Reading I NEED HELP ON MY HOMEWORK

profileLULULU
AnuclearWorldTransformed-Theriseofmultilateraldisorder.pdf

06 ©�1/1/�ax�sgd�@ldqhb‘m�@b‘cdlx�ne�@qsr�%�Rbhdmbdr� gssor9..cnh-nqf.0/-0051.C?DC^‘^/0676

@�Mtbkd‘q�Vnqkc�Sq‘mrenqldc9�� Sgd�Qhrd�ne�Ltkshk‘sdq‘k�Chrnqcdq

Rsdudm�D-�Lhkkdq

Sgd�dmc�ne�sgd�Bnkc�V‘q�oqnctbdc�fqd‘s�gnod�sg‘s�sgd�qhrjr�‘mc�c‘mfdqr�‘rrnbh‘sdc� vhsg�mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr�bntkc�ad�lhmhlhydc�nq�s‘ldc�hm�‘�bnnodq‘shud�hmsdqm‘shnm‘k� dmuhqnmldms�gd‘uhkx�qdftk‘sdc�ax�‘qlr�bnmsqnk-�He�‘qrdm‘kr�bntkc�ad�qdctbdc+�mtbkd, ‘q�vd‘onmr�l‘qfhm‘khydc+�cdrs‘ahkhyhmf�e‘bsnqr�bnmrsq‘hmdc�nq�dkhlhm‘sdc+�‘mc�oqn, khedq‘shnm� oqdudmsdc� hm� ‘ vnqkc� hmbqd‘rhmfkx� fnudqmdc� ax� mdfnsh‘sdc� ‘qlr� bnmsqnk+� sgd�mtbkd‘q�odqhkr�ne�sgd�Bnkc�V‘q�vntkc�ad�kdes�adghmc-�Md‘qkx�sgqdd�cdb‘cdr�k‘s, dq+�sgdrd�gnodr�g‘ud�addm�c‘rgdc-�Hmrsd‘c+�qdk‘shnmr�‘lnmf�sgd�l‘inq�mtbkd‘q�onv, dqr�g‘ud�fqnvm�lnqd�bnmsdmshntr+�sgd�roqd‘c�ne�mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr�sn�mdv�rs‘sdr�g‘r� qdrtksdc�hm�vnqqxhmf�qdfhnm‘k�mtbkd‘q�nqcdqr+�‘mc�sdbgmnknfhb‘k�‘cu‘mbdr�‘qd�q‘hr, hmf�mdv�sgqd‘sr�‘mc�onrrhakx�hmsqnctbhmf�mdv�hmrs‘ahkhshdr+�vghkd�‘qlr�bnmsqnk�hr�hm� ‘�rs‘sd�ne�md‘q�sns‘k�bnkk‘ord-�@�mdv�mtbkd‘q�nqcdq+�bnlahmhmf�sq‘chshnm‘k�bnmbdqmr� vhsg�chrshmbshud�mdv�c‘mfdqr+�hr�gdqd-�Sgd�odqhkr�ne�sghr�mdv�‘mc�rshkk�dunkuhmf�mtbkd, ‘q�qd‘khsx�ltrs�ad�tmcdqrsnnc he�sgdx�‘qd�sn�ad�r‘edkx�l‘m‘fdc-�

S gd� dmc� ne� sgd� Bnkc� V‘q� hmrohqdc� gnodr� sg‘s� sgd� odqrhrsdms� sgqd‘s� ne� mt, bkd‘q�v‘q�bntkc�ad�kdes�adghmc�vhsg�sgd�svdmshdsg�bdmstqx-�Hmrsd‘c+�hm�sgd� onrsflBnkc�V‘q�dq‘+�sgd�bnmsntqr�ne�sgd�fkna‘k�mtbkd‘q�nqcdq�g‘ud�addm�qd,

rg‘odc+�oqnctbhmf�‘�mdv�mtbkd‘q�dmuhqnmldms�›kkdc�vhsg�chrshmbshud�qhrjr�‘mc�‘c, chshnm‘k�odqhkr-�Mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr�g‘ud�qdf‘hmdc�‘�bdmsq‘k�ok‘bd�hm�sgd�che›btks ‘mc� bnlodshshud�qdk‘shnmr�‘lnmf�sgd�l‘inq�onvdqr+�ats�hm�‘�eq‘ldvnqj�sg‘s�hr�kdrr�ah, k‘sdq‘k� ‘mc� lnqd� sqh‘mftk‘q-� Sgd� roqd‘c� ne� mtbkd‘q� vd‘onmr� sn� ‘cchshnm‘k� rs‘sdr� g‘r� ltkshokhdc� sgd� rntqbdr� ne� mtbkd‘q� qhrj� ‘mc� hmsqnctbdc� mdv� o‘sgv‘xr� sn� sgd� trd� ne� mtbkd‘q� vd‘onmr-� Tmoqdbdcdmsdc� ed‘qr� ne� mtbkd‘q� sdqqnqhrl� g‘ud� g‘tms, dc�onkhbx,�l‘jdqr�‘mc�bnmrdptdmskx�g‘c�‘�l‘inq�hmfitdmbd�nm�onkhbx-�Hm�‘cchshnm+� sgd�‘cu‘mbd�ne�sdbgmnknfx�hr�bqd‘shmf�mdv�sgqd‘sr�‘mc�bg‘kkdmfdr+�rtbg�‘r�bxadq, ‘ss‘bjr�‘mc�bxadq�drohnm‘fd+�vghkd�‘krn�onsdmsh‘kkx�tmcdqlhmhmf�sgd�rtquhu‘ahkhsx�ne� sq‘chshnm‘k�mtbkd‘q�enqbdr�‘mc�gdmbd�dqnchmf�sgd�cdsdqqdms�rs‘ahkhsx�sg‘s�g‘r�knmf� addm�sgntfgs�drrdmsh‘k�enq�bnms‘hmhmf�mtbkd‘q�c‘mfdqr-�@kk�sghr�g‘r�tmenkcdc�vghkd� ‘qlr�bnmsqnk�g‘r�addm�md‘qkx�dkhlhm‘sdc�eqnl�sgd�ohbstqd+�lnuhmf�snv‘qc�‘m�tm, bnmrsq‘hmdc�dmuhqnmldms�hm�vghbg�sgd�mdv�mtbkd‘q�cxm‘lhbr�b‘m�ok‘x�nts+�vhsg� ‘qlr�q‘bd�oqdrrtqdr�‘mc�onsdmsh‘k�hmrs‘ahkhshdr�‘kqd‘cx�hm�uhdv-�Vg‘s�g‘r�dldqfdc�

D o w n lo a d e d fro m h ttp ://d ire c t.m it.e d u /d a e d /a rtic le -p d f/1 4 9 /2 /1 7 /1 8 3 2 6 4 2 /d a e d _ a _ 0 1 7 8 7 .p d f b y U N IV O F C A L IF O R N IA S A N T A B A R B A R A u s e r o n 1 5 M a y 2 0 2 3

07 Cºc‘ktr+�sgd�Intqm‘k�ne�sgd�@ldqhb‘m�@b‘cdlx�ne�@qsr�%�Rbhdmbdr

@�Mtbkd‘q�Vnqkc�Sq‘mrenqldc9�Sgd�Qhrd�ne�Ltkshk‘sdq‘k�Chrnqcdq

‘mc�hr�rshkk�dldqfhmf�hr�‘�lnqd�bnlokdw+�lnqd�che›btks+�‘mc�kdrr�qdftk‘sdc�mtbkd‘q� dmuhqnmldms�vgnrd�chrshmfthrghmf�g‘y‘qcr�ltrs�ad�r‘edkx�m‘uhf‘sdc�he�vd�‘qd�sn� ‘unhc�sgd�l‘mx�mhfgsl‘qhrg�mtbkd‘q�trd�rbdm‘qhnr-�Tmcdqrs‘mchmf�gnv�ltbg�g‘r� bg‘mfdc+�‘mc�sgd�hlokhb‘shnmr�ne�sgnrd�bg‘mfdr+�kd‘cr�chqdbskx�sn�sgd�bnmbktrhnm� sg‘s�mtbkd‘q�qhrjr�‘qd�cq‘l‘shb‘kkx�hmbqd‘rhmf-�

Ctqhmf� sgd� Bnkc� V‘q+� sgd� qhu‘kqx� adsvddm� sgd� Rnuhds� Tmhnm� ‘mc� sgd� Tmhsdc� Rs‘sdr� cnlhm‘sdc� sgd� fkna‘k� mtbkd‘q� nqcdq-� Sgdrd� svn� rs‘sdr� vdqd� oqdnbbtohdc� vhsg�nmd�‘mnsgdq�‘mc�‘l‘rrdc�u‘rs�‘qrdm‘kr�ne�mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr�hm�deenqsr�sn�f‘hm� ‘cu‘ms‘fd�‘mc�sn�cdsdq�sgd�‘lahshnmr�‘mc�b‘o‘ahkhshdr�ne�sgd�nsgdq-�Lnrs�ne�sgd�enq, l‘shud�sgdnqdshb‘k�‘mc�onkhbx,nqhdmsdc�sghmjhmf�‘ants�mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr�dldqfdc� hm�sghr�ahk‘sdq‘k�bnmsdws9�bnmbdoshnmr�ne�rs‘ahkhsx�‘mc�hmrs‘ahkhsx+�sgd�knfhb�ne�‘qlr� bnmsqnk+�sgd�m‘stqd�ne�bqhrhr�l‘m‘fdldms+�cdkhadq‘shnmr�‘ants�cdsdqqdmbd�‘mc�sgd� ‘cdpt‘bx�ne�mtbkd‘q�enqbd�onrstqdr+�‘mc�‘qftldmsr�‘ants�gnv�sgd�onvdqetk�lt, st‘k�hmsdqdrs�hm�‘unhchmf�mtbkd‘q�v‘q�bntkc�adrs�ad�otqrtdc-�Sghr�vnqkc�v‘r�mns+� ne�bntqrd+�otqdkx�ahk‘sdq‘k-�Nm�sgd�Vdrsdqm�rhcd+�sgd�Tmhsdc�Jhmfcnl ‘mc�Eq‘mbd� ‘bpthqdc�rl‘kk�mtbkd‘q�‘qrdm‘kr+�ats�sgdrd�rs‘sdr�vdqd�enql‘k�‘kkhdr�ne�sgd�Tmhsdc� Rs‘sdr�‘mc�sgdhq�mtbkd‘q�‘rrdsr�vdqd�rddm�‘r�lhmnq�rtookdldmsr�sn�M?SN&r�mtbkd, ‘q�b‘o‘ahkhsx-�Nm�sgd�Bnlltmhrs�rhcd�ne�sgd�fqd‘s�D‘rs,Vdrs�bnlodshshnm+�Bghm‘� cdudknodc�mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr+�ats�hsr�enqbd�v‘r�udqx�rl‘kk�‘mc�khlhsdc+�Bghm‘�hsrdke� v‘r�rshkk�‘�vd‘j�cdudknohmf�bntmsqx+�Bghm‘&r�qdk‘shnmrgho�vhsg�sgd�Rnuhds�Tmhnm� v‘r�kdrr�rs‘akd�sg‘m�sg‘s�ne�sgd�M?SN�‘kkhdr+�‘mc�sgd�Bghmdrd�sgqd‘s�v‘r�l‘rrhud, kx�nudqrg‘cnvdc�ax�‘�Rnuhds�‘qrdm‘k�sg‘s�od‘jdc�‘s�md‘qkx�enqsx�sgntr‘mc�mtbkd‘q� vd‘onmr-�Hs�v‘r�sgd�bnmeqnms‘shnm�adsvddm�sgd�svn�fqd‘s�mtbkd‘q�shs‘mr�sg‘s�rsqtb, stqdc�sgd�fkna‘k�mtbkd‘q�nqcdq�ctqhmf�sgd�Bnkc�V‘q�‘mc�cnlhm‘sdc�sgd�onkhshbr+� onkhbhdr+� ‘mc� sghmjhmf� ‘rrnbh‘sdc� vhsg� mtbkd‘q� vd‘onmr-� Vd� ltrs� mnv� bnld� sn� fqhor�vhsg�sgd�e‘bs�sg‘s�sghr�mtbkd‘q�nqcdq�mn�knmfdq�dwhrsr+�‘mc�hs�hr�tmbkd‘q�vgdsg, dq�sgd�rnktshnmr�‘mc�udqhshdr�ne�sgd�ahk‘sdq‘k�dq‘�vhkk�ad�‘cdpt‘sd�hm�snc‘x&r�lnqd� bnlokdw�mtbkd‘q�dmuhqnmldms-

Ctqhmf�sgd�enqsx,›ud�xd‘qr�ne�sgd�Bnkc�V‘q+�Lnrbnv�‘mc�V‘rghmfsnm�fq‘ct‘kkx� bnmrsqtbsdc�‘�mtbkd‘q�qdk‘shnmrgho�sg‘s�v‘r�qdf‘qcdc�‘r�qd‘rnm‘akx�rs‘akd�’sgntfg� vnqqhdr� ‘ants� cdrs‘ahkhyhmf� cdudknoldmsr� odqrhrsdc(+� v‘r� gd‘uhkx� qdftk‘sdc� ax�� mdfnsh‘sdc�‘fqddldms�’sgntfg�cntasr�‘ants�‘qlr�bnmsqnk�vdqd�dudq,�oqdrdms(+�‘mc� v‘r� inhmskx� l‘m‘fdc� uh‘� ‘m� nmfnhmf� ‘qlr� bnmsqnk� oqnbdrr� ’sgntfg� bqhshbr� ptdr, shnmdc� sgd� cdrhq‘ahkhsx� ‘mc� deedbshudmdrr� ne� sghr� ‘ooqn‘bg(-� Sgdqd� vdqd� qhrjr� ‘mc� c‘mfdqr+�ats�sgd�ahk‘sdq‘k�rsqtbstqd�g‘c�‘�bdqs‘hm�bk‘qhsx�‘mc�rhlokhbhsx9�svn�mtbkd‘q� adgdlnsgr�bnlodshmf�choknl‘shb‘kkx�vghkd�rddjhmf�sn�cdsdq�nmd�‘mnsgdq�vhsgnts� ro‘qjhmf�‘�mtbkd‘q�v‘q-�Sghr�v‘r�‘�vnqkc+�hm�rdbtqhsx�sgdnqhrs�Sgnl‘r�Rbgdkkhmf&r� ogq‘rd+�sg‘s�vd�sgntfgs�vd�tmcdqrsnnc-0

Sgd�dmc�ne�sgd�Bnkc�V‘q�hmhsh‘kkx�oqnctbdc�mdv�vnqqhdr�‘mc�c‘mfdqr+�o‘qshbt, k‘qkx�adb‘trd�sgd�chrhmsdfq‘shnm�ne�sgd�Rnuhds�Tmhnm�kdes�sgd�u‘rs�Rnuhds�mtbkd‘q�‘q, rdm‘k�rb‘ssdqdc�‘bqnrr�sgd�mdvkx�hmcdodmcdms�rs‘sdr�sg‘s�dldqfdc�eqnl�sgd�Rnuhds�

D o w n lo a d e d fro m h ttp ://d ire c t.m it.e d u /d a e d /a rtic le -p d f/1 4 9 /2 /1 7 /1 8 3 2 6 4 2 /d a e d _ a _ 0 1 7 8 7 .p d f b y U N IV O F C A L IF O R N IA S A N T A B A R B A R A u s e r o n 1 5 M a y 2 0 2 3

038�’1(�Roqhmf�1/1/ 08

Rsdudm�D-�Lhkkdq

bnkk‘ord+�q‘hrhmf�sgd�onrrhahkhsx�ne�mdv�mtbkd‘q,‘qldc�rs‘sdr�‘mc�b‘trhmf�bnmbdqm� sg‘s�mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr+�l‘sdqh‘kr+�nq�odqrnmmdk�lhfgs�kd‘j�hmsn�mtbkd‘q�ak‘bj�l‘q, jdsr�‘mc�oqnuhcd�noshnmr�enq�qnftd�rs‘sdr�nq�mnmrs‘sd�‘bsnqr-�Hm�sgd�sq‘mrhshnm�eqnl� sgd�nkc�vnqkc�sn�sgd�mdv+�sgdrd�qhrjr�qdoqdrdmsdc�‘m�tqfdms�bg‘kkdmfd+�‘mc�hs�vntkc� s‘jd�rdudq‘k�xd‘qr�‘mc�bnmrhcdq‘akd�deenqs�sn�bnmrnkhc‘sd�Rnuhds�mtbkd‘q�‘rrdsr�hmsn� Qtrrh‘+�vghbg�v‘r�‘bbdosdc�ax�jdx�‘bsnqr�rtbg�‘r�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr�‘r�sgd�rnkd�mt, bkd‘q�rtbbdrrnq�rs‘sd�sn�sgd�enqldq�Rnuhds�Tmhnm-�

Ld‘mvghkd+� gnvdudq+� qdk‘shnmr� adsvddm� Lnrbnv� ‘mc� V‘rghmfsnm� ’vgn� ad, svddm� sgdl� rshkk� onrrdrrdcfl‘mc� onrrdrrflsgd� nudqvgdklhmf� l‘inqhsx� ne� sgd� vnqkc&r�mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr(�pthbjkx�‘rrtldc�‘�ltbg�lnqd�admhfm�enql�‘r�sgdx�sn, fdsgdq�enql‘kkx�oqnbk‘hldc�'‘m�dq‘�ne�eqhdmcrgho�‘mc�o‘qsmdqrgho-„1 Sghr ‘kknvdc+ ‘r� nmd� bnmsdlonq‘mdntr� ‘m‘kxrhr� ots� hs+� 'rdqhntr� bnmrhcdq‘shnm� ne� hmsdqm‘shnm, ‘k�nqcdqr�oqdchb‘sdc�nm�ghfg�kdudkr�ne�rdbtqhsx�bnnodq‘shnm-„2�Sgd�qdok‘bdldms�ne� hmsdmrd�qhu‘kqx�vhsg�bnmfdmh‘k�qdk‘shnmr�‘mc�bnnodq‘shnm�rddldc�sn�nodm�to�gtfd� uhrs‘r�enq�mdfnsh‘sdc�qdrsq‘hms�‘mc�inhms�l‘m‘fdldms�ne�sgd�mtbkd‘q�nqcdq-�Qdfidbs, hmf�sgd�noshlhrl�ne�sgd�shld+�‘mnsgdq�‘m‘kxrhr�rtffdrsdc9�'Sgd�qdunktshnmr�ne�0878� g‘ud�nodmdc�tmoqdbdcdmsdc�noonqstmhshdr�enq�lnqd�rvddohmf�‘fqddldmsr-�@qlr� bnmsqnk� b‘m� mnv� adfhm� chrl‘mskhmf� sgd� D‘rs,Vdrs� lhkhs‘qx� bnmeqnms‘shnmflmns� ldqdkx�lncdq‘shmf�hsr�qhrjrfl‘mc�sgdqdax�gdko�rg‘od�sgd�rdbtqhsx�rsqtbstqd�ne�sgd� onrsflBnkc�V‘q�vnqkc-„3�Hmcddc+�rnnm�‘esdq�sgd�bnkk‘ord�ne�sgd�Rnuhds�Tmhnm+�‘l, ahshntr�mdv�‘qlr�bnmsqnk�naidbshudr�dldqfdc�nm�sgd�ahk‘sdq‘k�‘fdmc‘-�@s�sgd�Atrg, Xdksrhm�rtllhs�hm�V‘rghmfsnm+�C-B-+�hm�Itmd�0881+�enq�dw‘lokd+�sgd�svn�oqdrhcdmsr� ‘mmntmbdc�sg‘s�sgdx�g‘c�‘fqddc�sn�l‘jd�cq‘l‘shb�btsr�hm rsq‘sdfhb�mtbkd‘q�enqb, dr+�sn�dkhlhm‘sd�cdrs‘ahkhyhmf�ltkshokd,v‘qgd‘c�’LHQU+�nq�ltkshokd�hmcdodmcdmskx� s‘qfds‘akd�qddmsqx�udghbkd(�lhrrhkdr+�‘mc�sn�tmcdqs‘jd�‘m�‘qq‘x�ne�nsgdq�bnnodq‘shud� ld‘rtqdr9�oqnuhrhnmr�bnch›dc�hm�sgd�RS?QS�HH�‘fqddldms� ne� I‘mt‘qx� 0882-� Oqdrh, cdms�Atrg�ghlrdke�tmcdqrbnqdc�sgd�tmoqdbdcdmsdc�bg‘q‘bsdq�ne�sghr�'dwsq‘nqch, m‘qx�‘fqddldms+„�mnshmf�‘s�ghr�inhms�oqdrr�bnmedqdmbd�vhsg�Oqdrhcdms�Xdksrhm�sg‘s� 'sghr�etmc‘ldms‘k�‘fqddldms�vghbg�hm�d‘qkhdq�xd‘qr�bntkc�mns�g‘ud�addm�bnlokds, dc�dudm�hm�‘�cdb‘cd�g‘r�addm�bnlokdsdc�hm�nmkx�›ud�lnmsgr-�Ntq�‘ahkhsx�sn�qd‘bg� sghr�‘fqddldms�rn�pthbjkx�hr�‘�sqhatsd�sn�sgd�mdv�qdk‘shnmrgho�adsvddm�sgd�Tmhsdc� Rs‘sdr�‘mc�Qtrrh‘-„4�Sgdqd�rddldc�sn�ad�dudqx�qd‘rnm�sn�ad�gnodetk�sg‘s�sgd�mdv�dq‘� vntkc ad�l‘qjdc�ax�bnnodq‘shnm�‘mc�qdrsq‘hms�hm�mtbkd‘q�‘ee‘hqr-

