Discussion and 3 comments
�
�QO��<j<�Q[��I<YjPE<gI
+g<hP<[j��P<ZGPIgI���IgIZQ<P��<gZhI[��.<<OP<p��IDD<g�� /gQ[<jP�!<[G<Y<dk���hPQhP�!IPg<�²�/kWk�.<W<[
�[��[Gkhjgs�.QNI�qQjP��[INNQEQI[EQIh«
�6RXUFH��2(&'�+HDOWK�6WDWLVWLFV�����
«�[G��g]q[Q[O�Q[��I<YjPE<gI��<j<«
�
����RI�WKH�GDWD�LV� ³XQVWUXFWXUHG´�DQG� VWRUHG�LQ�YHU\�
GLIIHUHQW�IRUPDWV� � LQ�GLIIHUHQW�VLORV�
«7QjP�!<[s��E]hshjIZ�/j<XIP]YGIgh
�
£ Y<QZh�<[G��QYYQ[O £ �ddg]p<Yh�<[G� �I[Q<Yh
£ +]dkY<jQ][��I<YjP� <[G�.QhX
£ +]dkY<jQ][��I<YjP £ +<jQI[j�/QZQY<gQjs £ �gkO��QhE]pIgs�
£ �!.h £ YQ[QE<Y�[]jIh £ !IGQE<Y�QZ<OIh £ YQ[QE<Y�jgQ<Yh £ �I[]ZQEh� £ .Ih]kgEI�<YY]E<jQ][
£ 6Qj<Y�hQO[h £ �EjQpQjs�YIpIYh� £ "kjgQjQ][<Y�G<j< £ �IP<pQ]g<Y�G<j< £ /]EQ<Y�Q[jIg<EjQ][h
+<jQI[jh +g]pQGIgh
+<sIgh +P<gZ<���
�gkO� ]Zd<[QIh
«0P<j�"IIG��QO��<j<��[<YsjQEh
0]�.IGkEI� ]hjh�<[G��Zdg]pI�$kjE]ZIh
�
7RS�8VH� &DVHV�IRU� %LJ�'DWD� $QDO\WLFV
,PSURYH� &OLQLFDO� 7ULDOV
3UHGLFW� 'LVHDVHV
)LQG�&XUHV� �H�J���IRU� &DQFHU�
6WXG\� 3RSXODWLRQ� +HDOWK
3UHYHQW� 'LVHDVHV�
�SURDFWLYHO\�
,PSURYH� &DUH�
(IILFLHQF\� DQG�&RVW�
C
)UDJPHQWHG�� 6LORHG�'DWD
(YLGHQFH�DQG ,QVLJKWV
5HGXFH�&RVWV
,PSURYH�2XWFRPHV 6KDUHG� 'DWD
3HUVRQDOL]HG�FDUH
5LJKW�LQWHUYHQWLRQ
5LJKW�SDWLHQW�
5LJKW�WLPH
+ROLVWLF�EHQHILWV
3DWLHQWV 3URYLGHUV 3D\HUV 3KDUPD�
� �
�
¹Ä�ÃÁÈ0�¥"��¦�Q[�ÃÁÂÆ�¹ÂÃ0�¥"��¦�Q[�ÃÁÃÃ
/Z<gj�!][Is��h��kIYQ[O��QOQj<Y��I<YjP
�
<hI�/jkGs���Zdg]pI� <gI��NNQEQI[Es�<[G� ]hj
È
*RDOV Љ 2SWLPDO�XWLOL]DWLRQ�RI�UHVRXUFHV Љ 5HGXFH�SUHVFULSWLRQ�RI�DQWLELRWLFV�IRU�
FKLOGUHQ� Љ &KDUJHV�EDVHG�RQ�FODLP�SDWWHUQ Љ 5HGXFH�FDUH�FRVW�E\�*HQRPLF�DQDO\WLFV Љ 5HGXFH�FODLP�GHQLDOV�
