Article

Article-ReviewRubric-Tagged.pdf

Rubric for Article Review

Task Description: Select an article relating to one of the five strands of Reading (Phonemic Awareness, Phonics, Reading Fluency, Vocabulary, Comprehension).

Criteria Points Exemplary Effective Minimal Unsatisfactory

Content of Review

 25  In depth and well organized content

 Meets length requirement with quality content

 Excellent summary

 Content is adequately organized and comprehensive

 Length requirement is met with adequate content

 Adequate summary

 Content is minimally organized

 Length requirement is not met; minimal content

 Basic summary

 Content is not organized  Length requirement is

not met; poor content  Incomplete summary  Evidence of plagiarism

Appropria te Topic

 25  Relevant to assigned subject matter and peer interest

 Article content exceeds requirements

 Relevant to assigned subject matter

 Article content meets expectations

 Minimal relevance to assigned subject matter

 Article content fails to meet all requirements

 Not relevant to assigned subject matter

 Fails to meet content requirements

Significan ce to Class / Relativity to Class

 25  Article has great significance

 Student summary exceeds average peer perspective and understanding

 Student displays understanding of article’s relevance to topic

 Article has some significance

 Student summary meets project expectations

 Some understanding of article’s relevance to topic

 Article has little significance

 Summary meets minimal expectations

 Little understanding of article’s relevance to topic

 Article has no significance

 Summary does not meet minimal expectations

 No understanding of article’s relevance

Article Submissio n

 25  Article printed/copied and effectively displayed on 8½ x 11 paper

 Display of article includes correct citation

 Article printed/copied and displayed on 8 ½ x 1 paper

 Display of article includes correct citation

 Article attached to summary

 Partial documentation of article

 No article

Final Score ________________