Chapter 3 (4)
1
CULTURAL DIFFERENCES AND THEIR INFLUENCE ON
STUDENT LEARNING EXPERIENCES IN
AMERICAN SCHOOLS
by Darlene Grayson
A Capstone Presented in Partial Fulfillment
Of the Requirements for the Degree
Doctor of Education
South College, Knoxville, TN
Graduation 2026
APPROVED BY:
Dr. Matthew Johnson, Ed.D., Capstone Chair
2
Table of Contents
CHAPTER 3: DATA COLLECTION PLAN............................................................................................3
Overview................................................................................................................................................... 3
Research Design....................................................................................................................................... 4
Site (or Setting).......................................................................................................................................10
Participants.............................................................................................................................................12
Researcher Positionality........................................................................................................................15
Interpretive Framework........................................................................................................................15
Philosophical Assumptions..................................................................................................................19
Researcher’s Role................................................................................................................................ 25
Procedures.............................................................................................................................................. 26
Permissions.......................................................................................................................................... 26
Recruitment..........................................................................................................................................29
Data Collection Plan.............................................................................................................................. 31
Data Collection Approach #1: Classroom Observations..................................................................... 31
Data Collection Approach #2: Semi-Structured Interviews or Focus Groups.....................................36
Data Collection Approach #3: Document or Artifact Review.............................................................42
Data Collection Approach #4: Researcher Reflective Journal.............................................................43
Data Synthesis........................................................................................................................................ 45
Data Organization and Preparation...................................................................................................... 45
Coding and Theme Development........................................................................................................ 46
Analysis of Student Engagement and Culturally Responsive Teaching.............................................. 47
Comparison Across Data Sources........................................................................................................50
Interpretation and Action Research Reflection....................................................................................51
Trustworthiness.................................................................................................................................... 53
Credibility............................................................................................................................................ 54
Transferability...................................................................................................................................... 57
Dependability....................................................................................................................................... 58
Confirmability......................................................................................................................................59
Ethical Considerations.......................................................................................................................... 61
Areas of Concern for Chair Review..................................................................................................... 64
Summary.................................................................................................................................................65
References...............................................................................................................................................68
3
CHAPTER 3: DATA COLLECTION PLAN
Overview
This chapter details the methodology through which the researcher will investigate
culturally responsive teaching (CRT) and student engagement in a culturally and linguistically
diverse middle school classroom. Building on the problem of practice presented in Chapter One
and the academic literature reviewed in Chapter Two, the study will examine how CRT practices
are implemented and how students experience these practices in relation to behavioral,
emotional, and cognitive engagement. The methodological approach recognizes that teaching
and learning are context-specific processes shaped by classroom relationships, cultural identities,
learning experiences, and institutional conditions (Gay, 2018; Ladson-Billings, 2021b; Osher et
al., 2020). The chapter explains the qualitative action research design, research setting,
participants, researcher positionality, permissions, recruitment procedures, data collection
methods, and procedures for organizing and interpreting the evidence.
A qualitative action research approach is appropriate for examining a concern of practice
because it combines systematic data collection, reflection, and purposeful action to inform
improvement within the setting where the concern occurs (Mertler, 2024; Stringer & Aragón,
2020). This approach aligns with the research gap identified in Chapter Two concerning how
educators implement and adapt CRT practices and how students experience those practices in
their classrooms (Aguayo et al., 2024; Anyichie et al., 2023; Franco et al., 2024). The study will
involve six educators and twelve students from the selected middle school. Data will be collected
through classroom observations, individual semi-structured educator interviews, student focus
groups, instructional document and artifact reviews, and the researcher's reflective journal.
4
The study will follow one action research cycle consisting of an initial investigation,
reflection on the initial evidence, refinement of existing instructional practices, follow-up
evidence collection, and further reflection. The instructional refinements will focus on
incorporating students' cultural experiences into lesson materials, connecting their perspectives
to classroom discussions, and providing meaningful opportunities for participation and
collaboration. These adjustments will be informed by the initial evidence rather than treated as
predetermined solutions. Following implementation, the researcher will examine how the refined
practices are enacted and experienced by participants.
The chapter will also explain how evidence will be analyzed while maintaining separate
distinctions among behavioral, emotional, and cognitive engagement. Classroom observations
will document instructional practices and observable behavioral participation, whereas students'
accounts will provide primary evidence concerning their emotional and cognitive experiences.
The chapter will further address trustworthiness through credibility, transferability, dependability,
and confirmability, as well as ethical responsibilities associated with conducting research
involving minors. Collectively, these methodological elements will guide a systematic and
ethically responsible investigation that connects classroom evidence with instructional
improvement (Mertler, 2024; Stringer & Aragón, 2020).
Research Design
This study will employ a qualitative action research design to investigate how culturally
responsive teaching (CRT) practices are enacted and experienced in a culturally and
linguistically diverse middle school classroom and how they relate to student engagement. The
selection of this design is informed by the practice-based nature of the research problem
presented in Chapter One and the research gap established in Chapter Two. Although previous
5
scholarship has examined the principles, potential benefits, and challenges of implementing CRT,
further investigation is needed into how educators enact, interpret, and adapt these practices in
classroom settings and how students experience them (Aguayo et al., 2024; Anyichie et al., 2023;
Franco et al., 2024). Qualitative action research is appropriate because it supports the systematic
examination of a practice-related concern while connecting evidence collection, reflection, and
instructional improvement (Mertler, 2024; Stringer & Aragón, 2020).
The design is appropriate because the research problem concerns instructional practices,
classroom interactions, and participants' interpretations of their learning experiences. Student
engagement extends beyond observable classroom participation and includes behavioral,
emotional, and cognitive dimensions. Consequently, observing whether a student participates in
classroom activities is not sufficient to establish how the student feels about learning or how
much mental effort the student invests in a task (Fredricks et al., 2019; Wang et al., 2020). For
example, a student may participate in an activity without experiencing a sense of belonging,
while another student may be intellectually invested in a lesson without frequently contributing
verbally. Understanding these experiences requires attention to the meanings students attribute to
classroom relationships, instructional practices, and learning opportunities (Eccles & Roeser,
2023; Osher et al., 2020). A qualitative approach will allow the researcher to examine these
perspectives within the context in which they occur.
Action research connects systematic investigation with purposeful action intended to
improve professional practice. Its theoretical foundation is associated with Lewin's (1946) work
on the relationship between research and action in addressing social problems. In educational
settings, action research involves identifying a concern of practice, collecting and interpreting
evidence, planning and implementing an appropriate action, examining the results, and reflecting
6
on possible improvements (Mertler, 2024; Stringer & Aragón, 2020). Rather than focusing
exclusively on describing existing conditions, this approach enables educators and researchers to
use evidence to inform instructional decisions. The present study will follow one complete action
research cycle consisting of initial investigation, reflection, instructional refinement, follow-up
evidence collection, and further reflection.
The instructional action will involve refining existing CRT practices rather than
introducing an entirely new instructional program. The refinement will focus on three areas:
incorporating students' cultural experiences and perspectives into lesson materials, creating
meaningful connections between students' experiences and classroom discussions, and providing
varied opportunities for students to contribute, collaborate, and demonstrate their understanding.
For lesson materials, the participating educators will examine existing instructional resources and
identify appropriate opportunities to incorporate diverse cultural perspectives and connections to
students' experiences. Classroom discussions will be refined to provide more intentional
opportunities for students to contribute perspectives and connect lesson content with their
experiences. Participation opportunities will also be considered so that students have meaningful
ways to contribute and demonstrate their understanding. These refinements will be informed by
the initial evidence and developed within the instructional and organizational conditions of the
school. The participating educators will be involved in the refinement of their classroom
practices, consistent with the approved research procedures.
The action research cycle will begin with an initial investigation of existing instructional
practices and student engagement. During this stage, classroom observations, educator
interviews, student focus groups, and reviews of relevant instructional documents will provide
evidence concerning current CRT practices and students' classroom experiences. The researcher
7
will also maintain a reflective journal to document observations, questions, and developing
interpretations. Initial evidence will be examined to identify patterns and areas where existing
instructional practices may be strengthened. The researcher will then reflect on these findings
and use them to inform the instructional refinements. This initial reflection is important because
the action will be based on evidence from the classroom rather than assumptions about what
students or educators need (Mertler, 2024; Stringer & Aragón, 2020).
Following the instructional refinement, the researcher will collect follow-up evidence
through additional classroom observations, educator interviews, student focus groups, reviews of
relevant instructional materials, and reflective journaling. The purpose of this follow-up stage
will be to examine how the refined practices are implemented and how educators and students
experience them. The researcher will compare the initial and follow-up evidence to identify
similarities, differences, and areas requiring further consideration. This study will complete one
action research cycle. Further reflection will identify whether the refined practices appear
appropriate for continuation or whether additional adjustments may be considered beyond the
scope of the present cycle. The study will not establish additional formal cycles or leave the
number of cycles undetermined. The sequence of investigation, reflection, action, follow-up
examination, and further reflection will guide the study's procedures and analysis (Mertler, 2024;
Stringer & Aragón, 2020).
The study's design is also informed by the conceptual foundations discussed in Chapter
Two. Culturally Relevant Pedagogy emphasizes academic achievement while recognizing the
importance of cultural competence and critical consciousness. This framework supports the
study's focus on instructional practices that acknowledge students' cultural experiences and
create meaningful opportunities for learning and participation (Ladson-Billings, 2021b).
8
Sociocultural Learning Theory emphasizes the role of social interaction and cultural tools in
learning, which is relevant to examining classroom relationships, discussions, and instructional
opportunities as interconnected aspects of the learning environment (Vygotsky, 1978). Together,
these perspectives provide a foundation for examining how educators enact and refine CRT
practices and how students experience classroom learning.
The importance of context must also be recognized because CRT cannot be separated
from the educational environments in which teachers and students interact. Its implementation
may be influenced by curriculum requirements, available instructional resources, professional
learning opportunities, school expectations, and educators' assumptions about teaching and
learning (Chang & Viesca, 2022; Darling-Hammond et al., 2020). Similarly, students' classroom
experiences may be shaped by interactions among cultural identity, peer relationships, classroom
climate, and access to meaningful learning opportunities (Gay, 2018; Osher et al., 2020). The
study will therefore examine instructional practices in relation to the conditions of the selected
school and classroom. Cultural and linguistic diversity will not be treated as a barrier to
engagement or as an explanation for differences in students' participation.
Reflection is an essential part of the action research process because it allows educators
and researchers to examine instructional decisions, consider evidence, and identify opportunities
for improvement. CRT encourages educators to consider whether instructional practices
recognize students' experiences, provide meaningful opportunities for contribution, and establish
respectful classroom environments (Gay, 2018; Ladson-Billings, 2021b). In this study, reflection
will occur after the initial investigation and again after the follow-up evidence collection. Initial
reflection will inform the instructional refinements, while subsequent reflection will examine
how the refinements were implemented and experienced. This process will provide a systematic
9
basis for considering instructional improvement rather than relying solely on personal judgments
about whether a lesson was successful (Mertler, 2024; Stringer & Aragón, 2020).
The study will examine behavioral, emotional, and cognitive engagement as three related
but distinct dimensions. Behavioral engagement concerns observable actions, such as
participation and involvement in learning activities. Emotional engagement concerns students'
feelings and experiences, including interest, relationships, and belonging. Cognitive engagement
concerns students' mental effort, investment in understanding, and persistence with learning tasks
(Fredricks et al., 2019; Wang et al., 2020). Classroom observations will provide evidence about
instructional practices and observable behavioral participation. Emotional and cognitive
engagement will be explored primarily through students' accounts during focus groups. The
researcher will not infer students' emotional experiences or cognitive investment solely from
outward behaviors. Each dimension will be analyzed separately, although relationships among
them may be considered when supported by the evidence.
A qualitative action research design will provide an opportunity to develop a detailed
understanding of instructional practices and participants' experiences before and after the
instructional refinement. Although the study will examine differences in evidence across the
action research cycle, it will not assume that CRT alone caused any observed changes in
engagement. Classroom relationships, instructional conditions, curriculum demands, and
individual student experiences may also influence how students respond to learning
opportunities. Findings will therefore be interpreted in relation to the instructional practices
implemented, the context in which they occurred, and the perspectives represented in the
collected evidence (Gay, 2018; Mertler, 2024).
10
Overall, qualitative action research provides a coherent methodological approach for
addressing the study's practice-oriented purpose. It supports the investigation of existing CRT
practices, the identification and implementation of instructional refinements, and the examination
of how those refinements are experienced in an authentic middle school classroom. One
complete action research cycle will connect initial investigation and reflection with instructional
refinement, follow-up evidence collection, and further reflection (Mertler, 2024; Stringer &
Aragón, 2020). The design will guide the selection of the research setting and participants, the
researcher's role, data collection procedures, evidence synthesis, trustworthiness strategies, and
ethical safeguards. Maintaining alignment among the research questions, instructional action,
collected evidence, and interpretations will be essential to the methodological rigor of the study.
The purpose is to develop a context-specific understanding of CRT and student engagement and
to use the evidence to inform thoughtful instructional improvement, rather than to assume that a
particular teaching strategy will produce uniform outcomes across students or educational
settings (Gay, 2018; Stringer & Aragón, 2020).