([DPSOH���/HDQ7DDV� Љ ,PEDODQFH�EHWZHHQ�
,QIXVLRQ�� DSSRLQWPHQW�� VXSSO\�DQG� GHPDQG�
Љ )UHTXHQW�PLG�GD\� SHDNV
Љ 8QSUHGLFWDEOH�ORQJ� ZDLW
Љ 6XE�RSWLPDO� XWLOL]DWLRQ�RI� UHVRXUFHV�
Љ 0DQXDO�DSSURDFK� FDXVHV�RYHU� VWDIILQJ
gIGQjh�� I<[0<hh�E]Z
6WDQIRUG�LQIXVLRQ�WUHDWPHQW�KDQGOLQJ��������FDVHV� DQQXDOO\
&RORUDGR�&DQFHU�&HQWHU�IDFLQJ�PLG�GD\�SHDN� �ORQJ� ZDLW
5HVXOWV�DQG� 7DNHDZD\V 0DFKLQH�OHDUQLQJ� GHOLYHUV�NH\�UHVXOWV 6WDQIRUG�,QIXVLRQ�� Љ ����KLJKHU�
SDWLHQWV��DW����� ORZHU�FRVWV
Љ ����ZDLW�WLPH� UHGXFWLRQ�DW�PLG� GD\��
&RORUDGR�&DQFHU� &HQWHU�� Љ ����KLJKHU�
SDWLHQWV Љ ����ORZHU�RYHUWLPH Љ 6LJQLILFDQW�VWDII�
VDWLVIDFWLRQ
�
<hI�/jkGs���QhI<hI�+gIGQEjQ][
�
�<j<�/]kgEIh�<[G��QO��<j<��[<YsjQEh�+Y<jN]gZ � �Ij[<�h�G<j<D<hI�]N�ÄÈ��Q[GQpQGk<Yh � �IZ]Og<dPQE�¥<OI��D]Gs�Z<hh�Q[GIr�IjE�¦ � !IGQE<Y�EY<QZ��dP<gZ<Es�EY<QZ � <D]g<j]gs�jIhj�<[G��Q]ZIjgQEh�I[OQ[IIgQ[O�gIhkYjh � �"/��I<YjPE<gI��[<YsjQEh�dY<jN]gZ�N]g�<EEkg<jI�
dgIGQEjQ][�]N�Q[jIgpI[jQ][�]kjE]ZIh
�D]kj�!Ij<D]YQE�/s[Gg]ZI� � +I]dYI�qQjP�jPgII�]g�Z]gI�]N�jPIhI�gQhX�N<Ej]gh�P<pI�ZIj<D]YQE�
hs[Gg]ZI��Q[hkYQ[�gIhQhj<[EI��PQOP��+��PQOP�jgQOYsEIgQGIh��Y]q� ��
� !]gI�jP<[�][I�Q[�jPgII�1�/��<GkYjh�P<pI�ZIj<D]YQE�hs[Gg]ZI � !Ij<D]YQE�hs[Gg]ZI�Q[EgI<hIh�gQhXh�]N�PI<gj�GQhI<hI��hjg]XI�
<[G�GQ<DIjIh���j�Qh�E]hjYs�j]�jgI<j�
.IhkYjh � .IpIghI�I[OQ[IIgQ[O�<[G��]gq<gG�hQZkY<jQ][�
¥.��/¦��E<[�YI<g[�Z]GIYh�GQgIEjYs�Ng]Z�G<j<� qPQEP�E<djkgI�jPI�k[GIgYsQ[O�ZIEP<[QhZh�<[G� dg]EIhhIh�E][hQhjI[j�qQjP�jPI�G<j<
� �I[Ig<jIG�Q[GQpQGk<Y�Q[hQOPjh��qQjP�<EEkg<Es � �IpIY]dIG�j<gOIjIG�E]hj�INNIEjQpI�E<gI�
Z<[<OIZI[j�dg]Og<Zh�N]g�Q[GQpQGk<Yh�qQjP�]g� <j�gQhX�N]g�ZIj<D]YQE�hs[Gg]ZI
�]<Y� �EEkg<jIYs�dgIGQEj�hkDhIfkI[j�gQhX�]N�ZIj<D]YQE� hs[Gg]ZI�<[G�Qjh�p<gQ]kh�N<Ej]gh�][�D]jP�d]dkY<jQ][�<[G� Q[GQpQGk<Y�YIpIY
�
<hI�/jkGs���QhI<hI�+gIpI[jQ][
�
$DWIEjQpIh � +gIpI[j�GQhI<hIh�<[G�GIYQpIg�Z]gI�INNIEjQpI ������PI<YjPE<gI�jPg]kOP�dg]<EjQpI�Q[jIgpI[jQ][ ������<[G�YQNIhjsYI�EP<[OIh� � �[NIg�Q[hQOPjh�Ng]Z�d<jQI[j�G<j<�<[G�E]ggIY<jI ������qQjP�d]dkY<jQ][�PI<YjP � +<jQI[j�G<j<��dg]NQYI��pQj<Y�hQO[h��<EjQpQjs��GQIj� ������hYIId��dPshQ]Y]OQE<Y�<[G�DIP<pQ]g<Y�Q[GQE<j]gh
+Y<sIgh � 7IYYj]X�¥hj<gjkd�qQjP�à¹ÂÅÆ!�g<QhIG¦�� ������ <NKqIYY� ][EQIgOI�<[G��[hQOPjh�<ddh�N]g������� ������dIgh][<YQvIG�PI<YjP�h]YkjQ][h�N]g�IpIgsG<s ������E][hkZIgh
� ��!�7<jh][��I<YjP���E]O[QjQpI�E]ZdkjQ[O�� D<EXI[G�Q[�jPI�EY]kG
�[O<OIZI[j�<[G��[<YsjQEh�+Y<jN]gZ � <NIqIYY��I<YjP�$djQZQv<jQ][�+Y<jN]gZ � �]g�d]dkY<jQ][�PI<YjP�Z<[<OIgh�<[G�E][hkZIgh � +Igh][<YQvIG�dY<[�jP<j�I[O<OIh�E][hkZIgh�Q[�
PI<YjPs�DIP<pQ]gh�pQ<�gIq<gGh��hjgI<ZYQ[IG� E]ZZk[QE<jQ][��<EjQ][<DYI�Q[hQOPjh
� �[jIYYQOI[j��I<YjP��jQ[Ig<gs� �<EjQ][�dY<[�qQjP� gIE]ZZI[G<jQ][h�jP<j�OIj�DIjjIg�qQjP�khI�<[G� ]pIg�jQZI
� 7<jh][��I<YjP�dY<jN]gZ�dg]pQGIh�[<jkg<Y� Y<[Ok<OI�dg]EIhhQ[O�j]�<hhIhh�khIg�h�<EjQpQjs� O]<Yh�<[G�dg]pQGI�dg]Zdjh
.IhkYjh � /j<jI�]N� ]Y]g<G]�I[O<OIZI[j� � ]�hd][h]gIG�Ds�1[QjIG��I<YjPE<gI�<[G��<QhIg � ÆÁÚ�d<gjQEQd<jQ][�Q[�dg]Og<Z � ÇÆÁÚ�Q[EgI<hI�Q[�PI<YjP�<hhIhhZI[j�E]ZdYIjQ][ � ¹ÂÁÁ��<q<gGIG�N]g�PI<YjPs�DIP<pQ]gh� � $jPIg�hkEEIhhNkY�g]YY]kjh�qQjP� I[jkg<��I<YjP�� ������ ]ZZk[Qjs��I<YjP�+Y<[�¥7<hPQ[Oj][¦�� ]pI[jgs� �������I<YjP�ZIgQE<
�
ÂÁ
:DWVRQ� +HDOWK
