – Knowledge Questions 3
Question 1 3
Question 2 3
Question 3 3
Question 4 3
Assessment Event 2: University of Great Australia Simulation 4
Task 1: Task 1 Plan for Recruitment 4 1.1 Obtain approval to fill position 4 1.2 Assist in preparing job descriptions 4 1.3 Consult with relevant personnel 4
Task 2: Plan for selection 5 2.1 Choose appropriate channels and technology for advertisement 5 2.2 Advertise the position 5 2.3 Convene selection panel 5 2.4 Assist in development of interview questions 5 2.5 Assist in short listing applicants 6 2.6 Develop a schedule for interviews from the shortlist 6
Task 3 Support Selection Process 7 3.1 Participate in the interview process with applicants 7 3.2 Contacts referees 7 3.3 Prepare selection report and make recommendations 7 3.4 Advise unsuccessful applicants 7 3.5 Advise successful applicant 7 3.6 Establish a cloud repository to name, save and store the template in accordance with organisational requirements 8
Task 4 Induct successful applicant 9 Prepare necessary documents and advise others for induction arrangements: 9
Appendix A: University of Great Australia Simulation 10
Simulation Background 10
Simulation Phases 10
Your Role in the Simulation 11 Phase 1: 11 Phase 2: 11
Simulation Setup 12
Assessment Conditions for the Observation 13
Appendix B: Observation Check Sheet 14
BSBHRM405 Student Assessment Guide v4.0 Page 1
Assessment Information
Welcome to your Student Assessment Guide for BSBHRM405 Support The Recruitment, Selection and Induction of
Staff.
This Guide provides you with information on the assessment particularly what you have to do and to what level of
performance.
This assessment has the following two events:
Assessment Event 1 – Knowledge Questions
There are four questions that will provide us with evidence of your general knowledge of tools, documents,
processes, and legislative context in relation to recruitment, selection and induction.
This assessment is completed in your own time and by a submission date provided by your Assessor. You may use
support material in the development of your responses, but you must indicate the source. In addition, you must not
‘cut and paste’ content from your source, rather, use your words, unless it is a direct quote.
Assessment Event 2 – Simulation: University of Great Australia
You will complete a number of tasks that will provide us with evidence of your skills with in recruiting, selecting and
inducting a staff member University of Great Australia (UGA), which operates in multiple locations across Australia.
These tasks will be based on your role as a Human Resources Officer.
To complete the Simulation, you will need to refer to the following resources:
UGA Recruitment and
Selection Policy and
Procedures
UGA’s policy and procedures related to recruitment, selecting and inducting staff. You
will use this policy and procedures document throughout the simulation in Assessment
Event 2.
Job Description for HR
Assistant
Template that contains the key requirements of the job. It also contains notes that were
provided by the HR Manager. You will complete this job description in Task 1.2
Mock Resumes This file contains five resumes that are applying for the position of HR Assistant. You will
use this in Task 2.5.
Interview Notes
Template
Template that contains the format for recording the responses of the applicant in the
interview. You will use this in Task 3.1
Selection Outcome
Report
This template is used to summarise the findings from the interview. You will use this in
Task 3. 3
Referee Reports This folder provides a sample of the feedback obtained from the Referees. You will use
this information to make a final decision on the preferred applicant in Task 3.4.
Induction Folder Folder that includes the organisation’s template of an employment contract and a
checklist for a new job starter. You will use these documents in Task 4.
Remember, you do not type your responses in this Student Assessment Guide, but use the Student Assessment
Workbook, which is a separate document. This document is simply a guide to explain what you are required to do, and
by doing so, this will assist you to perform at your best.
Please note that your responses for both assessment events can (where appropriate) use dot point format. See below
for an example of a dot point response and a full sentence response.
Dot point format Presentation Plan includes the following:
outcomes
needs of the audience
context.
BSBHRM405 Student Assessment Guide v4.0 Page 2
Full sentence format When you are preparing for a Presentation, there are a number of tasks that must be
carried out. These are; listing the outcomes that you want to achieve, followed by the
identification of the needs of your audience. When you have completed these two tasks,
you then check on the room you will be conducting the simulation in etc.
