MODULE 3 BACKGROUND - EMPLOYMENT-AT-WILL AND PROGRESSIVE DISCIPLINE

5/15/2021 At-Will Employment—How Does It Apply to Your Business Today? | HR Exchange Network

https://www.hrexchangenetwork.com/employment-law/columns/at-will-employment-how-does-it-apply-to-your-busin 1/4

+Filter Categories

At-Will Employment—How Does It Apply to Your Business Today? � Add bookmark

Devora Lindeman � 05/10/2010

I recently mentioned to a colleague that I wished clients would call me before they fired the pregnant employee. No disrespect intended to pregnant ladies here (having been one myself—twice). However, one of my goals in life seems to be to get employers to understand that they can take certain actions when disciplining and discharging employees that can likely provide them with legal protections should the employee (pregnant or otherwise) determine to sue claiming that his or her termination was wrongful. But, understanding what those actions might be involves calling their lawyer before firing the employee. Calling afterwards to tell me that "I fired Jenna today for always missing her deadlines—by the way, she told me last week that she was pregnant and wanted to know what our maternity leave policy was, but I told her I had to get back to her about that," may be too late. In trying to impress the "call me before" point upon clients, what do I hear? "She was employed at-will. I can fire her at any time, for any reason, can’t I?" "Well," I, the lawyer, try to calmly respond, ". . . maybe." Most states in the U.S. still recognize the doctrine of "at will" employment—that employment that exists at the will of the employer and the employee. As long as both sides want the relationship to continue (as long as they "will" it), it will continue. When one no longer wants to be part of that relationship, the law allows the employee to quit at any time, and the employer to fire the employee at any time, for any reason, without cause or notice. At-will employees can be fired for a good reason, bad reason, or no reason at all . . . but not for a discriminatory reason. "But, but," my client stammered, "Jenna was not fired for a discriminatory reason. She was fired because she could never meet a deadline." Perhaps—but she was also fired right after she advised you that she was pregnant, asked about maternity benefits, and you had yet to answer that question. In other words, employee discharges not only need to not be discriminatory, but they also can not appear to be discriminatory. What do you think Jenna is going to tell her state’s fair employment practices agency when she files a discriminatory discharge claim? Here’s how it will work:

Jenna: I was illegally fired because I was pregnant. Client: You are at will; I can fire you whenever I want. Court/Lawyer: Jenna claims she is fired for a discriminatory reason. Even if she is at will, you can not fire her for a discriminatory reason. You need a legitimate, business reason to counter her claim of discrimination. What’s your reason? Client: She missed deadlines. Court/Lawyer: OK. What is your proof of that? Client: (Will either present the proof . . . or will not have any proof because client failed to document and/or failed to take necessary counseling or other actions prior to the termination. The difference in being able to defend against such claims is often dependant on whether the client called their employment lawyer before terminating this employee’s employment.)

"So why do I have to be so careful not to destroy my employees’ at-will status if it doesn’t mean anything?" wails the client. "Because," I, the lawyer, sigh, "it does mean something." Here’s why: Let’s say the client has proof of the missing deadlines; sufficiently shows the termination was not discriminatory; Jenna

Tags: Employment Lawyer At-Will Employment Maternity Leave Policy Discriminatory Devora Lindeman

We use cookies and similar technologies to recognize your visits and preferences, as well as to measure the effectiveness of campaigns and analyze traffic.

To learn more about cookies, including how to disable them, view our Cookie Policy Close

5/15/2021 At-Will Employment—How Does It Apply to Your Business Today? | HR Exchange Network

https://www.hrexchangenetwork.com/employment-law/columns/at-will-employment-how-does-it-apply-to-your-busin 2/4

cannot show that her termination was motivated by her pregnancy; so the client wins the discriminatory discharge claim. But wait, claims Jenna, missing deadlines is not a good enough reason to fire an employee! Now what? If Jenna is at-will and employer has done nothing to destroy the at-will relationship: Claim dismissed. Client does not need a "good enough" reason to fire Jenna. She’s at-will and could be fired for good reason, bad reason or no reason at all. But what if Jenna is not at-will: The court could go on to determine whether the reason was "good enough," and whether Jenna should have been fired. It could determine that the reason was not good enough and that, even though the client won the discrimination claim, the client loses the wrongful termination claim and either needs to reinstate the employee or pay her monetary damages (or both). This result is not inconceivable. So, yes, being at-will matters. The moral of the story is—employment lawyers can be useful before you get legal claims. Human Resource professionals and employment lawyers can work as a team to strengthen the company’s legal protections. Call your employment lawyer before terminating employees where there are potential risks of legal claims associated with the termination. The fact that the employee is at-will will not prevent that employee from asserting a discrimination claim, valid or otherwise. Companies need to be smart. Let your employment lawyer help you set up potential defenses against those employee claims which are becoming ever more prevalent in these interesting times.