Site (or Setting)
The study will take place in a 6th through 8th grade middle school. The school provides a
school environment in which culturally and linguistically diverse classrooms and culturally
responsive teaching (CRT) practices can be analyzed from the perspective of students. These
contextual factors relevant to the school are the grade-level structure, the student body, the
instructional arrangements, and the organizational environment of the school. To ensure the
anonymity of the institution and its community, the school is anonymized and potentially
identifying information is omitted from the description (Stringer & Aragón, 2020).
11
The school's instructional and organizational context will be important for understanding
the interactions between educators and students. Relevant contextual characteristics will include
the cultural and linguistic diversity represented in the student population, classroom instructional
practices, curriculum expectations, available learning resources, and school-wide educational
priorities. These characteristics are relevant because culturally responsive instruction involves
recognizing students' experiences and perspectives and creating meaningful opportunities for
them to participate in learning (Gay, 2018; Ladson-Billings, 2021b). Examining the study within
a specific school will allow the researcher to consider how CRT is implemented under the
instructional and organizational conditions of that setting rather than treating middle schools as
interchangeable educational environments.
The middle school context is particularly relevant because students at this developmental
stage experience changes in identity formation, peer relationships, academic expectations, and
their sense of belonging. These social and developmental experiences may be relevant to how
students experience classroom instruction and learning opportunities. Student engagement will
therefore be examined as a multidimensional concept rather than being defined solely by
observable behavior or task completion (Darling-Hammond et al., 2020; Wang et al., 2020). The
study will explore students' reported experiences of classroom relationships, instructional
relevance, and opportunities for participation without assuming that particular behaviors indicate
a specific emotional or cognitive state.
The organizational environment of the school will also be considered when examining
how CRT is implemented. Curriculum requirements, instructional resources, professional
learning opportunities, school expectations, and educators' professional practices may influence
the instructional decisions made within classrooms (Anyichie et al., 2023; Darling-Hammond et
12
al., 2020). These conditions will be considered when interpreting the evidence gathered during
the study. The researcher will not attribute differences in student engagement to cultural or
linguistic backgrounds without supporting evidence. Instead, attention will be given to the
instructional practices, classroom relationships, and contextual conditions that participants
describe or that are documented through the approved data collection procedures.
The study will involve six educators and twelve students from the selected middle school.
The educators will participate in individual semi-structured interviews, while the students will
participate in focus groups. Classroom observations will provide evidence about instructional
practices and observable behavioral engagement. The researcher will also review relevant lesson
plans, instructional materials, and classroom activities associated with the observed lessons and
the instructional refinements. A reflective journal will be maintained throughout the research
process. These data collection approaches will allow the researcher to examine the
implementation of CRT practices alongside educators' perspectives and students' accounts of
their classroom experiences.
The selected setting is consistent with the qualitative action research design because the
study focuses on examining and improving a concern of practice within the context where it
occurs. Action research emphasizes context-specific investigation, systematic reflection, and the
use of evidence to inform professional practice (Mertler, 2024; Stringer & Aragón, 2020).
Examining CRT practices and student engagement within the selected school will provide insight
into how instructional practices are enacted and experienced in that particular educational
environment. The findings will be interpreted in relation to the setting and evidence collected
rather than presented as universally applicable conclusions about all middle schools.
13
Before recruitment and data collection begin, the researcher will obtain the required
institutional approval and authorization from the appropriate school and district authorities. The
researcher will also follow the approved procedures for obtaining informed consent from adult
participants, parental or guardian permission for student participation, and student assent, as
applicable. Confidentiality procedures will be established to protect the identities and
information of participating educators and students. If a pseudonym is required to protect the
school's identity, that pseudonym will be used consistently throughout the dissertation. The final
site description will reflect the approved research setting and include only information relevant
to understanding the study (Mertler, 2024; Stringer & Aragón, 2020).
Participants
Participants will be purposefully selected because the study requires individuals who can
provide relevant information about culturally responsive teaching (CRT) and student engagement
in the selected middle school. Purposeful sampling is appropriate for qualitative research because
it allows the researcher to select participants with direct experience of the phenomenon being
investigated rather than seeking a statistically representative sample (Mertler, 2024; Stringer &
Aragón, 2020). Accordingly, the study will involve six educators and twelve students from the
selected middle school. These participants will provide perspectives on instructional practices,
classroom interactions, cultural representation, and students' experiences of learning.
The six educator participants will be selected based on their direct involvement in
teaching, planning, or supporting instruction in the participating classroom setting. Their
perspectives will provide information about instructional planning, the implementation of
culturally responsive strategies, professional reflection, and contextual factors that influence
classroom practices. The twelve student participants will be selected from students enrolled in
14
the participating classroom setting who have direct experience of the instruction being examined.
Their participation will provide insight into classroom relationships, cultural representation,
participation opportunities, and the relevance of instructional activities to their learning
experiences. Including both educator and student perspectives will support an examination of
how CRT practices are implemented and experienced from different positions within the
classroom environment (Aguayo et al., 2024; Anyichie et al., 2023).
Educator inclusion criteria will require participants to be employed at the selected middle
school, have direct responsibility for teaching or supporting instruction in the participating
classroom setting, and be willing to participate in the approved research activities. These criteria
will ensure that educators can provide relevant accounts of instructional decisions, classroom
practices, and the conditions influencing CRT implementation. Student inclusion criteria will
require participants to be enrolled in the participating classroom setting during the study period
and to have experience of the instruction being examined. Students will participate voluntarily
and will not be selected on the basis of their level of classroom participation, academic
performance, cultural background, or perceived engagement. Their participation or decision not
to participate will not affect their grades, access to instruction, relationships with school
personnel, or other educational opportunities.
Because the student participants may be minors, additional ethical safeguards will be
followed. The study will comply with institutional review requirements and applicable school
policies concerning parental or guardian permission and student assent. Information about the
study will be presented in age-appropriate language, explaining its purpose, the nature of
participation, confidentiality protections, and the right to decline or withdraw without penalty.
Required parental or guardian permission and student assent will be obtained before students
15
participate in research activities. The researcher will also remain attentive to potential power
differences between students, educators, and school personnel, particularly when inviting
students to participate in focus groups (Mertler, 2024; Stringer & Aragón, 2020).
The total proposed sample will consist of eighteen participants: six educators and twelve
students. This sample is appropriate for a small-scale qualitative action research study because it
allows the researcher to examine classroom practices and gather detailed perspectives from both
educators and students within one school setting. The purpose of the sample is not to achieve
statistical representation but to develop a context-specific understanding of the problem of
practice. Including both groups will allow the researcher to compare educators' descriptions of
instructional practices with students' accounts of their classroom experiences. The sample size
also reflects the practical requirements of conducting school-based action research, including
recruitment, obtaining permissions, collecting evidence, and completing analysis within the
project timeframe (Mertler, 2024; Stringer & Aragón, 2020).
The educator participants will take part in individual semi-structured interviews, while
the twelve student participants will take part in focus groups. These methods will allow
educators to describe their instructional decisions and experiences individually, while students
will have opportunities to discuss their classroom experiences and perspectives. Classroom
observations, instructional document and artifact reviews, and the researcher's reflective journal
will provide additional evidence concerning the implementation of CRT practices and the
classroom context. The same participant groups will be involved in the initial and follow-up
stages of the action research cycle, subject to continued voluntary participation and the approved
research procedures.
16
To protect participants' identities, pseudonyms or participant codes will be used in
research notes, interview records, focus group transcripts, and reports. Identifying details will be
excluded or generalized when describing classroom practices and participant experiences.
Records containing personal information will be managed according to the approved data-
protection procedures. The researcher will also recognize that students may experience the same
instructional practice differently. No individual participant's perspective will be presented as
representative of an entire cultural or linguistic group (Aguayo et al., 2024; Gay, 2018).
Purposeful selection, clearly defined inclusion criteria, voluntary participation, and
confidentiality protections will support a participant approach consistent with the qualitative and
reflective purposes of the study.
Researcher Positionality
Researcher positionality concerns how a researcher's background, experiences, values,
assumptions, and relationship to the research setting may influence the research process and
interpretation of findings. In this qualitative action research study, positionality will be
considered throughout the investigation of culturally responsive teaching (CRT) and student
engagement in a culturally and linguistically diverse middle school classroom. Qualitative
inquiry involves interpreting participants' experiences within their social and educational
contexts. Therefore, the researcher will critically examine personal assumptions and remain open
to perspectives that may challenge initial expectations (Creswell & Poth, 2018). Action research
also requires reflexivity so that the researcher's decisions, interpretations, and involvement in
examining classroom practices are recognized throughout the investigation (Mertler, 2024;
Stringer & Aragón, 2020).
17
Interpretive Framework
This study will be guided by an interpretive paradigm that recognizes the importance of
participants' experiences, interactions, and contexts in understanding culturally responsive
teaching (CRT) and student engagement. An interpretive approach is based on the understanding
that educational phenomena can be examined by exploring how individuals interpret and assign
meaning to their experiences. Educators and students may understand the same classroom
practice differently because of their experiences, relationships, expectations, and social contexts
(Creswell & Poth, 2018). This framework is appropriate for examining CRT because culturally
responsive practice extends beyond the use of particular instructional strategies to include
cultural recognition, classroom relationships, and connections between instruction and students'
experiences (Gay, 2018; Ladson-Billings, 2021b). The interpretive paradigm will therefore guide
the research design, data collection, and analysis by emphasizing participants' perspectives and
the meanings they attribute to classroom experiences.
Student engagement will be examined as a multidimensional concept involving
behavioral, emotional, and cognitive dimensions. These dimensions provide complementary
perspectives on students' experiences in the learning environment, but they will not be treated as
interchangeable (Wang et al., 2020). Behavioral engagement concerns observable actions such as
participation and involvement in classroom learning activities. Emotional engagement concerns
students' reported feelings and experiences, including interest, belonging, and relationships
within the classroom. Cognitive engagement concerns students' reported mental effort,
investment in understanding, and persistence with learning tasks. Examining these dimensions
separately will allow the researcher to develop a more complete understanding of student
engagement without reducing it to a single observable behavior.
18
The interpretive framework will guide how evidence concerning each engagement
dimension is understood. Classroom observations will provide information about instructional
practices and observable behavioral engagement, such as opportunities for participation and
students' involvement in classroom activities. However, observations will not be used
independently to determine whether students feel interested, included, or intellectually invested
in learning. Emotional and cognitive engagement will be explored primarily through students'
accounts during focus groups. For example, limited verbal participation will not automatically be
interpreted as a lack of interest or cognitive investment. Similarly, frequent participation will not
automatically establish that a student feels a sense of belonging or finds the learning activity
meaningful. These distinctions will guide the interpretation of the evidence throughout the study
(Wang et al., 2020).
The interpretive approach will also facilitate examination of student engagement within
its sociocultural context. Classroom interactions occur within relationships, cultural
environments, instructional conditions, and broader educational settings that may influence how
learning experiences are understood. For example, an opportunity to participate in a classroom
discussion may be experienced differently depending on students' relationships with the
educator, previous classroom experiences, and perceptions of the learning environment. The
researcher will therefore consider both what is documented through classroom observations and
the meanings participants attribute to their experiences. Students' cultural knowledge and
experiences will be treated as relevant aspects of their perspectives rather than explanations for
limited participation. This orientation aligns with culturally responsive teaching, which
recognizes students' experiences and cultural understandings as important resources for learning
(Gay, 2018; Ladson-Billings, 2021b).
19
The framework will also support examination of how educators and students understand
culturally responsive practices in the selected middle school. Educators will have opportunities
to explain their instructional decisions in relation to curriculum expectations, professional
experiences, classroom relationships, and efforts to recognize students' backgrounds. Students
will describe their experiences of instructional activities, classroom discussions, cultural
representation, and opportunities to connect learning with their experiences. These perspectives
may overlap or differ, and both will be considered when examining how CRT is implemented
and experienced. The study will not assume that any specific instructional practice produces a
particular level of engagement. Instead, participants' accounts, classroom conditions, and
patterns identified across the collected evidence will inform interpretation.
An interpretive paradigm also recognizes the researcher's role in developing
interpretations from the evidence. The researcher will therefore examine participants' accounts
while considering how personal assumptions, experiences, and expectations may influence
analysis. For example, frequent classroom participation may initially appear to indicate strong
engagement. However, student accounts may reveal that participation does not necessarily
correspond with emotional interest or cognitive investment. Recognizing these possibilities will
help the researcher consider alternative interpretations rather than relying on initial impressions.
The study will focus on participants' perspectives and develop conclusions that remain consistent
with the available evidence, approved research questions, and scope of the investigation
(Creswell & Poth, 2018).
Reflexivity will be an important part of this process. Reflexivity involves examining
assumptions, decisions, and the researcher's role throughout the inquiry. Because this study
concerns CRT and student engagement, the researcher will reflect on personal expectations about
20
effective teaching, classroom participation, cultural responsiveness, and student behavior. These
expectations may influence which classroom experiences receive attention and how participants'
accounts are interpreted. Reflexive journaling will help the researcher document assumptions,
distinguish participants' statements from personal interpretations, consider alternative
explanations, and record decisions made during the analysis. This process aligns with action
research, which emphasizes systematic reflection on professional practice and the use of
evidence to inform improvement (Mertler, 2024; Stringer & Aragón, 2020).
