Art Appreciation
Medlock – Art Exp Refl Paper 1
Art Experience Reflection Paper
It is time to visit an art museum! If we were meeting in person, this would be an in-person visit*, & most major cities have an art museum; for our online class, the visit can be a virtual tour! You will virtually visit a visual art museum to view exhibits & reflect on 1. the overall experience as well as 2. a focused experience with one work of art. Your visit must be from this current semester (do not write about a previous visit prior to this course unless you want to re-visit a museum you have been to in person before).
GUIDELINES: tips & how to get started 1. Plan your tour: research what museums / galleries you have
available; use the list provided (you can go off-listing if you check with the instructor). artsandculture.google is fine to use IF you tour an actual art museum: google lets you streetview through several art museums around the world! – this does NOT include one of their articles about artworks).
2. Link to main official list: https://www.travelandleisure.com/attractions/museums- galleries/museums-with-virtual-tours
3. View the entire museum exhibit(s) – permanent collection &/or temporary exhibits. Describe this. 4. Choose one work of art to focus your essay about. Follow the DAIJ format (explained below). 5. Resources as keys to success!: 1. Follow the Content Structure below to write your paper. 2. Read
the rubric to see how it will be graded. 3. Look at the supplemental file “Art Crit Step-by-Step” for a lengthy detailed approach of what to include if you like hints & prompts (if this is overwhelming, don’t use it; it’s meant to walk people through details they might not have considered).
6. Format: Write a 1000-1200 word count paper (about 2-4p). The paper should be typed, double- spaced, using a clear professional 12-point font. Your name, date, & paper title should be at the top, page numbers at the bottom, word count at the end.
7. Edit the final draft carefully. Use spell check & grammar check, also re-read (aloud is best) your work carefully to check for mistakes; a peer review is wise: ask someone to read your paper. Please do not use contractions (like “don’t”) in an academic paper, & keep your tone formal not casual. Avoid “I think / I belive” and just state your case and support it. Keep your own personal tone and be creative, but not casual. Research and cite your sources (see above).
8. Submit this, titled Essay-Name.pdf to the appropriate Dropbox folder under Assignments in D2L; as usual, late papers will have points deducted.
9. Write in your own words, using the art criticism format below (DAIJ: Describe, Analyze, Interpret, Judge), based on your own experience, educated from what you learned in class. Plagiarism is not tolerated, simply write in your own words & cite your sources for quotes & research.
10. Photos: include 1+ (screenshot or download, copy/paste, & cite your photo source – your own photo, web link, etc.), mention your photos in your writing to make connections.
*BONUS OPP: if you are able to visit an art museum in person for this assignment, upload in the Dropbox Bonus folder 4+ photos (where permitted in the museum) including one of your ticket, & include yourself in some of the photos at the museum. Up to 30 additional points. If you are in the Nashville area, the Frist or Cheekwood are great options. Frist has some free nights for students; check websites for info on prices, times, parking, covid policies, etc. These museums have world-famous exhibits.
Medlock – Art Exp Refl Paper 2
CONTENT STRUCTURE: (modified from Prof Alana Taylor, Alabama State University) Listed below are summaries of expected content each section. See the “Art Crit Step-by-Step” file for detailed instructions on what to look for in each section if you like helps, hints, prompts. You do not have to address every single point; that is a comprehensive guide recommended to follow. I. INTRODUCTION: In one paragraph describe your overall visit to the museum (who, what, where, when, why, observations – walk the reader into your experience).
! What is this paper about? ! Where did you attend an exhibit? (if online – state that & include the source) ! When did you attend this exhibit? (might also include dates of temporary exhibits if useful) ! Why did you choose this museum/gallery? ! Whom did you go with (if online, this might still apply)
< Choose an artwork to critique > II. BODY: 4 parts of Art Criticism: DAIJ (Describe, Analyze, Interpret, Judge) on the artwork you choose. 1. DESCRIBE: In the 2nd paragraph (the 1st step of DAIJ) describe the artist & artwork. Most of these things are included in the label near the artwork.
! Title of the work ! Name of the artist ! Date of the work (if provided) ! Subject matter (what the artwork is about) ! Style (realistic, representational, abstract, nonobjective) ! Medium (category, i.e., drawing, print, painting, sculpture, ceramics, etc.) ! Medium (materials, i.e., pencil, charcoal, oil paint, acrylic paint, clay, wood, metal) ! Dimension (two-dimensional or three-dimensional ! Size (height, width, depth) ! Format (shape) 2. ANALYZE: In the 3rd paragraph (the 2nd step of DAIJ) analyze how the Elements of Art & Principles of Design are used. ! Identify & describe the most dominant Elements of Art that make up the composition. (You might
mention obvious ones that are not used if helpful.) Line / Shape / Form / Color / Texture / Value ! Identify & describe which Principles of Design are used to arrange the Elements in the composition.