+LQGVDLW� *RRJOH� &ORXG
�<j<��[<YsjQEh���!<EPQ[I� I<g[Q[O������+Y<jN]gZh�<[G�/IgpQEIh
3K\V,4 2SWXP
+<jQI[jh +g]pQGIgh +<sIgh
$SS $SS $SS
�I<YjP�Qj <gI�Qj.IhI<gEP�Qj
7I<g<DYIh ²�/I[h]gh
,QRYDORQ +ROGLQJV
$PDUD
�<j<� �OOgIO<jQ][� +Y<jN]gZh�
�<j<�/P<gQ[O� �[QjQ<jQpIh
(05 &ODLP V
%LOOLQJ
�ZIgOQ[O� <[GhE<dI����QOQj<Y��I<YjP��]YG�.khP
/HDQ7D DV
*16
+<jQI[j��[O<OIZI[j� +Y<jN]gZh�<[G�/IgpQEIh
.IhI<gEP�/jkGQIh�<[G� YQ[QE<Y�0gQ<Yh
/Z<gjdP][I� YQI[jh�¥Q$/¦
���
2PDGD
&OLQLFD O�1RWHV
5HVRXUF H�8VDJH
�<j<
�[hQOPjh
�[�ÃÁÂÅ��ZIGQE<Y�gIE]gGh�<EE]k[jIG�N]g�ÅÄÚ�]N�<YY�G<j<�hj]YI[�<[G�jPI� PI<YjPE<gI�hIEj]g�P<h�hII[�jPI�DQOOIhj�Q[EgI<hI�Q[�G<j<�jPINj�hQ[EI� ÃÁÂÁ�¥N<g�Z]gI�h]�jP<[�DkhQ[Ihh�]g�O]pIg[ZI[j�hIEj]gh¦�
/P<gI�qQjP� <gI���]g� <jEP�!I��N�9]k� <[
��
�3ULYDF\ �NHHS� VHFXUH�
2ZQHUVKLS �ZKR� RZQV"�
$FFXUDF\ �QRLVH"�
5HOHYDQFH� �WRR�PXFK"�
0LVXVH �SHQDOL]H"�
�gI�7I�0PIgI�9Ij�« ][O�.]<G���kZds�.QGI���
ÂÃ
7KH�EHVW�ZD\�WR�SUHGLFW�WKH�IXWXUH� LV�WR�FUHDWH�LW�
��$EUDKDP�/LQFROQ�DQG�3HWHU�'UXFNHU
/LNHO\�:LQQHUV�DQG�/RVHUV 3DWLHQWV�ZLOO�ZLQ�EXW�PLJKW�SD\�PRUH
%HWWHU��PRUH�HIILFLHQW��DQG�WLPHO\�FDUH�ZLWK�PRUH�FKRLFHV 0LJKW�SD\�KLJKHU�SUHPLXPV�EDVHG�RQ�ILWQHVV�DQG�OLIHVW\OH� GDWD��IRU�SRRU�FKRLFHV�
3URYLGHUV�±�KRVSLWDOV�ZLOO�ZLQ�EXW�GRFWRUV�FRXOG�VHH�WUDGHRIIV +LJKHU�HIILFLHQFLHV�DQG�ORZHU�FRVWV 6RPH�VSHFLDOWLHV�ZLOO�EHQHILW��EXW�QRW�DOO 3ULYDWH�SUDFWLFHV�PD\�VWUXJJOH���ORVH ³,QWHOOLJHQW�PDFKLQHV´�PD\�FRPSOHPHQW�GRFWRUV��EXW�DOVR�VTXHH]H�WKHP� PRUH
3D\HUV�±�LQVXUDQFH�FRPSDQLHV�FRXOG�ZLQ�EXW�LW�GHSHQGV 'HSHQGV�RQ�PL[�RI�KHDOWK\�YV�XQKHDOWK\�SRSXODWLRQ
�<EX�0]�0PI�¥�I<YjPs¦��kjkgI
��
2���"
ÂÅ