The interpretive framework is also consistent with the context-specific and reflective
characteristics of action research. Action research involves examining a concern of practice
within the setting where it occurs and using evidence to inform reflection and professional
decision-making. In this study, the researcher will examine classroom experiences, instructional
practices, and participants' accounts in relation to CRT and the separate dimensions of student
engagement. The initial evidence will inform the refinement of existing instructional practices,
and follow-up evidence will be examined to understand how those refinements are implemented
and experienced. The researcher will not assume that any observed differences are solely
attributable to a particular teaching method. Interpretations will remain grounded in the evidence
and recognize contextual factors that may influence participants' experiences (Mertler, 2024;
Stringer & Aragón, 2020).
Philosophical Assumptions
The philosophical assumptions underpinning this study will inform how culturally
responsive teaching, student engagement, and participants' classroom experiences are understood
and interpreted. Qualitative research requires researchers to recognize their assumptions when
designing an inquiry because these assumptions influence the questions asked, the evidence
21
collected, and the interpretations developed (Creswell & Poth, 2018). This study will address
ontological, epistemological, and axiological assumptions to establish a philosophical foundation
for investigating CRT in a culturally and linguistically diverse middle school setting. These
assumptions are particularly relevant because classroom experiences are shaped by social
relationships, cultural backgrounds, instructional practices, and institutional expectations.
Consistent with the interpretive paradigm, the study will emphasize participants' perspectives
rather than presume that there is only one explanation for student engagement or instructional
decision-making (Creswell & Poth, 2018; Wang et al., 2020).
The ontological assumption concerns the nature of reality and whether a phenomenon has
one objective meaning or may be experienced differently by individuals in particular contexts
(Creswell & Poth, 2018). This study will adopt an interpretive ontological position that
recognizes multiple perspectives on classroom teaching and student engagement. Students may
experience the same instructional practice differently because of their previous educational
experiences, relationships with educators, cultural experiences, and feelings of belonging.
Similarly, educators may have different understandings of culturally responsive instruction based
on their professional experiences, beliefs, and classroom responsibilities. One group's
perspective will not automatically be considered more accurate than another's. Instead, the study
will consider how these different perspectives contribute to understanding the implementation
and experience of CRT within the selected middle school. Research on student engagement also
emphasizes the importance of considering learners' developmental and sociocultural contexts
rather than examining engagement in isolation (Wang et al., 2020).
This ontological position requires careful interpretation of observable classroom
behaviors. Although participation and involvement provide useful evidence of behavioral
22
engagement, they cannot independently establish students' emotional or cognitive experiences. A
student may complete assigned activities without reporting interest or a sense of belonging.
Another student may demonstrate substantial cognitive investment without frequently speaking
during classroom discussions. These dimensions must therefore be considered separately, with
emotional and cognitive engagement explored primarily through students' accounts. In addition,
students' cultural backgrounds and the languages they speak will not be treated as
interchangeable explanations for their learning behaviors. Culturally responsive teaching
emphasizes instruction that recognizes students' cultural backgrounds, while Culturally Relevant
Pedagogy emphasizes academic success, cultural competence, and critical consciousness (Gay,
2018; Ladson-Billings, 2021b). The study will interpret engagement through classroom practices
and participants' perspectives rather than assuming that cultural identity determines educational
experience.
The epistemological assumption concerns how knowledge is developed and how the
researcher can understand the experiences being investigated (Creswell & Poth, 2018).
Consistent with the interpretive paradigm, this study will adopt the position that knowledge
about CRT and student engagement can be developed through inquiry into participants'
perspectives and the educational contexts in which their experiences occur. Understanding will
involve interpretation of the evidence collected and consideration of the circumstances in which
participants describe their experiences. The researcher will not assume that knowledge can be
separated entirely from interpretation. Instead, the conclusions will be based on the evidence
gathered, the context in which it emerges, and the reasoning used to interpret it. Qualitative
inquiry supports this approach by examining how individuals understand and assign meaning to
23
their experiences rather than reducing those experiences to predetermined explanations (Creswell
& Poth, 2018).
The epistemological position will also recognize that participants may provide different
or contradictory accounts of the same classroom event. For example, an educator may
understand an instructional activity as an effort to incorporate students' cultural knowledge,
while students may have different views about whether their experiences were meaningfully
represented. Rather than treating such differences as evidence that one perspective must be
incorrect, the researcher will examine the context and meaning of the differing accounts. Action
research encourages systematic examination of practice and reflection on evidence to develop
professional understanding (Mertler, 2024; Stringer & Aragón, 2020). Accordingly, the
researcher will distinguish between participants' statements, observations, documented
instructional practices, and the interpretations developed through analysis. Claims about
differences in engagement before and after the instructional refinement will remain proportionate
to the evidence. Participants' perceptions will not be treated as proof of a causal relationship
between CRT and student outcomes.
The axiological assumption addresses the influence of values and ethical commitments
on the research process. Qualitative researchers should recognize that their values and
experiences may influence the focus of an inquiry and the interpretations developed from the
evidence (Creswell & Poth, 2018). In this study, the focus on culturally responsive teaching
reflects an interest in understanding how classroom practices recognize students' experiences and
support meaningful educational opportunities. This orientation is consistent with scholarship
examining the relationship between culturally informed instruction, students' experiences, and
educational opportunities (Gay, 2018; Ladson-Billings, 2021b). However, a commitment to
24
examining CRT will not lead the researcher to assume that every practice described as culturally
responsive will necessarily be experienced positively or will improve engagement. Maintaining
openness to different findings will help ensure that interpretations are based on the evidence
rather than predetermined expectations (Mertler, 2024).
To address the influence of values and assumptions, the researcher will apply reflexive
practices throughout the inquiry. These practices will include examining initial expectations,
documenting decisions made during evidence interpretation, and considering alternative
explanations for identified patterns. Reflexivity is particularly important when interpreting
cultural experiences because the researcher's understanding of a participant's account may differ
from the meaning the participant intended to communicate. Action research emphasizes
reflective examination of practice, which supports the questioning of assumptions and
reconsideration of interpretations as evidence emerges (Mertler, 2024; Stringer & Aragón, 2020).
When differing perspectives arise, the researcher will seek to represent them accurately rather
than treating discrepancies as problems that must be eliminated. The study will also avoid
portraying cultural or linguistic diversity as a deficit and will consider the influence of
instructional and institutional conditions on participants' experiences (Gay, 2018).
The ontological, epistemological, and axiological assumptions will provide a coherent
philosophical foundation for the study. The ontological position recognizes that participants may
experience classroom practices differently; the epistemological position emphasizes developing
interpretations through evidence and context; and the axiological position requires
acknowledgment of the researcher's values and assumptions (Creswell & Poth, 2018). These
assumptions are consistent with action research because they emphasize context-specific inquiry,
reflective examination of evidence, and evidence-informed reconsideration of educational
25
practice (Mertler, 2024; Stringer & Aragón, 2020). Their application will help maintain
alignment among the study's philosophical orientation, approved research questions, data
collection procedures, and analysis. Ultimately, the study will seek to develop a contextually
informed understanding of how CRT is implemented and experienced in relation to student
engagement while recognizing the value and limitations of the evidence collected.
Researcher’s Role
The researcher will serve as the primary investigator responsible for organizing the study,
obtaining required permissions, coordinating participant recruitment, collecting and analyzing
evidence, and interpreting findings in relation to the approved research questions and qualitative
action research design. Action research requires a reflective approach in which the researcher
systematically examines a concern of practice and uses evidence to inform improvement
(Mertler, 2024; Stringer & Aragón, 2020). The researcher will therefore maintain clear
distinctions between the responsibilities of the researcher and the experiences and contributions
of the educator and student participants. Reflexivity will be practiced throughout the study to
examine how the researcher's understanding of CRT, student engagement, and classroom
instruction may influence research decisions and interpretations (Creswell & Poth, 2018).
The researcher will be responsible for conducting classroom observations, interviewing
the six educator participants, facilitating student focus groups, reviewing approved instructional
documents and artifacts, and maintaining a reflective journal. During classroom observations, the
researcher will document instructional practices, classroom interactions, and observable
behavioral engagement without assuming that outward behavior establishes students' emotional
or cognitive experiences. Those dimensions will be examined primarily through students'
accounts. The researcher will also maintain appropriate boundaries during participant
26
interactions and ensure that students understand that participation is voluntary and unrelated to
their academic performance or relationships with educators.
Reflexivity will help the researcher recognize how personal values, expectations,
assumptions, and professional perspectives may influence the collection and interpretation of
evidence. Reflective journal entries will document observations, questions, developing
interpretations, and decisions made during the study. The researcher will use these records to
consider alternative explanations, distinguish direct observations from personal interpretations,
and identify assumptions that may affect the analysis. This practice will be especially important
when examining cultural experiences, instructional practices, and differences between educator
and student perspectives (Mertler, 2024; Stringer & Aragón, 2020).
The researcher will also contribute to the action research process by examining the initial
evidence and using it to inform the refinement of existing classroom practices in collaboration
with participating educators, consistent with the approved protocol. Following implementation,
the researcher will collect and examine follow-up evidence to understand how the refined
practices are experienced. The final reflection will consider what the evidence indicates about the
instructional refinements and whether further improvement may be appropriate. Throughout this
process, the researcher will uphold ethical responsibilities, protect participant confidentiality, and
avoid generalized conclusions about cultural or linguistic groups. The researcher's role will
therefore involve systematic inquiry, careful interpretation, and reflective engagement with
evidence while remaining attentive to the perspectives and experiences of all participants (Gay,
2018; Mertler, 2024; Stringer & Aragón, 2020).
27
Procedures
The procedures for this study will establish a systematic process for examining culturally
responsive teaching (CRT) practices and student engagement in a culturally and linguistically
diverse middle school. Before beginning recruitment or data collection, the researcher will obtain
the institutional, ethical, and school-site approvals required to conduct the study. Following
approval, the researcher will recruit six educators and twelve students who meet the established
participation criteria. Data will be collected through classroom observations, individual semi-
structured educator interviews, student focus groups, instructional document and artifact reviews,
and a researcher reflective journal.
The study will follow one action research cycle consisting of initial evidence collection,
reflection, instructional refinement, follow-up evidence collection, and further reflection. During
the initial investigation, the researcher will examine existing instructional practices and gather
evidence concerning student engagement. The initial findings will inform refinements to
instructional practices in collaboration with participating educators. These refinements may
involve incorporating students' cultural experiences into instructional materials and classroom
discussions and providing meaningful opportunities for students to participate, collaborate, and
demonstrate their understanding. Following implementation, the researcher will collect follow-
up evidence using the established data collection methods and reflect on the findings in relation
to the initial evidence. This process will support a systematic examination of instructional
practice and identify opportunities for continued improvement (Mertler, 2024; Stringer &
Aragón, 2020).
28
Permissions
Before recruitment and data collection, the researcher will obtain the institutional and
ethical approvals required for the proposed study. The researcher will submit the study proposal
to South College in accordance with its research approval procedures and obtain approval from
the appropriate institutional review board or designated ethics review body before initiating
research activities. Institutional approval is essential in educational research because studies
involving educators and students may involve sensitive information about instructional practices,
academic experiences, and social relationships (Creswell & Poth, 2018). No recruitment,
participant contact, or data collection will begin before the required approvals have been granted.
In addition to institutional approval, the researcher will obtain permission from the school
district, school administration, or other authorized site representatives, as required by the
selected research setting. This process will establish whether the researcher may access the
school, participating classrooms, educators, students, and instructional materials necessary for
the study. The researcher will communicate the purpose and scope of the project, explain the
proposed data collection activities, and clarify the responsibilities of the researcher and
participating educators. Permission will also address any school-specific requirements
concerning classroom access, student participation, confidentiality, and the handling of
instructional documents or artifacts. These steps are consistent with action research principles,
which emphasize collaboration, responsible engagement with the research setting, and attention
to the needs of the participating community (Mertler, 2024; Stringer & Aragón, 2020).
The researcher will obtain informed consent from participating educators and, for
students under the age of 18, parental or legal guardian permission and student assent in
accordance with institutional and school requirements. Consent and assent materials will explain
29
the purpose of the study, expected activities, potential risks and benefits, confidentiality
protections, and the voluntary nature of participation. Students will receive age-appropriate
information to help them understand what participation involves and make an informed decision
about whether to participate. Research involving children requires additional protections to
safeguard their rights and welfare (Protection of Human Subjects, 2025). The researcher will
follow the requirements established by the reviewing institutional body and will not substitute
general consent procedures for the specific requirements applicable to this study.
Participation will remain voluntary throughout the research process. Educators and
students will be informed that they may decline participation or withdraw without penalty or
negative consequences. Because educational settings may involve differences in authority and
power, particular care will be taken to ensure that students do not feel pressured to participate. If
the researcher has a supervisory, instructional, or evaluative relationship with potential
participants, an independent third party without such responsibilities will distribute recruitment
information and receive expressions of interest. The researcher will not use an existing position
of authority to influence participation decisions. Participation or nonparticipation will not affect
students' grades, educational opportunities, or relationships with school personnel, nor will it
affect educators' professional standing or employment.