@s�sgd�ntsrds�ne�sgd�onrsflBnkc�V‘q�dq‘+�sgdm+�‘�vdkk,dk‘anq‘sdc�‘mc�cnlhm‘s, hmf� ahk‘sdq‘k� mtbkd‘q� eq‘ldvnqj� hmg‘ahsdc� ‘m� tmoqdbdcdmsdckx� g‘qlnmhntr� hm, sdqm‘shnm‘k�onkhshb‘k�bnmsdws+�Qtrrh‘m�‘mc�@ldqhb‘m�mtbkd‘q�enqbdr�vdqd�rgqhmj, hmf�cq‘l‘shb‘kkx+�sgd�a‘k‘mbd�v‘r�qdf‘qcdc�‘r�rs‘akd+�mtbkd‘q�‘qlr�bnmsqnk�g‘c�qd‘k� lnldmstl+�‘mc�hs�rddldc�‘r�he�mtbkd‘q�c‘mfdqr�vdqd�adhmf�rtars‘msh‘kkx�s‘ldc-� Adb‘trd�sgd�mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr�kdes�adghmc�ax�sgd�Rnuhds�Tmhnm�hm�mdvkx�hmcdodm, cdms�rs‘sdr�vdqd�adhmf�qdknb‘sdc�sn�Qtrrh‘+�hs�‘krn�rddldc�khjdkx�sg‘s�sgd�ahk‘sdq, ‘k�rsqtbstqd�ne�sgd�mtbkd‘q�nqcdq�vntkc�qdl‘hm�hms‘bs-�Etqsgdq+�sgdqd�g‘c�mns�addm�

D o w n lo a d e d fro m h ttp ://d ire c t.m it.e d u /d a e d /a rtic le -p d f/1 4 9 /2 /1 7 /1 8 3 2 6 4 2 /d a e d _ a _ 0 1 7 8 7 .p d f b y U N IV O F C A L IF O R N IA S A N T A B A R B A R A u s e r o n 1 5 M a y 2 0 2 3

1/ Cºc‘ktr+�sgd�Intqm‘k�ne�sgd�@ldqhb‘m�@b‘cdlx�ne�@qsr�%�Rbhdmbdr

@�Mtbkd‘q�Vnqkc�Sq‘mrenqldc9�Sgd�Qhrd�ne�Ltkshk‘sdq‘k�Chrnqcdq

‘m�nodm�‘cchshnm�sn�sgd�qnrsdq�ne�mtbkd‘q�‘qldc�rs‘sdr�rhmbd�sgd�085/r+�vgdm�Bgh, m‘�‘bpthqdc�mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr9�Hrq‘dk&r�oqnfq‘l�qdl‘hmdc�no‘ptd�‘mc�tm‘bjmnvk, dcfdc�vghkd�Rntsg�@eqhb‘&r�knmf,ghccdm�mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr�oqnfq‘l�g‘c�addm�sdq, lhm‘sdc�hm�0878-�Vghkd�oqnkhedq‘shnm�vnqqhdr�qdl‘hmdc�’Mnqsg�Jnqd‘�v‘r�‘kqd‘cx� knnlhmf�‘r�‘�oqnakdl(+�sgdqd�vdqd�mn�hlldch‘sd�mnmoqnkhedq‘shnm�bqhrdr�nm�sgd� hmsdqm‘shnm‘k�‘fdmc‘+�‘mc�hs�rddldc�sg‘s�sgd�bdmsq‘k�mtbkd‘q�bg‘kkdmfd�vntkc�ad� l‘m‘fhmf�sgd�T-R-,Qtrrh‘m�mtbkd‘q�qdk‘shnmrgho�hm�sgd�bnmsdws�ne�vg‘s�Oqdrhcdms� Fdnqfd�G-�V-�Atrg�b‘kkdc�sgd�mdv�vnqkc�nqcdq-�Sgdrd�bhqbtlrs‘mbdr�f‘ud�qhrd�sn� dwsq‘u‘f‘ms�uhrhnmr�ne�sgd�mtbkd‘q�nqcdq�sg‘s�lhfgs�mnv�ad�onrrhakd-�@�G‘qu‘qc� oqnidbs�nm�bnnodq‘shud�cdmtbkd‘qhy‘shnm+�enq�dw‘lokd+�rtffdrsdc�hm�0882�sg‘s�he�sghr� oqnohshntr�lnldms�vdqd�etkkx�dwoknhsdc+�hs�lhfgs�ad�onrrhakd�sn�‘bghdud�'sgd�dkhl, hm‘shnm�ne�mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr�eqnl�sgd�bdmsq‘k�qnkd�sgdx�g‘ud�ok‘xdc�hm�hmsdqm‘shnm, ‘k�khed�enq�›esx�xd‘qr„�‘mc�sn�'drs‘akhrg�mdv�hmsdqm‘shnm‘k�mnqlr�sg‘s�otrg�mtbkd‘q� vd‘onmr�sn�sgd�eqhmfd�ne�hmsdqm‘shnm‘k�khed-„5

Ats�mn�rtbg�vnqkc�g‘r�bnld�sn�o‘rr-�Hmrsd‘c+�nudq�‘�odqhnc�ne�md‘qkx�sgqdd�cd, b‘cdr+�sgd�admhfm�ahk‘sdq‘k�mtbkd‘q�nqcdq�‘mc�sgd�ghfg�gnodr�sg‘s�‘bbnlo‘mhdc�hs� g‘ud�chr‘ood‘qdc-6�Sgd�noshlhrshb�dwodbs‘shnmr�ne�sgd�d‘qkx�onrsflBnkc�V‘q�odqh, nc�g‘ud�addm�akhfgsdc+�nauhntrkx+�ax�sgd�rsqhjhmf�cdsdqhnq‘shnm�ne�T-R-,Qtrrh‘m�qd, k‘shnmr�sg‘s�g‘r�qduhudc�sgd�qhu‘kqx�‘mc�gnrshkhsx�ne�sgd�oqduhntr�dq‘-�Gnvdudq+�sghr� e‘bsnq�‘knmd�cndr�mns�‘cdpt‘sdkx�‘bbntms�enq�sgd�qd‘khshdr�ne�sgd�btqqdms�lnldms� hm� mtbkd‘q� ‘ee‘hqr-� Hmcddc+� he� sgd� cdb‘x� ne� sgd� qdk‘shnmrgho� adsvddm� V‘rghmfsnm� ‘mc� Lnrbnv� hmunkudc� rhlokx� sgd� qdrsnq‘shnm� ne� rnldsghmf� khjd� sgd� cnlhm‘shmf� Bnkc�V‘q�mtbkd‘q�a‘k‘mbd+�vd�vntkc�ad�nm�e‘lhkh‘q�fqntmc+�a‘bj�nm�Rbgdkkhmf&r�� vdkk,tmcdqrsnnc�sdqq‘hm�ne�l‘hms‘hmhmf�ahk‘sdq‘k�mtbkd‘q�rs‘ahkhsx�vhsghm�sgd�bnm, ›mdr�ne�‘�bnmfihbst‘k�‘mc�rnldshldr�snwhb�onkhshb‘k�qdk‘shnmrgho-�Vg‘s�g‘r�dldqfdc� hr�rnldsghmf�cheedqdms+�rnldsghmf�tme‘lhkh‘q9�‘�mtbkd‘q�dmuhqnmldms�vgnrd�dr, rdmsh‘k�cxm‘lhbr�b‘mmns�ad�b‘ostqdc�ax�‘�rhmfkd�nudqvddmhmf�ahk‘sdq‘k�qdk‘shnm, rgho� ‘s� sgd� bnqd� ne� sgd� rxrsdl-� Sghr� ntsbnld� hr� sgd� qdrtks� ne� ‘s� kd‘rs� entq� l‘inq� bg‘mfdr�hm�sgd�‘ssqhatsdr�ne�sgd�mtbkd‘q�nqcdq+�bg‘mfdr�sg‘s�g‘ud�‘qqhudc�tmdudmkx� ‘mc�›setkkx�nudq�‘�rdudq‘k�cdb‘cd�odqhnc-�Snfdsgdq+�gnvdudq+�sgdx�g‘ud�bnlahmdc� sn�sq‘mrenql�sgd�mtbkd‘q�dmuhqnmldms�hm�v‘xr�sg‘s�‘qd�khjdkx�sn�l‘jd�hs�lnqd�che›, btks�sn�bnms‘hm�sgd�qhrjr�‘mc�c‘mfdqr�‘rrnbh‘sdc�vhsg�mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr-

S gd�dqnrhnm�ne�sgd�ahk‘sdq‘k�mtbkd‘q�nqcdq-�Hm�bnmsq‘rs�sn�sgd�ahonk‘q�Bnkc�V‘q�hm, sdqm‘shnm‘k�nqcdq+�fqd‘s,onvdq�qdk‘shnmr�‘qd�mn�knmfdq�nudqvgdklhmfkx�ah, k‘sdq‘k-�Bghm‘&r�rstmmhmf�qhrd�nudq�sgd�o‘rs�pt‘qsdq,bdmstqx�g‘r�bg‘mfdc�

sgd�cxm‘lhbr�‘lnmf�sgd�lnrs�onvdqetk�rs‘sdr�‘s�sgd�gd‘qs�ne�sgd�hmsdqm‘shnm‘k�rxr, sdl-�Hm�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr+�Bghm‘�hr�mnv�vhcdkx�rddm�‘r�sgd�fqd‘sdrs�bg‘kkdmfd�sn� @ldqhb‘m�onvdq�‘mc�hmsdqdrsr�enq�sgd�enqdrdd‘akd�etstqd-�Rsqhjhmfkx+�sgd�Odms‘fnm� adkhdudr�sg‘s�Adhihmf�hr�g‘qmdrrhmf�hsr�fqnvhmf�onvdq�sn�dmnqlntr�‘lahshnmr9�'@r� Bghm‘�bnmshmtdr�hsr�dbnmnlhb�‘mc�lhkhs‘qx�‘rbdmc‘mbd+�‘rrdqshmf�onvdq�sgqntfg�

D o w n lo a d e d fro m h ttp ://d ire c t.m it.e d u /d a e d /a rtic le -p d f/1 4 9 /2 /1 7 /1 8 3 2 6 4 2 /d a e d _ a _ 0 1 7 8 7 .p d f b y U N IV O F C A L IF O R N IA S A N T A B A R B A R A u s e r o n 1 5 M a y 2 0 2 3

038�’1(�Roqhmf�1/1/ 10

Rsdudm�D-�Lhkkdq

‘m�‘kk,ne,m‘shnm�knmf,sdql�rsq‘sdfx+�hs�vhkk�bnmshmtd�sn�otqrtd�‘�lhkhs‘qx�lncdqm, hy‘shnm�oqnfq‘l�sg‘s�rddjr�Hmcn,O‘bh›b�qdfhnm‘k�gdfdlnmx�hm�sgd�md‘q,sdql�‘mc� chrok‘bdldms�ne�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr�sn�‘bghdud�fkna‘k�oqddlhmdmbd�hm�sgd�etstqd-„7

Adhihmf&r� onrstk‘sdc� fn‘k� ne� chrok‘bhmf� sgd� Tmhsdc� Rs‘sdr� nauhntrkx� qdoqdrdmsr� ‘� etmc‘ldms‘k�sgqd‘s�sn�@ldqhb‘&r�qnkd�hm�sgd�vnqkc�‘mc�hr�bdqs‘hm�sn�dkhbhs�uhfnqntr� bntmsdq‘bshnm�ax�V‘rghmfsnm-

Rhltks‘mdntrkx+�Qtrrh‘�g‘r�qddldqfdc�‘r�‘�qhu‘k-�Vhsg�hsr�bnmsdmshntr�onkhbhdr+� ‘ffqdrrhud�adg‘uhnq+�‘mc�sgntr‘mcr�ne�mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr�hs�vhkk�bnmshmtd�sn�›ftqd� bdmsq‘kkx�hm�V‘rghmfsnm&r�odqbdoshnmr-�Ats�mn�knmfdq�cndr�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr�enbtr� hm�‘�rhmftk‘q�v‘x�nm�Lnrbnv-�Hmbqd‘rhmfkx+�Qtrrh‘�‘mc�Bghm‘�‘qd�o‘hqdc�‘r�sgd�k‘qf, drs�sgqd‘sr�sn�T-R-�rdbtqhsx�‘mc�sn�@ldqhb‘m�hmfitdmbd�hm�sgd�hmsdqm‘shnm‘k�nqcdq-� Sghr�b‘m�ad�rddm�ok‘hmkx�hm�sgd�1/06�T-R-�M‘shnm‘k�Rdbtqhsx�Rsq‘sdfx+�vghbg�rs‘sdr� sg‘s� 'Bghm‘� ‘mc� Qtrrh‘� bg‘kkdmfd� @ldqhb‘m� onvdq+� hmfitdmbd+� ‘mc� hmsdqdrsr+� ‘s, sdloshmf�sn�dqncd�@ldqhb‘m�rdbtqhsx�‘mc�oqnrodqhsx-„8�Sghr�sgdld�hr�dbgndc�‘mc� tmcdqrbnqdc�hm�sgd�Sqtlo�‘clhmhrsq‘shnm&r�1/07�Mtbkd‘q�Onrstqd�Qduhdv�’MOQ(+� vghbg�ghfgkhfgsr�'sgd�qdstqm�ne�fqd‘s�onvdq�bnlodshshnm„�‘r�nmd�ne�sgd�‘mhl‘s, hmf�enqbdr�rg‘ohmf�T-R-�mtbkd‘q�onkhbx�‘mc�hcdmsh›dr�Adhihmf�‘mc�Lnrbnv�‘r�l‘inq� rntqbdr�ne�@ldqhb‘m�hmrdbtqhsx-�@bbnqchmf�sn�sgd�MOQ+�'Fkna‘k�sgqd‘s�bnmchshnmr� g‘ud�vnqrdmdc�l‘qjdckx-�-�-�-�Hmsdqm‘shnm‘k�qdk‘shnmr ‘qd�unk‘shkd-�Qtrrh‘�‘mc�Bghm‘� ‘qd�bnmsdrshmf�sgd�hmsdqm‘shnm‘k�mnqlr�‘mc�nqcdq�vd�g‘ud�vnqjdc�vhsg�ntq�‘kkhdr+� o‘qsmdqr+�‘mc�ldladqr�ne�sgd�hmsdqm‘shnm‘k�bnlltmhsx�sn�athkc�‘mc�rtrs‘hm-„0/�

Bghm‘&r�fqnvhmf�rs‘str�‘r�‘�rdqhntr�bg‘kkdmfdq�sn�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr�vhkk�hmduhs‘, akx�l‘jd�sgd�mtbkd‘q�qdk‘shnmrgho�‘s�sgd�bnqd�ne�sgd�fkna‘k�mtbkd‘q�nqcdq�lnqd�sqh, ‘mftk‘q-�Ahk‘sdq‘k�cxm‘lhbr�vhkk�ne�bntqrd�qdl‘hm�hlonqs‘ms+�ats�sgdx�vhkk�ad�hm, fitdmbdc�‘mc�rnldshldr�rg‘odc�ax�sgqdd,rhcdc�bnmrhcdq‘shnmr-�Sghr�vhkk�mns�ad�‘� rxlldsqhb‘k� sqh‘mfkd+� adb‘trd� Bghm‘&r� cnbsqhmd� ne� lhmhltl� cdsdqqdmbd� ‘mc� hsr� qdrsq‘hms�hm�sgd�‘bpthrhshnm�ne�mtbkd‘q�‘rrdsr�g‘r�oqnctbdc�‘�mtbkd‘q�enqbd�onrstqd� bnmrhcdq‘akx�rl‘kkdq�‘mc�lnqd�khlhsdc�hm�b‘o‘ahkhsx�sg‘m�sgd�‘qrdm‘kr�ne�sgd�Tmhs, dc�Rs‘sdr�‘mc�Qtrrh‘-�Lnrbnv&r�sgntr‘mcr�ne�mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr�vhkk�enq�sgd�enqdrdd, ‘akd�etstqd�bnmrshstsd�sgd�k‘qfdrs�mtbkd‘q�sgqd‘s-�Ats�Bghm‘&r�rsd‘cx�mtbkd‘q�lnc, dqmhy‘shnm�oqnfq‘l�hr�bqd‘shmf�‘�lnqd�b‘o‘akd�enqbd�sg‘s�hr�uhdvdc�‘r�vnqqhrnld� ax�V‘rghmfsnm+�qdpthqhmf�‘�'s‘hknqdc„�cdsdqqdms�qdronmrd-�'Ntq�s‘hknqdc�rsq‘sdfx� enq�Bghm‘+„�sgd�1/07�Mtbkd‘q�Onrstqd�Qduhdv�rs‘sdr+�'hr�cdrhfmdc�sn�oqdudms�Adh, ihmf� eqnl� lhrs‘jdmkx� bnmbktchmf� sg‘s� hs� bntkc� rdbtqd� ‘m� ‘cu‘ms‘fd� sgqntfg� sgd� khlhsdc�trd�ne�hsr�sgd‘sdq�mtbkd‘q�b‘o‘ahkhshdr�nq�sg‘s�‘mx�trd�ne�mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr+� gnvdudq�khlhsdc+�hr�‘bbdos‘akd-„00

Sghr�sgqdd,rhcdc�mtbkd‘q�qdk‘shnmrgho�vhkk�oqnctbd�lnqd�bnlokdw�hmsdq‘bshnmr� ‘lnmf� ‘mc� lnqd� bnlokhb‘sdc� b‘kbtk‘shnmr� enq� sgd� sgqdd� oqns‘fnmhrsr-� Bghm‘&r� fqnvhmf�hlohmfdldms�nm�sgd�Qtrrh‘m,@ldqhb‘m�nqahs�aqhmfr�hmsn�sgd�lhw�ne�fqd‘s,� onvdq�qdk‘shnmr�‘m�‘bsnq�vhsg�cheedqhmf�uhdvr�nm�sgd�oqdedqqdc�bg‘q‘bsdqhrshbr�ne� sgd�hmsdqm‘shnm‘k�nqcdq�‘mc�rnldshldr�chudqfdms�odqrodbshudr�nm�jdx�hrrtdr�khjd�

D o w n lo a d e d fro m h ttp ://d ire c t.m it.e d u /d a e d /a rtic le -p d f/1 4 9 /2 /1 7 /1 8 3 2 6 4 2 /d a e d _ a _ 0 1 7 8 7 .p d f b y U N IV O F C A L IF O R N IA S A N T A B A R B A R A u s e r o n 1 5 M a y 2 0 2 3

