DB063

Criteria Ratings Points

Content 20 to >17.0 pts

Advanced

• Major points are clearly articulated and sufficiently supported. • The introduction, summary, critique, and personal response, and conclusion are evident, clear, and concise.

17 to >16.0 pts

Proficient

• Major points are clearly articulated, but not sufficiently supported. • The introduction, summary, critique, and personal response are not clear and concise.

16 to >0.0 pts

Developing

• Major points are not clear, nor are they given sufficient support. • The introduction, summary, critique, and personal response are not evident.

0 pts

Not Present

20 pts

Content

Connections to a Geopolitical Framework

20 to >17.0 pts

Advanced

The student presents at least 7 geopolitically relevant points in the analysis

17 to >16.0 pts

Proficient

The student presents at least 4 – 5 geopolitically relevant points in the analysis

16 to >0.0 pts

Developing

The student presents at least 3 geopolitically relevant points in the analysis

0 pts

Not Present

20 pts

Content

Personal Position and Reflection

20 to >17.0 pts

Advanced

A personal position and reflection, including addressing the main objections of the position, is clearly articulated and appropriate biblical and theological support is integrated.

17 to >16.0 pts

Proficient

A personal position and reflection, including addressing the main objections of the position, is present and appropriate biblical and theological support is integrated.

16 to >0.0 pts

Developing

A personal position and reflection, including addressing the main objections of the position, is present but there is no biblical and theological support present. OR A personal position and reflection, including addressing the main objections is not present, even if biblical support is present.

0 pts

Not Present

20 pts

Content

References

10 to >9.0 pts

Advanced

Quotes from the 5 – 6 books are present and clearly demonstrated.

9 to >7.0 pts

Proficient

Quotes from the 3 – 4book are present.

7 to >0.0 pts

Developing

Quotes from the 0 – 2 books are present.

0 pts

Not Present

10 pts

Book Review Grading Rubric | PPOG506_B02_202140

Criteria Ratings Points

Structure

Formatting

20 to >17.0 pts

Advanced

• Current Turabian guidelines are followed. • The length is 5 – 7 pages. • The review is typed, in 12-point Times New Roman font, double spaced, with 1-inch margins.

17 to >16.0 pts

Proficient

• Current Turabian guidelines are followed with few errors. • The length is 3 – 4 pages. • The review is typed, in 12-point Times New Roman font, double spaced, with 1-inch margins.

16 to >0.0 pts

Developing

• Current Turabian guidelines are not followed or are followed with frequent errors. • The length is fewer than 3 pages. • Any of the following are not present: o Typed review o 12-point font o Times New Roman font o Double spacing o 1-inch margins

0 pts

Not Present

20 pts

Structure

Spelling and Grammar

10 to >9.0 pts

Advanced

There are minimal or no grammatical and/or spelling errors.

9 to >7.0 pts

Proficient

There are some grammatical and/or spelling errors.

7 to >0.0 pts

Developing

There are continuous grammatical and/or spelling errors.

0 pts

Not Present

10 pts

Total Points: 100

Book Review Grading Rubric | PPOG506_B02_202140