Confidentiality and data protection procedures will be established before data collection
begins. The researcher will use pseudonyms or participant codes when reporting findings and
will remove identifying information from research records and written reports whenever
possible. Access to identifiable research information will be restricted to the researcher and any
individuals specifically authorized under the approved research protocol. Research records will
be stored securely and retained or destroyed according to institutional requirements. Because
30
student focus groups involve participants hearing one another's contributions, students will also
be informed that the researcher cannot guarantee that other group members will maintain
confidentiality. The researcher will explain the importance of respecting other participants'
privacy and avoiding the sharing of personal information outside the group. These safeguards are
particularly important when participants discuss classroom experiences, relationships, and
instructional practices that they may not want attributed to them personally (Creswell & Poth,
2018).
Finally, the researcher will maintain documentation of institutional and site approvals,
consent and assent procedures, recruitment activities, and any approved changes to the research
plan. Any proposed modification involving participants, recruitment, or data collection
procedures will be submitted for the required approval before implementation. Maintaining these
records will provide a clear account of how the study was conducted and support the
transparency and trustworthiness of the research process (Mertler, 2024; Stringer & Aragón,
2020).
Recruitment
Participant recruitment will begin after all required institutional, ethical, and school-site
approvals have been obtained. The study will use purposeful sampling to recruit six educators
and twelve students from the selected middle school. Purposeful sampling is appropriate for
qualitative research because participants are selected based on their direct experience with the
phenomenon being investigated and their ability to provide relevant information (Creswell &
Poth, 2018). The educator participants will be individuals directly involved in teaching, planning,
or supporting instruction in the participating classroom setting. Student participants will be
enrolled in the participating classroom setting and will have experience with the instructional
31
practices being examined. The final selection of participants will follow the inclusion criteria
established in the approved research protocol.
Recruitment materials will explain the purpose of the study, participation requirements,
expected research activities, and procedures for protecting participants' privacy. Educators will
receive information about the individual semi-structured interviews, classroom observations, and
possible review of relevant instructional materials. Students and their parents or legal guardians
will receive age-appropriate information explaining the student focus groups and any classroom
observation activities involving the student participants. The materials will also explain that
participation is voluntary, that participants may withdraw without penalty, and that declining
participation will not affect their educational or professional standing. Contact information for
the researcher and the appropriate institutional representative will be provided so that prospective
participants can ask questions before deciding whether to participate (Creswell & Poth, 2018).
Recruitment and consent procedures for student participants will include parental or legal
guardian permission and student assent in accordance with the approved institutional and school-
site requirements. Students will not be included in interviews, focus groups, or other individual
data collection activities unless the required permission and assent have been obtained. The
researcher will explain the study in language appropriate to the students' ages and developmental
levels and will make clear that they may decline to participate or withdraw at any time without
negative consequences.
Because classroom observations may take place in settings where both participating and
nonparticipating students are present, the researcher will follow the observation procedures
specifically approved by the institutional review body and school. The researcher will establish
in advance how students without the required permission or assent will be handled during
32
observations. The observation protocol will focus on instructional practices, classroom context,
and observable behavioral engagement among eligible participants. The researcher will not
record identifiable information or individual behavioral data about students who have not
consented to participate. If the presence of nonparticipating students makes it impossible to
distinguish eligible participants or avoid collecting information about nonparticipants, the
researcher will not proceed with that observation until an approved alternative arrangement has
been established. This approach will protect the privacy and rights of students who do not
participate while allowing the study to examine classroom practices appropriately.
After the required consent and assent procedures have been completed, the researcher
will confirm the final group of six educators and twelve students. Only individuals who meet the
inclusion criteria and complete the applicable consent or assent requirements will participate in
the study's data collection activities. Recruitment records and completed consent documents will
be stored securely and accessed only by authorized individuals in accordance with the approved
research protocol. These procedures will support the ethical recruitment of participants and
establish a consistent foundation for examining CRT practices and student engagement (Mertler,
2024).
Data Collection Plan
The Data Collection Plan describes how evidence will be collected to investigate
culturally responsive teaching (CRT) practices and student engagement in the selected middle
school. The study will use five complementary sources of evidence: classroom observations,
individual semi-structured educator interviews, student focus groups, instructional document and
artifact reviews, and a researcher reflective journal. Each method will contribute a different
perspective on instructional practices and student experiences. Classroom observations will
33
provide contextual evidence about teaching practices, classroom interactions, and observable
behavioral engagement. Educator interviews and student focus groups will provide participants'
perspectives on instructional practices and the three dimensions of engagement. Document
reviews will provide additional information about instructional planning and materials, while the
reflective journal will help the researcher examine assumptions, decisions, and emerging
interpretations throughout the study.
The data collection process will follow one action research cycle consisting of initial
evidence collection, reflection, instructional refinement, follow-up evidence collection, and
further reflection. During the initial stage, the researcher will conduct three classroom
observations, interview six educators, facilitate three student focus groups, review relevant
instructional materials, and maintain reflective journal entries. The initial evidence will inform
reflection and collaboration with participating educators to identify appropriate refinements to
existing instructional practices. These refinements will focus on incorporating students' cultural
experiences and perspectives into lesson materials and classroom discussions and providing
meaningful opportunities for participation, collaboration, and demonstrating understanding.
Following implementation, the researcher will conduct three additional classroom observations,
follow-up interviews with the six educators, and follow-up focus group sessions with the same
three student groups. Relevant instructional materials will also be reviewed to identify changes
associated with the refinements. This process will support comparison of the initial and follow-
up evidence and further reflection on the instructional practices examined in the study (Mertler,
2024; Stringer & Aragón, 2020).
34
Data Collection Approach #1: Classroom Observations
Classroom observations will be used to develop an understanding of how CRT practices
are implemented in the selected middle school setting. Observations are appropriate for
qualitative research because they allow the researcher to document instructional practices,
classroom conditions, and interactions as they occur in their natural setting rather than relying
exclusively on participants' recollections (Creswell & Poth, 2018). Research examining CRT has
also demonstrated the value of classroom observations for identifying instructional practices and
aspects of teaching that may not be fully captured through general measures of pedagogical
quality (Lavigne et al., 2022). Although observations can provide useful evidence about
classroom practices and interactions, they will not be treated as proof that a particular
instructional practice causes changes in student engagement (Franco et al., 2024a).
The observation process will be guided by the conceptual framework of the study, which
incorporates culturally relevant pedagogy and sociocultural learning theory. Culturally relevant
pedagogy emphasizes academic success, cultural competence, and critical consciousness as
important dimensions of teaching and learning (Ladson-Billings, 2021). Similarly, culturally
responsive teaching recognizes the importance of understanding students' cultural knowledge
and experiences when making instructional decisions (Gay, 2018). Sociocultural learning theory
emphasizes the role of social interaction and the learning environment in shaping students'
learning experiences (Wang et al., 2020). These perspectives will guide the researcher's attention
to how instructional practices recognize students' experiences, support participation, and create
opportunities for interaction and learning.
The observation protocol will focus on the following areas: (a) instructional presentation
and task design; (b) connections between lesson content and students' experiences; (c)
35
opportunities for student participation and explanation; (d) teacher responses to student questions
and errors; (e) peer collaboration; (f) recognition of students' cultural knowledge and linguistic
resources; (g) classroom interactions and environmental conditions; and (h) observable
behavioral engagement, including participation and persistence with learning activities. These
areas will guide data collection without functioning as a rigid checklist. The researcher will also
document unexpected events and contextual details that may help explain how instructional
practices occur in the participating classrooms. The observation instrument will be developed in
alignment with the research questions and conceptual framework and included in the study
appendix.
A critical distinction will be maintained between observable behavior and students'
internal experiences. Classroom observations will document instructional practices, classroom
context, and observable behavioral engagement only. Behavioral engagement may include
observable participation, involvement in classroom activities, and persistence with assigned
tasks. However, the researcher will not interpret visible behavior as direct evidence of students'
emotional or cognitive engagement. A student who does not speak during a classroom discussion
may still be interested, emotionally connected to the lesson, or thinking carefully about the
content. Similarly, frequent participation does not necessarily demonstrate understanding,
belonging, or intellectual investment. Emotional engagement, including students' feelings of
belonging, interest, comfort, or exclusion, will be examined primarily through student accounts.
Cognitive engagement, including mental effort, understanding, critical thinking, and investment
in learning, will also be explored primarily through students' descriptions of their experiences
and other appropriate participant evidence. This distinction will prevent the researcher from
36
making unsupported conclusions about students' psychological processes based solely on
outward behavior (Gay, 2018; Wang et al., 2020).
The study will include six classroom observations conducted over a six-week period,
with each observation lasting approximately 30–45 minutes during a regular lesson. Three
observations will take place during the initial evidence collection stage, before instructional
refinement. The remaining three will take place after the refined practices have been
implemented. This arrangement will provide opportunities to examine classroom practices before
and after the instructional adjustments while minimizing disruption to normal instructional
activities. The observations will be scheduled in coordination with the participating educators
and school administration and conducted according to the approved research protocol.
During each observation, the researcher will use the approved observation protocol and
field notes to document relevant classroom events. Descriptive notes will include information
about the lesson setting, instructional activities, teacher prompts, student responses, opportunities
for participation, peer interactions, and relevant environmental conditions. Notes concerning
student behavior will describe what the researcher directly observes without assigning emotional
or cognitive meanings to those actions. Reflective notes will be maintained separately and will
include questions, emerging patterns, and preliminary interpretations that require further
examination. Separating descriptive and reflective notes will help distinguish recorded evidence
from the researcher's developing explanations (Creswell & Poth, 2018).
The researcher will also document contextual conditions that may influence participation
in classroom activities. These may include task complexity, interruptions, opportunities to
contribute, instructional modifications, and the organization of classroom activities. Only
information permitted under the approved research protocol will be recorded, and the researcher
37
will not collect identifiable information about students who have not provided the required
permission and assent. If nonparticipating students are present and their information cannot be
reliably excluded from the observation, the researcher will follow the approved alternative
arrangement or postpone the observation until an appropriate arrangement is established. These
safeguards will protect students' privacy while allowing the researcher to examine classroom
practices in their natural setting (Mertler, 2024; Stringer & Aragón, 2020).
Following each observation, the researcher will review the field notes to clarify entries
and identify questions requiring further investigation. Preliminary patterns will be considered
tentative rather than conclusive findings. For example, the researcher may identify recurring
opportunities for students to connect lesson content with their experiences or observe differences
in how teachers respond to student contributions. Such observations will provide contextual
information for examining instructional practices but will not independently establish how
students feel about those practices or how deeply they engage cognitively. The researcher will
therefore compare observation evidence with educator interviews, student focus group accounts,
and relevant instructional documents. This approach will support a more comprehensive
interpretation of classroom practices while acknowledging that different participants may
understand the same classroom experiences differently (Creswell & Poth, 2018; Franco et al.,
2024b).
Overall, classroom observations will provide contextual evidence about how CRT
practices are implemented and how behavioral engagement is expressed during instruction. Their
purpose will be to document classroom events and instructional interactions rather than to
determine the effectiveness of individual practices or infer students' internal experiences. By
using a structured observation protocol, separating descriptive and reflective notes, and
38
comparing observations with other evidence sources, the researcher will support a context-
sensitive examination of CRT and student engagement (Lavigne et al., 2022; Mertler, 2024;
Wang et al., 2020).
Data Collection Approach #2: Semi-Structured Interviews or Focus Groups
Individual semi-structured interviews and student focus groups will provide evidence
about how educators and students understand and experience CRT practices and student
engagement. Although classroom observations will document instructional practices, classroom
interactions, and observable behavioral engagement, interviews and focus groups will allow
participants to explain the meanings they attribute to their experiences. Individual interviews can
provide detailed accounts of educators' instructional decisions and professional experiences,
while focus groups can encourage students to share perspectives and respond to one another's
contributions (Creswell & Poth, 2018). Aguayo et al. (2024) demonstrated the value of student
focus groups for exploring how middle and high school students perceive teachers' culturally
responsive practices, including experiences involving inclusive instruction, teacher attitudes, and
cultural representation. This approach is therefore appropriate for examining student perspectives
within the present study.
The study will include six educators who are directly involved in teaching, planning, or
supporting instruction in the participating classroom setting. Each educator will participate in
two individual semi-structured interviews: one during the initial evidence collection stage and
another after the instructional refinements have been implemented. This will result in twelve
educator interview sessions. Each interview will last approximately 30–40 minutes and will
follow an interview guide developed in alignment with the study's research questions and
conceptual framework.
39
The initial interviews will explore educators' existing instructional practices, experiences
with culturally responsive teaching, perceptions of classroom engagement, and challenges
associated with creating inclusive learning opportunities. Participants will be invited to describe
how they incorporate students' cultural experiences and linguistic resources into instruction, how
they encourage classroom participation, and how they respond to students' questions and
contributions. The researcher will also ask educators to identify areas of instructional practice
that may benefit from refinement. Open-ended questions and follow-up prompts will allow
educators to provide examples and explain their instructional decisions without assuming that
particular strategies are necessarily effective (Creswell & Poth, 2018; Gay, 2018).