Performance required
complete all of the questions and tasks listed in the Student Assessment Workbook
meet all the requirements listed in this Student Assessment Guide
your responses to the questions and tasks must be relevant, accurate and specific
submit your completed Student Assessment Workbook to your Assessor within the set timeframes
your work must be in your own words
where you use an external source of information, you must provide citation.
Please be aware that your Assessor is here to provide you with the necessary support throughout the assessment
process. If you have questions, then contact them for guidance.
BSBHRM405 Student Assessment Guide v4.0 Page 3
Assessment Event 1 – Knowledge Questions
The information contained in this assessment event lists the questions that you will need to develop a written
response. These questions are theoretical and provide evidence of your understanding of the principles and practices
of recruitment, selection and induction in terms of processes and legislative context.
Each question includes the requirements which indicate what you have to do and the depth of your response to
achieve a satisfactory result.
Question 1
Explain the human resources life cycle (HRLC) and the place of recruitment and selection.
R 1. explain the HRLC:
provide an explanation of the six stages
word count is approximately 150 words in total
R 2. explain the place of recruitment and selection:
explain the importance of recruitment and selection within the model
word count is approximately 50 words.
Question 2
Identify legislation relevant to recruitment, selection and induction (RSI) of staff.
R 1. list and explain three legislations
R 2. explanation will include an example of their relevance to RSI
R 3. word count is approximately 50 words per legislation.
Question 3
Describe channels and technology to advertise vacancies.
R 1. identify and explain four channels
R 2. these descriptions will include the type of technology being used
R 3. word count is approximately 50 words for each channel
Question 4
Explain a range of interviewing techniques and their application.
R 1. list and explain four interviewing techniques
R 2. provide an example of their application including pros and cons
R 3. word count is approximately 50 words for each technique.
BSBHRM405 Student Assessment Guide v4.0 Page 4
Assessment Event 2: University of Great Australia Simulation
In this assessment, you will undertake a number of tasks associated with the recruitment, selection and induction of
staff for the ‘Human Resource Assistant’ position for the University of Great Australia (UGA).
In this simulation, you will perform the following actions:
plan for the recruitment and selection process
support the selection process
plan the induction process.
Please ensure that you familiarise yourself with this set of requirements that underpin this simulation. This includes
understanding the background of the simulation and the criteria you will be assessed on. These are located in the
Appendix of this document.
Task 1: Task 1 Plan for Recruitment
In this task, you will analyse the relevant information provided and then finalise a job description that is compliant
with relevant laws, national standards and UGA’s policies in order to ensure that the job is ready to be advertised.
1.1 Obtain approval to fill position
R 1. read the UGA Policy and Procedures and prepare an email for the HR Manager:
email will cover key procedures to initiate the recruitment process
include a request for approval
R 2. send the email to the HR Manager
R 3. word count of this email is approximately 200 words.
1.2 Assist in preparing job descriptions
R 1. review the abbreviated job description for the position (the ‘Job Description for HR Assistant’ document):
complete the selection criteria using the notes from the HR Manager
populate the terms and conditions
all sections must contain appropriate requirements
R 2. word count is not critical.
1.3 Consult with relevant personnel
R 1. send an email to the HR Manager and include the following content:
attach the completed position description
attach a summary on how you ensure that the job description is compliant with:
- role requirements
- relevant legislation, codes and national standards
- organisational policies and procedures
request feedback on the accuracy of your position description
include any feedback in the finalisation of the job description
if no further change, sought approval to advertise for the position
R 2. word count for this email is approximately 200 words.
BSBHRM405 Student Assessment Guide v4.0 Page 5
Task 2: Plan for selection
In this task, you will prepare for the selection process. This will include advertising the vacancy, convening the selection
panel, developing interview questions, short-listing applicants, and scheduling the interviews with relevant
stakeholders.
2.1 Choose appropriate channels and technology for advertisement
R 1. review policies and procedures and select three appropriate advertising channels
R 2. provide justification for each selection
R 3. word count is approximately 250 words.
2.2 Advertise the position
R 1. prepare an advertisement for the staff website and email to the HR Manager
R 2. seek approval from the HR Manager to advertise position:
request feedback on the accuracy of your advertisement
include any feedback in the finalisation of the advertisement
R 3. word count is approximately 200 words.