11 Cºc‘ktr+�sgd�Intqm‘k�ne�sgd�@ldqhb‘m�@b‘cdlx�ne�@qsr�%�Rbhdmbdr

@�Mtbkd‘q�Vnqkc�Sq‘mrenqldc9�Sgd�Qhrd�ne�Ltkshk‘sdq‘k�Chrnqcdq

mtbkd‘q�oqnkhedq‘shnm�nq�nm�rhfmh›b‘ms�ok‘xdqr�rtbg�‘r�Mnqsg�Jnqd‘+�Hq‘m+�‘mc�O‘, jhrs‘m-01�Deedbshud�l‘m‘fdldms�ne�sghr�sgqdd,rhcdc�qdk‘shnmrgho�vhkk�ad�che›btks+� ‘r�b‘m�‘kqd‘cx�ad�rddm�hm�sgd�eqhbshnmr�sg‘s�g‘ud�‘qhrdm�hm�T-R-�qdk‘shnmr�vhsg�ansg� Bghm‘�‘mc�Qtrrh‘�‘mc�hm�sgd�onsdmsh‘k�‘khfmldms�ne�Adhihmf�‘mc�Lnrbnv�‘f‘hmrs� V‘rghmfsnm-02

Sgd� mtbkd‘q� onkhbx� qdudqadq‘shnmr� ‘lnmf� sgd� sgqdd� bnmsdmchmf� onvdqr� ‘qd� �‘kqd‘cx�‘oo‘qdms-�Hm�sgd�@ldqhb‘m�chrbtrrhnm�‘ants sgd�e‘sd�ne�sgd�ahk‘sdq‘k�T-R-,� Qtrrh‘ Hmsdqldch‘sd,Q‘mfd�Mtbkd‘q�Enqbdr�’HME(�Sqd‘sx+�enq�dw‘lokd+�V‘rghmf, snm&r�oqnsq‘bsdc�bnmbdqmr�‘ants�Qtrrh‘m�mnmbnlokh‘mbd�ots�sgd�hrrtd�nm�sgd�‘fdm, c‘+�ats�sgd�b‘rd�enq�sdqlhm‘shmf�sgd�‘fqddldms�hmbqd‘rhmfkx�hmbktcdc�sgd�‘qftldms� sg‘s�sgd�HME�g‘mchb‘oodc�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr�hm�hsr�deenqs�sn�bnod�vhsg�sgd�athkc,to� ne�Bghmdrd�enqbdr�hm�sgd�Vdrsdqm�O‘bh›b-�Bghm‘�v‘r�mns�‘�o‘qsx�sn�sgd�HME�‘fqdd, ldms�‘mc+�adhmf�tmbnmrsq‘hmdc+�l‘cd�‘�gd‘ux�hmudrsldms�hm�rgnqd,a‘rdc�lhrrhkdr� sg‘s�vdqd�rddm�‘r�‘�rdqhntr�sgqd‘s�sn�T-R-�‘kkhdr�‘mc�T-R-�m‘u‘k�enqbdr�hm�sgd�qdfhnm-� Sgd�HME�‘fqddldms�oqnghahsdc�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr�‘mc�Qtrrh‘�eqnl�cdoknxhmf�k‘mc, a‘rdc�lhrrhkdr�vhsg�‘�q‘mfd�adsvddm�4//�‘mc�4+4//�jhknldsdqr+�vghbg�oqdbktcdc� T-R-�fqntmc,a‘rdc�cdoknxldmsr�hm�@rh‘�sn�neerds�sgd�Bghmdrd�lhrrhkd�b‘o‘ahkhsx-�Hm� sdqlr�ne�sgd�Rhmn,@ldqhb‘m�bnlodshshnm�hm�sgd�O‘bh›b+�sgd�HME�b‘ld�sn�ad�vhcdkx� qdf‘qcdc�‘r�‘�rsq‘sdfhb�kh‘ahkhsx-03 Hmcddc+ vgdm sgd T-R- vhsgcq‘v‘k eqnl sgd HME snnj�enql‘k�deedbs�nm�@tftrs�1+�1/08+�hs�v‘r�hlldch‘sdkx�‘oo‘qdms�sg‘s�sgd�Bghm‘� e‘bsnq�g‘c�vdhfgdc�gd‘uhkx�hm�sgd�@ldqhb‘m�cdbhrhnm-�Sgd�sdqlhm‘shnm�ne�sgd�sqd‘, sx�bnhmbhcdc�vhsg�sgd�mdvr�sg‘s�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr�v‘r�ok‘mmhmf�‘�mdv�lhrrhkd�'hm, sdmcdc�sn�bntmsdq Bghm‘+„�‘mc�sgd�T-R-�rdbqds‘qx�ne�cdedmrd�dwoqdrrdc�sgd�fn‘k�ne� cdoknxhmf�fqntmc,a‘rdc�lhrrhkdr�hm�@rh‘�‘r�rnnm�‘r�onrrhakd-04�Lnrbnv�v‘r�lnudc� ax�‘�rhlhk‘q�b‘kbtk‘shnm+�adb‘trd�Bghmdrd�ldchtl,q‘mfd�lhrrhkdr�bntkc�ghs�s‘qfdsr� hm�Qtrrh‘�ats�Qtrrh‘�v‘r�oqdudmsdc�ax�sgd�HME�‘fqddldms�eqnl�cdoknxhmf�‘�rxl, ldsqhb‘k�b‘o‘ahkhsx-05 Gdmbd+ Lnrbnv enkknvdc V‘rghmfsnm hm ‘mmntmbhmf sg‘s hs� vntkc� vhsgcq‘v� eqnl� sgd� HME-� Ltst‘k� @ldqhb‘m� ‘mc� Qtrrh‘m� ‘bbtr‘shnmr� ne� mnmbnlokh‘mbd�vdqd�sgd�oqnwhl‘sd�b‘trd�ne�sgdrd�vhsgcq‘v‘kr+�ats�tmcdqfhqchmf�� sgdrd�cdbhrhnmr�vdqd�rsq‘sdfhb�b‘kbtk‘shnmr�sg‘s�qdfidbsdc�sgd�sgqdd,rhcdc�m‘stqd�ne� sgd�dmuhqnmldms-�

@�rhlhk‘q�sqhk‘sdq‘k�cxm‘lhb�b‘m�ad�rddm�hm�sgd�bnmsdws�ne�a‘kkhrshb�lhrrhkd�cd, edmrd�’ALC(-�Gdqd�vd�›mc�‘�qntmc,qnahm�ne�qdbhoqnb‘k�bnmbdqm+�cqhudm�ax�V‘rg, hmfsnm&r� rtrs‘hmdc� hmudrsldms� hm� lhrrhkd� cdedmrd� nudq� ‘� odqhnc� ne� cdb‘cdr-� Ad, b‘trd�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr�vhsgcqdv�eqnl�sgd�@msh,A‘kkhrshb�Lhrrhkd�’?AL(�Sqd‘sx�hm� 1//1+�sgdqd�‘qd�mn�kdf‘k�bnmrsq‘hmsr�nm�lhrrhkd�cdedmrd�cdoknxldmsr+�‘mc�sgd�Tmhs, dc�Rs‘sdr�‘ood‘qr�sn�onrrdrr�‘m�dwo‘mrhud�‘oodshsd�enq�rtbg�b‘o‘ahkhshdr-�Sgntfg� btqqdms�cdoknxldmsr�‘mc�b‘o‘ahkhshdr�‘qd�pthsd�khlhsdc+�o‘qshbtk‘qkx�‘f‘hmrs�needm, rhud�enqbdr�‘r�k‘qfd�‘r�sgnrd�onrrdrrdc�ax�Qtrrh‘�‘mc�Bghm‘+�Lnrbnv�‘mc�Adhihmf� chrok‘x�o‘ko‘akd�‘ooqdgdmrhnm�sg‘s�sgdhq�cdsdqqdms�onrstqdr�l‘x�dudmst‘kkx�ad�tm, cdqlhmdc�ax�‘cu‘mbdr�hm�T-R-�lhrrhkd�cdedmrd-�

D o w n lo a d e d fro m h ttp ://d ire c t.m it.e d u /d a e d /a rtic le -p d f/1 4 9 /2 /1 7 /1 8 3 2 6 4 2 /d a e d _ a _ 0 1 7 8 7 .p d f b y U N IV O F C A L IF O R N IA S A N T A B A R B A R A u s e r o n 1 5 M a y 2 0 2 3

038�’1(�Roqhmf�1/1/ 12

Rsdudm�D-�Lhkkdq

Sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr�g‘r�rntfgs�sn�‘kk‘x�rtbg�ed‘qr�ax�hmrhrshmf�sg‘s�hsr�lhrrhkd�cd, edmrd�oqnfq‘l�hr�‘hldc�‘s�nsgdq�rs‘sdr�vhsg�rl‘kk�b‘o‘ahkhshdr+�rtbg�‘r�Mnqsg�Jn, qd‘�‘mc�Hq‘m+�‘mc�k‘bjr�sgd�b‘o‘ahkhsx�sn�onrd�‘�rdqhntr�sgqd‘s�sn�Qtrrh‘m�nq�Bghmdrd� mtbkd‘q� enqbdr-� Gnvdudq+� dwokhbhs� chrok‘xr� ne� hmsdqdrs� hm� sgd� Tmhsdc� Rs‘sdr� hm� cd, udknohmf�m‘shnm‘k�lhrrhkd�cdedmrd�enq sgd�gnldk‘mc+�bnmshmtdc�rtars‘msh‘k�hmudrs, ldms�hm�lhrrhkd�cdedmrd�sdbgmnknfx+�‘mc�nbb‘rhnm‘k�tm‘cnqmdc�bnlldmsr�ax�T-R-� ne›bh‘kr�‘mc�‘m‘kxrsr�‘ants�lnqd�‘lahshntr�lhrrhkd�cdedmrd�fn‘kr�tmcdqlhmd�T-R-� ‘ssdlosr�sn�qd‘rrtqd�Qtrrh‘�‘mc�Bghm‘�‘ants�hsr�lhrrhkd�cdedmrd�ok‘mr-�Hm�e‘bs+�sgd� Sqtlo�‘clhmhrsq‘shnm&r�Lhrrhkd�Cdedmrd�Qduhdv+�qdkd‘rdc�hm�I‘mt‘qx�1/08+�l‘jdr� hs�bkd‘q�sg‘s�nmd�ne�sgd�fn‘kr�ne�sgd�T-R-�ALC�deenqs�hr�sn�cd‘k�vhsg�bg‘kkdmfdr�eqnl� Qtrrh‘ ‘mc� Bghm‘-06 Hm tmudhkhmf sgd Lhrrhkd Cdedmrd Qduhdv+ Oqdrhcdms Sqtlo ghlrdke�dlog‘rhydc�sgd�dwo‘mrhud�‘mc�nodm,dmcdc�m‘stqd�ne�sgd�T-R-�ALC�oqn, fq‘l9�'Ntq�fn‘k�hr�rhlokd-�Sn�dmrtqd�sg‘s�vd�b‘m�cdsdbs�‘mc�cdrsqnx�‘mx�lhrrhkd� k‘tmbgdc�‘f‘hmrs�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr�‘mxvgdqd+�‘mxshld+�‘mxok‘bd-„07�Bghm‘�hr�‘krn� khjdkx sn�g‘ud�s‘jdm�mnsd�vgdm�sgd�m‘shnm‘k�rdbtqhsx�‘cuhrnq�ne�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr� r‘hc+�'Bghm‘�hr�athkchmf�hsr�mtbkd‘q�b‘o‘bhsx�mnv-�Hs&r�nmd�ne�sgd�qd‘rnmr�vgx�vd&qd� knnjhmf�‘s�rsqdmfsgdmhmf�ntq�m‘shnm‘k�lhrrhkd�cdedmrd�rxrsdl�gdqd�hm�sgd�Tmhsdc� Rs‘sdr-„08�Enq�Qtrrh‘+�lhrrhkd�cdedmrd�g‘r�addm�cdrbqhadc�‘r�'‘�atqmhmf�hrrtd-„1/� Qtrrh‘m�Oqdrhcdms�Uk‘chlhq�Otshm�g‘r�addm�qdod‘sdckx�ntsronjdm�‘ants�sgd�c‘m, fdq�onrdc�ax�T-R-�ALC-�Hm�ghr�‘mmt‘k�l‘inq�roddbg�sn�sgd�Qtrrh‘m�Edcdq‘k�@rrdl, akx�hm�1/07+�gd�qdl‘qjdc+�'Sgd�T-R-�hr�odqlhsshmf�bnmrs‘ms+�tmbnmsqnkkdc�fqnvsg� ne�sgd�mtladq�ne�‘msh,a‘kkhrshb�lhrrhkdr+�hloqnuhmf�sgdhq�pt‘khsx+�‘mc�bqd‘shmf�mdv� lhrrhkd�k‘tmbghmf�‘qd‘r-�He�vd�cn�mns�cn�rnldsghmf+�dudmst‘kkx�sghr�vhkk�qdrtks�hm� sgd�bnlokdsd�cdu‘kt‘shnm�ne�Qtrrh‘&r�mtbkd‘q�onsdmsh‘k-„�Otshm�okdcfdc�sg‘s�'vd� vhkk�l‘jd�sgd�mdbdrr‘qx�deenqsr�sn�mdtsq‘khyd�sgd�sgqd‘sr�onrdc�ax�sgd�cdoknxldms� ne�sgd�T-R-�fkna‘k�lhrrhkd�cdedmbd�rxrsdl„�‘mc�ntskhmdc�‘m�dwsdmrhud�rds�ne�mtbkd‘q� lncdqmhy‘shnm�deenqsr�sg‘s�vdqd�itrsh›dc�‘r�qd‘bshnmr�sn�sgd�T-R-�ALC�oqnfq‘l-10

Sqh‘mftk‘q�bnmrhcdq‘shnmr�‘qd�‘krn�l‘jhmf�sgdlrdkudr�edks�hm�sgd�qd‘kl�ne�‘qlr� bnmsqnk-�Hmbqd‘rhmfkx+�sgd�uhdv�hm�V‘rghmfsnm�hr�sg‘s�Bghm‘�vhkk�mddc�sn�ad�cq‘vm� hmsn�mdfnsh‘shnmr�‘mc�‘fqddldmsr�sg‘s�vdqd�nmbd�ahk‘sdq‘k-�Bghm‘&r�fqnvhmf�onvdq+� sgd�rsd‘cx�lncdqmhy‘shnm�ne�hsr�mtbkd‘q�enqbdr+�bnmbdqmr�‘ants�sgd�onrrhakd�etstqd� dwo‘mrhnm�ne�hsr�mtbkd‘q�‘qrdm‘k+�‘mc�hsr�rs‘str�vhsg�Qtrrh‘ ‘r�‘�oqhl‘qx�bg‘kkdmf, dq�sn�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr�bnlahmd�sn�rtffdrs�sg‘s�hm�sgd�etstqd�hs�vhkk�ad�hmbqd‘rhmf, kx�che›btks�ansg�sn�kd‘ud�Bghm‘�nts�‘mc�sn�hlonrd�‘cchshnm‘k�bnmrsq‘hmsr�nm�T-R-� ‘mc�Qtrrh‘m�mtbkd‘q�b‘o‘ahkhshdr�he�Bghm‘�qdl‘hmr�tmbnmrsq‘hmdc-�Hs�hr�mns�‘�mdv� sgntfgs�sn�rtffdrs�sg‘s�etstqd�rsq‘sdfhb�‘qlr�‘fqddldmsr�rgntkc�hmbktcd�Bghm‘+� ats�sghr�b‘kbtk‘shnm�hr�adbnlhmf�hmbqd‘rhmfkx�duhcdms�hm�onkhbx�chrbtrrhnmr-�Oqdr, hcdms�Sqtlo+�enq�dw‘lokd+�g‘r�hmrsqtbsdc�ghr�sd‘l�sn�oqdo‘qd�enq�onrrhakd�mtbkd, ‘q�mdfnsh‘shnmr�sg‘s�vntkc�hmbktcd�ansg�Bghm‘�‘mc�Qtrrh‘-�Hmbktchmf�Bghm‘�hm�et, stqd� ‘qlr� bnmsqnk� rddlr� tmcdqrs‘mc‘akd+� qd‘rnm‘akd+� ‘mc� cdrhq‘akd+� ats� ‘s� kd‘rs� hm�sgd�rgnqs,sn,ldchtl�sdql+�hs�vhkk�qdoqdrdms�‘�rhfmh›b‘ms�bnlokhb‘shnm�sg‘s�hr�

D o w n lo a d e d fro m h ttp ://d ire c t.m it.e d u /d a e d /a rtic le -p d f/1 4 9 /2 /1 7 /1 8 3 2 6 4 2 /d a e d _ a _ 0 1 7 8 7 .p d f b y U N IV O F C A L IF O R N IA S A N T A B A R B A R A u s e r o n 1 5 M a y 2 0 2 3

13 Cºc‘ktr+�sgd�Intqm‘k�ne�sgd�@ldqhb‘m�@b‘cdlx�ne�@qsr�%�Rbhdmbdr

@�Mtbkd‘q�Vnqkc�Sq‘mrenqldc9�Sgd�Qhrd�ne�Ltkshk‘sdq‘k�Chrnqcdq

lnqd�khjdkx�sn�hlodcd�oqnfqdrr�sg‘m�sn�kd‘c�sn�sgqdd,rhcdc�bnmrsq‘hmsr-11�Mtbkd, ‘q�‘qlr�bnmsqnk�vhsg�Bghm‘�hr�tmoqdbdcdmsdc+�hsr�enqbd�onrstqd�hr�mns�bnlo‘q‘akd� sn�sgnrd�ne�Qtrrh‘�‘mc�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr+�‘mc�Adhihmf�rgnvr�mn�hmsdqdrs�hm�o‘qshbh, o‘shmf�hm�mdfnsh‘shnmr�tmcdq�sgdrd�bhqbtlrs‘mbdr-�@r�Qhbg‘qc�Atqs+�bghde�mdfnsh, ‘snq�ne�sgd�Rsq‘sdfhb�@qlr�Qdctbshnm�Sqd‘sx+�‘mc�Inm�Vnkersg‘k+�mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr� dwodqs�‘mc�Cºc‘ktr�‘tsgnq+�g‘ud�vqhssdm+�'Sqxhmf�sn�dwo‘mc�mtbkd‘q�cd‘kr�sn�hm, bktcd�Bghm‘�mnv�l‘x�rddl�khjd�‘�fnnc�hcd‘+�ats�hm�oq‘bshbd+�hs�vhkk�g‘ud�khsskd�nq�mn� bg‘mbd�ne�adhmf�‘bghdudc-„12�@mc�hm�sgd�knmfdq�sdql+�‘r�vdkk+�hs�l‘x�oqnud�che›btks� sn�›mc�ltst‘kkx�‘bbdos‘akd�rnktshnmr�hm�sgqdd,v‘x�mdfnsh‘shnmr+�jddohmf�hm�lhmc� sg‘s�dudm�sgd�ahk‘sdq‘k�rsq‘sdfhb�‘qlr�mdfnsh‘shnmr�vdqd�nesdm�‘qctntr�‘mc�o‘hmr, s‘jhmf�‘ee‘hqr�sg‘s�qdpthqdc�xd‘qr�sn�qd‘bg�‘fqddldms-

Hm�rgnqs+�sgd�e‘lhkh‘q�ahk‘sdq‘k�mtbkd‘q�nqcdq�sg‘s�cnlhm‘sdc�mtbkd‘q�‘ee‘hqr�enq� sgd�›qrs�rhw�nq�rdudm�cdb‘cdr�ne�sgd�mtbkd‘q�‘fd�hr�e‘chmf�‘v‘x-�Hm�hsr�ok‘bd�rs‘mcr� ‘� sqh‘mftk‘q� qdk‘shnmrgho� vgnrd� bnlokdwhshdr� vhkk� nmkx� fq‘ct‘kkx� ad� chrbnudqdc+� vgnrd�cxm‘lhbr�‘qd�nmkx�adfhmmhmf�sn�ad�kd‘qmdc-�

S gd�dldqfdmbd�ne�qdfhnm‘k�mtbkd‘q�rtarxrsdlr-� Hm�sgd�gnodetk�c‘xr�‘s�sgd�adfhm, mhmf�ne�sgd�onrsflBnkc�V‘q�dq‘+�bnmbdqmr�‘ants�mtbkd‘q�qdk‘shnmrghor�hm�qd, fhnm‘k�rdsshmfr�rhlokx chc�mns�dwhrs�adb‘trd�ntsrhcd�ne�sgd�D‘rs,Vdrs�bnm,

sdws+�mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr�vdqd�mns�‘�o‘qs�ne�sgd�dpt‘shnm-�Hm�0880+�Hrq‘dk�v‘r�sgd�nmkx� rs‘sd�sgntfgs�sn�onrrdrr�mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr�ntsrhcd�ne�sgd�›ud�mtbkd‘q,‘qldc�rs‘sdr� ‘bjmnvkdcfdc�ax�sgd�Sqd‘sx�nm�sgd�Mnm,Oqnkhedq‘shnm�ne�Mtbkd‘q�Vd‘onmr�’MOS(+� ‘mc� Hrq‘dk&r� mtbkd‘q� b‘o‘ahkhsx� v‘r� no‘ptd+� tm‘bjmnvkdcfdc+� ‘mc� g‘c� mns� oqn, unjdc�rtbbdrretk�mtbkd‘q�‘bpthrhshnm�ax�nsgdq rs‘sdr�hm�sgd�Lhcckd�D‘rs-13�

Sg‘s� adf‘m� sn� bg‘mfd� hm� L‘x� 0887� vgdm� Hmch‘� ‘mc+� rnnm� sgdqd‘esdq+� O‘jhrs‘m� sdrsdc� mtbkd‘q� vd‘onmr+� adbnlhmf� sgd� ›qrs� rs‘sdr� hm� rdudq‘k� cdb‘cdr� sn� nodmkx� sq‘mrfqdrr�sgd�mnmoqnkhedq‘shnm�mnql�‘mc�rddj�‘�cdoknxdc�mtbkd‘q�b‘o‘ahkhsx-�Hm�sgd� hmsdqudmhmf�xd‘qr+�ansg�Mdv�Cdkgh�‘mc�Hrk‘l‘a‘c�g‘ud�hmudrsdc�rsd‘chkx�hm�sgdhq� mtbkd‘q� oqnfq‘lr+� g‘ud� oqnctbdc� mtbkd‘q� vd‘onmr� mtladqhmf� hm� sgd� gtmcqdcr+� ‘mc� g‘ud� ‘bpthqdc hmbqd‘rhmfkx� chudqrd� ‘mc� b‘o‘akd� cdkhudqx� rxrsdlr-� @� qdfhnm‘k� mtbkd‘q�nqcdq�mnv�dwhrsr�hm�Rntsg�@rh‘fl‘�cq‘l‘shb�bg‘mfd�eqnl�sgd�vnqkc�ne�0880-

Mtbkd‘q,‘qldc� Rntsg� @rh‘� hr� ‘� rntqbd� ne� l‘inq� bnmbdqm� enq� rdudq‘k� qd‘rnmr-� Ehqrs+�qdk‘shnmr�adsvddm�Hmch‘�‘mc�O‘jhrs‘m�qdl‘hm�eq‘tfgs�‘mc�rdqhntr�hmbhcdmsr� adsvddm�sgdl�nbbtq�vhsg�rnld�qdftk‘qhsx-�@�rsqhmf�ne�bqhrdrflsgd�0888�J‘qfhk�V‘q+� sgd�1//0�sdqqnqhrs�‘ss‘bj�nm�sgd�Hmch‘m�O‘qkh‘ldms�hm�Mdv�Cdkgh+�sgd�1//7�anla, hmfr�hm�Ltla‘h+�‘lnmf�nsgdq�hmbhcdmsr�‘mc�bk‘rgdrflg‘r�ghfgkhfgsdc�sgd�c‘mfdqr� ne�‘btsd�eqhbshnm�adsvddm�svn�mtbkd‘q,‘qldc�rs‘sdr-�Hm�L‘qbg�1/08+�‘m�Hmch‘m�‘hq, bq‘es�uhnk‘sdc�O‘jhrs‘mh�‘hqro‘bd+�v‘r�rgns�cnvm+�‘mc�sgd�ohkns�v‘r�b‘ostqdc+�bqd‘s, hmf�‘�onsdmsh‘kkx�hmbdmch‘qx�bqhrhr�‘mc�oqnuhchmf�xds�‘mnsgdq�hkktrsq‘shnm�ne�sgd�e‘bs� sg‘s�Rntsg�@rh‘�hr�‘�c‘mfdqntr�rdsshmf�enq�mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr-�Rdbnmc+�hs�hr�mns�bkd‘q� gnv�rs‘akd�sgd�mtbkd‘q�a‘k‘mbd�hm�Rntsg�@rh‘�b‘m�ad-�E‘q�eqnl�adhmf�rdo‘q‘sdc�ax�

D o w n lo a d e d fro m h ttp ://d ire c t.m it.e d u /d a e d /a rtic le -p d f/1 4 9 /2 /1 7 /1 8 3 2 6 4 2 /d a e d _ a _ 0 1 7 8 7 .p d f b y U N IV O F C A L IF O R N IA S A N T A B A R B A R A u s e r o n 1 5 M a y 2 0 2 3

038�’1(�Roqhmf�1/1/ 14

Rsdudm�D-�Lhkkdq

gdlhrogdqdr+�‘r�vdqd�sgd�Rnuhds�Tmhnm�‘mc�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr+�Hmch‘�‘mc�O‘jhrs‘m� ‘qd�hlldch‘sd�mdhfganqr�vhsg�‘�rg‘qdc�anqcdq�‘mc�‘�ghrsnqx�ne�v‘q-�Chrs‘mbdr�‘mc� fixhmf�shldr�‘qd�rgnqs+�v‘qmhmf�shld�vhkk�ad�lhmhl‘k+�mtbkd‘q�‘rrdsr�‘mc�bnll‘mc� ‘mc�bnmsqnk�l‘x�ad�utkmdq‘akd�’onrrhakx�oqnctbhmf�oqddloshud�nq�trd,sgdl,nq, knrd,sgdl�oqdrrtqdr(+�‘mc�hm�O‘jhrs‘m&r�b‘rd+�hs�g‘r�‘cnosdc�‘�M?SN,khjd�cnbsqhmd� ne� ›qrs� trd� hmsdmcdc� sn� mdtsq‘khyd� Hmch‘&r� bnmudmshnm‘k� ‘cu‘ms‘fdr-� Sgd� Hmch‘m� ‘mc� O‘jhrs‘mh� fnudqmldmsr� g‘ud� rgnvm� sgdhq� ‘ahkhsx� sn� l‘m‘fd� hmbhcdmsr� vghkd� ‘unhchmf�drb‘k‘shnm+�ats�hs�hr�e‘q�eqnl�qd‘rrtqhmf�sg‘s�sghr�onrrhakx�oqdb‘qhntr�mt, bkd‘q�a‘k‘mbd�hr�sdrsdc�ax�bqhrhr�‘esdq�bqhrhr-�Hs�hr�sghr�cxm‘lhb�sg‘s�kd‘cr�l‘mx�sn�ad, khdud�sg‘s�mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr�‘qd�lnqd�khjdkx�sn�ad�trdc�hm�Rntsg�@rh‘�sg‘m�‘mxvgdqd� dkrd-�Sghqc+�Hmch‘&r�rdbtqhsx�onkhbx�‘mc�mtbkd‘q�onrstqd�‘qd�hmfitdmbdc�mns�nmkx�ax� O‘jhrs‘m�ats�‘krn�ax�Bghm‘+�vhsg�vgnl�hs�g‘r�‘�ghrsnqx�ne�tmdudm�qdk‘shnmr+�tmqd, rnkudc� anqcdq� hrrtdr+� bnmbdqm� ‘ants� Adhihmf&r� bknrd� qdk‘shnmr� vhsg� O‘jhrs‘m+� ‘mc� o‘rs�v‘qr�vhsghm�khuhmf�ldlnqx-�Gdqd�sgdm�vd�›mc�‘mnsgdq�sqh‘mfkd+�nmd�sg‘s�hm, sdqrdbsr�vhsg�sgd�fqd‘s,onvdq�sqh‘mfkd�‘mc�q‘hrdr�sgd�oqnrodbs�ne�b‘rb‘chmf�qhookd� deedbsr-�Bghmdrd�qdronmrdr�sn�cdudknoldmsr� hm�T-R-�mtbkd‘q�onkhbx�b‘m�‘eedbs�Hm, ch‘&r�b‘kbtk‘shnmr+�vghbg�hm�stqm�vhkk�g‘ud�hlokhb‘shnmr�enq�O‘jhrs‘m-�

@esdq�Hmch‘�‘mc�O‘jhrs‘m�b‘ld�Mnqsg�Jnqd‘-�@r�sgd�Bnkc�V‘q�qdbdcdc�‘mc�‘r� enqldq� Rnuhds� vd‘onmr� vdqd� rdbtqdc� hm� Qtrrh‘+� knnlhmf� oqnkhedq‘shnm� bnmbdqmr� bdmsdqdc� nm� Mnqsg� Jnqd‘&r� mtbkd‘q� adg‘uhnq-� Gnvdudq+� sghr� bqhrhr� v‘r� rs‘udc� nee�enq�md‘qkx�‘�cdb‘cd�ax�sgd�0883�@fqddc�Eq‘ldvnqj+�vghbg�rhfmh›b‘mskx�bnm, rsq‘hmdc�Oxnmfx‘mf&r�mtbkd‘q�oqnfq‘l�‘mc�ots�hsr�mtbkd‘q�‘rrdsr�tmcdq�H?D?�rt, odquhrhnm-�Ats�sghr�‘qq‘mfdldms�bnkk‘ordc�hm�1//1+�Mnqsg�Jnqd‘�vhsgcqdv�eqnl� sgd�MOS�hm�1//2+�‘mc�ax�1//5+�hs�g‘c�bnmctbsdc�hsr�›qrs�sdrs�ne�‘�mtbkd‘q�vd‘onm-�Hm� sgd�rtardptdms�cdb‘cd�‘mc�‘�g‘ke+�Mnqsg�Jnqd‘�g‘r�bnmctbsdc�‘�rdqhdr�ne�mtbkd‘q� vd‘onm�‘mc�lhrrhkd�sdrsr�‘mc�‘bpthqdc�‘m�drshl‘sdc�edv�cnydm�mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr+� g‘r�cdoknxdc�lhrrhkdr�b‘o‘akd�ne�ghsshmf�qdfhnm‘k�s‘qfdsr�rtbg�‘r�I‘o‘m�‘mc�Rntsg� Jnqd‘+�‘mc�g‘r�sdrsdc�lhrrhkdr�ne�hmsdqbnmshmdms‘k�q‘mfd�sg‘s+�he�cdoknxdc+�vntkc� fhud�Oxnmfx‘mf�sgd�‘ahkhsx�sn�sgqd‘sdm�s‘qfdsr� hm�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr�vhsg�mtbkd‘q� ‘ss‘bj-�Sgtr+�nmd�ne�sgd�vnqkc&r�lnrs�hrnk‘sdc�‘mc�dqq‘shb�qdfhldr+�kdc�ax�‘m�dw, sqdldkx�‘tsgnqhs‘qh‘m�fnudqmldms�sg‘s�ok‘bdr�dwsq‘nqchm‘qx�onvdq�hm�sgd�g‘mcr� ne�‘�rhmfkd�dbbdmsqhb�hmchuhct‘k+�hr�‘�mtbkd‘q,‘qldc�rs‘sd-�Sghr�g‘r�addm�nmd�ne�sgd� lnrs�chrstqahmf�cdudknoldmsr�ne�sgd�o‘rs�svdmsx�xd‘qr�‘mc�g‘r�fqd‘skx�bnlokhb‘s, dc�sgd�rdbtqhsx�cxm‘lhbr�hm�Mnqsgd‘rs�@rh‘-

Mnqsg�Jnqd‘�hr�‘�rs‘sd+�lnqdnudq+�vhsg�‘�knmf�ghrsnqx�ne�cddokx�gnrshkd�qdk‘shnmr� vhsg�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr�‘mc�hsr�qdfhnm‘k�‘kkhdr-�Hmcddc+�adb‘trd�‘�enql‘k�od‘bd�sqd‘, sx�v‘r�mdudq�qd‘bgdc�adsvddm�Mnqsg�Jnqd‘�‘mc�sgd�bn‘khshnm�ne�rs‘sdr�sg‘s�entfgs� ‘f‘hmrs�hs+�sgdrd�rs‘sdr�qdl‘hm�sdbgmhb‘kkx�hm�‘�rs‘sd�ne�v‘q-�Oxnmfx‘mf�g‘r�fhudm� ltbg� duhcdmbd� nudq� ‘� oqnsq‘bsdc� odqhnc� ne� shld� sg‘s� hs� eddkr� ‘btsdkx� sgqd‘sdmdc� ax� sgd� Tmhsdc� Rs‘sdr� ‘mc� hsr� Rntsg� Jnqd‘m� ‘kkxflvgn� snfdsgdq� cv‘qe� Mnqsg� Jn, qd‘�hm�dbnmnlhb�lhfgs�‘mc�lhkhs‘qx�onvdqflrn�hs�hr�khjdkx�sg‘s�hs�qdf‘qcr�hsr�mtbkd‘q�

D o w n lo a d e d fro m h ttp ://d ire c t.m it.e d u /d a e d /a rtic le -p d f/1 4 9 /2 /1 7 /1 8 3 2 6 4 2 /d a e d _ a _ 0 1 7 8 7 .p d f b y U N IV O F C A L IF O R N IA S A N T A B A R B A R A u s e r o n 1 5 M a y 2 0 2 3

15 Cºc‘ktr+�sgd�Intqm‘k�ne�sgd�@ldqhb‘m�@b‘cdlx�ne�@qsr�%�Rbhdmbdr

@�Mtbkd‘q�Vnqkc�Sq‘mrenqldc9�Sgd�Qhrd�ne�Ltkshk‘sdq‘k�Chrnqcdq

vd‘onmr�‘r�‘�mdbdrr‘qx�ft‘q‘msnq�ne�hsr�rdbtqhsx+�he�mns�rtquhu‘k-�Oxnmfx‘mf&r�ed‘q� ne� ‘ss‘bj� ‘ood‘qr� sn� ad� fdmthmdflmns� rtqoqhrhmfkx+� rhmbd� sgd� Tmhsdc� Rs‘sdr� g‘r� hm�e‘bs�sgqd‘sdmdc�Mnqsg�Jnqd‘�hm�‘�u‘qhdsx�ne�v‘xrfl‘mc�hr�‘�unk‘shkd�e‘bsnq�sg‘s� bntkc�oqnud�cdrs‘ahkhyhmf�‘mc�dudm�drb‘k‘snqx�hm�‘�bqhrhr-

Sgd�Mnqsg�Jnqd‘m�rhst‘shnm�hlohmfdr�nm�sgd�hmsdqdrsr�ne�Bghm‘�‘mc�Qtrrh‘�‘r� vdkk�‘r�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr+�ld‘mhmf�sg‘s�hm�Mnqsgd‘rs�@rh‘�vd�›mc�‘�pt‘cqhk‘sdq‘k� rds�ne�mtbkd‘q,‘qldc�rs‘sdr�hmunkudc�hm�‘ssdloshmf�sn�l‘m‘fd�sgd�qdfhnm&r�rdbt, qhsx�‘ee‘hqr+�ats�vhsg�cheedqdms�qdk‘shnmrghor�‘lnmf�sgd�pt‘cqhk‘sdq‘k ‘bsnqr+�che, edqdms�b‘o‘ahkhshdr�sn�hmfitdmbd�sgd�qdfhnm‘k�rhst‘shnm+�‘mc�cheedqdms�hmsdqdrsr�‘mc� oqdedqqdc�ntsbnldr-�Sn�bnlokhb‘sd�l‘ssdqr�etqsgdq+�svn�jdx�‘bsnqr�hm�sgd�qdfhnm+� I‘o‘m�‘mc�Rntsg�Jnqd‘+�‘qd�@ldqhb‘m�‘kkhdr�‘mc�admd›s�eqnl�T-R-�mtbkd‘q�ft‘q‘m, sddr-�Mnqsgd‘rs�@rh‘�hr�‘�gd‘uhkx�mtbkd‘qhydc�qdfhnm9�dudqx�‘bsnq�hm�sgd�qdfhnm�hr�‘� o‘qs�ne�sgd�qdfhnm‘k�mtbkd‘q�nqcdq+�vgdsgdq�chqdbskx�nq�hmchqdbskx-

Sghr� chrstqahmf� ohbstqd� hkktrsq‘sdr� rdudq‘k� tmenqstm‘sd� bnmrdptdmbdr� ne� sgd� qhrd�ne�qdfhnm‘k�mtbkd‘q�nqcdqr-�Ehqrs+�‘r�v‘r�sgd�b‘rd�hm�Rntsg�@rh‘+�sgd�rhst‘shnm� hm�Mnqsgd‘rs�@rh‘�q‘hrdr�mtbkd‘q�qhrjr�hm�‘m�dmuhqnmldms�hm�vghbg�adkkhbnrd�qgdsn, qhb�g‘r�addm�bnllnmok‘bd�‘mc�rdqhntr�hmbhcdmsrflhmbktchmf�lhmnq�trdr�ne�enqbdfl g‘ud� qdbtqqdc-� Sgd� tmdwodbsdc� cçsdmsd� hm� 1/07� adsvddm� Oqdrhcdms� Sqtlo� ‘mc� Mnqsg�Jnqd‘m�kd‘cdq�Jhl�Inmf,tm�g‘r�b‘kldc�sgd�rhst‘shnm�enq�sgd�shld�adhmf+�ats� hs�hr�mns�bkd‘q�gnv�knmf�sg‘s�vhkk�k‘rs�nq�vgdqd�hs�hr�gd‘chmf-�Sgdhq�e‘hkdc�G‘mnh�rtl, lhs�rtffdrsr�sg‘s�bnmshmtdc�oqnfqdrr�l‘x�mns�ad�enqsgbnlhmf-�Ats�sgd�lnqd�bnl, lnm�lncd�hm�Mnqsg�Jnqd‘m�qdk‘shnmr�vhsg�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr�‘mc�Rntsg�Jnqd‘�g‘r� addm�eqhbshnm�‘mc�bnmeqnms‘shnm-�Hmcddc+�sgd�‘msdbdcdms�sn�sgd�SqtloflJhl�Inmf, tm�gnmdxlnnm�v‘r�sgd�v‘q�rb‘qd�ne�1/06-�Nm�sgd�@ldqhb‘m�rhcd+�sghr�v‘r�l‘qjdc� ax� sgd� lnudldms� ne� m‘u‘k� enqbdr+� oqnunb‘shud� fihfgsr� ‘knmf� Mnqsg� Jnqd‘&r� bn‘rs+� du‘bt‘shnm�ne�rnld�T-R-�bhshydmr�eqnl�Rntsg�Jnqd‘+�‘mc�g‘qrg�sgqd‘sr�eqnl�Oqdr, hcdms� Sqtlo-� Vhsg� ‘� bqdrbdmcn� ne� hmfi‘ll‘snqx� qgdsnqhb� hm� sgd� k‘sd� rtlldq� ne� 1/06+� Sqtlo� cdkhudqdc� ghr� lnrs� fi‘lanx‘ms� ‘mc� ldlnq‘akd� khmd9� 'Mnqsg� Jnqd‘� adrs�mns�l‘jd�‘mx�lnqd�sgqd‘sr�sn�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr-�Sgdx�vhkk�ad�lds�vhsg�›qd�‘mc� etqx�khjd�sgd�vnqkc�g‘r�mdudq�rddm-„�Sghr�v‘r+�‘r�sgd�Mdv�Xnqj�Shldr�‘bbntms�bnl, ldmsdc+� 'bghkkhmf� k‘mft‘fd� sg‘s� dunjdc� sgd� gnqqnq� ne� ‘� mtbkd‘q� dwbg‘mfd-„14� Nm� sgd�Mnqsg�Jnqd‘m�rhcd+�1/06�v‘r�‘�xd‘q�ne�ltkshokd�lhrrhkd�sdrsr+�‘�mtbkd‘q�vd‘onm� sdrs+�‘mc�aq‘rg�qgdsnqhb�eqnl�Jhl�Inmf,tm+�hmbktchmf�odqrnm‘k�hmrtksr�ne�Oqdrhcdms� Sqtlo-�Sghr�v‘r�‘�bnmsdrs�hm�qdbhoqnb‘k�sgqd‘s�‘mc�oqnunb‘shud�‘bshnmr�sg‘s�oqn, ctbdc� fdmthmd� ed‘qr� ne� v‘q-� 'Mtbkd‘q� v‘q� rddlr� sdqqhexhmfkx� hl‘fhm‘akd+„� vqnsd� Mdv�Xnqj�Shldr�bnktlmhrs�Mhbgnk‘r�Jqhrsne�hm�sgd�lhcrs�ne�sghr�bqhrhr-15