The follow-up interviews will take place after the instructional refinements have been
implemented. Educators will be invited to discuss their experiences incorporating students'
cultural experiences into lesson materials and classroom discussions and providing additional
opportunities for participation, collaboration, and demonstrating understanding. Questions will
explore what changes were made, how the refinements were incorporated into instruction, what
challenges emerged, and how educators interpreted the available evidence. Educators will also be
encouraged to identify aspects of the instructional process that may require additional
improvement. Comparing initial and follow-up interviews will help the researcher examine how
educators describe their instructional decisions and experiences throughout the action research
cycle.
Twelve students will participate in three focus groups, with four students in each group.
Each group will participate in two sessions: one before the instructional refinements and one
after implementation. This arrangement will result in six student focus group sessions. Each
session will last approximately 40–45 minutes. The same four students will participate in both
40
sessions within each group, provided they continue to meet the participation requirements and
voluntarily agree to remain involved. This arrangement will allow the researcher to examine
students' initial experiences and compare them with their accounts after the instructional
practices have been refined.
The initial focus groups will explore students' experiences with classroom instruction,
cultural representation in lesson content, relationships with teachers and peers, and opportunities
to participate in learning activities. Students will be encouraged to describe whether classroom
materials connect with their experiences, whether they feel comfortable contributing to
discussions, and which instructional practices support or limit their involvement. The researcher
will use open-ended questions and follow-up prompts to encourage students to explain their
experiences in their own words. Aguayo et al. (2024) demonstrated the usefulness of student
focus groups for identifying instructional practices students perceive as supportive or
exclusionary. Accordingly, student perspectives will be central to understanding how classroom
practices are experienced rather than relying exclusively on educators' descriptions of their
intentions.
The follow-up focus groups will examine how students experienced the refined
instructional practices. Questions will explore whether students noticed changes in lesson
materials, classroom discussions, and opportunities to participate or collaborate. Students will be
invited to describe which changes they found meaningful, whether any difficulties remained, and
whether the instructional activities supported their learning experiences. The researcher will not
assume that all students will respond to the refinements in the same way. Positive, negative,
mixed, or unchanged experiences will be documented and considered during analysis.
41
The interview and focus group protocols will address the three dimensions of student
engagement while keeping them analytically distinct. Behavioral engagement will be explored
through questions about participation, involvement in activities, persistence, and different ways
of contributing to classroom learning. Emotional engagement will be examined through students'
descriptions of interest, belonging, comfort, relationships with teachers and peers, and feelings
about the classroom environment. Cognitive engagement will be explored through questions
about mental effort, understanding, problem-solving, critical thinking, and the extent to which
instructional activities encourage students to consider ideas more deeply (Wang et al., 2020).
Students' accounts will provide the primary evidence for understanding their emotional and
cognitive experiences. Educator perspectives may provide additional context about instructional
intentions and perceived student responses, but they will not replace students' own descriptions
of their experiences.
The questions will be open-ended, unbiased, and appropriate for the age and role of each
participant. Students will not be led to view CRT positively or to describe cultural and linguistic
differences as problems that must be overcome. Instead, they will be encouraged to discuss
positive, negative, and mixed experiences. Participants will also be able to raise issues beyond
the predefined engagement dimensions when those issues are relevant to their classroom
experiences. This approach will help the researcher remain attentive to participants'
interpretations rather than imposing predetermined explanations (Creswell & Poth, 2018; Gay,
2018; Ladson-Billings, 2021).
Educator interviews and student focus groups will be conducted separately to reduce
potential power differences and support open communication. Educators will discuss their
instructional decisions and implementation experiences, while students will describe how they
42
experience classroom practices. Comparing these accounts will help the researcher examine
areas of agreement and difference between educators' instructional intentions and students'
reported experiences. Such comparisons will not assume that one account is automatically more
accurate than another; instead, differences will be considered as meaningful evidence about how
classroom practices may be understood from different perspectives (Aguayo et al., 2024).
Participation in interviews and focus groups will be voluntary. Educators will provide
informed consent, while student participation will require parental or legal guardian permission
and student assent in accordance with the approved research protocol. Participants will be
informed that they may decline to answer questions or withdraw according to the approved
procedures without negative consequences. Student focus group participants will also be
informed that the researcher cannot guarantee that other students will maintain confidentiality
outside the group. The researcher will explain the importance of respecting other participants'
privacy and will avoid questions that unnecessarily encourage disclosure of sensitive personal or
family information (Creswell & Poth, 2018).
With the required participant consent and institutional and school authorization,
interviews and focus groups will be audio-recorded to support accurate transcription and
analysis. If recording is not authorized or a participant does not consent to recording, the
researcher will follow the approved note-taking procedure. Transcripts and notes will be
reviewed for accuracy, and identifying information will be removed or replaced with
pseudonyms or participant codes. The researcher will securely maintain recordings, transcripts,
and notes in accordance with the approved data protection procedures (Creswell & Poth, 2018;
Stringer & Aragón, 2020).
43
After each round of interviews and focus groups, the researcher will review the
transcripts or notes to identify emerging themes, differing perspectives, and questions requiring
further exploration. Initial accounts will help identify experiences and concerns that may inform
instructional refinement. Follow-up accounts will provide additional evidence about how
educators and students experienced the refined practices. Potential areas of analysis may include
belonging and exclusion, cultural representation, teacher–student relationships, participation
opportunities, perceived barriers to engagement, and connections between lesson content and
students' experiences. These areas will guide analysis without preventing the identification of
additional themes that emerge from participants' accounts (Creswell & Poth, 2018).
The researcher will compare educator interviews and student focus group accounts across
the initial and follow-up stages and examine how they relate to classroom observations and
instructional documents. Similarities and differences will be considered rather than assuming that
all participants experienced the refinements in the same way. Behavioral engagement will be
considered using relevant observational and participant evidence, while students' accounts will
remain central to understanding their emotional experiences and cognitive investment. This
comparison will support reflection on the instructional refinements and help identify practices
that may warrant further attention. The process is consistent with action research principles that
connect evidence collection, reflection, changes in practice, and subsequent examination
(Mertler, 2024; Stringer & Aragón, 2020).
Overall, individual educator interviews and student focus groups will provide
complementary evidence about how CRT practices are understood and experienced before and
after instructional refinement. The twelve educator interview sessions and six student focus
group sessions will allow the researcher to examine instructional intentions alongside students'
44
reported experiences. Through open-ended questioning, voluntary participation, and careful
interpretation, the researcher will seek to represent participants' perspectives without overstating
conclusions about the relationship between CRT and student engagement (Aguayo et al., 2024;
Gay, 2018; Mertler, 2024).
Data Collection Approach #3: Document or Artifact Review
Document and artifact review will provide supporting evidence about instructional
planning, lesson content, and classroom activities associated with CRT practices. Documents can
help qualitative researchers understand how practices are planned, represented, and implemented
within a particular setting (Creswell & Poth, 2018). In this study, document review will focus on
lesson plans, instructional materials, and classroom activities associated with the observed
lessons and instructional refinements. These materials will help the researcher examine how
educators incorporate students' cultural experiences, perspectives, and linguistic resources into
instructional planning and learning opportunities.
The researcher will review relevant instructional materials from the initial and follow-up
stages of the action research cycle, subject to the required permissions and availability of the
documents. Initial materials will provide evidence about existing instructional plans and
activities before refinement. Follow-up materials will be examined to identify changes associated
with the instructional adjustments. The review will consider how lesson content connects with
students' experiences, whether instructional materials represent diverse perspectives, how
learning activities provide opportunities for participation and collaboration, and how planned
tasks support students in explaining and demonstrating their understanding. These areas will
guide the review while allowing the researcher to identify relevant information that does not fit
the initial categories (Creswell & Poth, 2018; Mertler, 2024).
45
The document review process will use a researcher-developed review protocol aligned
with the study's research questions and conceptual framework. The protocol will guide the
identification of relevant instructional content, cultural connections, participation opportunities,
and planned learning activities. The researcher will also record contextual information about the
purpose and use of each document when that information is available. The review will not
assume that the presence of culturally relevant content in a lesson plan proves that the
corresponding activity was implemented or that students experienced it positively. Similarly, the
absence of a particular feature in a document will not automatically establish that the teacher did
not use a culturally responsive practice during instruction.
Document and artifact evidence will be examined alongside classroom observations,
educator interviews, and student focus group accounts. For example, a lesson plan may
demonstrate an educator's intention to connect instructional content with students' experiences,
while classroom observations may show how that connection was incorporated into the lesson.
Student accounts may then provide evidence about whether students found the material relevant
or felt represented in the classroom discussion. Differences between the planned instruction,
observed practices, and student experiences will be considered during analysis rather than treated
as contradictions that must be resolved in favor of one source. Triangulating evidence from
different sources will support a more comprehensive interpretation of the instructional practices
examined in the study (Aguayo et al., 2024; Franco et al., 2024b; Stringer & Aragón, 2020).
Confidentiality will be maintained throughout the document review process. The
researcher will request only instructional materials relevant to the study and authorized for
review. Documents containing personally identifiable student information or confidential records
unrelated to the research questions will be excluded. If relevant materials contain identifying
46
information, the researcher will follow the approved procedures for redaction or secure handling
before including them in the analysis. The researcher will not use student grades, disciplinary
records, or other confidential student records unless they are specifically included in the
approved research protocol. This approach will limit unnecessary collection of personal
information and protect the privacy of educators and students.
Overall, document and artifact review will provide supporting evidence about how
instructional practices are planned and refined. By examining lesson plans, instructional
materials, and classroom activities before and after refinement, the researcher will be able to
consider changes in instructional planning alongside observed classroom practices and
participant accounts. Documents will remain a complementary source of evidence rather than a
standalone measure of CRT implementation or student engagement (Creswell & Poth, 2018;
Mertler, 2024).
Data Collection Approach #4: Researcher Reflective Journal
The researcher reflective journal will document observations, assumptions, questions,
methodological decisions, and emerging interpretations throughout the study. Reflective
journaling is appropriate for action research because the process involves examining professional
practice, considering evidence, and using reflection to inform improvement (Mertler, 2024;
Stringer & Aragón, 2020). In this study, the journal will help the researcher examine how CRT
practices are implemented and interpreted in relation to student engagement while remaining
aware of the influence of personal assumptions on the research process.
Journal entries will be completed after classroom observations, educator interviews,
student focus groups, document reviews, and other approved research activities. Each entry will
distinguish descriptive information from reflective comments and preliminary interpretations.
47
Descriptive entries will record relevant details about the research activity, including the
procedures followed, contextual conditions, and issues that arose during data collection.
Reflective entries will identify questions, possible patterns, uncertainties, and assumptions that
require further examination. For example, the researcher may document an observed classroom
interaction and separately consider possible explanations for that interaction. Those explanations
will remain tentative until they can be examined against other evidence, including participants'
accounts (Creswell & Poth, 2018).
The journal will also provide a space for examining assumptions about culture, teaching,
belonging, and student engagement. Because CRT is context-sensitive, the researcher will remain
attentive to the possibility that instructional practices may be interpreted differently by educators
and students. Reflective entries will help identify instances in which personal expectations may
influence how classroom interactions are understood. For example, the researcher will avoid
assuming that frequent verbal participation necessarily indicates strong engagement or that
limited participation reflects a lack of interest. These reflections will reinforce the distinction
between observable behavioral engagement and students' reported emotional and cognitive
experiences (Gay, 2018; Wang et al., 2020).
The reflective journal will also document decisions made throughout the single action
research cycle. During the initial evidence collection stage, entries will identify emerging
questions and issues requiring consideration. During reflection and instructional refinement, the
journal will record how initial evidence informs proposed adjustments to lesson materials,
classroom discussions, and participation opportunities. During follow-up evidence collection,
entries will document the researcher's observations about the implementation process,
methodological challenges, and questions that arise from the new evidence. The final reflective
48
entries will consider similarities and differences between the initial and follow-up evidence and
identify areas that may warrant further improvement.
Journal entries will support the organization of emerging interpretations and provide an
ongoing record of the researcher's decisions and reflections. However, the journal will not
replace participant accounts, classroom observations, or instructional documents as sources of
evidence about CRT and student engagement. Nor will the researcher's reflections be treated as
proof that a particular instructional practice is effective. Instead, the journal will help the
researcher examine personal assumptions, maintain awareness of methodological decisions, and
consider how interpretations are supported by the available evidence (Creswell & Poth, 2018;
Stringer & Aragón, 2020).
Overall, the reflective journal will support transparency and reflexivity throughout the
research process. By maintaining entries across initial evidence collection, instructional
refinement, follow-up evidence collection, and further reflection, the researcher will document
the development of the inquiry and examine the influence of personal interpretations. The journal
will therefore serve as a supporting tool for understanding the research process and strengthening
the credibility and dependability of the study (Mertler, 2024; Stringer & Aragón, 2020).
Data Synthesis
Data synthesis will involve organizing, examining, coding, and interpreting evidence
collected through classroom observations, individual educator interviews, student focus groups,
document and artifact reviews, and the researcher's reflective journal. The purpose will be to
develop a contextualized understanding of how culturally responsive teaching (CRT) is practiced
and experienced in relation to student engagement within a culturally and linguistically diverse
middle school. Qualitative analysis requires systematic examination of evidence while
49
considering the meanings participants attribute to their experiences and the circumstances in
which those experiences occur (Creswell & Poth, 2018). Accordingly, data synthesis will focus
on identifying recurring concepts, relationships, differences, and themes rather than relying on
isolated observations or predetermined conclusions.
