WAQP Week 7 Assignment 2

Rubric Standard | Complete > Does the prospectus contain all the required elements? Refer to the annotated outline to see the required parts of the Dissertation Prospectus document.

Note. Please complete following the directions provided, using the stem sentences, and referring to the examples in the appendix.

Title

Understanding Compassion Fatigue in Law Enforcement First Responders: A Qualitative Study

Supporting Literature

The first step in developing your prospectus is to search the literature related to the general area you want to investigate (see social problem below). In your review of recent, empirical literature, what keywords did you search and in what databases?

The keywords and databases searched included Compassion fatigue, Law enforcement, Police officers, first responders, Secondary traumatic stress, Burnout, Emotional exhaustion, Vicarious trauma, Occupational stress, Trauma exposure, Psychological resilience, Organizational support, Coping strategies, Mental health in policing. The databases include PsycINFO, Criminal Justice Abstracts, SAGE Journals, JSTOR, ProQuest Criminal Justice Database, Scopus, EBSCO Criminal Justice Abstracts, and National Criminal Justice Reference Service (NCJRS).

Provide at least 10 brief summaries of recent, scholarly (peer-reviewed) articles that support/justify a current and relevant problem in your discipline or professional field. Source(s) supporting your framework should be included. Include the complete, APA reference entry, followed by (a) an in-text citation; (b) what was studied; (c) what was found; and (d) why this research is important in relation to your study. This evidence provides the justification for your research problem.

Blumberg, D. M., Papazoglou, K., & Schlosser, M. D. (2020). Organizational solutions to the moral risks of policing. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 17(20), 7461. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph17207461

(a) (Blumberg et al., 2020)

(b) The study examined the moral risks faced by law enforcement professionals, including moral distress, moral injury, ethical exhaustion, compassion fatigue, and lapses in ethical decision-making. The authors propose organizational strategies for police agencies to better address these risks, focusing on prevention efforts in recruitment, training, supervision, and promotion, as well as intervention approaches for affected officers.

(c) The authors found that organizational strategies such as ethical training, peer support, and leadership development can mitigate moral risks and compassion fatigue.

(d) This research is important as it provides potential organizational strategies that could be explored to mitigate compassion fatigue's impact in law enforcement.

Bosma, L. J., & Henning, S. L. (2022). Compassion fatigue among officers. FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin. https://leb.fbi.gov/articles/featured-articles/compassion-fatigue-among-officers

(a) (Bosma & Henning, 2022)

(b) This article reviews the literature on compassion fatigue in law enforcement, focusing on its behavioral outcomes and implications for counseling. The study examines risk factors, symptoms, and treatment measures for compassion fatigue among police officers, highlighting the importance of early intervention, workplace support, and counseling programs. The research emphasizes the need for collaboration between mental health professionals and law enforcement agencies to implement effective strategies for preventing and treating compassion fatigue, ultimately improving officer well-being and job performance.

(c) The study revealed that law enforcement officers suffer from compassion fatigue due to prolonged exposure to traumatic events and emphasized the need for organizational mental health resources.

(d) The research is critical as it highlights the importance of institutional responses to officer wellbeing.

Burnett, M. E., Sheard, I., & St Clair-Thompson, H. (2020). The prevalence of compassion fatigue, compassion satisfaction and perceived stress, and their relationships with mental toughness, individual differences and number of self-care actions in a UK police force. Police Practice and Research, 21(4), 383-400. https://doi.org/10.1080/15614263.2019.1617144

(a) (Burnett et al., 2020)

(b) This study examines compassion fatigue, satisfaction, and stress in UK police, finding 20% experience negative outcomes. It identifies shift work, mental toughness, personality, and self-care as key predictors of well-being, suggesting ways to improve psychological health in law enforcement.

(c) Results showed significant relationships between compassion fatigue, mental toughness, and self-care actions.

(d) This research is relevant as it provides insights into individual factors that may influence compassion fatigue, which could inform exploration of how officers manage this issue.

Carroll, J. J., Mital, S., Wolff, J., Noonan, R. K., Martinez, P., Podolsky, M. C., Green, T. C. (2020). Knowledge, preparedness, and compassion fatigue among law enforcement officers who respond to opioid overdose. Drug and Alcohol Dependence, 217, 108257. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.drugalcdep.2020.108257

(a) (Carroll et al., 2020)

(b) This study examines patrol officers' knowledge of Good Samaritan Laws (GSLs), experiences with overdose (OD) response, and perspectives on opioid OD prevention and response strategies. The research surveyed 2,829 officers, finding that while most knew if their state had a GSL, only 26% correctly understood its limited immunity provisions.