Rdbnmc+� Mnqsg� Jnqd‘� chrok‘xr� edv� ne� sgd� pt‘khshdr� ‘mc� b‘o‘ahkhshdr� sg‘s� l‘jd� enq�deedbshud�bqhrhr�l‘m‘fdldms-16�Hsr�lhkhs‘qx�bnll‘mc�rxrsdl�hr�tmkhjdkx�sn�oqn, lnsd�‘bbtq‘sd�‘mc�sqtsgetk�qdonqshmf�vghkd�hsr�d‘qkx,v‘qmhmf�rxrsdlr�k‘bj�rnoghrsh, b‘shnm�‘mc�qdctmc‘mbx-�Lhrs‘jdr+�lhrodqbdoshnmr+�‘mc�dqqnqr�‘qd�tmkhjdkx�sn�ad�qd, onqsdc�nq�bnqqdbsdc�adb‘trd�ne�sgd�ed‘q�ne�otmhrgldms�hm�‘�g‘qrg�cnldrshb�onkhshb‘k�

D o w n lo a d e d fro m h ttp ://d ire c t.m it.e d u /d a e d /a rtic le -p d f/1 4 9 /2 /1 7 /1 8 3 2 6 4 2 /d a e d _ a _ 0 1 7 8 7 .p d f b y U N IV O F C A L IF O R N IA S A N T A B A R B A R A u s e r o n 1 5 M a y 2 0 2 3

038�’1(�Roqhmf�1/1/ 16

Rsdudm�D-�Lhkkdq

dmuhqnmldms-�Rdmhnq�cdbhrhnm,l‘jdqr�‘qd�pthsd�khjdkx�sn�ad�nodq‘shmf�nm�sgd�a‘rhr� ne�hm‘cdpt‘sd�nq�hm‘bbtq‘sd�hmenql‘shnm+�vgdsgdq�qdronmchmf�sn�‘m�‘bst‘k�bqhrhr�nq� ‘�e‘krd�‘k‘ql-�Hm�‘cchshnm+�Oxnmfx‘mf�bnlahmdr�rtars‘msh‘k�utkmdq‘ahkhsx�sn�‘ss‘bj� vhsg�cddo�’‘mc�onrrhakx�v‘qq‘msdc(�ed‘qr�ne�‘ss‘bj+�‘�lhw�sg‘s�bntkc�oqnud�rg‘qokx� drb‘k‘snqx�hm�‘�bqhrhr+�drodbh‘kkx�hm�uhdv�ne�Mnqsg�Jnqd‘&r�oqddloshud�mtbkd‘q�cnb, sqhmd-�He�Oxnmfx‘mf�adkhdudr+�qhfgskx�nq�vqnmfkx+�sg‘s�hs�hr�tmcdq�‘ss‘bj�nq�‘ants�sn� ad�‘ss‘bjdc+�hs�bntkc�vdkk�eddk�oqdrrtqdc�sn�trd�mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr�oqddloshudkx�d‘q, kx�hm�‘�bqhrhr-�Sgd�dwhrsdmbd�ne�rtbg�hmbdmshudr�hm�‘�qdfhnm�oqnmd�sn�sdmrhnm�‘mc�bnm, eqnms‘shnm‘k�hmbhcdmsr�hr�dwsqdldkx�c‘mfdqntr-�Sgdqd�hr�khsskd�qd‘rnm�sn�ad�bnm›cdms� sg‘s�sgd�Mnqsg�Jnqd‘m�rxrsdl�vntkc�ad�hmbkhmdc�nq�‘akd�sn�adg‘ud�hm�‘�b‘qdetk+�b‘t, shntr+�qdrsq‘hmdc+�nq�chrbhokhmdc�v‘x�tmcdq�sgd�oqdrrtqd�ne�‘�mtbkd‘q�bqhrhr-�Sgd�sq‘, chshnm‘k�qdldcx�sn�rtbg�mtbkd‘q�qhrjr�hr�sn�oqnlnsd�rsq‘sdfhb�rs‘ahkhsx+�vghbg�vntkc� hlokx�‘bbdoshmf+�he�mns�e‘bhkhs‘shmf+�sgd�dldqfdmbd�ne�‘�ltst‘k�cdsdqqdmbd�qdk‘shnm, rgho�adsvddm�Oxnmfx‘mf�‘mc�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr-�Adb‘trd�ne�Mnqsg�Jnqd‘&r�khlhsdc� mtbkd‘q�b‘o‘ahkhshdr�‘mc�V‘rghmfsnm&r�l‘rrhud�‘cu‘ms‘fd�hm�lhkhs‘qx�onvdq+�hs� hr� mns�bkd‘q�vgdsgdq�hs�hr�onrrhakd�enq�Oxnmfx‘mf�sn�cdudkno�‘�bqdchakd�cdsdqqdms�onr, stqd-�Ats�sgd�oqnakdl�hr�dw‘bdqa‘sdc�ax�@ldqhb‘m�onkhbhdr�‘hldc�‘s�oqdrdquhmf�bn, dqbhud�‘mc�oqddloshud�noshnmr�‘f‘hmrs�Mnqsg�Jnqd‘9�T-R-�onkhbx�oqnknmfr�‘mc�qdhm, enqbdr�sgd�hmrs‘ahkhshdr�sg‘s�q‘hrd�eqhfgsdmhmf�mtbkd‘q�qhrjr�nm�sgd�Jnqd‘m�odmhmrtk‘-� Enq�sgd�enqdrdd‘akd�etstqd+�‘�bqhrhr+�‘m�hmbhcdms+�nq�dudm�‘�e‘krd�‘k‘ql�hm�sghr�qdfhnm� qdoqdrdmsr�‘�chrsqdrrhmfkx�ok‘trhakd�o‘sg�sn�sgd�trd�ne�mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr-

Sghqc+�sgd�Mnqsg�Jnqd‘m�b‘rd�chrok‘xr�‘r�vdkk�sgd�hmsdqbnmmdbsdcmdrr�ne�qdfhnm, ‘k�mtbkd‘q�nqcdqr�vhsg�sgd�vhcdq�fkna‘k�dmuhqnmldms-�Sn�oqnuhcd�oqnsdbshnm�eqnl� sgd�Mnqsg�Jnqd‘m�lhrrhkd�sgqd‘s�hm�Mnqsgd‘rs�@rh‘+�enq�dw‘lokd+�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr� hr�cdoknxhmf�hsr�Sgd‘sdq�Ghfg�@kshstcd�@qd‘�Cdedmrd�’SG??C(�rxrsdl�hm�Rntsg�Jn, qd‘-�Sn�@ldqhb‘m�dxdr+�sghr hr�‘�khlhsdc�‘mc�otqdkx�qdfhnm‘k�cdoknxldms+�‘hldc�‘s� Mnqsg�Jnqd‘+�vghbg�rgntkc�g‘ud�mn�rhfmh›b‘ms� hlokhb‘shnmr�enq�Bghm‘-�Odqg‘or� mns� rtqoqhrhmfkx+� Adhihmf� cndr� mns� rdd� hs� sg‘s� v‘x� ‘mc� g‘r� qd‘bsdc� udqx mdf‘shud, kx+�bqhshbhyhmf�sgd�lnud�‘mc�oqdrrtqhmf�Rntsg�Jnqd‘�sn�bg‘mfd�hsr�onkhbx-�Bghm‘�‘o, od‘qr�sn�adkhdud�sg‘s�sgd�q‘c‘q�‘rrnbh‘sdc�vhsg�sgd�SG??C�cdoknxldms�hm�Rntsg� Jnqd‘�vhkk�‘tfldms�dwhrshmf�@ldqhb‘m�b‘o‘ahkhshdr�hm�v‘xr�sg‘s�hmbqd‘rd�sgd�T-R-� ‘ahkhsx�sn�oqdbhrdkx�sq‘bj�‘mc�s‘qfds�Bghmdrd�lhrrhkdr+�sgdqdax�cdfq‘chmf�hsr�cdsdq, qdms�enqbd-17�@r�Kh�Ahm+�nmd�ne�Bghm‘&r�kd‘chmf�rsq‘sdfhb�dwodqsr�‘mc�‘�bnmsqhatsnq� sn�sghr�unktld+�g‘r�dwok‘hmdc+�'Bghm‘�g‘r�sn�vnqqx�sg‘s�sgd�SG??C�q‘c‘q�hm�sgd� QNJ�vntkc�tmcdqlhmd�Bghm‘&r�mtbkd‘q�cdsdqqdmbd�ax�bnkkdbshmf�hlonqs‘ms�c‘s‘� nm�Bghmdrd�mtbkd‘q�v‘qgd‘cr�sg‘s�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr�bntkc�mns�‘bpthqd�eqnl�nsg, dq�rntqbdr-„18�Sgtr+�V‘rghmfsnm&r�deenqs�sn�‘ccqdrr�sgd�bg‘kkdmfd�onrdc�ax�Mnqsg� Jnqd‘&r�mtbkd‘q�‘qrdm‘k�hr�g‘uhmf�‘�chqdbs�hlo‘bs�nm�hsr�qdk‘shnmrgho�vhsg�Bghm‘-�He�� Bghm‘�qdronmcr�uhfnqntrkx�sn�sghr�odqbdhudc�sgqd‘s�sn�hsr�cdsdqqdms�enqbd+�sghr�vhkk� ‘klnrs�rtqdkx�g‘ud�hlokhb‘shnmr�enq�nsgdq�mtbkd‘q�‘bsnqr�’o‘qshbtk‘qkx�Hmch‘(�hm�sgd� sqh‘mfkdr�sg‘s�hmunkud�Bghm‘-

D o w n lo a d e d fro m h ttp ://d ire c t.m it.e d u /d a e d /a rtic le -p d f/1 4 9 /2 /1 7 /1 8 3 2 6 4 2 /d a e d _ a _ 0 1 7 8 7 .p d f b y U N IV O F C A L IF O R N IA S A N T A B A R B A R A u s e r o n 1 5 M a y 2 0 2 3

17 Cºc‘ktr+�sgd�Intqm‘k�ne�sgd�@ldqhb‘m�@b‘cdlx�ne�@qsr�%�Rbhdmbdr

@�Mtbkd‘q�Vnqkc�Sq‘mrenqldc9�Sgd�Qhrd�ne�Ltkshk‘sdq‘k�Chrnqcdq

Vhsg�sgd�dldqfdmbd�ne�qdfhnm‘k�mtbkd‘q�a‘k‘mbdr+�sgdqd�‘qd�mdv�mtbkd‘q�ok‘x, dqr+� mdv� qhrjr+� mdv� rntqbdr� ne� onsdmsh‘k� mtbkd‘q� trd+� ltkshokxhmf� vnqqhdr� ‘ants� mtbkd‘q� rs‘ahkhsx+� ‘mc� mdv� rdsr� ne� hmsdqrdbshmf� onkhbx� bnmbdqmr� ‘mc� b‘kbtk‘shnmr-� Lnqdnudq+�sgdrd�qdfhnm‘k�cxm‘lhbr�‘qd�ok‘xhmf�nts�hm�sgd�bnmsdws�ne�‘m�hmsdqm‘, shnm‘k� rxrsdl� sg‘s� hr� lnqd� bnlokdw� ‘mc� ‘� bnqd� mtbkd‘q� nqcdq� ‘lnmf� sgd� l‘inq� onvdqr�sg‘s�hr�lnqd�sqh‘mftk‘q�sg‘m�ahk‘sdq‘k-�@r�onkhshb‘k�rbhdmshrs�‘mc�bndchsnq�ne� sghr�unktld�Qnadqs�Kdfunkc�g‘r�vqhssdm�ne�sghr�bg‘kkdmfd+�

Nudq� sgd� enqsx�xd‘qr� ne� sgd� Bnkc� V‘q+� kd‘cdqr+� cdedmrd� ok‘mmdqr+� ‘mc� otmchsr� rknvkx� b‘ld�sn�tmcdqrs‘mc�sgd�cxm‘lhbr�ne�‘�svn,rhcdc�mtbkd‘q�bnlodshshnm�hm�‘�svn,rhcdc� fkna‘k�rdsshmffldudm�he�sg‘s�rdsshmf�adf‘m�sn�knrd�hsr�bngdrhnm�hm�hsr�k‘sdq�xd‘qr-�Ats�gnv� vdqd�sgd�cxm‘lhbr�ne�‘�l‘mx,rhcdc�mtbkd‘q vnqkc+�vhsg�o‘hqhmfr�‘mc�sqh‘mfkdr�ltksh, okxhmf+�hm�‘�eq‘bstqdc�hmsdqm‘shnm‘k�onkhshb‘k�rdsshmf�sn�ad�tmcdqrsnnc>2/�

Sghr�ptdrshnm�onrdr�‘�mdv�bg‘kkdmfd�‘mc�qdoqdrdmsr�‘m�dmnqlntr�bg‘mfd�eqnl� sgd�vnqkc�ne�0880-

M tbkd‘q�sdqqnqhrl�bkhlar�sgd�‘fdmc‘�ne�vnqqhdr-�Hs�hr�rhlokx�hlonrrhakd�sn�tm, cdqrs‘mc� @ldqhb‘m rdbtqhsx� onkhbx� hm� sgd� onrsflBnkc� V‘q� dq‘� vhsgnts� qdbnfmhyhmf�sgd�bdmsq‘khsx�ne�mtbkd‘q�sdqqnqhrl�hm�V‘rghmfsnm&r�sgqd‘s�

odqbdoshnmr-� Sn� ad� rtqd+� mtbkd‘q� sdqqnqhrl� v‘r� ‘� bnmbdqm� dudm� ctqhmf� sgd� Bnkc� V‘q+�ats�hs�v‘r�mns�oqnlhmdms�hm�sgd�onkhbx�chrbntqrd�‘mc�hs�v‘r�mns�‘�l‘inq�hmfit, dmbd�nm�mtbkd‘q�onkhbx-20�Rhmbd�sgd�dmc�ne�sgd�Bnkc�V‘q+�gnvdudq+�hs�g‘r�kd‘os�to� sgd�‘fdmc‘�ne�mtbkd‘q�vnqqhdr9�hmcddc+�enq�‘�mtladq�ne�xd‘qr+�mtbkd‘q�sdqqnqhrl� v‘r�vhcdkx�qdf‘qcdc�‘r�sgd�fq‘udrs�c‘mfdq�sn�@ldqhb‘m�rdbtqhsx-21�Sghr�dkdu‘shnm� nbbtqqdc�hm�svn�og‘rdr-�Hm�sgd�›qrs+�rs‘qshmf�hm�sgd�d‘qkx�088/r+�sgd�cqhuhmf�bnmrhc, dq‘shnm�v‘r�ed‘q�sg‘s�sgd�l‘rrhud�ats�rg‘ssdqdc�‘mc�hlonudqhrgdc�Rnuhds�mtbkd‘q� bnlokdw�lhfgs� kd‘j�vd‘onmr,qdkdu‘ms�l‘sdqh‘kr�‘mc�dwodqshrd�‘mc�sgdqdax�oqn, uhcd�‘�onsdmsh‘kkx�k‘qfd�rtookx�ne�mtbkd‘q�‘rrdsr�enq�‘m�hmsdqm‘shnm‘k�ak‘bj�l‘qjds-� Sghr�bntkc�etdk�sgd�oqnkhedq‘shnm�ne�vd‘onmr�sn�rs‘sdr�ats�bntkc�‘krn�oqnuhcd�‘m�no, onqstmhsx�enq�dwsqdlhrs�sdqqnqhrs�fqntor�sn�f‘hm�‘bbdrr�sn�mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr�nq�sgd� l‘sdqh‘kr�‘mc�dwodqshrd�sn�l‘jd�sgdl-�Hm�sgd�bg‘nshb�‘esdql‘sg�ne�sgd�bnkk‘ord�ne� sgd�enqldq�Rnuhds�Tmhnm+�vhsg�onkhshb‘k�‘mc�rnbh‘k�hmrs‘ahkhsx�vhcdroqd‘c+�atcfdsr� oktlldshmf+�‘mc�ydqn�cdl‘mc�enq�sgd�rdquhbdr�ne�sgd�mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr�bnlokdw+� sgdqd�v‘r�mn�bnm›cdmbd�sg‘s�sgd�Rnuhds�Tmhnm&r�mtbkd‘q�‘rrdsr�vntkc�ad�oqnodq, kx�rdbtqdc-�Sghr�v‘r�tmcdqrsnnc�‘r�‘�bqhrhr�‘mc�adb‘ld�‘m�‘ahchmf�oqhnqhsx�ctqhmf� sgd�088/r-�Sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr�k‘tmbgdc�sgd�Bnnodq‘shud�Sgqd‘s�Qdctbshnm�oqnfq‘l� ’‘krn�jmnvm�‘r�sgd�Mtmm,Ktf‘q�oqnfq‘l+�‘esdq�sgd�svn�rdm‘snqr�vgn�ronmrnqdc� sgd�nqhfhm‘k�kdfhrk‘shnm(�hm�0880+�‘hldc�‘s�vnqjhmf�vhsg�Qtrrh‘�sn�dmrtqd�sg‘s�‘kk� mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr�‘mc�l‘sdqh‘kr�vdqd�r‘edkx�‘mc�rdbtqdkx�rsnqdc-�Xd‘qr�ne�deenqs�‘mc� ahkkhnmr� ne� cnkk‘qr� vdqd� hmudrsdc� hm� sghr� deenqs+� vhsg� bnmrhcdq‘akd� rtbbdrr� hm� hl, oqnuhmf�sgd�rdbtqhsx�‘s�Qtrrh‘m�mtbkd‘q�e‘bhkhshdr-�Sghr�dwodqhdmbd�‘krn�oqnctbdc�

D o w n lo a d e d fro m h ttp ://d ire c t.m it.e d u /d a e d /a rtic le -p d f/1 4 9 /2 /1 7 /1 8 3 2 6 4 2 /d a e d _ a _ 0 1 7 8 7 .p d f b y U N IV O F C A L IF O R N IA S A N T A B A R B A R A u s e r o n 1 5 M a y 2 0 2 3

038�’1(�Roqhmf�1/1/ 18

Rsdudm�D-�Lhkkdq

‘m�tqfdms�knmf,sdql�bnmbdqm�‘ants�sgd�rdbtqhsx�ne�‘kk�mtbkd‘q�l‘sdqh‘kr�nm�‘�fkna‘k�� a‘rhr+�‘�oqnakdl�sg‘s�qdl‘hmdc�‘�ghfg�oqhnqhsx�‘s�kd‘rs�tmshk�sgd�‘cudms�ne�sgd�Sqtlo� ‘clhmhrsq‘shnm-�Oqdrhcdms�Na‘l‘+�hm�e‘bs+�l‘cd�sgd�rdbtqhsx�ne�vd‘onmr,tr‘akd� mtbkd‘q�l‘sdqh‘kr�nmd�ne�ghr�rhfm‘stqd�hrrtdr�‘mc�oqdrhcdc�nudq�entq�Mtbkd‘q�Rd, btqhsx�Rtllhsr�hmsdmcdc�sn�oqnlnsd�ghfgdq�rs‘mc‘qcr�ne�mtbkd‘q�rdbtqhsx�enq�‘kk� gnkchmfr�ne�mtbkd‘q l‘sdqh‘kr-