(You might mention ones that are not used.) Emphasis / Movement / Balance / Contrast / Rhythm / Unity. Describe how unity is achieved in the composition.
3. INTERPRET: In the 4th paragraph (the 3rd step of DAIJ) interpret the historically understood meaning of this artwork (you will need some historic/cultural context from research; such as major concepts & social influence) AND your own interpretation.
! Is there any social / historical / geographical context to this artwork & / or the artist. (What is going on in this artist’s world, & is s/he responding to it?)
Medlock – Art Exp Refl Paper 3
! What do you think is the message the artist is trying to convey to the viewer? ! What is the theme of the artwork? ! What do you think is the purpose of the artwork? ! Is it possible this artwork has been mis/interpreted in one way & you have a new concept? 4. JUDGE: In the 5th paragraph (the 4th step of DAIJ) make a judgment (evaluate) whether or not you like this artwork & why or why not. (Notice this is at the end, now with an educated opinion.)
! Why did you choose this artwork? ! Is your initial impression of this artwork different after spending time with it & describing, analyzing,
& interpreting it? ! What do you think about the artwork? Why? ! What is the value you find in the artwork? Why? ! Would you want this artwork in your home (would you want to live with it?) Why? ! Does it communicate a valuable or beneficial idea, feeling, or principle for the viewer? Why? ! What is your rating of the craftsmanship of the work, i.e., do you think the artist used the materials
well? ! What information can you use from your description, analysis & interpretation to support your ideas
& opinions? III. CONCLUSION: In the 6th & final brief paragraph, conclude; summarize & wrap up your reflection on the art experience.
! Summary ! Observations (what did you notice, surprises, senses, interesting discoveries) ! Help the reader to want to visit this museum & see this artwork. WORKS CITED: cite your references for research & images.
Medlock – Art Exp Refl Paper 4
Rubric: _____/100 pts
PARAGRAPH ! EXCELLENT LEVEL ! POINT VALUE !
INTRODUCTION
Summarizes basic overview of the material to be covered, & the experience.
Helps the reader experience the museum as if in person; inspires the reader to go to this (or an) art exhibit. Sets the context for the following paragraphs about one particular work of art.
Excellent / Good / Fair / Poor
10 < - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ->0
DESCRIBE
Includes: Title; Artist; Medium; Materials; Dimensions; Style; Subject Matter; Size; Format
Helps the reader “see” the artwork; describes 8-9 specific details. Gives an accurate & complete description of what the art work depicts. The reader is able to visualize the work as though actually viewing it. Uses 6-7 appropriate art terms; Does not include A, I, or J.
Excellent / Good / Fair / Poor
12 < - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ->0
ANALYZE
Identifies & discusses how several Elements of Art are used to create the artwork. Identifies & discusses several Principles of Design used to arrange the composition. Analysis is accurate, thorough & provides appropriate examples from the work to support each identified & discussed. Exceptional use of art terms. Does not include D, I, or J.
Excellent / Good / Fair / Poor
12 < - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ->0
INTERPRET
Clearly expresses thoughts & opinions about the artwork (researched & personal based on describing & analyzing). Excellent & well thought out articulation of the meaning, theme, purpose of the work based on careful observation & analysis of the work. Formulates reasonable hypotheses about symbolic or metaphorical meaning. Provides specific, accurate examples from the artwork to support opinions, ideas & hypotheses. Researched context for historical meaning & possible misinterpreations. Includes personal meaning. Exceptional use of art terms. Does not include D, A, or J.
Excellent / Good / Fair / Poor
12 < - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ->0
JUDGE Student clearly expresses thoughts & opinions about the value of artwork that are well-justified based on the description, analysis, & interpretation.
Excellent / Good / Fair / Poor
12 < - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ->0
Medlock – Art Exp Refl Paper 5
Well thought out articulation of the value of the work. Uses references & examples from description, analysis & interpretation convincingly to support evaluation. Excellent discussion of craftsmanship & creativity. Exceptional use of art terms. Does not include D, A, or I.
CONCLUSION
Summarizes what we just read giving a polished completion to the reflection on the art experience.
Excellent / Good / Fair / Poor
10 < - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ->0
OVERALL QUALITY ! EXCELLENT LEVEL ! POINT VALUE !
WORKS CITED Academic use of research with references included (either footnotes or endnotes, or referenced throughout) with Works Cited / Bibliography at the end
Excellent / Good / Fair / Poor
10 < - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ->0
FORMATTING DETAILS
Title, page #, word count, photo: all requirements are included as given in the format guidelines above. Professionally presented. Style is your choice, but must be consistent & academic.
Excellent / Good / Fair / Poor
10 < - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ->0
EDITING / GRAMMAR
Professional / academic writing: well- organized, engaging to read. Sentences are consistently strong with varied structures; Strongly academic in tone; Language is clear & precise. Uses appropriate vocabulary; few / no errors in spelling, subject-verb agreement, contractions, & punctuation.
Excellent / Good / Fair / Poor
12 < - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ->0