2.3 Convene selection panel
R 1. prepare a check sheet for the tasks as convener of a panel
R 2. prepare a check sheet for the responsibilities of the panel members
R 3. each check sheet must contain a minimum of six criteria
R 4. send email to HR Manager requesting that they contact panel members that meet the check sheet criteria:
request feedback on the accuracy of your check sheets
include any feedback in the finalisation of the check sheets
R 5. word count is not critical.
2.4 Assist in development of interview questions
R 1. using the table below, list questions to be asked to applicants:
list in the essential selection criteria column which selection criteria is being used
comment on the appropriateness of the question
provide a recommendation to improve accuracy
R 2. word count is approximately 50 words per question.
Interview Question Essential Selection Criteria Appropriateness and
recommendations
1. Please demonstrate your experience by giving a five minute presentation about the key processes with recruitment, selection and induction
2. What do you think will be a challenge in this role and how will you address this?
3. What skills do you have that will be useful in this position?
BSBHRM405 Student Assessment Guide v4.0 Page 6
Interview Question Essential Selection Criteria Appropriateness and
recommendations
4. Describe the documents you have produced in your previous roles?
5. What would be the tasks you would carry out in the first week
6. With the written document provided to you, please circle as many mistakes as possible in the five minutes available
7. What do you think are the attributes to be an effective team member?
2.5 Assist in short listing applicants
R 1. using the resumes provided:
review each resume and put each in order of preference
include a reason for this prioritisation
R 2. word count is approximately 50 words per applicant.
2.6 Develop a schedule for interviews from the shortlist
R 1. with your prioritisation of resumes, prepare a schedule of interviews, including:
status of interview
date of interview
time of interview
location
stakeholders to be informed
R 2. include both the successful and unsuccessful applicants
R 3. send this to the HR Manager
R 4. word count is not critical.
BSBHRM405 Student Assessment Guide v4.0 Page 7
Task 3 Support Selection Process
In this task, you will participate in the interview process with two other stakeholders (Selection Panel members) where
you will conduct a face-to-face interview with each of the two job applicants. After the interview, you will interact with
these two panel members to negotiate for the preferred applicant. Then you will finalise the selection process using
the appropriate documentation.
3.1 Participate in the interview process with applicants
R 1. participate in a 30-minutes interview with each of the two applicants:
ask a minimum of three questions
take notes of responses for all questions and document in the ‘Interview Notes Template’ provided
use a rating system to evaluate each applicant’s performance
hold a 15 minutes meeting with the Selection Panel members and negotiate the preferred applicant
R 2. actions within this 45-minute session must demonstrate all the criteria listed in the Observation Check Sheet.
3.2 Contacts referees
R 1. review the referee reports received for the two applicants:
summarise the strengths
summarise the limitations
R 2. include this summary in the ‘Selection Outcome Report’ provided
R 3. word count is not critical.
3.3 Prepare selection report and make recommendations
R 1. prepare the ‘Selection Outcome Report’ using the template provided
R 2. send to HR Manager with recommendations
R 3. word count is not critical.
3.4 Advise unsuccessful applicants
R 1. develop draft ‘Regret Emails’:
Regret Email 1: covering email for the unsuccessful applicants
Regret Email 2: response to these applicants who may seek more information on the outcome
R 2. send an email to the HR Manager:
include a formal introduction, body and closure
attach the draft Regret Emails
seek feedback on these drafts
R 3. include any feedback in the finalisation of the ‘Regret Emails’ (if required)
R 4. word count is approximately 100 words per email.
3.5 Advise successful applicant
R 1. develop draft ‘Letter of Offer’ that is in line with UGA’s policy and procedures
R 2. send the draft ‘Letter of Offer’ to the HR Manager:
include an overview to the situation
seek feedback on the draft
R 3. include any feedback in the finalisation of the ‘Letter of Offer’ (if required)
R 4. word count is approximately 300 words for the letter.
BSBHRM405 Student Assessment Guide v4.0 Page 8
3.6 Establish a cloud repository to name, save and store the template in accordance with
organisational requirements
R 1. setup the HR Database
R 2. store HR files in the database
R 3. all of the above must be in line with UGA’s policy and procedures
R 4. share the database with the HR Manager for their review.
BSBHRM405 Student Assessment Guide v4.0 Page 9
Task 4 Induct successful applicant
In this task, you will plan the induction process for the new team member. To achieve this, you will send an email to
your HR Manager and request that the new applicant’s work team are informed of their start date and orientation.
