expert

Criteria Ratings Points

Identification of Strategic Problem(s) and/or Issue(s)

25 to >22.0 pts

Advanced

All strategic problems/issues faced by the organization are clearly identified.

22 to >20.0 pts

Proficient

Most of the strategic problems/issues faced by the organization are identified.

20 to >0.0 pts

Developing

Some of the strategic problems/issues faced by the organization are identified.

0 pts

Not Present

A few, if any, of the strategic problems/issues faced by the organization are identified.

25 pts

Assessment of Strategy Improvement

30 to >27.0 pts

Advanced

Includes a superior assessment of how the organization’s executives could have improved the strategy for change management.

27 to >24.0 pts

Proficient

Includes an assessment of how the organization’s executives could have improved the strategy for change management.

24 to >0.0 pts

Developing

Marginally includes an assessment of how the organization’s executives could have improved the strategy for change management.

0 pts

Not Present

Does not include an assessment of how the organization’s executives could have improved the strategy for change management.

30 pts

Recommendation of Next Steps

25 to >22.0 pts

Advanced

Clearly provides recommendations for next steps in strategic action grounded in current literature or best practices.

22 to >20.0 pts

Proficient

Provides recommendations for next steps in strategic action grounded in current literature or best practices.

20 to >0.0 pts

Developing

Marginally provides recommendations for next steps in strategic action grounded in current literature or best practices.

0 pts

Not Present

Does not provide recommendations for next steps in strategic action grounded in current literature or best practices.

25 pts

Assurance of Learning Case Study: Hospital Reengineering Grading Rubric | BUSI691_B01_202230

Criteria Ratings Points

Supported by Current Literature and Industry Best Practices

25 to >22.0 pts

Advanced

All 5 supporting references are scholarly and have been peer reviewed within the last 5 years plus the course textbook and Bible are included.

22 to >20.0 pts

Proficient

Most of the supporting references, excluding the textbook, are scholarly and have been peer reviewed within the last 5 years, and/or fewer than 5 references are included. The course textbook and Bible are included.

20 to >0.0 pts

Developing

Some of the supporting references, excluding the textbook, are scholarly and/or have been peer reviewed within the last 5 years, and/or fewer than 4 references are included. The course textbook and/or Bible is not included.

0 pts

Not Present

Less than half of the supporting references are scholarly and/or have been peer reviewed within the last 5 years, or fewer than three references are included. The course textbook and/or Bible is not included.

25 pts

Page Length 15 to >13.0 pts

Advanced

Explained in at least 5 pages.

13 to >12.0 pts

Proficient

Explained in 3-4 pages.

12 to >0.0 pts

Developing

Explained in 2 pages.

0 pts

Not Present

Explained in 1 or fewer pages.

15 pts

APA Formatting 15 to >13.0 pts

Advanced

No APA formatting issues are identified.

13 to >12.0 pts

Proficient

One or two APA formatting issues are identified.

12 to >0.0 pts

Developing

Three to five APA formatting issues are identified.

0 pts

Not Present

Six or more APA formatting issues are identified.

15 pts

Grammar and Spelling

15 to >13.0 pts

Advanced

No grammar and/or spelling issues are identified.

13 to >12.0 pts

Proficient

One or two grammar and/or spelling issues are identified.

12 to >0.0 pts

Developing

Between three and five grammar and/or spelling issues are identified.

0 pts

Not Present

At least six grammar and/or spelling issues are identified.

15 pts

Total Points: 150

Assurance of Learning Case Study: Hospital Reengineering Grading Rubric | BUSI691_B01_202230