�Upcoming Events The Science of Employee Experience 18 May, 2021 Online

Register Now | Learn More

Collaborate, Learn and Work Better in the Hybrid Workplace 25 May, 2021 Online

Register Now | Learn More

CHRO Exchange - Future of Work May 26, 2021

Register Now | View Agenda | Learn More

HR Tech Live APAC June 08 - 09, 2021 100% Online

Register Now | Learn More

HR Shared Services June 08 - 10, 2021 Online Event

Register Now | View Agenda | Learn More

Reimagining the Gen Z Candidate Experience in a Virtual World 08 June, 2021 Online

Register Now | Learn More

MORE EVENTS

Follow Us

         

Subscribe to our Free Newsletter Insights from the world’s foremost thought leaders delivered to your inbox.

We use cookies and similar technologies to recognize your visits and preferences, as well as to measure the effectiveness of campaigns and analyze traffic.

To learn more about cookies, including how to disable them, view our Cookie Policy Close

5/15/2021 At-Will Employment—How Does It Apply to Your Business Today? | HR Exchange Network

https://www.hrexchangenetwork.com/employment-law/columns/at-will-employment-how-does-it-apply-to-your-busin 3/4

RECOMMENDED

RECOMMENDED

SUBSCRIBE

Latest Webinars What You Need to Know About the State of Skills in 2021 � 2021-06-17 � 02:00 PM - 03:00 PM EST

Join Degreed as they share insights from their State of Skills report and highlight where you need t...

How to Keep Employees Engaged When Managing Distributed Teams � 2021-06-16 � 02:00 PM - 03:00 PM AEST

Distributed teams are quickly becoming a key aspect of the new normal, but keeping those teams engag...

Reimagining the Gen Z Candidate Experience in a Virtual World � 2021-06-08 � 02:00 PM - 03:00 PM EST

Recruitment strategies had to change during COVID-19 and that has made reaching viable candidates mo...

MORE WEBINARS

Accommodating an Employee's Religion—Having the Necessary Conversations

� 2012-09-04

By Devora Lindeman

Accommodating an Employee's Religion— Having the Necessary Conversations

� 2012-09-04

By Devora Lindeman

The Social Media Password Debate

� 2012-04-12

By Devora Lindeman

9 Tips to Keep Your Legal Bills Down

� 2011-09-09

By Devora Lindeman

When Your Employee Won't Sign

� 2011-08-18

By Devora Lindeman

< >

< >

We use cookies and similar technologies to recognize your visits and preferences, as well as to measure the effectiveness of campaigns and analyze traffic.

To learn more about cookies, including how to disable them, view our Cookie Policy Close

5/15/2021 At-Will Employment—How Does It Apply to Your Business Today? | HR Exchange Network

https://www.hrexchangenetwork.com/employment-law/columns/at-will-employment-how-does-it-apply-to-your-busin 4/4

FIND CONTENT BY TYPE

News Articles Videos Interviews Podcasts Webinars White Papers Infographics Reports Columns

HR EXCHANGE NETWORK COMMUNITY

Contact Us About Us Advertise with us User Agreement Cookie Policy Become a Member Today Sponsorship - Online Events

ADVERTISE WITH US Reach HR professionals through cost-effective marketing opportunities to deliver your message, position yourself as a thought leader, and introduce new products, techniques and strategies to the market.

LEARN MORE JOIN THE HR EXCHANGE NETWORK COMMUNITY Join HR Exchange Network today and interact with a vibrant network of professionals, keeping up to date with the industry by accessing our wealth of articles, videos, live conferences and more.

SIGN UP TODAY!

HR Exchange Network, a division of IQPC © 2021 All rights reserved. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy.

Careers With IQPC | Contact Us | About Us | Cookie Policy

           

We use cookies and similar technologies to recognize your visits and preferences, as well as to measure the effectiveness of campaigns and analyze traffic.

To learn more about cookies, including how to disable them, view our Cookie Policy Close