Prepare necessary documents and advise others for induction arrangements:
R 1. collate necessary documentation:
populate the ‘Employment Contract’ template
upload the completed ‘Employment Contract’ template to the HR database
upload the ‘New Job Starter Checklist’ template to the HR database
R 2. send an email to the HR Manager which contained:
an overview to the appointment
requests an induction with the Team Leader
this induction includes all relevant key points that are in line with UGA procedures
seek feedback on the completed ‘Employee Contract’ and the arrangements noted
R 3. use feedback make the necessary amendments (where required)
R 4. word count is approximately 200 words for the email.
BSBHRM405 Student Assessment Guide v4.0 Page 10
Appendix A: University of Great Australia Simulation
Simulation Background
The University of Great Australia (UGA) is based in Sydney with campuses in Brisbane, Adelaide and Perth. The
University has an international outlook which celebrates diversity through hosting 18,000 students in total, with 5,000
international students enrolled from 35 countries. At UGA, students have the opportunity to participate in student
exchange programs offered in conjunction with over 50 partner institutions across the globe.
UGA is a major international university with more than 400 full-time equivalent employees from diverse backgrounds.
The University places a strong emphasis on diversity, ethics and integrity in faculty, academic research, staff
management, student recruitment, and student teaching experience.
UGA is committed to providing the best staff support; for this reason, the following employee benefits options are
provided to the members of the university, as stated in the Employee Benefits Booklet form:
medical insurance (Medibank)
on-site gym
childcare facilities
dental insurance
retirement plan
free staff parking
library
UGA Optometrist Clinic
17% (of annual salary) superannuation coverage through UniSuper.
Annual salary is paid on a fortnightly basis through direct deposit, and is based on 76 ordinary hours per fortnight
including one hour lunch break, five days during the week, excluding weekends.
At a recent senior staff meeting, it was tabled that many Managers from various departments are not following
protocol and what is particularly worrying is the selection of applicants where it was found:
applicants are sourced for interview not through a formal advertising process but by word of mouth
no interview panels with Managers appointing applicants at their own discretion
limited documentation for auditing purposes
Research into the impact of this process has uncovered poor performance of new recruits who may not be appropriate
for the position. In addition, the tension amongst some staff members who believe that the process is biased and
unfair and not providing equal opportunity for selection based on merit.
As a result, Senior Management have requested an immediate halt to staff recruitment until staff are educated on the
policies and procedures. In addition, they have approved the appointment of a dedicated Human Resource Assistant
whose role will be to provide support to all Managers on the recruitment, selection and induction of staff.
You have been appointed to provide assistance to the Human Resource Manager to follow the correct process and
recruit, select and induct an appropriate applicant to this position.
Simulation Phases
This simulation is divided into the following phases:
Phase 1: plan for recruitment and selection.
Phase 2: support the selection process.
Phase 3: plan the induction process.
BSBHRM405 Student Assessment Guide v4.0 Page 11
Your Role in the Simulation
The simulation centres on your role as a Human Resources Officer for the University of Great Australia. In this
simulation, you will interact with two stakeholders as the selection panel and two job applicants for the role of support
to the recruitment, selection and induction process across departments at the University.
You will be the Human Resource Officer of University of Great Australia in the simulation. Your roles and
responsibilities in the simulation are as follows:
Phase 1:
Phase 1 occurs from Tasks 1.1 to Tasks 2.6. In Phase 1 your main duties in the organisation are as follows:
obtain approval to fill position
develop job description
obtain approval and advertise position
shortlist applicants for interview.
Phase 2:
Phase 2 occurs in Tasks 3.1 to Tasks 3.3.
In Task 3.1, you will conduct interviews as the Human Resource Officer of University of Great Australia with the
shortlisted applicants in interaction with two interview panel members.
Each of the interview session will have a duration of 45 minutes (30 minutes for the interview and 15 minutes for the
analysis) for each applicant.
Note that your Assessor will not play a role in this observation activity as they will be observing your interaction with
the stakeholders and documenting evidence in the Observation Check Sheet provided in Appendix B.