The analysis will follow the single action research cycle established for this study. It will
begin with the organization and examination of initial evidence, followed by coding, theme
development, and reflection on existing instructional practices. The initial findings will inform
instructional refinements developed in collaboration with participating educators. After
implementation, the researcher will collect and analyze follow-up evidence to examine how the
refinements were implemented and experienced. The final stage will involve comparing initial
and follow-up findings and reflecting on possible improvements to instructional practice. This
sequence will ensure that data synthesis supports both the interpretation of the research evidence
and the action-oriented purpose of the study (Mertler, 2024; Stringer & Aragón, 2020).
Data Organization and Preparation
The initial stage of data synthesis will involve organizing and preparing the collected
evidence for analysis. Observation notes, educator interview transcripts or notes, student focus
group transcripts or notes, relevant classroom documents, and reflective journal entries will be
compiled into clearly identified and securely maintained records. Each record will be labeled
according to its data source, collection stage, and relevant participant code or group identifier.
For example, educator interviews and student focus groups will be distinguished according to
whether they were conducted before or after the instructional refinements. Classroom
observation records and instructional documents will also be identified according to their
respective collection stages. Where audio recording and transcription are authorized and
50
participants have provided the required consent, transcripts will be reviewed for accuracy before
analysis. If recording is not authorized or a participant does not consent to recording, the
researcher will use the approved note-taking procedures. These steps will help maintain an
organized record of the evidence and preserve the connection between collected information and
subsequent interpretations (Creswell & Poth, 2018).
The researcher will become familiar with the evidence through repeated reading and
examination of each data source. During this process, preliminary observations, questions, and
potential patterns will be documented without treating initial impressions as established findings.
Familiarization allows qualitative researchers to identify potentially meaningful ideas while
remaining attentive to the broader context in which statements and interactions occur (Braun &
Clarke, 2022). For this study, particular attention will be given to instructional practices,
classroom relationships, cultural representation, belonging, opportunities for participation, and
students' reported learning experiences. These areas are relevant because student engagement
includes behavioral, emotional, and cognitive dimensions that may not be equally visible or
expressed in classroom settings (Wang et al., 2020).
The researcher will also organize the evidence according to the initial and follow-up
stages of the action research cycle. Initial evidence will provide a description of existing
instructional practices and participants' experiences before refinement. Follow-up evidence will
provide information about the implementation and experience of the refined practices.
Maintaining this distinction will allow the researcher to examine similarities and differences
across the two stages without assuming that every change in the evidence resulted from the
instructional adjustments.
51
Coding and Theme Development
Following familiarization, the researcher will use a coding process to identify meaningful
segments of evidence relevant to the research purpose and approved research questions. Coding
will involve assigning concise labels to statements, observed interactions, document features, and
relevant reflective entries. For example, evidence describing opportunities for students to
connect lesson content with their cultural experiences may receive a preliminary code related to
cultural connection. Student descriptions of feeling respected, represented, or comfortable
contributing may be coded under concepts such as belonging, emotional safety, or classroom
relationships. These examples will guide the coding process without establishing predetermined
conclusions about the findings.
The coding process will combine deductive and inductive approaches. Deductive coding
will be informed by the study's conceptual framework and the established dimensions of student
engagement. CRT concepts and behavioral, emotional, and cognitive engagement will provide
initial areas of attention during evidence examination (Wang et al., 2020). However, the
researcher will remain open to information that does not fit these initial categories. Inductive
coding will allow unexpected experiences, contextual influences, and explanations to emerge
from participants' accounts and other collected evidence. Combining these approaches will
support theoretically informed analysis while allowing participants' perspectives and the specific
circumstances of the research setting to shape the developing interpretations (Braun & Clarke,
2022; Creswell & Poth, 2018).
After initial coding, related codes will be compared and organized into broader
categories. The researcher will examine whether categories represent distinct classroom
experiences, whether some overlap, and whether additional refinement is necessary. Potential
52
themes may concern relationships between instructional representation and participation, the
influence of teacher–student interactions on students' reported sense of belonging, or differences
between educators' instructional intentions and students' experiences. Themes will be retained
only when supported by the collected evidence. They will represent meaningful patterns relevant
to the research purpose rather than simply reproducing the topics included in interview questions
or observation protocols (Braun & Clarke, 2022).
Throughout coding and theme development, the researcher will retain examples of
evidence that support, challenge, or complicate emerging interpretations. Differences between
participants' experiences will not be excluded simply because they do not fit a developing
pattern. Instead, contrasting accounts and unexpected findings will be examined to determine
whether they reveal differences in individual experiences, classroom conditions, or
interpretations of instructional practices. This approach will help ensure that the analysis reflects
the range of evidence rather than presenting an artificially consistent account of the study.
Analysis of Student Engagement and Culturally Responsive Teaching
The analysis will examine CRT practices and student engagement as related but distinct
areas of inquiry. Evidence concerning CRT will be used to identify how instructional practices
incorporate cultural perspectives, connect lesson content with students' experiences, recognize
linguistic resources, and provide opportunities for meaningful participation. These areas are
consistent with culturally responsive teaching scholarship, which emphasizes the importance of
understanding students' cultural backgrounds and experiences when developing instructional
practices (Gay, 2018). However, identifying a culturally responsive practice will not
automatically establish that students experienced it positively or that it improved their
53
engagement. The researcher will distinguish between the instructional practices educators
implement and the experiences students report in response to those practices.
Student engagement will be examined through three separate dimensions: behavioral,
emotional, and cognitive engagement. These dimensions will be coded and interpreted
independently rather than combined into a single generalized measure of engagement.
Behavioral engagement will concern observable classroom actions, including participation in
discussions, involvement in learning activities, and persistence with assigned tasks. Classroom
observations will provide evidence of these behaviors and the instructional conditions in which
they occur. However, visible participation will not automatically be interpreted as evidence of
emotional interest or cognitive investment. Similarly, limited verbal participation will not
automatically be classified as disengagement because students may demonstrate thinking, effort,
and persistence in ways that are not directly observable.
Emotional engagement will be examined primarily through students' accounts of their
experiences, including descriptions of belonging, interest, relationships, comfort, and feelings
about participating in classroom activities. Cognitive engagement will also be examined
primarily through students' descriptions of their mental effort, understanding, persistence with
challenging tasks, intellectual investment, and perceived relevance of learning activities. These
distinctions are important because outward classroom behaviors do not necessarily reveal
students' emotional experiences or the extent of their cognitive investment (Wang et al., 2020).
Consequently, emotional and cognitive engagement will not be inferred solely from observation
records or treated as interchangeable with behavioral participation.
Separate analytical categories will be maintained for each engagement dimension. For
instance, evidence of frequent participation may support an interpretation concerning behavioral
54
engagement, but it will not independently establish emotional belonging or cognitive investment.
Likewise, a student's description of feeling represented in classroom materials may provide
evidence relevant to emotional engagement, but it will not automatically demonstrate increased
behavioral participation or deeper cognitive effort. The researcher will examine possible
relationships among the dimensions while preserving their analytical distinctions. This approach
will prevent conclusions about overall engagement from being based on evidence that supports
only one dimension.
The analysis will also consider contextual conditions that may influence how CRT
practices are implemented and experienced. Curriculum requirements, classroom relationships,
language expectations, instructional materials, and opportunities for contribution may shape
students' experiences of particular teaching practices. Therefore, CRT will be interpreted in
relation to the classroom context rather than solely through the presence of particular materials or
activities (Gay, 2018). The researcher will not attribute differences in engagement to students'
cultural or linguistic backgrounds without supporting evidence. Instead, the analysis will
examine how instructional decisions, classroom relationships, and learning conditions relate to
the experiences described by participants.
Comparison Across Data Sources
An important component of data synthesis will involve comparing evidence across the
different data sources. Classroom observations will provide information about instructional
practices, classroom conditions, and observable behavioral engagement. Educator interviews will
provide insight into instructional decisions, professional experiences, and perceptions of the
refinement process. Student focus groups will provide accounts of how students experience
classroom practices, including their feelings about belonging, participation, and learning.
55
Document reviews will provide supporting evidence about instructional planning and materials,
while the reflective journal will help the researcher examine assumptions and interpretations
developed throughout the inquiry. Comparing these sources will provide a broader understanding
of the research setting than relying on a single source of evidence (Creswell & Poth, 2018;
Stringer & Aragón, 2020).
The researcher will examine both convergence and divergence across the sources.
Convergence may occur when different sources support a similar interpretation. For example, a
lesson plan may include multiple cultural perspectives, an observation may document how the
material is incorporated into instruction, and students may describe the content as relevant to
their experiences. Such convergence may strengthen the interpretation by showing consistency
across different forms of evidence. However, it will not establish that the practice benefits every
student or produces the same experience for all participants. Research on culturally responsive
classroom practices emphasizes the importance of examining students' experiences rather than
relying exclusively on teacher intentions or observer assessments (Aguayo et al., 2024).
Divergence will receive equal consideration. An educator may describe an instructional
activity as inclusive, while students may report feeling that their experiences were not
represented or that they were uncomfortable participating. Similarly, observations may document
differences in classroom participation that do not correspond directly with students' descriptions
of their interest or understanding. These differences will not automatically be treated as errors or
inconsistencies in the evidence. Instead, they may reveal differences in how instructional
practices are understood and experienced by educators and students or demonstrate the
limitations of interpreting internal experiences through observable behavior (Aguayo et al., 2024;
56
Wang et al., 2020). The researcher will document contrasting accounts and consider possible
explanations supported by the collected evidence.
Comparison will also occur between the initial and follow-up evidence. The researcher
will examine whether instructional practices changed following refinement, whether participants
described different experiences, and whether the evidence revealed similarities or differences
across the two stages. These comparisons will remain descriptive and interpretive rather than
being presented as proof that the instructional refinements alone caused changes in student
engagement.
Interpretation and Action Research Reflection
The initial stage of interpretation will involve reviewing and refining the emerging
themes to determine how effectively they address the study's purpose and approved research
questions. The researcher will examine whether each theme is supported by sufficient evidence,
whether contrasting cases have been considered, and whether interpretations accurately represent
the collected records. Reflective journal entries will help document changes in the researcher's
thinking and identify instances in which personal assumptions or professional expectations may
have influenced coding and interpretation decisions (Creswell & Poth, 2018). This process
reflects action research principles, which emphasize the systematic examination of professional
practice through evidence, reflection, and purposeful action (Mertler, 2024; Stringer & Aragón,
2020).
The initial findings will inform a specific instructional refinement rather than ending with
interpretation or recommendations alone. The researcher will work with participating educators
to examine the initial evidence and identify appropriate adjustments to existing instructional
practices. The refinement process will focus on three areas: incorporating students' cultural
57
experiences and perspectives into lesson materials, creating meaningful connections between
students' experiences and classroom discussions, and providing varied opportunities for students
to contribute, collaborate, and demonstrate their understanding. These areas will provide a
direction for refinement, but the specific adjustments will be informed by the initial evidence
rather than imposed as predetermined solutions. Educator perspectives, student accounts,
classroom observations, and available instructional documents will help identify which practices
may require attention. The refinements will build on existing classroom instruction rather than
introduce an entirely new educational program.
Following the initial analysis and reflection, participating educators will implement the
agreed-upon instructional refinements within the approved study procedures. The purpose of this
stage will be to examine how existing instructional practices can be adjusted in response to the
evidence gathered during the initial investigation. The researcher will document the refinement
process through the approved observation protocol, relevant instructional materials, educator
interviews, student focus groups, and reflective journal entries. Any proposed instructional
changes will remain within the scope of the approved research protocol and school authorization.
After implementation, the researcher will conduct follow-up evidence collection to
examine the refined practices and participants' experiences. This stage will include three
additional classroom observations, follow-up individual interviews with the six educators,
follow-up focus group sessions with the same three groups of four students, and review of
relevant instructional materials associated with the refinements. The researcher will continue
using the same approved instruments and analytical distinctions established during the initial
stage. Behavioral engagement will be examined through observable classroom actions and
relevant participant accounts, while emotional and cognitive engagement will be explored
58
primarily through students' descriptions of their experiences. The three dimensions will remain
separate throughout the follow-up analysis (Wang et al., 2020).
The follow-up evidence will be organized and coded using the same general analytical
approach applied to the initial evidence. The researcher will compare the two stages to identify
similarities, differences, recurring patterns, and additional questions that emerged after
implementation. Particular attention will be given to whether the intended refinements were
incorporated into instruction, how educators described the implementation process, and how
students experienced the adjusted lesson materials, classroom discussions, and participation
opportunities. The analysis will also consider whether the refinements addressed the concerns
identified during the initial investigation or whether other challenges remained.
The researcher will interpret differences between the initial and follow-up evidence
cautiously. Any changes in observed participation or participant accounts will be considered in
relation to the instructional context and other factors that may have influenced classroom
experiences. The study will not assume that the instructional refinements alone caused changes
in engagement or that every student experienced the same outcomes. Instead, the purpose will be
to understand how the refined practices were implemented and experienced within the selected
middle school and what the collected evidence suggests about opportunities for improving
instruction.