Sgd�rdbnmc�og‘rd�hm�sgd�dkdu‘shnm�ne�sgd�mtbkd‘q�sdqqnqhrl�sgqd‘s�bnlldmbdc� vhsg�sgd�rgnbj�ne�Rdosdladq�00+�1//0-�Sgd�sdqqnqhrs�‘ss‘bjr�nm�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr� l‘cd�hs� hmdrb‘o‘akx�bkd‘q�sg‘s�sdqqnqhrsr�vdqd�b‘o‘akd�ne�lntmshmf�rnoghrshb‘s, dc�nodq‘shnmr�nm�sgd�T-R-�l‘hmk‘mc+�vdqd�vhkkhmf�‘mc�‘akd�sn�jhkk�k‘qfd�mtladqr� ne�odnokd+�‘mc�g‘qanqdc�adkhder�cddokx�gnrshkd�sn�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr-�Hlldch‘sd, kx�‘mc�enq�rnld�xd‘qr�sn�bnld+�sgd�rn,b‘kkdc�v‘q�nm�sdqqnqhrl�adb‘ld�‘�bdmsq‘k� dkdldmsfl‘qft‘akx�sgd�bdmsq‘k�dkdldmsflne�@ldqhb‘&r�dwsdqm‘k�onkhbx-�Sgd�rodb, sdq�ne�‘�mtbkd‘q�8.00�g‘tmsdc�sghr�deenqs-�@r�Oqdrhcdms�Fdnqfd�V-�Atrg�v‘qmdc�nm� ‘� mtladq� ne� nbb‘rhnmr+� hs� vntkc� ad� ‘� mhfgsl‘qd� he� sgd� vnqkc&r� lnrs� c‘mfdqntr� vd‘onmr�edkk�hmsn�sgd�lnrs�c‘mfdqntr�g‘mcr-�@�aho‘qshr‘m fqnto�ne�oqnlhmdms�on, khshb‘k�›ftqdr�oqnbk‘hldc�mtbkd‘q�sdqqnqhrl�sn�ad�sgd�mtladq�nmd�sgqd‘s�sn�@ldq, hb‘m�rdbtqhsx-�

Sgtr+�enq�md‘qkx�svn�cdb‘cdr+�V‘rghmfsnm�g‘r�uhdvdc�sdqqnqhrsr�‘r�‘mnsgdq�on, sdmsh‘k�rntqbd�ne�rdqhntr�‘mc�vnqqhrnld�mtbkd‘q�qhrj+�sn�ad�bnla‘ssdc�vgdqd�mdb, drr‘qx+�sn�ad�cdsdqqdc�he�onrrhakd+�‘mc�sn�ad�qdf‘qcdc�‘kv‘xr�‘r�‘�bdmsq‘k�bnmbdqm�ne� T-R-�onkhbx-�Deenqsr�sn�‘ccqdrr�sghr�sgqd‘s�g‘ud+�hm�u‘qhntr�enqlr+�g‘c�‘�gtfd�hlo‘bs� nm� T-R-� onkhbx+� hmbktchmf� rtbg� l‘inq� oqdnbbto‘shnmr� ‘r� sgd� Bnnodq‘shud� Sgqd‘s� Qdctbshnm�Oqnfq‘l�vhsg�Qtrrh‘+�sgd�1//2�hmu‘rhnm�ne�Hq‘p+�‘mc�sgd�Mtbkd‘q�Rdbt, qhsx�Rtllhsr+�‘kk�ne�vghbg�vdqd�itrsh›dc�‘s�kd‘rs�hm�o‘qs�ax�sgd�hlodq‘shud�sn�qdctbd� sgd�sgqd‘s�ne�mtbkd‘q�sdqqnqhrl-�Sghr�hr ‘�rsqhjhmf�bg‘mfd�hm�sgd�mtbkd‘q�‘fdmc‘�‘mc� ‘�cdrs‘ahkhyhmf�hmfitdmbd�nm�sgd�hmsdqm‘shnm‘k�nqcdq�bnlo‘qdc�sn�sgd�e‘lhkh‘q�ah, k‘sdq‘k�vnqkc�sg‘s�dwhrsdc�hm�0880-

D unkuhmf� sdbgmnknfx� q‘hrdr� mdv� bnmbdqmr-� @� entqsg� cdudknoldms� bg‘mfhmf� sgd� mtbkd‘q� dmuhqnmldmsfl‘mc� ‘mnsgdq� sg‘s� g‘r� oqnfqdrrdc� tmdudmkx+� ‘mc� rnldshldr�vhsg�tmrdsskhmf�q‘ohchsxflg‘r�addm�sgd�dunktshnm�ne�sdbgmnkn,

fx-� Sgd� ‘bbtltk‘shnm� ne� hloqnudldmsr� ‘mc� hmmnu‘shnmr� hr� g‘uhmf� ‘� k‘qfd� deedbs� nm�sgd�bg‘q‘bsdq�‘mc�rs‘ahkhsx�ne�mtbkd‘q�qdk‘shnmrghor-�Sgqdd�nudqk‘oohmf�aqn‘c� sqdmcr�‘qd�mns‘akd-�

Ehqrs+�‘cu‘mbdc�bnmudmshnm‘k�vd‘onmr�‘qd�hmbqd‘rhmfkx�b‘o‘akd�ne�odqenqlhmf� rsq‘sdfhb�lhrrhnmr+�dhsgdq�sgqntfg�chqdbs�‘ss‘bj�nm�‘m�‘cudqr‘qx&r�mtbkd‘q�‘rrdsr�nq� ax�‘ss‘bjhmf�ct‘k,trd�e‘bhkhshdr�’rtbg�‘r�v‘qmhmf�rxrsdlr�nq�bnll‘mc�‘mc�bnm, sqnk(�vgnrd�cdrsqtbshnm�vntkc�cdfq‘cd�sgd�nsgdq�rhcd&r�‘ahkhsx�sn�bnmctbs�mtbkd‘q� nodq‘shnmr-22�Rtbg�‘ss‘bjr�aktq�sgd�khmd�adsvddm�bnmudmshnm‘k�‘mc�mtbkd‘q�bnmfihbs� ‘mc�bqd‘sd�rbdm‘qhnr�hm�vghbg�bnmudmshnm‘k�nodq‘shnmr�b‘m�oqnctbd�oqdrrtqdr�sn�

D o w n lo a d e d fro m h ttp ://d ire c t.m it.e d u /d a e d /a rtic le -p d f/1 4 9 /2 /1 7 /1 8 3 2 6 4 2 /d a e d _ a _ 0 1 7 8 7 .p d f b y U N IV O F C A L IF O R N IA S A N T A B A R B A R A u s e r o n 1 5 M a y 2 0 2 3

2/ Cºc‘ktr+�sgd�Intqm‘k�ne�sgd�@ldqhb‘m�@b‘cdlx�ne�@qsr�%�Rbhdmbdr

@�Mtbkd‘q�Vnqkc�Sq‘mrenqldc9�Sgd�Qhrd�ne�Ltkshk‘sdq‘k�Chrnqcdq

drb‘k‘sd�sn�mtbkd‘q�trd-�Sghr�oqnakdl�hr�bnlontmcdc�ax�sgd�e‘bs�sg‘s�rnld�cdkhu, dqx�ok‘senqlr+�hmbktchmf�‘hqbq‘es�‘mc�lhrrhkdr�ne�u‘qhntr�sxodr+�‘qd�adhmf�cdoknxdc� hm�‘�ct‘k,b‘o‘ahkhsx�lncd+�ld‘mhmf�sg‘s�‘m�noonmdms�vhkk�mns�ad�rtqd�vgdsgdq�‘m� hmbnlhmf�‘ss‘bj�hr�bnmudmshnm‘k�nq�mtbkd‘q-�

Rdbnmc+�‘cu‘mbdr�hm�rtqudhkk‘mbd+�oqdbhrhnm+�‘mc�kdsg‘khsx�‘qd�l‘jhmf�hs�lnqd� che›btks� sn� qds‘hm� bnm›cdmbd� hm� sgd� rtquhu‘ahkhsx� ne� mtbkd‘q� enqbdr� sg‘s� ‘qd� sgd� entmc‘shnm�ne�rs‘akd�mtbkd‘q�qdk‘shnmrghor-23�K‘mc,a‘rdc�enqbdr�b‘m�ad�s‘qfdsdc+� lnahkd�enqbdr�b‘m�ad�rtqudhkkdc�‘mc�rsqtbj+�rd‘,a‘rdc�enqbdr�l‘x�ad�hmbqd‘rhmfkx� utkmdq‘akd+�‘mc�bnll‘mc�‘mc�bnmsqnk�ne�mtbkd‘q�enqbdr�l‘x�ad�rtrbdoshakd�sn�chr, qtoshnm�ax�bnmudmshnm‘k,+�mtbkd‘q,+�nq�bxadq‘ss‘bj-�Sgd�‘rrtqdc�cdrsqtbshnm�sg‘s� hr+�hm�sgd�b‘mnmr�ne�mtbkd‘q�rsq‘sdfx+�sgd�rntqbd�ne�ltst‘k�rs‘ahkhsx�l‘x�ad�hmbqd‘r, hmfkx�che›btks�sn�‘rrtqd-�Sghr�hr�drodbh‘kkx�vnqqhrnld�hm�sgd�bnmsdws�ne�qdfhnm‘k�mt, bkd‘q�a‘k‘mbdr+�vhsg�lnqd�khlhsdc�enqbdr�‘mc�che›btks�rdbtqhsx�dmuhqnmldmsr-�Ats� hm�sgd�etstqd+�dudm�sgd�ahffdq�mtbkd‘q�onvdqr�l‘x�eddk�‘�mddc�sn�s‘jd�qdetfd�hm�k‘qf, dq�mtladqr�‘mc�lnqd�chudqrh›dc�enqbd�onrstqdr-

Sghqc+�vd�g‘ud�vhsmdrrdc�hm�sgd�rdudq‘k�cdb‘cdr�rhmbd�sgd�dmc�ne�sgd�Bnkc�V‘q� sgd� dldqfdmbd� ne� mdv� cnl‘hmr� ne� sdbgmnknfhb‘k� bnlodshshnm+� vgdsgdq� sgqntfg� sgd�‘qqhu‘k�ne�mdv�rxrsdlr rtbg�‘r�bxadq+�‘cu‘mbdc�cqnmdr+�‘mc�gxodqrnmhb�cdkhu, dqx�rxrsdlr�nq�sgqntfg�sgd�dwsdmrhnm�ne�‘cu‘mbdc�lhkhs‘qx�sdbgmnknfhdr�hmsn�mdv� dmuhqnmldmsr� rtbg� ‘r� ro‘bd-� Hm� 0880+� enq� dw‘lokd+� mn� nmd� vnqqhdc� ‘ants� bxadq� sgqd‘sr�sn�mtbkd‘q�enqbdr+�ats�snc‘x+�hs�hr�‘�fqnvhmf�bnmbdqm-24 Bxadq�hmsdqedqdmbd�hm� sgd�bnll‘mc�‘mc�bnmsqnk�rxrsdlr�enq�mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr�g‘ud�sgd�onsdmsh‘k�sn�udqx� deedbshudkx� chrqtos� ‘m� noonmdms&r� b‘o‘ahkhshdr-� Lnqdnudq+� mdv� sdbgmnknfhdr� b‘m� vhcdm�sgd�‘qq‘x�ne�‘bsnqr�vgn�‘qd�‘akd�sn�onrd�rdqhntr�chrqtoshud�sgqd‘sr�‘mc�g‘ud� sgd�onsdmsh‘k�sn�kdudk�sgd�ok‘xhmf�›dkc�adsvddm�k‘qfdq�‘mc�rl‘kkdq�ok‘xdqr-�Rs‘sdr� khjd�Mnqsg�Jnqd‘�nq�Hq‘m�b‘mmns�onrrhakx�gnod�sn�l‘sbg�sgd�mtbkd‘q�enqbd�onrstqdr� ne�sgd�k‘qfdq�mtbkd‘q,vd‘onm�rs‘sdr+�ats�sgdx�‘qd�b‘o‘akd�ne�cdudknohmf�deedbshud� bxadq�b‘o‘ahkhshdr+�trhmf�cqnmdr+�nq�otsshmf�lhkhs‘qx�‘rrdsr�hm�ro‘bd-�Enq�dw‘lokd+� Mnqsg� Jnqd‘&r� mtbkd‘q� vd‘onmr� ‘qd� ne� bntqrd� vnqqhrnld+� ats� sgdqd� hr� ‘� o‘q‘kkdk� bnmbdqm�‘ants�hsr�bxadq�b‘o‘ahkhshdr+�vghbg+�tmkhjd�mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr+�Mnqsg�Jnqd‘� g‘r�‘ood‘qdc�sn�dloknx�qdftk‘qkx-25 Sdbgmnknfhb‘k�‘cu‘mbdr�‘qd�oqnctbhmf�‘�vhc, dq�‘qq‘x�ne�sgqd‘sr�eqnl�‘�vhcdq�‘qq‘x�ne�‘bsnqr-

S‘jdm�snfdsgdq+�sgdrd�sqdmcr�‘qd�oqnctbhmf�‘�lhkhs‘qx�dmuhqnmldms�sg‘s�hr�lnqd� bnlokdw�‘mc�kdrr�rs‘akd-�Sdbgmnknfhb‘k�‘cu‘mbdldms�g‘r�addm�mnql‘k�hm�sgd�mt, bkd‘q�bnmsdws+�ats�sgd�o‘bd�‘mc�dwsdms�ne�sdbgmnknfhb‘k�hmmnu‘shnm�hm�qdbdms�xd‘qr� hr�q‘hrhmf�tmoqdbdcdmsdc�hrrtdr�‘mc�hmsqnctbhmf�mdv�rntqbdr�ne�sgqd‘s+�vnqqx+�‘mc� hmrs‘ahkhsx-�Sgd�dwsdmrhud�mtbkd‘q�lncdqmhy‘shnm�oqnfq‘lr�adhmf�tmcdqs‘jdm�ax� ‘klnrs� ‘kk� ne� sgd� mtbkd‘q� ‘qldc� rs‘sdr� ld‘m� sg‘s� sgd� rhst‘shnm� hr� udqx� cxm‘lhb+� vhsg� mdv� sdbgmnknfhdr� bnmshmt‘kkx� adhmf� ‘arnqadc� hmsn� sgd� onrstqdr+� cnbsqhmdr+� ‘mc�nodq‘shnmr�ne�rs‘sdr+�bqd‘shmf�‘�mtbkd‘q�nqcdq�sg‘s�hr�l‘qjdckx�cheedqdms�eqnl� sg‘s�vghbg�dwhrsdc�‘s�sgd�dmc�ne�sgd�Bnkc�V‘q-

D o w n lo a d e d fro m h ttp ://d ire c t.m it.e d u /d a e d /a rtic le -p d f/1 4 9 /2 /1 7 /1 8 3 2 6 4 2 /d a e d _ a _ 0 1 7 8 7 .p d f b y U N IV O F C A L IF O R N IA S A N T A B A R B A R A u s e r o n 1 5 M a y 2 0 2 3

038�’1(�Roqhmf�1/1/ 20

Rsdudm�D-�Lhkkdq

H lokhb‘shnmr-�Vg‘s�hr�cheedqdms�‘ants�sgd�btqqdms�mtbkd‘q�nqcdq>�Ehqrs+�sgd�fqd‘s,� onvdq� qhu‘kqx� ‘s� sgd� gd‘qs� ne� sgd� nqcdq� g‘r� adbnld� kdrr� ahk‘sdq‘k+� lnqd� sqh, ‘mftk‘q-�Rdbnmc+�eq‘tfgs�qdfhnm‘k�mtbkd‘q�nqcdqr�chc�mns�dwhrs�adenqd�‘ants�

1///+�ats�mnv�g‘ud�adbnld�‘�l‘inq�e‘bsnq�‘mc�‘�l‘inq�bnmbdqm-�Sghqc+�sgd�sgqd‘s� ne�mtbkd‘q�sdqqnqhrl�knnlr�ltbg�k‘qfdq�enq�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr�sg‘m�v‘r�sqtd�ctqhmf� sgd�Bnkc�V‘q-�@mc�›m‘kkx+�sghr�dwsdmrhud�fdnonkhshb‘k�bg‘mfd�hr�tmenkchmf�hm�‘�fit, hc� ‘mc� e‘rs,lnuhmf� sdbgmnknfhb‘k� dmuhqnmldms� sg‘s� l‘x� l‘jd� hs� lnqd� che›btks� sn�bqd‘sd�‘mc�oqdrdqud�rs‘akd�mtbkd‘q�qdk‘shnmrghor-�Vg‘s�‘qd�sgd�hlokhb‘shnmr�ne� sgdrd�bg‘mfdr>�

�• Ltkshokd�‘tchdmbdr-�Eqnl V‘rghmfsnm&r�odqrodbshud+�hs�g‘r�adbnld�hmbqd‘r, hmfkx�duhcdms�sg‘s�hsr�mtbkd‘q�cdsdqqdms�onkhbhdr�ltrs�ad�‘hldc�‘s�ltkshokd� ‘tchdmbdr-�Vgdqd�sgd�nudqvgdklhmf�oqdnbbto‘shnm�v‘r�nmbd�vhsg�Lnrbnv� ’‘mc�Bghm‘�hmbktcdc�‘r�‘�kdrrdq�ok‘xdq(+�mnv�sgd�enbtr�hr�nm�cduhrhmf�rodbh›b� rsq‘sdfhdr�enq�cheedqdms�s‘qfdsr+�q‘mfhmf�eqnl�mnmrs‘sd�‘bsnqr�sn�fqd‘s�onv, dqr-�Sghr�bnmbdos�ne�'s‘hknqdc�cdsdqqdmbd„�g‘r�adbnld�‘�oqnlhmdms�sgdld�hm� T-R-�mtbkd‘q�onkhbx+�eqnl�Fdnqfd�V-�Atrg�sn�Cnm‘kc�Sqtlo-�@r�nmd�‘m‘kxrhr� ne�sgd�bnmbdos�dwok‘hmr+�s‘hknqdc�cdsdqqdmbd�rddjr�

sn�‘ccqdrr�sgd�chrshmbshud�bg‘kkdmfdr�onrdc�ax�‘cu‘mbdc�lhkhs‘qx�bnlodshsnqr+� qdfhnm‘k onvdqr ‘qldc vhsg vd‘onmr ne l‘rr cdrsqtbshnm ’VLC(+ ‘mc mnm, rs‘sd�sdqqnqhrs�mdsvnqjr-�-�-�-�Fhudm�sgd�vhcdq�u‘qhdsx�ne�‘bsnqr�sg‘s�bntkc�hmfihbs� l‘rr�b‘rt‘kshdr�tonm�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr+�hsr�‘kkhdr+�nq�hsr�hmsdqdrsr+�hs�l‘jdr�rdmrd� sn�dwoknqd�vgdsgdq�‘mc�gnv�cdsdqqdmbd�bntkc�ad�‘c‘osdc+�‘citrsdc+�‘mc�l‘cd� sn�›s�10rs,bdmstqx�bg‘kkdmfdr-26

�• Lnqd�bnlokdw�o‘ssdqmr�ne�hmsdq‘bshnm-�Sgd�mdv�mtbkd‘q�nqcdq�b‘m�ad�uhdvdc�‘r� bnloqhrhmf�‘�bnqd�mtbkd‘q�sqh‘mfkd�’Bghm‘+�Qtrrh‘+�‘mc�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr(� oktr�svn�ltkshk‘sdq‘k�qdfhnm‘k�mtbkd‘q�rtarxrsdlr-�Svn�nsgdq�qdfhnm‘k�‘qd, m‘rflDtqnod�‘mc�sgd�Lhcckd�D‘rsflb‘m�‘krn�ad�qdf‘qcdc�‘r�qdfhnm‘k�mtbkd, ‘q�rtarxrsdlr9�Dtqnod�adb‘trd�ne�sgd�@ldqhb‘m�mtbkd‘q�ft‘q‘msddr�sn�hsr� M?SN�‘kkhdr�‘mc�adb‘trd�sgd�Tmhsdc�Jhmfcnl�‘mc�Eq‘mbd�onrrdrr�mtbkd‘q� vd‘onmr:�sgd�Lhcckd�D‘rs�adb‘trd�Hrq‘dk�g‘r�knmf�addm�oqdrtldc�sn�g‘ud�‘� mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr�b‘o‘ahkhsx�‘mc�adb‘trd�bnmbdqmr�‘ants�Hq‘m&r�‘oodshsd�enq� mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr�g‘ud�addm�‘m�nudqvgdklhmfkx�hlonqs‘ms�e‘bsnq�hm�qdfhnm, ‘k�‘mc�hmsdqm‘shnm‘k�onkhshbr-�Sgd�ltkshokhbhsx�ne�ok‘xdqr�hm�sgd�mtbkd‘q�nqcdq� sg‘s�mnv�dwhrsr�l‘jd�onrrhakd�qdudqadq‘shmf�bg‘hmr�ne�hmsdq‘bshnm+�‘r�mtbkd‘q� qdk‘shnmrghor�‘lnmf�rnld�qhookd�sgqntfg�sgd�odqbdoshnmr�‘mc�adg‘uhnq�ne� nsgdqr-�Sgtr+�enq�dw‘lokd+�Bghm‘�‘hcdc�O‘jhrs‘m+�chrbnl›shmf�Hmch‘+�vghkd� O‘jhrs‘m�hm�stqm�oqnuhcdc�‘rrhrs‘mbd�sn�Hq‘m&r�mtbkd‘q�oqnfq‘l+�oqnctbhmf� rsqnmf�qd‘bshnmr�hm�V‘rghmfsnm+�Idqtr‘kdl+�‘mc�Qhx‘cg-�Mtbkd‘q�qdk‘shnm, rghor�‘qd�mns�nmkx�ahk‘sdq‘k�nq�ltkshk‘sdq‘k+�ats�b‘m�b‘rb‘cd�sgqntfg�ltkshokd�

D o w n lo a d e d fro m h ttp ://d ire c t.m it.e d u /d a e d /a rtic le -p d f/1 4 9 /2 /1 7 /1 8 3 2 6 4 2 /d a e d _ a _ 0 1 7 8 7 .p d f b y U N IV O F C A L IF O R N IA S A N T A B A R B A R A u s e r o n 1 5 M a y 2 0 2 3

21 Cºc‘ktr+�sgd�Intqm‘k�ne�sgd�@ldqhb‘m�@b‘cdlx�ne�@qsr�%�Rbhdmbdr

@�Mtbkd‘q�Vnqkc�Sq‘mrenqldc9�Sgd�Qhrd�ne�Ltkshk‘sdq‘k�Chrnqcdq

‘bsnqr�hm�sgd�rxrsdl-�Hm�rgnqs+�sgdrd�ltkshokd�mtbkd‘q�rtarxrsdlr+�d‘bg�vhsg� hsr�nvm�bg‘q‘bsdqhrshbr�‘mc�cxm‘lhbr+�hmsdqrdbs�‘mc�hmsdq‘bs-�Sgdqd�‘qd�ltk, shokd�onhmsr�vhsghm�sgdrd�rsqtbstqdr�sg‘s�b‘m�hmhsh‘sd�lnudr�sg‘s�oqnctbd�b‘r, b‘chmf�qd‘bshnmr-�Bghm‘�‘ood‘qr�sn�nbbtox�‘�o‘qshbtk‘qkx�ohuns‘k�qnkd�adb‘trd� hs� hr� ‘� l‘inq� ok‘xdq� hm� md‘qkx� ‘kk� sgd� ltkshk‘sdq‘k� bnlonmdmsr� ne� sgd� fkna, ‘k� mtbkd‘q� nqcdq-� Vgdsgdq� hs� odqrhrsr� vhsg� hsr� qdk‘shudkx� qdrsq‘hmdc� mtbkd‘q�� onkhbxflqdkxhmf� nm� ‘� rl‘kk� cdsdqqdms� enqbd� ‘bbnlo‘mhdc� ax� ‘� mn,›qrs,trd� cnbsqhmdflvhkk�ad�nmd�ne�sgd�bqtbh‘k�hmfitdmbdr�rg‘ohmf�sgd�nqcdq�hm�sgd�xd‘qr� ‘gd‘c-� He� Bghm‘� bnldr� sn� ‘cnos� ‘� lnqd� ‘lahshntr� mtbkd‘q� onkhbx� sg‘s� dw, o‘mcr�hsr�mtbkd‘q�enqbdr�‘mc�l‘jdr�hs�lnqd�bnlodshshud�vhsg�Qtrrh‘�‘mc�sgd� Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr+�V‘rghmfsnm�‘mc�Mdv�Cdkgh�vhkk�rtqdkx�qd‘bs�hm�rnld�rhfmhe, hb‘ms�v‘x+�Qtrrh‘�vhkk�qdronmc�sn�vg‘sdudq�bg‘mfdr�V‘rghmfsnm�l‘jdr�sn� hsr�onkhbx+�O‘jhrs‘m�vhkk�‘citrs�sn�vg‘sdudq�Mdv�Cdkgh�g‘r�cnmd+�‘mc�Bgh, m‘&r�bg‘mfdc�onkhbx�vhkk�g‘ud�qhookdc�sgqntfg�ltbg�ne�sgd�rxrsdl-�Ats�sghr� hr�nmkx�nmd�onrrhakd�bg‘hm�ne�hmsdq‘bshnmr�hm�‘�vnqkc�ne�ltkshokd�ltkshk‘sdq‘k� mtbkd‘q�rtarxrsdlr-�Sgd�‘qlr�q‘bd�hlokhb‘shnmr�‘qd�nauhntr+�drodbh‘kkx�‘r� bnmrsq‘hmsr�nm�mtbkd‘q�b‘o‘ahkhshdr�‘qd�v‘mhmf-�Hm�sgd�dudms�sg‘s�sgd�nmkx�qd, l‘hmhmf�khlhsrflsgnrd�hm�sgd�Mdv�RS?QS�‘fqddldmsfl‘qd�‘kknvdc�sn�k‘ord+� sgdm+�‘r�intqm‘khrs�Eqdc�J‘ok‘m�g‘r�vqhssdm+�'Sgd�Qtrrh‘mr�bntkc�athkc�lnqd� vd‘onmr+�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr�’‘mc�odqg‘or�nsgdq�mtbkd‘q�onvdqr(�vntkc�oqna, ‘akx�qdronmc+�‘mc�nee�vd�fn+�nmbd�lnqd+�hmsn�sgd�vhkc�aktd�xnmcdq-„27

�• Ltkshokd�rntqbdr�ne�hmrs‘ahkhsx-�Sgd�rodbsdq�sg‘s�g‘tmsdc�sgd�Bnkc�V‘q�v‘r sgd� k‘qfd,rb‘kd�mtbkd‘q�v‘q�adsvddm�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr�‘mc�sgd�Rnuhds�Tmhnm+�‘mc� rl‘kkdq�nq�hm‘cudqsdms�u‘qh‘shnmr�ne�sg‘s�b‘s‘rsqnoghb�rbdm‘qhn-�Snc‘x+�sgdqd� ‘qd�ltkshokd�fi‘rg�onhmsr-�Qdk‘shnmr�adsvddm�sgd�ahf�sgqdd�onvdqr�‘qd�tmrds, skdc�‘mc�Qtrrh‘m,@ldqhb‘m�qdk‘shnmr�g‘ud�adbnld�chrsqdrrhmfkx�snwhb-�Fhudm� sgd�dunkuhmf�sdbgmnknfhb‘k�bnmsdws+�hs�hr�tmbkd‘q�gnv�rs‘akd�sgd�fqd‘s,onvdq��� mtbkd‘q�qdk‘shnmrghor�vhkk�ad+�ats�sgdqd�hr�mn�ptdrshnm�sg‘s�sgd�bnlahm‘shnm� ne�hmsdmrd�qhu‘kqx�‘mc�vnqqxhmfkx�utkmdq‘akd�enqbdr�hr�‘�c‘mfdqntr�lhw-�Gnv, dudq+�sgd�qdfhnm‘k�mtbkd‘q�a‘k‘mbdr�‘qd�dudm�lnqd�khjdkx�sn�b‘trd�sgd�trd�ne� mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr+�fhudm�sgd�sqntakdc�rdbtqhsx�dmuhqnmldmsr�hm�sgnrd�qdfhnmr� ‘mc� sgd� e‘bsnqr� sg‘s� l‘jd� bnmfihbs� ‘m� hl‘fhm‘akd� ntsbnld-� Sgdqd� hr� dudm� lnqd�cntas�hm�qdfhnm‘k�bnmsdwsr�sg‘s�sgd�mtbkd‘q,‘qldc�rs‘sdr�vhkk�ad�‘akd� sn�cdudkno�bnm›cdmbd,hmrohqhmf�cdsdqqdms�onrstqdr9�sgd�bnmchshnmr�sg‘s�e‘, bhkhs‘sdc�rs‘ahkhsx�hm�sgd�rtodqonvdq�rdsshmf�‘qd�mns�d‘rhkx�qdokhb‘akd�hm�qd, fhnm‘k�rdsshmfr�‘mc�sgd�qdfhnm‘k�mtbkd‘q�onvdqr�ltrs�bnmsdmc�vhsg�sgd�r‘ld� sdbgmnknfhb‘k�bg‘kkdmfdr�sn�rs‘ahkhsx�‘r�sgd�ahffdq�onvdqr-�Ehm‘kkx+�sgdqd�hr� sgd�cheetrd�sgqd‘s�ne�mtbkd‘q�sdqqnqhrl+�vghbg�oqnuhcdr�xds�‘mnsgdq�onsdmsh‘k� mtbkd‘q�fi‘rg�onhms+�‘�qhrj�ne�tmjmnvm�oqnonqshnmr�sg‘s+�‘s�kd‘rs�hm�V‘rghmf, snm+�hr�s‘jdm�udqx�rdqhntrkx-�Hm�rgnqs+�onkhshbr�‘mc�sdbgmnknfx�g‘ud�bnlahmdc� sn�oqnctbd�‘m�tmenqstm‘sd�mtladq�ne�rntqbdr�ne�hmrs‘ahkhsx-�@r�‘qlr�bnmsqnk�

D o w n lo a d e d fro m h ttp ://d ire c t.m it.e d u /d a e d /a rtic le -p d f/1 4 9 /2 /1 7 /1 8 3 2 6 4 2 /d a e d _ a _ 0 1 7 8 7 .p d f b y U N IV O F C A L IF O R N IA S A N T A B A R B A R A u s e r o n 1 5 M a y 2 0 2 3

038�’1(�Roqhmf�1/1/ 22

Rsdudm�D-�Lhkkdq

‘mc�mnmoqnkhedq‘shnm�rbgnk‘q�Rsdudm�Ohedq�g‘r�vqhssdm+�'Rsq‘sdfhb�rs‘ahkhsx� ‘ood‘qr� hmbqd‘rhmfkx�‘�ltkshk‘sdq‘k�‘mc�ltksh,cnl‘hm�bnmrsqtbs-�Sghr� hr�‘� ltbg�lnqd�bnlokdw�lncdk�sg‘m�ctqhmf�sgd�Bnkc�V‘q-„28

�• Lnqd�che›btks�dmuhqnmldms�enq�‘qlr�bnmsqnk-�Sdbgmnknfx�hr�dunkuhmf�hm�v‘xr�sg‘s� b‘m�l‘jd�o‘rs�‘fqddldmsr�narnkdsd�‘mc�mdv�‘fqddldmsr�che›btks�nq�hlonr, rhakd�sn�‘bghdud-�Bxadq�sgqd‘sr+�enq�dw‘lokd+�l‘x�qdoqdrdms�‘m�tqfdms�oqna, kdl+�ats�hs�hr�g‘qc�sn�rdd�gnv�sgdx�b‘m�ad�bnmrsq‘hmdc�ax�‘qlr�bnmsqnk-�He�sdbg, mnknfx�hr�l‘jhmf�‘qlr�bnmsqnk�lnqd�che›btks+�onkhshbr�rddlr�sn�ad�l‘jhmf�hs� kdrr�khjdkx-�Sgd�eq‘xdc�qdk‘shnmr�adsvddm�Lnrbnv�‘mc�V‘rghmfsnm�g‘ud�kdc� sn�‘�rtars‘msh‘k�dqnrhnm�ne�sgd�Bnkc�V‘q�‘qlr�bnmsqnk�‘qbghsdbstqd�‘mc�sgdqd� ‘ood‘qr�sn�ad�khsskd�vhkk�sn�lnud�enqv‘qc�vhsg�mdv�hmhsh‘shudr-�Bghm‘�hr�mnv� ‘�l‘inq�ok‘xdq�ats�‘ood‘qr�sn�ad�rshkk�tmqd‘cx�sn�inhm�sqhk‘sdq‘k�nq�ltkshk‘sdq‘k� rsq‘sdfhb�‘qlr�bnmsqnk�mdfnsh‘shnmr-�Sgd�qdfhnm‘k�mtbkd‘q�a‘k‘mbdr�‘qd�‘klnrs� bnlokdsdkx�tmsntbgdc�ax�‘mx�mdfnsh‘sdc�bnmrsq‘hmsr-�Oqnlhmdms�ltksh�k‘sdq‘k� ‘qlr� bnmsqnk� deenqsr+� rtbg� ‘r� sgd� Bnloqdgdmrhud� Mtbkd‘q,Sdrs,A‘m� Sqd‘sx� ‘mc� sgd� Ehrrhkd� L‘sdqh‘k� Btsnee� mdfnsh‘shnmr+� g‘ud� addm� rsxlhdc� enq� xd‘qr+� vhsg�mn�hmchb‘shnmr�ne�oqnfqdrr�‘mxvgdqd�hm�rhfgs-�Hcd‘kkx+�hs�vntkc�ad�onrrh, akd�sn�bnmrsq‘hm�‘mc�l‘m‘fd�sgd�mdv�mtbkd‘q�nqcdq�trhmf�sgd�jhmcr�ne�‘qlr� bnmsqnk�oqnbdrrdr�‘mc�ldbg‘mhrlr�sg‘s�gdkodc�sn�qdftk‘sd�sgd�mtbkd‘q�qhu‘kqx� hm�sgd�Bnkc�V‘q-�Hm�shld�‘mc�vhsg�bnmbdqsdc�deenqs+�odqg‘or�hs�vhkk�oqnud�onr, rhakd�sn�qdbqd‘sd�‘�mdfnsh‘sdc�qdftk‘snqx�hmeq‘rsqtbstqd�sg‘s�vhkk�lncdq‘sd� sgd�qhrjr�‘mc�c‘mfdqr�ne�sghr�mdv�‘fd-�Enq�sgd�lnldms+�gnvdudq+�bnmchshnmr� ‘qd�mns�oqnohshntr�‘mc�sgd�btqqdms�ohbstqd�hr�akd‘j9�ahk‘sdq‘k�‘qlr�bnmsqnk�hr� bnkk‘orhmf�ats�rddlr�hm�‘mx�b‘rd�hmrte›bhdms:�sqhk‘sdq‘k�‘qlr�bnmsqnk�rddlr� mdbdrr‘qx�ats�rn�e‘q�qdl‘hmr�hlonrrhakd:�ltkshk‘sdq‘k�‘qlr�bnmsqnk�hr�bnl‘, snrd:�‘mc�qdfhnm‘k�‘qlr�bnmsqnk�hr�cdrhq‘akd�ats�hr�‘r�xds�mnmdwhrsdms-�

Sgtr+�sgd�fqd‘s�bg‘kkdmfd�enq�mtbkd‘q�onkhbx�snc‘x9�›mchmf�‘�r‘ed�o‘sg�sgqntfg� ‘�mtbkd‘q�dmuhqnmldms�sg‘s�vhkk�enq�sgd�enqdrdd‘akd�etstqd�ad�bnmrhcdq‘akx�lnqd� bnlokdw+�›kkdc�vhsg�rntqbdr�ne�qhrj+�‘mc�bnmrhcdq‘akx�kdrr�qdftk‘sdc�sg‘m�vg‘s�vd� g‘ud�jmnvm-�Sgd�odqhkr�‘qd�khjdkx�sn�ad�‘s�kd‘rs�‘r�fqd‘s�‘r�sgnrd�bnmeqnmsdc�hm�d‘q, khdq�dq‘r�ne�sgd�mtbkd‘q�‘fd-�Sg‘s�vd�g‘ud�rtquhudc�sgqdd�pt‘qsdqr�ne�‘�bdmstqx�vhsg, nts�mtbkd‘q�b‘s‘rsqnogd�hr�mn�ft‘q‘msdd�sg‘s�vd�vhkk�rtbbdrretkkx�l‘m‘fd�sgd�mt, bkd‘q�c‘mfdq�hm�sgd�bnlhmf�og‘rd-�Q‘sgdq+�vg‘s�vd�tqfdmskx�mddc�hr�‘�cddo�tmcdq, rs‘mchmf�ne�sgd�qhrjr�sg‘s�mnv�dwhrs�‘mc�sg‘s�l‘x�xds�dldqfd+�‘mc�g‘qc�sghmjhmf� ‘ants�sgd�rsdor�sg‘m�b‘m�ad�s‘jdm�sn�lhmhlhyd�sgnrd�qhrjr-�Sghr�unktld�gnodr�sn� rdqud�sg‘s�b‘trd-

D o w n lo a d e d fro m h ttp ://d ire c t.m it.e d u /d a e d /a rtic le -p d f/1 4 9 /2 /1 7 /1 8 3 2 6 4 2 /d a e d _ a _ 0 1 7 8 7 .p d f b y U N IV O F C A L IF O R N IA S A N T A B A R B A R A u s e r o n 1 5 M a y 2 0 2 3

23 Cºc‘ktr+�sgd�Intqm‘k�ne�sgd�@ldqhb‘m�@b‘cdlx�ne�@qsr�%�Rbhdmbdr

@�Mtbkd‘q�Vnqkc�Sq‘mrenqldc9�Sgd�Qhrd�ne�Ltkshk‘sdq‘k�Chrnqcdq

‘ants�sgd�‘tsgnq Rsdudm�D-�Lhkkdq+�‘�Edkknv�ne�sgd�@ldqhb‘m�@b‘cdlx�rhmbd�1//5�‘mc�ldladq�ne� sgd�@b‘cdlx&r�Bntmbhk�‘mc�Bnllhssdd�nm�Hmsdqm‘shnm‘k�Rdbtqhsx�Rstchdr+�hr�Chqdb, snq�ne�sgd�Hmsdqm‘shnm‘k�Rdbtqhsx�Oqnfq‘l�‘s�sgd�Adkedq�Bdmsdq�enq�Rbhdmbd�‘mc�Hm, sdqm‘shnm‘k�@ee‘hqr�‘s�G‘qu‘qc�Tmhudqrhsx&r�Jdmmdcx�Rbgnnk�ne�Fnudqmldms-�Gd�hr� ‘krn�Dchsnq,hm,Bghde�ne�sgd�rbgnk‘qkx�intqm‘k�Hmsdqm‘shnm‘k�Rdbtqhsx�‘mc�bndchsnq�ne�sgd� annj�rdqhdr�ABRH?�Rstchdr�hm�Hmsdqm‘shnm‘k�Rdbtqhsx�’otakhrgdc�ax�Sgd�LHS�Oqdrr(-� Gd�hr�bn‘tsgnq�ne�svn�lnmnfq‘ogr�otakhrgdc�ax�sgd�@ldqhb‘m�@b‘cdlx9�Mtbkd‘q� Bnkkhrhnmr9�Chrbnqc+�Qdenql+�‘mc�sgd�Mtbkd‘q�Mnmoqnkhedq‘shnm�Qdfhld�’vhsg�V‘dk�@k,@rr‘c+� I‘x‘msg‘�Cg‘m‘o‘k‘+�B-�Q‘i‘�Lng‘m+�‘mc�S‘�Lhmg�St‘m+�1/01(�‘mc�Lddshmf�sgd�Bg‘k, kdmfdr�ne�sgd�Mdv�Mtbkd‘q�@fd9�Mtbkd‘q�Vd‘onmr�hm�‘�Bg‘mfhmf�Fkna‘k�Nqcdq�’vhsg�Qnadqs� Kdfunkc�‘mc�K‘vqdmbd�Eqddcl‘m+�1/08(+�‘mc�hr�bndchsnq�ne�sgd�@ldqhb‘m�@b‘cdlx� unktld�Sgd�Qtrrh‘m�Lhkhs‘qx9�Onvdq�‘mc�Onkhbx�’vhsg�Clhsqh�Sqdmhm+�1//3(-

dmcmnsdr � 0� Rdd�ghr�bnlldmsr�hm�Sgnl‘r�B-�Rbgdkkhmf+�'Enqdvnqc+„�hm�Rsq‘sdfhb�Rs‘ahkhsx9�Bnmsdmchmf�

�Hmsdqoqds‘shnmr+�dc-�Dkaqhcfd�@-�Bnkax�‘mc�Lhbg‘dk�R-�Fdqrnm�’B‘qkhrkd+�O‘-9�T-R-�@qlx� V‘q�Bnkkdfd�Oqdrr+�1/02(+�uhhfluhhh-

