FINAL EXAM
Abused and Abusive Partners in Understudied Populations
Cross-Cultural, Immigrant/Ethnic/Racial, Rural, Same-Sex, and Military Groups
Chapter 10
*
Cross-Cultural Intimate Partner Violence
- “Violence against women stretches across the globe and has existed throughout history.” (Barnett, p. 470)
- Recognition of the problem is not universal
- Lack of economic support strongly correlated to male intimate partner violence
- Immigrant status is associated with male assaultiveness
- Alcohol is highly associated with family violence
Family Violence Across the Lifespan, 3rd Edition
© 2011SAGE Publications
© 2011SAGE Publications
*
Cross-Cultural Intimate Partner Violence
- Chaos generated by wars or civil unrest inflates the level of violence
- Pro-violence attitudes related to male partner violence
- Lack of legal protection permits male partner violence
- Gender inequality plays a major role
- Women are as likely or as more likely than men to believe that wife beating is justified
Family Violence Across the Lifespan, 3rd Edition
© 2011SAGE Publications
© 2011SAGE Publications
*
Cross-Cultural Intimate Partner Violence
- Fundamentalist dogma across different religions appears to be at the core of a large share of violence against women
- The mental model of the good wife and the good daughter may help explain the acceptance of male violence in many South Asian societies
- Social role theory explains all cross-cultural data
Family Violence Across the Lifespan, 3rd Edition
© 2011SAGE Publications
© 2011SAGE Publications
*
- Prevalence of husband-to-wife partner violence in:
- Africa
- Broad range of female behaviors cited as justification for violence
- Intergenerational violence created as a result of witnessing violence
- Asia
- Women lack the most basic rights concerning their own bodies in many Asian countries
- Korea-power structure and partner violence
- Korea-patriarchal husbands
- India-dowry murders
- Nepal-attitudes toward women seem medieval (untouchables)
Family Violence Across the Lifespan, 3rd Edition
© 2011SAGE Publications
© 2011SAGE Publications
*
- Southern Asia-poverty contributes to violence
- Bangladesh-acid throwing
- China-jealousy
- Hong Kong (Chinese definition of IPV)
- Vietnam-attitudes toward gender
- Australia, New Zealand, and Pacific Islanders-risk of partner violence is increased as a result of marginalization in immigrant group in those countries
- Afghanistan, Pakistan, and Tajikistan
- Treatment and attitudes toward women are affected by fundamentalist Muslim beliefs
- Afghanistan-the Taliban
Family Violence Across the Lifespan, 3rd Edition
© 2011SAGE Publications
© 2011SAGE Publications
*
- Middle East
- Human rights abuses against women are rampant
- Honor societies
- Egypt-wife beating the result of cultural tradition that beating is justified
- Israel-pro-violent attitudes prevalent
- Palestine-strong approval of wife beating by both men (60.1%) and women (61.8%)
- Health professionals-collusion in a conspiracy of silence about violence against women
- Europe
- Efforts and responses to intimate partner violence across European continent lagged behind United States
Family Violence Across the Lifespan, 3rd Edition
© 2011SAGE Publications
© 2011SAGE Publications
*
- Russia
- Little research on male-to-female partner violence
- Risk factors include alcoholism and male partner’s exposure to his father’s physical abuse of his mother
- Latin America
- Patriarchal practices and machismo are strong contributors to male-to-female violence
- Mexican pregnant women
- Mexican social tie-not supportive and foster women’s victimization
- North America
- United States, Canada and Greenland have recognized male-to-female intimate partner violence as a social problem
Family Violence Across the Lifespan, 3rd Edition
© 2011SAGE Publications
© 2011SAGE Publications
*
Immigrant and Ethnic/Racial Intimate Partner Violence
- Woman’s decisions about partner abuse are filtered through cultural lens
- Immigrants: understanding worldview is key
- Collectivism or individualism
- Ethnic/Racial minorities
- Laws affecting immigrant women
- Cultural insensitivity and the law
- Prevalence of intimate partner violence among racial/ethnic groups
Family Violence Across the Lifespan, 3rd Edition