The final stage will involve further reflection on the initial and follow-up findings. The
researcher will revisit the themes, consider the extent to which the instructional refinements
addressed the issues identified during the initial investigation, and document lessons learned. The
reflection will also identify practices that may be maintained, modified, or considered for
59
additional improvement. Any further recommendations will be presented as potential next steps
rather than as an additional formal action research cycle within the current study.
Through this sequence of initial evidence collection, analysis, reflection, instructional
refinement, implementation, follow-up evidence collection, comparison, and further reflection,
data synthesis will fulfill the action-oriented purpose of the research design. The process will
connect the examination of CRT practices with participants' experiences of behavioral,
emotional, and cognitive engagement while maintaining appropriate distinctions among the
evidence sources. Ultimately, the findings will provide a context-specific understanding of how
instructional practices are experienced and how evidence-informed refinements may support
more inclusive classroom learning environments (Mertler, 2024; Stringer & Aragón, 2020).
Trustworthiness
Trustworthiness will be addressed through credibility, transferability, dependability, and
confirmability, four criteria commonly used to evaluate rigor in qualitative inquiry (Lincoln &
Guba, 1985). These criteria will guide how evidence is collected, interpreted, and presented in
this action research study examining culturally responsive teaching (CRT) and student
engagement. Trustworthiness is particularly important because qualitative findings involve
interpreting participants’ experiences within their educational and social contexts (Creswell &
Poth, 2018). Several strategies will support trustworthiness, including triangulation, member
checking, reflexive journaling, and maintaining an audit trail.
Triangulation will involve comparing evidence from five sources: classroom
observations, individual educator interviews, student focus groups, instructional document and
artifact reviews, and the researcher’s reflective journal. Each source will provide a different
perspective on CRT practices and student engagement. For example, instructional materials may
60
illustrate how educators incorporate cultural experiences into lessons, while classroom
observations will document instructional practices, classroom interactions, and observable
behavioral engagement. Educator interviews will provide insight into instructional decisions, and
student focus groups will offer accounts of their experiences, including their feelings of
belonging, interest, effort, and perceived relevance. Comparing these sources will help identify
patterns and inconsistencies without assuming that all participants experience or interpret
classroom practices in the same way (Creswell & Poth, 2018).
The researcher will also maintain documentation of data collection procedures, coding
decisions, emerging themes, and changes in interpretation. This audit trail will support
transparency by showing how the findings develop from the original evidence (Lincoln & Guba,
1985). Reflexive journaling will further encourage the researcher to examine personal
assumptions and consider alternative explanations when interpreting classroom practices and
participant experiences (Mertler, 2024). Trustworthiness will not depend on eliminating
subjectivity from the inquiry. Instead, it will be supported by transparent procedures, systematic
examination of evidence, and acknowledgment of the researcher’s role in qualitative
interpretation (Creswell & Poth, 2018).
Credibility
Credibility will focus on whether the study’s interpretations are adequately grounded in
the evidence collected and accurately represent participants’ accounts and the classroom context.
This criterion is important when examining how CRT practices are implemented and how
students experience behavioral, emotional, and cognitive engagement in culturally and
linguistically diverse middle school classrooms (Lincoln & Guba, 1985).
61
Triangulation will strengthen credibility by comparing evidence from classroom
observations, educator interviews, student focus groups, instructional documents and artifacts,
and the researcher’s reflective journal. Each source will contribute a distinct perspective.
Classroom observations will document instructional practices, classroom context, and observable
behavioral engagement, such as participation in assigned activities and interactions during
instruction. Student focus groups will provide primary evidence of emotional engagement,
including students’ reported feelings of belonging, interest, comfort, and connection to classroom
relationships. They will also provide accounts of cognitive engagement, including students’
descriptions of mental effort, persistence, perceived relevance, and investment in learning.
Educator interviews will provide additional perspectives on instructional decisions and
classroom practices, while document reviews will help identify how cultural experiences and
perspectives are represented in lesson plans, instructional materials, and classroom activities. The
reflective journal will document the researcher’s observations, assumptions, and developing
interpretations. Comparing these sources will support a more comprehensive examination of the
research context (Creswell & Poth, 2018).
Triangulation will not be used to determine which participant or source is correct when
accounts differ. Instead, inconsistencies will be examined as potentially meaningful evidence of
how classroom practices are experienced from different perspectives. For example, an educator
may describe a classroom activity as inclusive, while students may report different experiences
of representation or participation. These differences will be documented and considered during
interpretation rather than dismissed as errors. The researcher will also maintain clear distinctions
among behavioral, emotional, and cognitive engagement. Observable participation will not be
treated as sufficient evidence of students’ emotional belonging or cognitive investment, because
62
these dimensions cannot be reliably established through outward behavior alone (Wang et al.,
2020).
Member checking will also be used to support credibility. Following the initial educator
interviews and student focus groups, the researcher will prepare brief summaries of the main
points communicated by each participant. Each of the six educators will receive a summary of
their individual interview, and students will receive summaries limited to their own contributions
during their respective focus groups. Participants will be invited to review the summaries and
indicate whether they accurately reflect what they intended to communicate. They may clarify
statements, correct misunderstandings, or provide additional explanations. The researcher will
not distribute complete focus-group transcripts or summaries containing other participants’
identifiable contributions. Participants will also not be asked to approve preliminary themes or
the researcher’s overall interpretations. Member checking will focus specifically on the accuracy
of the summaries of participants’ own accounts. Any corrections or clarifications will be
documented and considered during subsequent analysis (Creswell & Poth, 2018).
Credibility will further be supported by reviewing coded evidence against the original
records and considering alternative interpretations before finalizing themes. Particular attention
will be given to assumptions that could influence the analysis, such as interpreting frequent
participation as proof of engagement or assuming that limited verbal participation indicates
disengagement. Behavioral engagement will be examined using observational evidence, while
emotional and cognitive engagement will be examined primarily through student accounts and
relevant supporting evidence. These distinctions will help ensure that each engagement
dimension is interpreted using appropriate evidence (Wang et al., 2020). Reflexive journaling
will also support critical examination of the researcher’s assumptions throughout the study
63
(Mertler, 2024). Together, triangulation, member checking, systematic review of coded evidence,
and reflexive journaling will strengthen the credibility of the findings.
Transferability
Transferability will be supported by providing sufficiently detailed descriptions of the
research setting, participants, classroom context, data collection procedures, and conditions
under which the findings are developed. In qualitative inquiry, transferability differs from
statistical generalizability because the purpose is not to demonstrate that findings represent a
larger population. Instead, detailed contextual descriptions allow readers to determine whether
insights from the study may be relevant to comparable educational settings (Lincoln & Guba,
1985).
The study will be conducted at [insert approved school name or pseudonym] in [insert
city, state, or region]. The research will involve six educators and twelve students from the
selected middle school. The student participants will be organized into three focus groups of
four. The final report will describe relevant characteristics of the school and classroom contexts,
including the grade levels represented, instructional conditions, and relevant features of the
culturally and linguistically diverse learning environment. These descriptions will provide
readers with information needed to understand the setting without disclosing unnecessary
identifying details about the school, educators, students, or other members of the educational
community. Confidentiality will guide decisions about which contextual details can be reported
(Creswell & Poth, 2018).
The study will also describe the circumstances surrounding the implementation and
examination of CRT practices. This contextual information is important because culturally
responsive practices are implemented within particular instructional, relational, and institutional
64
environments rather than in isolation (Gay, 2018). Student engagement may also vary according
to learning activities, classroom relationships, and students’ experiences within the learning
environment (Wang et al., 2020). Describing these conditions will help readers understand the
circumstances in which the findings emerged and assess their potential relevance to similar
middle school settings.
Because the study is designed to examine and improve practice within one educational
context, its findings will not be presented as universally applicable conclusions (Mertler, 2024;
Stringer & Aragón, 2020). Instead, the report will provide a transparent account of the CRT
practices examined, participants’ experiences, the evidence supporting the interpretations, and
the limitations associated with the research setting and sample. Readers will then be able to
consider whether the findings may inform practice in their own educational contexts. This
approach recognizes that experiences in one middle school cannot automatically represent the
experiences of all culturally and linguistically diverse students or schools.
Dependability
Dependability will focus on maintaining a clear and consistent record of the research
process so that readers can understand how the study was conducted and how methodological
decisions developed. In qualitative research, dependability is supported through transparent
documentation of procedures and decisions rather than by assuming that an inquiry must remain
completely unchanged regardless of what is learned during data collection (Lincoln & Guba,
1985). This approach is particularly relevant to action research, which involves systematic
reflection and responsive examination of educational practice (Mertler, 2024).
The researcher will maintain records of the study procedures, data collection activities,
document and artifact selection decisions, coding processes, and development of analytical
65
themes. The documentation will reflect the study’s single action research cycle, which will
include initial evidence collection, reflection on the initial findings, refinement of instructional
practices, follow-up evidence collection, and further reflection. The researcher will distinguish
between planned procedures and activities actually completed. If a change to the research
procedures becomes necessary, the reason for the change will be documented, and any required
institutional or school-level authorization will be obtained before implementation (Creswell &
Poth, 2018).
An audit trail will provide an organized record of how evidence progresses from
collection to interpretation. It will include dated methodological notes, coding records, versions
of analytical categories, reflective journal entries, and explanations for decisions to combine,
revise, or separate themes. These records will help demonstrate how the researcher’s
understanding develops and how interpretations are connected to the evidence collected (Lincoln
& Guba, 1985). The audit trail will be maintained securely and will exclude unnecessary
identifying information about participants.
Dependability will also be supported by maintaining alignment among the study’s
purpose, research questions, qualitative action research design, data collection methods, and
analytical procedures. The same five data sources will guide the examination of initial and
follow-up evidence: classroom observations, individual interviews with six educators, focus
groups involving twelve students, instructional document and artifact reviews, and the
researcher’s reflective journal. The study will include three initial and three follow-up classroom
observations, twelve educator interviews across the initial and follow-up stages, and six student
focus group sessions across the same stages. Systematic coding and comparison of evidence will
66
support consistent examination while allowing unexpected findings to emerge (Creswell & Poth,
2018; Stringer & Aragón, 2020).
Dependability does not mean that another researcher must reach identical conclusions.
Rather, it means that the research process is documented clearly and coherently enough for
readers to evaluate how evidence was collected, examined, and interpreted. Through the audit
trail and consistent alignment of procedures, the study will provide a transparent account of its
methodological decisions and the development of its findings.
Confirmability
Confirmability will address the extent to which the study’s interpretations are supported
by the evidence collected rather than primarily reflecting the researcher’s assumptions,
preferences, or expectations. Qualitative research recognizes that researchers participate in
interpreting evidence. Therefore, confirmability requires documenting how conclusions are
developed and examining how the researcher’s perspectives may influence the inquiry (Lincoln
& Guba, 1985). In this study, confirmability will help ensure that interpretations of CRT
practices and student engagement are grounded in documented classroom practices and
participants’ accounts.
The researcher’s reflective journal will support confirmability by documenting
observations, assumptions, questions, and changes in interpretation throughout the research
process. The researcher will distinguish direct observations from personal interpretations. For
example, when documenting limited verbal participation during a classroom observation, the
researcher will record the observable behavior without automatically interpreting it as
disengagement. Similarly, frequent verbal participation will not automatically be interpreted as
evidence of emotional belonging or cognitive investment. The researcher will consider relevant
67
student accounts and other supporting evidence before developing interpretations about students’
experiences. This distinction is important because observable classroom behavior cannot fully
represent students’ emotional or cognitive engagement (Wang et al., 2020).
Triangulation will provide an additional strategy for supporting confirmability. The
researcher will compare classroom observations, educator interviews, student focus groups,
instructional documents and artifacts, and reflective journal entries when examining emerging
themes. This comparison will help establish whether interpretations are supported by multiple
pieces of evidence or depend primarily on one participant’s account or the researcher’s
assumptions (Creswell & Poth, 2018). However, the researcher will not require all sources to
produce identical findings. Differences among observations, educator perspectives, and student
accounts will be documented and considered as part of the analysis. The researcher will also
preserve the distinction between behavioral, emotional, and cognitive engagement so that
interpretations remain consistent with the type of evidence available for each dimension.
An audit trail will further support confirmability by documenting coding decisions, theme
development, methodological changes, and the reasoning behind analytical interpretations. These
records will allow the researcher to revisit the original evidence and examine whether
conclusions are adequately supported (Lincoln & Guba, 1985). Reflexive examination will also
encourage the researcher to question how personal expectations about cultural responsiveness,
classroom participation, and student engagement may influence the interpretation of findings
(Mertler, 2024).
Confirmability will therefore be supported through transparent documentation, systematic
comparison of evidence, and ongoing reflection on the researcher’s interpretive role. These
strategies will not eliminate the influence of the researcher’s perspectives, nor will they suggest
68
that qualitative interpretation is entirely objective. Instead, they will make the researcher’s
decisions and assumptions more visible while demonstrating how the study’s findings are
grounded in the collected evidence. This process will strengthen the transparency and evidentiary
basis of the interpretations concerning CRT practices and student engagement.
Ethical Considerations
Ethical considerations will guide every stage of the proposed action research study. The
study will be conducted in accordance with applicable institutional review requirements, school-
site authorization procedures, and approved research protocols before participant recruitment or
data collection begins. Ethical qualitative research requires the researcher to protect participants’
autonomy, dignity, privacy, and welfare throughout the research process (Creswell & Poth,
2018). These responsibilities are particularly important in educational research involving
culturally and linguistically diverse middle school students because differences in age, authority,
and relationships with educators may influence participants’ willingness to participate or share
their experiences.