In Phase 2 your main duties in the organisation are as follows:
participate in the interview process by asking a minimum of three interview questions
listen to responses and seek clarification if unclear
answer any questions that the applicant may have on details of the position
assesses applicants against the selection criteria
discuss this assessment with others in the selection panel
use a rating system in this assessment to determine the preferred applicant
analyse comments from the Referees and make recommendations on the preferred applicant.
Phase 3:
Phase 3 occurs from Tasks 3.4 to Task 4. In Phase 3, your main duties in the organisation are as follows:
advise applicants of outcomes
secure preferred applicant
make the necessary arrangement for a proper induction into organisation.
BSBHRM405 Student Assessment Guide v4.0 Page 12
Simulation Setup
The simulation chosen is to give you the opportunity to provide evidence that demonstrates your ability to assist in
the recruitment, selection and induction for a position within the Human Resource Department. We have tried to
make this simulation as real as possible within a classroom setting through using documents and templates that typify
the industry. To carry out your role in this simulation will require you to follow these steps:
Step 1. At the commencement of the unit, your Assessor will overview the assessment with you. You will then
sign the declaration of your understanding located in the Student Assessment Workbook (Pre-
Assessment Checklist).
Step 2. Your Assessor will select actors form the RTO to role play in this simulation.
Step 3. Overview the assessment requirements and the ‘UGA Recruitment, Selection and Induction Policy and
Procedures’ document.
Step 4. You will send an email to the HR Manager (your Assessor) requesting approval to fill position and they
will respond to this email with feedback/approval (Task 1.1).
Step 5. Your Assessor will provide you with the job description for HR Assistant (Task 1.2).
Step 6. Send an email to the HR Manager requesting feedback on job description (Task 1.3).
Step 7. Send an email to the HR Manager requesting feedback and approval to advertise position (Task 2.2).
Step 8. You will prepare check sheets for the Panel Members. Send an email requesting HR Manager to contact
panel members (Task 2.3).
Step 9. You will review the pre-planned questions and assist in improving their accuracy (Task 2.4).
Step 10. Your Assessor will provide you with the resumes as a result of the advertisement (Task 2.5). You will
review these resumes and shortlist the applicants in accordance to the position requirements.
Step 11. You will send an email to the HR Manager with a schedule of interviews for the shortlisted applicants
(Task 2.6).
Step 12. Your Assessor will provide you with the ‘Interview Notes Template’ and ‘Selection Outcome Report’ to
be used in Task 3.1 and Task 3.3.
Step 13. You will undertake the two interviews within one observation session (Tasks 3.1). Your Assessor will
observe the session using Observation Check Sheet.
Step 14. You will provide the student with the Referee Reports (see ‘Referee Reports’ folder) to use in Task 3.2.
Step 15. You will send an email to the HR Manager and attach the draft Selection Outcome Report (Task 3.3).
Step 16. You will send an email to the HR Manager attaching the draft ‘Regret Emails’ on informing unsuccessful
applicants along with potential requests from applicants for more information (Task 3.4).
Step 17. You will send an email to the HR Manager with an attached draft ‘Letter of Offer’ (Task 3.5).
Step 18. You will create the HR database using Dropbox, uploads all the files in accordance to the UGA policy and
procedures (see Records Management section), and grants access to you for your review (Task 3.6).
Step 19. Your Assessor will provide you with the ‘Employment Contract’ and ‘New Job Starter Checklist’
templates. You will populate the ‘Employment Contract’ and then upload to Dropbox along with the
‘New Job Starter Checklist’ template.
Step 20. You will send an email to the HR Manager on details of the induction and request that they forward it to
the Team Leader where the successful applicant will be working. You will also maintain the HR Database
as required (Task 4).
Step 21. Upon the completion of the simulation, finalise your Student Assessment Workbook to be submitted to
your Assessor.
BSBHRM405 Student Assessment Guide v4.0 Page 13
Assessment Conditions for the Observation
The information in this section outlines the assessment conditions for the Observation which occurs in Phase 2 and
involves your interaction with the four stakeholders.
Before the Observation:
you must ensure that you have read and understood any documents required to undertake the Observation
you must ensure that you have read and understood all performance requirements listed under each task
you must ensure that you have read the requirements listed in the Observation Check Sheet as your performance
will be judged based on these criteria (see Appendix B)
your Assessor will inform you of the date of your Observation.