© 2011SAGE Publications
© 2011SAGE Publications
*
Immigrant and Ethnic/Racial Intimate Partner Violence
- Distinctive features of immigrants and minority intimate partner violence
- African Americans: economic distress and residency in socially disadvantaged neighborhood are key factors
- Arab Americans: patriarchal beliefs
- Native American Indians: historical racism affects aspects of their lives; limited access to services
Family Violence Across the Lifespan, 3rd Edition
© 2011SAGE Publications
© 2011SAGE Publications
*
Immigrant and Ethnic/Racial Intimate Partner Violence
- Asian Americans
- Strong cultural beliefs
- May not see partner’s violence as abusive
- Haitian immigrants
- Experiences and witnessing acts of violence affects incidence of intimate partner violence
- Wife beating is normal and occurs openly
- Latinos
- Latinas face many barriers: disclosure, language, fear of deportation and poverty
Family Violence Across the Lifespan, 3rd Edition
© 2011SAGE Publications
© 2011SAGE Publications
*
Immigrant and Ethnic/Racial Intimate Partner Violence
- Disclosure patterns
- Trait comparisons
- Gender trait comparison
- Differences among Latina partner-violent offenders
- Immigrant and ethnic batterers
- Motives for intimate partner violence
- Motives for female-to-male IPV
- Motives for African American female-to-male (FMIPV)
Family Violence Across the Lifespan, 3rd Edition
© 2011SAGE Publications
© 2011SAGE Publications
*
Immigrant and Ethnic/Racial Intimate Partner Violence
- Differences in attitudes toward the criminal justice system
- Calling the police
- Police behavior
- Consequences of male-to-female intimate partner violence
- Health problems
- Mental Health problems
- African Americans, Hispanics, and other races
- White, African Americans, and Latinas
- Latinos vs. non-Latinos
Family Violence Across the Lifespan, 3rd Edition
© 2011SAGE Publications
© 2011SAGE Publications
*
Immigrant and Ethnic/Racial Intimate Partner Violence
- Social support
- Asian women
- Latinas
- Differences in leave/stay decisions
- African American women
- Vietnamese women
- Mexican American
Family Violence Across the Lifespan, 3rd Edition
© 2011SAGE Publications
© 2011SAGE Publications
*
Rural Male-to-Female Intimate Partner Violence
- Law enforcement
- Several disadvantages face by women: distances, “good old boys network,” and anti-woman and anti-victim criminal justice system
- Male-to female intimate partner violence
- Designed as “intimate terrorism”
- Socio-demographic comparisons
- Socio-demographic profile similar to urban women except for age
- Help-seeking and services available
- Help seeking
- Coping strategies
Family Violence Across the Lifespan, 3rd Edition
© 2011SAGE Publications
© 2011SAGE Publications
*
Same-Sex Intimate Partner Violence (SSIPV)
- Same-sex IPV definitions
- Legal definitions
- Protective orders
- The genesis of homosexuality and the causes of violence
- Estimating the prevalence/incidence of same sex IPV
- Measurement
- Prevalence of same-sex IPV
Family Violence Across the Lifespan, 3rd Edition
© 2011SAGE Publications
© 2011SAGE Publications
*
Same-Sex Intimate Partner Violence (SSIPV)
- Official reports
- Estimates of same-sex IPV
- Reporting/disclosing same-sex IPV and crimes
- Partner violence
- Lesbians and public attitudes
- Attitudes of the public toward same-sex partner abuse
- Sexual orientation and faith leaders
Family Violence Across the Lifespan, 3rd Edition
© 2011SAGE Publications
© 2011SAGE Publications
*
Same-Sex Intimate Partner Violence (SSIPV)
- Individuals differences (traits) of homosexuals
- Dynamics of abusive lesbian relationship
- Consequences of same-sex intimate partner violence
- Responses of same-sex victims
- Leaving among lesbian women
Family Violence Across the Lifespan, 3rd Edition
© 2011SAGE Publications
© 2011SAGE Publications
*
The Military and Intimate Partner Violence
- IPV is similar to and different from those found in nonmilitary communities
- Differences center around the following:
- Post-traumatic stress disorder
- Relationship between PTSD and IPV
- Categorizing IPV offenders
- Responses to IPV and in the capacity to institute prevention measures
Family Violence Across the Lifespan, 3rd Edition
© 2011SAGE Publications
© 2011SAGE Publications
*