Discipline Investigation Essay

profilea414041861
6.DIpeerreview.docx

Discipline Investigation peer review Chiu, 2013

Writer ______________________ Reviewer _____________________

Section Criteria

YES

partially

Not yet

Introduction

There is an overview of the field being investigated (what) and the writer’s connection to this discourse community (why)

There is a brief preface to who was interviewed for the assignment

(“name” and specific job title)

The introduction “maps out” the organization of the paper to follow

Comments

________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Background and Career Path

How the informant began his/her “journey” in the career:

· Initial interest and the requirements and skills needed

(“stepping stones” -- education, training, etc.)

· Expectations and any “surprises” or challenges the informant experienced along the way

· Any additional reference to enhance this discussion of the field*

Roles and Responsibilities

What the informant’s detailed job description is:

· Overall qualifications and responsibilities + how the position fits in the overall structure of the company (macro-level)

· What smaller day-to-day tasks and skills are involved

(micro-level)

· What the challenges of the job are and how the informant deals with them

· Other types of jobs/positions related to the profession included?

· Any additional reference to enhance this discussion of the field*

Communications

Includes:

· The types of reading and writing mostly done on-the-job

· The typical audience for written communications

· The most important communication aspects of the job

(especially in regards to writing)

· Any additional reference to enhance this discussion of the field*

Comments

________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

section Criteria

YES

partially

Not yet

Conclusion

Includes:

· A reflection of what was learned through this D.I. – what new insight(s) did the writer gain, and any “surprises” that differed from or added to the initial expectations of the field

· A discussion of what the writer still needs to do in preparation and development for the profession

additional Criteria

YES

partially

Not yet

Organization

· Paper is organized and unified as a whole

Grammar/Syntax/Mechanics

· Sentences flow and errors do not distract reading or compromise meaning

· Wording and word choice is appropriate and accurate

Formatting/Presentation

· Paper is properly formatted according to guidelines

· There are appropriate headings to guide the reader

· Sources cited in-text follow a consistent citation style

(full citations of sources included under “Works Cited” at the end of the report – no separate page needed)

END COMMENTS:

________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

* Two additional sources to supplement information about the discipline/career investigated need to be integrated in the report

(can be included in any sections of the body)