During the Observation:
you will be interacting with the two panel members and two different applicants
these interviews will be done separately, however, within one observation session, in succession
each has a total duration of 45 minutes (30 minutes for the interview each and 15 minutes for the analysis of each
applicant)
other students will not be observers during the session as this will give them an unfair advantage
these stakeholders will be role played by staff from the RTO or other externals
your Assessor will brief them on your topics so that they can carry out their actions in an appropriate manner
you cannot refer to the Observation Check Sheet while undertaking the observation
your Assessor will:
- observe you individually based on the criteria in the Observation Check Sheet
- document their observations in detail on the Observation Check Sheet
- provide extensive written feedback
- ensure that the session will be free from distractions
you must comply with WHS requirements
you must demonstrate all the criteria in the Observation Check Sheet to achieve a satisfactory result for the
Observation.
After the observation:
if you are successful, your Assessor will summarise your performance during the observations
if you are unsuccessful, your Assessor will:
- provide written feedback on the Observation Check Sheet explaining their justification in detail
- communicate this feedback to you
- arrange another suitable time to observe your second attempt.
BSBHRM405 Student Assessment Guide v4.0 Page 14
Appendix B: Observation Check Sheet
We have provided the Observation Check Sheet for you to prepare for your assessment with the Assessor. Remember,
you will not be able to use this Check Sheet during this session. However, we recommend you use this as a planning
tool so that you are fully prepared for the observation.
Note that you must demonstrate all the criteria listed in the following Observation Check Sheet to be deemed
satisfactory.
Evidence Criteria: 1. Pre-interview:
ensure that the panel members have all documentation
explains clearly the interview process to the panel members
explains the importance of taking individual notes
agrees on roles particularly which questions are asked by panel
agrees on durations
2. Introduction welcomes applicant:
- greet is friendly
- introduces the Selection Panel
- is positive
- builds rapport with the applicant
states objectives of the interview, which are:
- specific and relevant
- achievable
- time framed
explains the format of the interview:
- clear and concise
- covers the structure
- communicates the estimated time of interview
3. Body asks a minimum of three questions:
- questions are aligned to written prepared document
- questions do not breach any legislation or policies and procedures
- any follow-on question is structured, planned and purposeful
- questions are time-framed
- takes notes with applicant responses
- seeks clarification if required
follows a logical structure
covers all pre-planned questions
4. Communication Skills
body language skills demonstrate the following:
- maintains eye contact
- appropriate facial expressions
- posture is appropriate
- gestures fit message (e.g.; nodding the head to confirm understanding)
BSBHRM405 Student Assessment Guide v4.0 Page 15
Evidence Criteria: verbal skills:
- vocal pitch is appropriate
- tone is pleasant
- pace is at the right speed to achieve clarity
- volume is appropriate
sensitive to the cultural diversity of the applicant:
- language avoids jargon
- language chosen is appropriate for task
- level of formality shows respect to applicant
- content is non-sensitive
listening:
- monitors non-verbal and verbal cues and responds to messages with appropriate questions – eg “would
you like me to ask that question again”
- encourages applicant to perform at their best with small verbal comments (e.g.; ‘Yes’, ‘uh huh’)
- asks follow-up questions (e.g.; Why? When? How a situation turned out? etc.)
- does not interrupt when the applicant is talking
5. Negotiation with Selection Panel
requests views and opinions
is attentive when listening
listens patiently and demonstrates respect
is confident, considerate and factual rather than emotional or critical
does not interrupt when a member is talking
tactfully challenges the views expressed by other members
backs up opinions with facts
uses open questions to explore issues
continuously interacts with members and contributes to the discussion
seeks collaboration using encouraging statements (e.g.; ‘May I have your opinion on this?’)
confirms understanding through open-ended questions (e.g.; ‘is this how you see the applicant?’)
exhibits credibility (knows what they are talking about)
negotiates towards finding a mutual ground but is assertive (yet respectful) when necessary
summarises a discussion to aid making a decision (e.g.; ‘do we agree on that now?’)
6. Reaching to a mutual agreement
deals with each selection criteria at a time giving each applicant a rating (poor, moderate, strong)
presents a rating for each applicant
with each rating provides a rationale
reaches agreement over ratings
performs this procedure for all selection criteria
scores the total rating for each applicant and concludes with quantitative decision where possible