(c) Findings indicated that officers with higher knowledge and preparedness reported lower levels of compassion fatigue.

(d) This research is important as it highlights a specific context (opioid response) where compassion fatigue occurs, which could inform exploration of various experiences of compassion fatigue.

Davies, L. E., Brooks, M., & Braithwaite, E. C. (2023). Compassion fatigue, compassion satisfaction, and burnout, and their associations with anxiety and depression in UK police officers: A mixed method analysis. The Police Journal, 96(3), 509-529. https://doi.org/10.1177/0032258X221106107

(a) (Davies et al., 2023)

(b) This study investigates the relationships between professional quality of life variables (compassion fatigue, compassion satisfaction, and burnout) and mental health outcomes in UK police officers. The research combines a quantitative survey with qualitative interviews to provide a comprehensive understanding of these issues. The authors aim to inform decision-making on strategies to build and maintain psychological wellbeing among police personnel.

(c) Results showed significant associations between these factors, with qualitative data revealing themes of workload, lack of support, and exposure to trauma.

(d) This research is relevant as it uses a mixed-method approach, providing both quantitative and qualitative insights that could inform qualitative study design in this area.

Denk-Florea, C. B., Gancz, B., Gomoiu, A., Ingram, M., Moreton, R., & Pollick, F. (2020). Understanding and supporting law enforcement professionals working with distressing material: Findings from a qualitative study. PLOS ONE, 15(11), e0242808. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0242808

(a) (Denk-Florea et al., 2020)

(b) This study examines the experiences of law enforcement personnel working with distressing materials, particularly child sexual abuse content. The research involved semi-structured interviews with 22 law enforcement professionals in England, UK. The study aims to identify factors impacting officers' resilience and provide recommendations for fostering resilience in organizations where employees are exposed to distressing content.

(c) Findings revealed various coping strategies and the importance of organizational support in managing emotional impact.

(d) This qualitative research is directly relevant to the study of compassion fatigue, providing insights into officers' experiences and coping strategies, as well as organizational response.

Gomes, G. P., Ribeiro, N., & Gomes, D. R. (2022). The impact of burnout on police officers' performance and turnover intention: The moderating role of compassion satisfaction. Administrative Sciences, 12(3), 92. https://doi.org/10.3390/admsci12030092

(a) (Gomes et al., 2022)

(b) This study examines the impact of burnout on performance and turnover intention among Portuguese police officers, while also investigating the moderating role of compassion satisfaction. The study aims to provide insights for better understanding burnout in police officers and offer practical recommendations for addressing this issue in law enforcement organizations.

(c) Results showed that burnout negatively affects performance and increases turnover intention, with compassion satisfaction moderating these relationships.

(d) This research is important as it highlights the interplay between burnout which is related to compassion fatigue and job outcomes, which could inform exploration of organizational impacts.

Grant, H. B., Lavery, C. F., & DeCarlo, J. (2019). An exploratory study of police officers: Low compassion satisfaction and compassion fatigue. Frontiers in Psychology, 9, 2793. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2018.02793

(a) (Grant et al., 2019)

(b) This study investigates compassion fatigue and compassion satisfaction among U.S. urban police officers, addressing a gap in research on these phenomena in law enforcement. The study aims to compare officers' levels of compassion fatigue and satisfaction to the general population and explore the relationships between these factors in the context of policing.

(c) Findings indicated that organizational stressors and exposure to traumatic events contribute to compassion fatigue.

(d) This research provides a foundation for understanding factors contributing to compassion fatigue, which is directly relevant to research questions in this area.

Papazoglou, K., Marans, S., Keesee, T., & Chopko, B. (2020). Police compassion fatigue. FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin, 1-9. https://leb.fbi.gov/articles/featured-articles/police-compassion-fatigue

(a) (Papazoglou et al., 2020)

(b) This article examines compassion fatigue among police officers, its impact on their well-being and job performance, and the importance of compassion satisfaction as a protective factor. The authors discuss the unique challenges officers face when dealing with traumatic incidents and victims, and how prolonged exposure can lead to emotional detachment or numbness. They recommend that law enforcement agencies implement measures to support officers and prevent or mitigate the negative effects of compassion fatigue, while promoting compassion satisfaction to improve officer well-being and community relations.

(c) The authors identified various factors contributing to compassion fatigue and suggested organizational and individual strategies for mitigation.

(d) This research provides a comprehensive overview of compassion fatigue in policing, which can help frame studies and inform potential organizational strategies to explore.

