SMGT 621 - Article Review: Coaching Philosophy Assignment

Criteria Ratings Points

Summary 35 to >31.0 pts

Advanced

The summary fully includes: the purpose of the article and EITHER a description of participants/sample, research design, methods (if applicable) OR an overview of the conceptual ideas proffered in the paper (if applicable).

31 to >28.0 pts

Proficient

The summary partially includes: the purpose of the article and EITHER a description of participants/sample, research design, methods (if applicable) OR an overview of the conceptual ideas proffered in the paper (if applicable).

28 to >0.0 pts

Developing

The summary vaguely includes all of the required items listed below OR some of the required items listed below are missing: the purpose of the article and EITHER a description of participants/sample, research design, methods (if applicable) OR an overview of the conceptual ideas proffered in the paper (if applicable).

0 pts

Not Present

35 pts

Analysis 35 to >31.0 pts

Advanced

The analysis fully includes: opportunities for further research not already stated in the article; application to your context of coaching, both philosophical and practical; other original insight or criticism; and implications of the findings and/or concepts.

31 to >28.0 pts

Proficient

The analysis partially includes: opportunities for further research not already stated in the article; application to your context of coaching, both philosophical and practical; other original insight or criticism; and implications of the findings and/or concepts.

28 to >0.0 pts

Developing

The analysis vaguely includes all of the required items listed below OR some of the required items listed below are missing: opportunities for further research not already stated in the article; application to your context of coaching, both philosophical and practical; other original insight or criticism; and implications of the findings and/or concepts.

0 pts

Not Present

35 pts

Format 10 to >9.0 pts

Advanced

• Current APA guidelines are followed. • Assignment is 2 pages.

9 to >7.0 pts

Proficient

• Current APA guidelines are followed with few errors. • Assignment is 1 page.

7 to >0.0 pts

Developing

• Current APA guidelines followed with frequent errors or not followed. • Assignment is less than 1 page.

0 pts

Not Present

10 pts

Grammar, Structure, and Spelling

10 to >9.0 pts

Advanced

Article Review is well-written with correct word choices, good phrasing, few grammatical errors, and few spelling errors.

9 to >7.0 pts

Proficient

Article Review is well-written with a few errors with word choice, phrasing, grammar, and/or spelling; errors do not distract or detract from the overall meaning.

7 to >0.0 pts

Developing

The assignment is poorly written. There are numerous errors with word choices, phrasing, grammar, and/or spelling; errors distract and detract from the overall meaning.

0 pts

Not Present

10 pts

Article Review Grading Rubric | SMGT621_B01_202130

Criteria Ratings Points

Article Details

10 to >9.0 pts

Advanced

• The article is published within the past 5 years. • The article is relevant to the course.

9 to >7.0 pts

Proficient

The article is published within the past 6–7 years or the article is somewhat relevant to the course.

7 to >0.0 pts

Developing

The article is published within the past 8–9 years and/or the article is not clearly relevant to the course.

0 pts

Not Present

10 pts

Total Points: 100

Article Review Grading Rubric | SMGT621_B01_202130