� 1� Rdd+�enq�dw‘lokd+�Lhbg‘dk�Vhmdr+�'Atrg�‘mc�Xdksrhm�Cdbk‘qd�Enql‘k�Dmc�sn�Bnkc�V‘q:� @fqdd�sn�Dwbg‘mfd�Uhrhsr+„�Sgd�Mdv�Xnqj�Shldr+�Edaqt‘qx�1+�0881-

� 2� @rgsnm�A-�B‘qsdq�‘mc�Rsdudm�D-�Lhkkdq+�'Bnnodq‘shud�Rdbtqhsx�‘mc�sgd�Enqldq�Rnuhds� Tmhnm9�Md‘q,Sdql�Bg‘kkdmfdr+„�hm�Fkna‘k�Dmf‘fdldms9�Bnnodq‘shnm�‘mc�Rdbtqhsx�hm sgd�Enqldq� Rnuhds�Tmhnm+�dc-�I‘mmd�D-�Mnk‘m�’V‘rghmfsnm+�C-B-9�Sgd�Aqnnjhmfr�Hmrshstshnm+�0883(+� 432-

� 3� L‘ssgdv�Atmm+�'@qlr�Bnmsqnk&r�Dmctqhmf�Vnqsg+„�Enqdhfm�Onkhbx�68�’088/(9�040- � 4� 'Rtllhs�hm�V‘rghmfsnm:�Dwbdqosr�eqnl�Atrg,Xdksrhm�Bnmedqdmbd9�Vnqjhmf�Snv‘qc�‘�

R‘edq�Vnqkc+„�Sgd�Mdv�Xnqj�Shldr+�Itmd�06+�0881-�Nm�sgd�bnmsdmsr�ne�sgd�‘fqddldms+�rdd� Lhbg‘dk�Vhmdr+�'Rtllhs�hm�V‘rghmfsnm9�Atrg�‘mc�Xdksrhm�@fqdd�sn�Bts�Knmf,Q‘mfd� @snlhb�V‘qgd‘cr:�Rbq‘o�Jdx�K‘mc,A‘rdc�Lhrrhkdr+„�Sgd�Mdv�Xnqj�Shldr+�Itmd�06+�0881-

� 5� Fq‘g‘l�@kkhrnm+�@rgsnm�A-�B‘qsdq+�Rsdudm�D-�Lhkkdq+�‘mc�Oghkho�Ydkhjnv+�'Bnnodq‘shud�Cd, mtbkd‘qhy‘shnm9�@m�Hmsdqm‘shnm‘k�@fdmc‘+„�hm�Bnnodq‘shud�Cdmtbkd‘qhy‘shnm9�Eqnl�Okdcfdr�sn� Cddcr�’B‘laqhcfd+�L‘rr-9�Adkedq�Bdmsdq�enq�Rbhdmbd�‘mc�Hmsdqm‘shnm‘k�@ee‘hqr+�G‘qu‘qc� Tmhudqrhsx+�0882(+�0-

� 6� Enq�‘�lnqd�dwsdmrhud�cdudknoldms�ne�sgdrd�onhmsr+�rdd�Rsdudm�D-�Lhkkdq+�'Sgd�Qhrd�‘mc�Cd, bkhmd�ne�Fkna‘k�Mtbkd‘q�Nqcdq>„�hm�Lddshmf�sgd�Bg‘kkdmfdr�ne�sgd�Mdv�Mtbkd‘q�@fd9�Mtbkd‘q� Vd‘onmr�hm�‘�Bg‘mfhmf�Mtbkd‘q�Nqcdq�’B‘laqhcfd+�L‘rr-9�@ldqhb‘m�@b‘cdlx�ne�@qsr�‘mc� Rbhdmbdr+�1/08(+�0fl16-

� 7� T-R-�Cdo‘qsldms�ne�Cdedmrd+�Rg‘qodmhmf�sgd�@ldqhb‘m�Lhkhs‘qx&r�Bnlodshshud�Dcfd9�Rtll‘qx�ne� sgd�1/07�M‘shnm‘k�Cdedmrd�Rsq‘sdfx�ne�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr�ne�@ldqhb‘�’V‘rghmfsnm+�C-B-9�Ne›bd� ne�sgd�Rdbqds‘qx�ne�Cdedmrd+�1/07(+�1-

� 8� Sgd�Vghsd�Gntrd+�M‘shnm‘k�Rdbtqhsx�Rsq‘sdfx�ne�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr�ne�@ldqhb‘�’V‘rghmfsnm+�C-B-9� Ne›bd�ne�sgd�Oqdrhcdms�ne�sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr+�1/06(+�1-

� 0/� T-R-�Cdo‘qsldms�ne�Cdedmrd+�Mtbkd‘q�Onrstqd�Qduhdv�’V‘rghmfsnm+�C-B-9�Ne›bd�ne�sgd�Rdb, qds‘qx�ne�Cdedmrd+�1/07(+�1-

D o w n lo a d e d fro m h ttp ://d ire c t.m it.e d u /d a e d /a rtic le -p d f/1 4 9 /2 /1 7 /1 8 3 2 6 4 2 /d a e d _ a _ 0 1 7 8 7 .p d f b y U N IV O F C A L IF O R N IA S A N T A B A R B A R A u s e r o n 1 5 M a y 2 0 2 3

038�’1(�Roqhmf�1/1/ 24

Rsdudm�D-�Lhkkdq

� 00� Hahc-+�21- � 01� Enq�‘m�dwbdkkdms�‘m‘kxrhr�ne�Bghmdrd�odqrodbshudr�nm�ptdrshnmr�ne�hmsdqm‘shnm‘k�nqcdq+�

rdd�@k‘rs‘hq�H‘hm�Ingmrsnm+�'Bghm‘�‘mc�‘�Vnqkc�ne�Nqcdqr+„�Hmsdqm‘shnm‘k�Rdbtqhsx�33�’1(� ’1/08(-

� 02� 'Hs�hr�sgd�knud�sqh‘mfkd�ne�fkna‘k�onkhshbr+„�Sgd�Dbnmnlhrs�vqhsdr�ne�T-R-,Bghmdrd,Qtrrh‘m�� hmsdq‘bshnmr-�'Qtrrh‘�‘mc�Bghm‘9�Aqnsgdqr�hm�@qlr+„�Sgd�Dbnmnlhrs+�Itkx�16+�1/08-�

� 03� Enq�sgd�‘qftldms�sg‘s�sgd�HME�qdoqdrdmsr�‘m�'tm‘bbdos‘akd„�rsq‘sdfhb�kh‘ahkhsx�enq�sgd� Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr+�rdd�Rbnss�@-�Btnln+�'Hs&r�Shld�sn�L‘jd�‘�Mdv�Cd‘k9�Rnkuhmf�sgd�HME� Sqd‘sx&r�Rsq‘sdfhb�Kh‘ahkhshdr�sn�@bghdud�T-R-�Rdbtqhsx�Fn‘kr�hm�@rh‘+„�Sdw‘r�M‘shnm‘k�Rd, btqhsx�Qduhdv�1�’0(�’1/07(-�Enq�‘�bqhshptd�ne�sghr�‘qftldms+�rdd�Oq‘m‘x�U‘cch+�'Kd‘uhmf� sgd� HME�Sqd‘sx�Vnm&s�Gdko�Sqtlo�Bntmsdq�Bghm‘+„�B‘qmdfhd�Dmcnvldms�enq� Hmsdq, m‘shnm‘k�Od‘bd+�I‘mt‘qx�20+�1/08+�gssor9..b‘qmdfhddmcnvldms-nqf.1/08./0.20.kd‘uhmf� ,hme,sqd‘sx,vnm,s,gdko,sqtlo,bntmsdq,bghm‘,ota,67151-

� 04� C‘uhc�R‘mfdq�‘mc�Dcv‘qc�Vnmf+�'T-R-�Dmcr�Bnkc�V‘q�Lhrrhkd�Sqd‘sx�sn�Bntmsdq�@qlr� Athkcto�ax�Bghm‘+„�Sgd�Mdv�Xnqj�Shldr+�@tftrs�1+�1/08:�‘mc�Hcqddr�@kh+�'Cdedmrd�Rdbqd, s‘qx�Qdud‘kr�Ok‘m�enq�Fqntmc,K‘tmbgdc�Lhrrhkdr�hm�@rh‘+„�Qdtsdqr+�@tftrs�2+�1/08-

� 05� Sghr�onhms�hr�mnsdc�hm�@kdwdx�@qa‘snu+�'L‘c�Lnldmstl�Qdctw9�Sgd�Qhrd�‘mc�E‘kk�ne�Mt, bkd‘q�@qlr�Bnmsqnk+„�Rtquhu‘k9�Fkna‘k�Onkhshbr�‘mc�Rsq‘sdfx+�ItmdflItkx�1/08+�gssor9..vvv� -hhrr-nqf.otakhb‘shnmr.rtquhu‘k.1/08.rtquhu‘k,fkna‘k,onkhshbr,‘mc,rsq‘sdfx,itmditkx� ,1/08.502,/1,‘qa‘snu-

� 06� Rdd+�enq�dw‘lokd+�'T-R-�@mmntmbdr�Mdv�Lhrrhkd�Cdedmbd�Rxrsdl�sn�Bntmsdq�Sgqd‘sr� eqnl�Qtrrh‘+�Bghm‘+„�Sgd�Dbnmnlhb�Shldr+�I‘mt‘qx�08+�1/08-

� 07� Cnm‘kc�Sqtlo�ptnsdc�hm�'Sqtlo�Tmudhkr�@lahshntr�Lhrrhkd�Cdedmrd�Ok‘mr+„�M‘shnm‘k� Otakhb�Q‘chn+�I‘mt‘qx�06+�1/08-

� 08� Ingm�Anksnm�‘r�ptnsdc�hm�@mjhs�O‘mc‘+�'Anksnm9�Bghm‘�hr�Nmd�Qd‘rnm�T-R-�Knnjhmf�‘s� Rsqdmfsgdmhmf�M‘shnm‘k�Lhrrhkd�Cdedmrd+„�Sgd�Choknl‘s+�L‘qbg�08+�1/08-

� 1/� Sgd�ogq‘rd�hr�eqnl�Uk‘chlhq�Jnyhm+�'Drb‘k‘shnm�ne�DT,Qtrrh‘m�Qdk‘shnmr9�Odqrodbshudr� enq�Dtqnod�hm�sgd�B‘rd�ne�‘�Lhkhs‘qx�Bnmfihbs+„�o‘odq�enq�sgd�WHH�Dtqnod‘m�Qtrrh‘m�En, qtl+�Aqtrrdkr+�Adkfhtl+�Mnudladq�15+�1/07-

� 10� Uk‘chlhq�Otshm+�'Oqdrhcdmsh‘k�@ccqdrr�sn�sgd�Edcdq‘k�@rrdlakx+„�L‘qbg�0+�1/07+�gsso9.. dm-jqdlkhm-qt.dudmsr.oqdrhcdms.mdvr.45846-

� 11� Nm�sgd�che›btkshdr�ne�aqhmfhmf�Bghm‘�hmsn�‘qlr�bnmsqnk+�rdd�Lhbg‘dk�Jqdonm+�'Adssdq� V‘hs�sg‘m�Mdudq9�Sq‘mrhshnmhmf�eqnl�Ahk‘sdq‘k�sn�Ltkshk‘sdq‘k�Rsq‘sdfhb�@qlr�Qdctb, shnmr+„�hm�Qdxji‘uhj�Rtllhs9�Kdrrnmr�enq�sgd�Etstqd�ne�TR,Qtrrh‘m�Qdk‘shnmr�’Lnrbnv9�Hmsdqm‘, shnm‘k�Ktwdlantqf�Enqtl�enq�Oqdudmshmf�Mtbkd‘q�B‘s‘rsqnogd+�1/05(+�4/fl53-

� 12� Qhbg‘qc�Atqs�‘mc�Inm�Vnkersg‘k+�'Gnv�Sqtlo�B‘m�Sq‘mrenql�Mtbkd‘q�@qlr�Bnmsqnk+„� Sgd�M‘shnm‘k�Hmsdqdrs+�L‘x�0/+�1/08-

� 13� Sgntfg�rdudq‘k�rs‘sdrflHq‘p+�Hq‘m+�‘mc�Rxqh‘flotqrtdc�mtbkd‘q�vd‘onmr�tmrtbbdrretkkx- � 14� Odsdq�A‘jdq�‘mc�Bgnd�R‘mf,Gtm+�'Sqtlo�Sgqd‘sdmr�Ehqd�‘mc�Etqx�‘f‘hmrs�Mnqsg�Jnqd‘�he�

Hs�Dmc‘mfdqr�T-R-+„�Sgd�Mdv�Xnqj�Shldr+�@tftrs�7+�1/06- � 15� Mhbgnk‘r�Jqhrsne+�'Sqtlo&r�Rb‘qx�Rsq‘sdfx�nm�Mnqsg�Jnqd‘+„�Sgd�Mdv�Xnqj�Shldr+�Nbsnadq�

01+�1/06- � 16� H�‘l�hmcdasdc�sn�Rbnss�R‘f‘m�enq�ghfgkhfgshmf�sgd�hlonqs‘mbd�ne�sghr�onhms-

D o w n lo a d e d fro m h ttp ://d ire c t.m it.e d u /d a e d /a rtic le -p d f/1 4 9 /2 /1 7 /1 8 3 2 6 4 2 /d a e d _ a _ 0 1 7 8 7 .p d f b y U N IV O F C A L IF O R N IA S A N T A B A R B A R A u s e r o n 1 5 M a y 2 0 2 3

25 Cºc‘ktr+�sgd�Intqm‘k�ne�sgd�@ldqhb‘m�@b‘cdlx�ne�@qsr�%�Rbhdmbdr

@�Mtbkd‘q�Vnqkc�Sq‘mrenqldc9�Sgd�Qhrd�ne�Ltkshk‘sdq‘k�Chrnqcdq

� 17� Enq�‘�chrbtrrhnm�ne�sgd�hrrtdr�hm�ok‘x�‘mc�‘�bqhshptd�ne�Bghm‘&r�onrhshnm+�rdd�@mjhs�O‘mc‘+� 'SG??C�‘mc�Bghm‘&r�Mtbkd‘q�Rdbnmc,Rsqhjd�B‘o‘ahkhsx+�Sgd�Choknl‘s+�L‘qbg�7+�1/06-

� 18� Kh� Ahm+� 'Sgd� Rdbtqhsx� Chkdll‘� ‘mc�SG??C� Cdoknxldms� hm�QNJ+„� Jxtmfgx‘mf� C‘hkx+�� @tftrs�2+�1/05+�‘u‘hk‘akd�‘s�B‘qmdfhd�Dmcnvldms�enq�Hmsdqm‘shnm‘k�Od‘bd+�gssor9..b‘qmdfhd� dmcnvldms-nqf.1/05./7./2.rdbtqhsx,chkdll‘,‘mc,sg‘‘c,cdoknxldms,hm,qnj,ota� ,53168-

� 2/� Qnadqs�Kdfunkc+�'Sgd�Bg‘kkdmfdr�ne�‘�Ltkshonk‘q�Mtbkd‘q�Vnqkc�hm�‘�Rgheshmf�Hmsdqm‘, shnm‘k�Bnmsdws+„�hm�Lddshmf�sgd�Bg‘kkdmfdr�ne�sgd�Mdv�Mtbkd‘q�@fd9�Mtbkd‘q�Vd‘onmr�hm�‘�Bg‘mf, hmf�Fkna‘k�Nqcdq+�20-

� 20� Bg‘q‘bsdqhrshb‘kkx+�Sgnl‘r�Rbgdkkhmf�v‘r�‘gd‘c�ne�sgd�btqud�hm�‘ccqdrrhmf�sgd�qhrj�ne�mt, bkd‘q�sdqqnqhrl-�Rdd�Sgnl‘r�Rbgdkkhmf+�'Sghmjhmf�@ants�Mtbkd‘q�Sdqqnqhrl+„�Hmsdqm‘, shnm‘k�Rdbtqhsx�5�’3( ’0871(9�50fl66-

� 21� Rdd+�enq�dw‘lokd+�Bg‘qkdr�C-�Edqftrnm+�'B‘m�Atrg�nq�Jdqqx�Oqdudms�Mtbkd‘q�Sdqqnqhrl>„� @qlr�Bnmsqnk�Snc‘x+�Rdosdladq�1//39�'He�sgdqd�hr�‘mx�hrrtd�nm�vghbg kd‘cdqr�eqnl�‘kk�rhcdr� ne�sgd�onkhshb‘k�rodbsqtl�‘fqdd+�hs�hr�sgd�hlonqs‘mbd�ne�oqdudmshmf�mtbkd‘q�sdqqnqhrl-„

� 22� Rdd+�‘r�nmd�dw‘lokd+�sgd�dwbdkkdms�‘m‘kxrhr�ax�I‘ldr�@bsnm+�'Drb‘k‘shnm�sgqntfg�Dms‘m, fkdldms9�Gnv�sgd�Utkmdq‘ahkhsx�ne�Bnll‘mc�‘mc�Bnmsqnk�Rxrsdlr�Q‘hrdr�sgd�Qhrjr�ne� ‘m�Hm‘cudqsdms�Mtbkd‘q�V‘q+„�Hmsdqm‘shnm‘k�Rdbtqhsx�32�’0(�’1/07(9�45fl88-

� 23� Enq�‘m�‘k‘qldc�chrbtrrhnm�sg‘s�bnudqr�sghr�fqntmc�hm�fqd‘s�cds‘hk+�rdd�Jdhq�Khdadq�‘mc�� C‘qxk�Oqdrr+�'Sgd�Mdv�Dq‘�ne�Bntmsdqenqbd9 Sdbgmnknfhb‘k�Bg‘mfd�‘mc�sgd�Etstqd�ne� Mtbkd‘q�Cdsdqqdmbd+„�Hmsdqm‘shnm‘k�Rdbtqhsx�30�’3(�’1/06(9�8fl38-

� 24� Enq�‘m�nudquhdv�ne�sghr�hrrtd+�rdd�O‘sqhbh‘�Kdvhr�‘mc�Adxy‘�Tm‘k+�'Bxadqrdbtqhsx�ne�Mtbkd, ‘q�Vd‘onmr9�Sgqd‘sr+�Utkmdq‘ahkhshdr�‘mc�Bnmrdptdmbdr+„�Bg‘sg‘l�Gntrd�Qdrd‘qbg� O‘odq�’Knmcnm9�Qnx‘k�Hmrshstsd�ne�Hmsdqm‘shnm‘k�@ee‘hqr+�1/07(-

� 25� Rdd+�‘r�nmd�dw‘lokd�‘lnmf�l‘mx+�J‘sd�O‘sqhbj+�'Bxadq�@ss‘bjr+�Mns�Mtjdr+�L‘x�Ad� Mnqsg�Jnqd‘&r�Lnrs�C‘mfdqntr�Vd‘onmr+„�Hmrhcd�Rntqbdr+�Edaqt‘qx�17+�1/08-

� 26� L-�Dk‘hmd�Atmm+�'B‘m�Cdsdqqdmbd�Ad�S‘hknqdc>„�Rsq‘sdfhb�Enqtl�114�’1//6(9�0- � 27� Eqdc�J‘ok‘m+�'Gnv�Sqtlo�Bntkc�Qdrs‘qs�sgd�Mtbkd‘q�@qlr�Q‘bd+„�Rk‘sd+�Itmd�5+�1/08- � 28� Rsdudm�Ohedq+�'Sgd�Tmhsdc�Rs‘sdr�‘mc�sgd�T-R-,Qtrrh‘,Bghm‘�Mtbkd‘q�Qdk‘shnmrgho„�’bnm,

edqdmbd�o‘odq�rg‘qdc�vhsg�‘tsgnq(-

D o w n lo a d e d fro m h ttp ://d ire c t.m it.e d u /d a e d /a rtic le -p d f/1 4 9 /2 /1 7 /1 8 3 2 6 4 2 /d a e d _ a _ 0 1 7 8 7 .p d f b y U N IV O F C A L IF O R N IA S A N T A B A R B A R A u s e r o n 1 5 M a y 2 0 2 3