Informed consent and student assent will be addressed before participation. The six adult
educator participants will receive information explaining the study’s purpose, procedures,
expected involvement, potential risks, confidentiality protections, and voluntary nature. For the
twelve student participants who are under the age of 18, parental or guardian permission and
student assent will be obtained in accordance with applicable institutional review requirements
and legal protections for research involving children. Information presented to students will use
age-appropriate language to help them understand the study, what participation involves, and
their right to decline or withdraw. Federal regulations governing research with children establish
69
additional protections, including requirements for parental permission and child assent when
applicable (Protection of Human Subjects, 2018).
Participation will remain voluntary throughout the study. Educators and students will be
informed that they may decline to answer individual questions or withdraw from the study in
accordance with the approved protocol without penalty or adverse consequences. Particular
attention will be given to preventing actual or perceived coercion arising from professional or
educational relationships. Students will be informed that participating or choosing not to
participate will not affect their grades, educational opportunities, relationships with educators, or
standing within the school. Similarly, educators will be informed that their decision to participate
or withdraw will not affect their employment or professional relationships. Recruitment and
communication procedures will be structured to reduce the possibility that individuals feel
pressured to participate because of differences in authority or status (Creswell & Poth, 2018).
Confidentiality and privacy will be protected through appropriate data collection, storage,
and reporting procedures. Pseudonyms or participant codes will be used in research records and
the final report, and identifying information about the school, participants, and other individuals
will be omitted or generalized when necessary. During classroom observations, the researcher
will focus on instructional practices, classroom context, and observable behavioral engagement
among the participating students. The researcher will avoid collecting identifiable information
about students who are not enrolled as research participants. If the presence of nonparticipating
students makes it impossible to conduct observations without recording their identifiable
information, the observation will be postponed or conducted using an alternative procedure
permitted by the approved protocol.
70
Additional confidentiality safeguards will apply to student focus groups. The twelve
student participants will take part in three groups of four, with each group participating in an
initial and a follow-up session. Before discussions begin, students will be reminded to respect
one another’s privacy and avoid sharing personal contributions outside the group. However, the
researcher will explain that confidentiality among focus-group participants cannot be guaranteed
because the researcher cannot control what other students disclose after the discussion. Reports
and research records will avoid identifying individual students through their comments or
descriptions. Member checking will also be conducted individually: students will receive
summaries limited to their own contributions rather than information identifying or revealing the
statements of other focus-group members.
Research records will be stored securely in accordance with institutional requirements
and the approved research protocol. Access will be limited to authorized individuals, and records
will be retained and disposed of according to applicable institutional policies. Any audio
recordings, interview notes, focus-group records, observation records, instructional documents,
and reflective journal entries will be handled using the approved data protection procedures.
Participants will be informed of the limits of confidentiality before consent or assent is obtained,
including circumstances in which disclosure may be required by law or institutional policy
(Creswell & Poth, 2018).
Protection from harm will involve minimizing unnecessary inconvenience, emotional
discomfort, and risks to participants’ educational or professional relationships. Interview and
focus-group questions will be designed to explore classroom practices and learning experiences
without pressuring participants to disclose information they consider embarrassing, private, or
unrelated to the study. Participants may decline to answer questions, request a pause, or
71
discontinue their involvement in accordance with the approved procedures. Any concerns arising
during data collection will be addressed using the applicable institutional and school-site
protocols.
Finally, the researcher will ensure that the presentation and interpretation of findings
respect participants’ dignity and cultural experiences. The study will avoid deficit-oriented
descriptions that portray culturally and linguistically diverse students as responsible for
challenges arising from instructional or institutional practices. Instead, the analysis will examine
how classroom practices, relationships, cultural representation, and opportunities for
participation relate to students’ reported and observed engagement. Findings will be limited to
information relevant to the study’s purpose while protecting participants’ identities and privacy.
These ethical practices will support the responsible examination of CRT and student engagement
while maintaining the researcher’s professional obligations to the educators, students, and school
community involved in the study (Mertler, 2024; Stringer & Aragón, 2020).
Areas of Concern for Chair Review
Two issues warrant further exploration before the research design and data collection
procedures are settled. These are the number of data collection approaches and their specific
combination. While the plans to use classroom observation, individual interviews or focus
groups, document or artifact analysis, and researcher reflective journal each may seem to
contribute unique perspectives, their inclusion would necessarily require considerable time and
resource expenditure in terms of data collection, data storage, and analysis. A qualitative
research design should theoretically integrate research questions, data sources, the nature of the
study, and resources (Creswell & Poth, 2018). Further thought might therefore be given to the
rationale for including all four approaches or to whether a narrower number of approaches could
72
serve to answer the research questions. This examination might also consider whether individual
interviews or focus groups are more appropriate for the planned participant population and for
eliciting the types of data desired.
The second area concerns ethical considerations if the proposed study is implemented.
Since the setting involves middle school students, future implementation would require careful
consideration of participant eligibility, school-site authorization, recruitment procedures,
confidentiality, and applicable institutional review requirements. If students aged under 18 were
to be recruited, the researcher would also need to ask for the corresponding parent's or guardian's
permission and the student's assent in line with any relevant requirements and any school
requirements. The researcher would need to consider whether pre-existing relationships with the
school or teachers or students could be perceived as coercive (Protection of Human Subjects,
2018). By contemplating these problem statements, the potential EdD capstone study will be
more methodologically sound, ethically studied, and feasible for implementation (Mertler, 2024).
Summary
This chapter presented the proposed data collection plan for examining how culturally
responsive teaching (CRT) practices influence student engagement in culturally and linguistically
diverse middle school classrooms. Guided by an action research design, the study will examine
existing instructional practices, explore students’ and educators’ experiences, and use collected
evidence to inform the refinement of classroom practices. The chapter established the research
design, proposed setting and participants, researcher positionality, procedures, data collection
approaches, data synthesis process, trustworthiness strategies, and ethical considerations that will
guide the investigation.
73
The proposed study will use multiple sources of qualitative evidence to develop an
understanding of CRT implementation and its relationship to behavioral, emotional, and
cognitive engagement. Classroom observations will document instructional practices and
observable student behaviors, while student focus groups and educator interviews will provide
insight into participants’ experiences and perspectives. Relevant instructional documents will
help identify how cultural experiences and perspectives are incorporated into classroom
materials, and the researcher’s reflective journal will document observations, assumptions, and
developing interpretations. These sources will be examined in relation to one another while
preserving the distinctions between the three dimensions of student engagement. In particular,
observable participation will not automatically be interpreted as evidence of emotional interest or
cognitive investment, which will be explored primarily through students’ accounts.
The chapter also established how the data will be organized, coded, compared, and
interpreted. Triangulation will support the examination of similarities and differences across data
sources, while member checking will allow participants to review summaries of their own
contributions and clarify possible misunderstandings. Credibility, transferability, dependability,
and confirmability will be supported through systematic documentation, reflexive journaling,
attention to the research context, and transparent analytical procedures. Ethical considerations
will guide participant recruitment, informed consent and assent, confidentiality, voluntary
participation, and the protection of student participants. Required institutional and school
permissions will be obtained before research activities and instructional refinements are
implemented.
Importantly, the proposed action research process will extend beyond collecting and
interpreting initial evidence. Initial findings will inform the refinement of existing classroom
74
practices, particularly the incorporation of students’ cultural experiences into lesson materials,
connections between students’ experiences and classroom discussions, and meaningful
opportunities for participation and collaboration. Following these refinements, additional
observations, student focus groups, educator interviews, and relevant document reviews will
provide evidence for examining how the changes are implemented and experienced. The
researcher will then compare the initial and follow-up findings, reflect on the evidence, and
identify whether further instructional adjustments may be appropriate. This sequence of
investigation, reflection, action, follow-up examination, and further reflection establishes the
iterative nature of the proposed action research process.
Overall, Chapter 3 provides the methodological foundation for conducting a systematic
and ethically responsible investigation of culturally responsive teaching and student engagement.
By examining instructional practices alongside the perspectives of students and educators, the
study will seek to develop a context-specific understanding of how classroom practices relate to
students’ learning experiences. The following chapter will present the findings derived from the
approved data collection and analysis procedures, with interpretations grounded in the evidence
collected and the distinct dimensions of student engagement.
75
References
Aguayo, D., Herman, K. C., Debnam, K. J., McCree, N., Smith, L. H., & Reinke, W. M. (2024).
Centering students’ voices in the exploration of in-classroom culturally responsive
practices. Journal of School Psychology, 105, Article 101317. https://doi.org/10.1016/
j.jsp.2024.101317
Anyichie, A. C., Butler, D. L., & Nashon, S. M. (2023). Exploring teacher practices for
enhancing student engagement in culturally diverse classrooms. Journal of Pedagogical
Research, 7(5), 183–207. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ1411779
Chang, W. C., & Viesca, K. M. (2022). Preparing teachers for culturally responsive/relevant
pedagogy (CRP): A critical review of research. Teachers College Record, 124(2), 197–
224. https://doi.org/10.1177/01614681221086676
Darling-Hammond, L., Flook, L., Cook-Harvey, C., Barron, B., & Osher, D. (2020). Implications
for educational practice of the science of learning and development. Applied
Developmental Science, 24(2), 97–140. https://doi.org/10.1080/10888691.2018.1537791
Franco, M. P., Bottiani, J. H., Debnam, K. J., Bonifay, W., Pandey, T., Karras, J., & Bradshaw, C.
P. (2024). The CARES classroom observation tool: Psychometrics of an observational
measure of culturally responsive practices. Journal of School Psychology, 107, 101381.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsp.2024.101381
Franco, M. P., Bottiani, J. H., & Bradshaw, C. P. (2024). Assessing teachers’ culturally
responsive classroom practice in PK–12 schools: A systematic review of teacher-,
student-, and observer-report measures. Review of Educational Research, 94(5), 743–798.
https://doi.org/10.3102/00346543231208720
76
Gay, G. (2018). Culturally responsive teaching: Theory, research, and practice (3rd ed.).
Teachers College Press. press. https://doi.org/10.65528/9780807776704
Ladson-Billings, G. (2021b). Culturally relevant pedagogy: Asking a different question. Teachers
College Press. https://doi.org/10.65528/9780807779859
Lavigne, A. L., Henrichs, L., Feliz, J. A. A., & Shao, S. (2022). Cultural responsivity and
common conceptualizations of “good” teaching in culturally and linguistically diverse
elementary classrooms in the US and the Netherlands. Teaching and Teacher Education,
118, 103812. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2022.103812
Lewin, K. (1946). Action research and minority problems. Journal of Social Issues, 2(4), 34–46.
Lincoln, Y. S., & Guba, E. G. (1985). Naturalistic inquiry. SAGE Publications.
Mertler, C. A. (2024). Action research: Improving schools and empowering educators. SAGE.
https://journalhosting.ucalgary.ca/index.php/ajer/article/download/56076/pdf/0
Protection of Human Subjects, 45 C.F.R. pt. 46, subpt. D (2018).
Osher, D., Cantor, P., Berg, J., Steyer, L., & Rose, T. (2020). Drivers of human development:
How relationships and context shape learning and development. Applied Developmental
Science, 24(1), 6–36. https://doi.org/10.1080/10888691.2017.1398650
Sarkar, R., & Kalita, L. (2026). Positivist, interpretive, and constructivist approaches: Research
paradigms. In Innovative Approaches to Social Research Challenges (pp. 71-138). IGI
Global Scientific Publishing. https://doi.org/10.4018/979-8-3373-6410-0.ch004
Stringer, E. T., & Aragón, A. O. (2020). Action research (5th ed.). SAGE Publications.
Vygotsky, L. S. (1978). Mind in society: The development of higher psychological processes.
Harvard University Press.
77
Wang, M. T., & Eccles, J. S. (2013). School context, achievement motivation, and academic
engagement: A longitudinal study of school engagement using a multidimensional
perspective. Learning and Instruction, 28, 12–23. https://doi.org/10.1016/
j.learninstruc.2013.04.002
White, M. G. (2020). Why human subjects research protection is important. Ochsner journal,
20(1), 16-33. https://doi.org/10.31486/toj.20.5012
- CHAPTER 3: DATA COLLECTION PLAN
- Overview
- Research Design
- Site (or Setting)
- Participants
- Researcher Positionality
- Interpretive Framework
- Philosophical Assumptions
- Researcher’s Role
- Procedures
- Permissions
- Recruitment
- Data Collection Plan
- Data Collection Approach #1: Classroom Observations
- Data Collection Approach #2: Semi-Structured Interviews or Focus Groups
- Data Collection Approach #3: Document or Artifact Review
- Data Collection Approach #4: Researcher Reflective Journal
- Data Synthesis
- Data Organization and Preparation
- Coding and Theme Development
- Analysis of Student Engagement and Culturally Responsive Teaching
- Comparison Across Data Sources
- Interpretation and Action Research Reflection
- Trustworthiness
- Credibility
- Transferability
- Dependability
- Confirmability
- Ethical Considerations
- Areas of Concern for Chair Review
- Summary
- References