Russo, C., Aukhojee, P., Tuttle, B. M., Johnson, O., Davies, M., Chopko, B. A., & Papazoglou, K. (2020). Compassion fatigue & burnout. In K. Papazoglou (Ed.), Power: Police Officer Wellness, Ethics, and Resilience (pp. 97-115). Academic Press. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-817872-0.00007-0

(a) (Russo et al., 2020)

(b) This chapter examines compassion fatigue and burnout among police officers, exploring their definitions, negative impacts, and relationships with PTSD. The authors discuss the stigma surrounding mental health issues in law enforcement and the maladaptive coping strategies often employed by officers. They highlight the importance of compassion satisfaction and adaptive coping strategies in preventing and reversing the effects of compassion fatigue and burnout, emphasizing the need for holistic approaches to support officers' well-being and job performance.

(c) The authors discussed various factors contributing to these issues and potential interventions.

(d) This research provides theoretical background on compassion fatigue in law enforcement, which can help frame studies and inform interview questions.

Stancel, K., Russo, C., Koskelainen, M., Papazoglou, K., & Tuttle, B. M. (2019). Police moral injury, compassion fatigue, and compassion satisfaction: A brief report. Salus Journal, 7(1), 42-57. https://doaj.org/article/ec5e9e76284b4e529aa65e203b239e70

(a) (Stancel et al., 2019)

(b) This study investigates the relationships between compassion fatigue, moral injury, and compassion satisfaction among Finnish police officers. The researchers surveyed 454 officers from the National Police of Finland to examine how compassion fatigue and moral injury affect officers' compassion satisfaction. The authors provide clinical and practical recommendations to reduce the impact of compassion fatigue and moral injury while enhancing compassion satisfaction in law enforcement.

(c) Findings indicated significant relationships between these constructs, highlighting the complex nature of emotional experiences in policing.

(d) This research is important as it introduces the concept of moral injury in relation to compassion fatigue, which could provide additional depth to the exploration of officers' experiences.

Rubric Standard | Justified > Is evidence presented that this problem is significant to the discipline and/or professional field? The prospectus should provide relevant statistics and evidence, documentable discrepancies, and other scholarly facts that point to the significance and urgency of the problem.

Problem

What was the social problem that prompted you to search the literature to find out more? Write in complete sentences using a scholarly tone.

The situation or issue that prompted me to search the literature is growing concern over the mental health and well-being of law enforcement first responders in dealing with traumatic incidents. The potential impact of compassion fatigue on officer performance necessitates a deeper understanding of this phenomenon.

Now that you have read and summarized some of the recent literature to understand your problem, and given what other researchers are exploring, what meaningful gap have you identified that your study will address? (What have others not yet explored about this problem that you will contribute with your study?)

Although researchers have investigated this issue, the topic has not been explored in this way: While quantitative studies have established the prevalence and correlates of compassion fatigue in law enforcement, there is limited in-depth qualitative research examining officers' personal experiences with compassion fatigue and its perceived impact on job performance. This gap in the literature limits the understanding of how to effectively address compassion fatigue at both individual and organizational levels (Burnett et al., 2020; Davies et al., 2023).

References

Burnett, M. E., Sheard, I., & St Clair-Thompson, H. (2020). The prevalence of compassion fatigue, compassion satisfaction and perceived stress, and their relationships with mental toughness, individual differences and number of self-care actions in a UK police force. Police Practice and Research, 21(4), 383-400. https://doi.org/10.1080/15614263.2019.1617144

Davies, L. E., Brooks, M., & Braithwaite, E. C. (2023). Compassion fatigue, compassion satisfaction, and burnout, and their associations with anxiety and depression in UK police officers: A mixed method analysis. The Police Journal, 96(3), 509-529. https://doi.org/10.1177/0032258X221106107

Based on all of the above information (social problem, literature review, gap), in one sentence, what is your research problem ?

The specific research problem that will be addressed through this study is the limited understanding of law enforcement first responders' lived experiences with compassion fatigue and its perceived effects on their job performance.

Rubric Standard | Meaningful > Has a meaningful problem and gap in the research literature been identified? In other words, is addressing this problem the logical next step, given the previous exploratory and confirmatory research (or lack thereof) on this topic? It is not acceptable to simply replicate previous research for a Ph.D. degree.

Rubric Standard | Original > Does this project have potential to make an original contribution? The problem must be an authentic "puzzle" that needs solving, not merely a topic that the researcher finds interesting. Addressing the problem should result in an original contribution to the field or discipline.

Purpose

To address your stated research problem, what is the purpose of your study? Will you describe, compare, explore, examine, etc.? Complete the purpose sentence below and be sure to clarify your variables/concepts of interest.

The purpose of this Qualitative study is to explore the lived experiences of law enforcement first responders regarding compassion fatigue and their perception of its impact on their job performance. This study aims to investigate two primary concepts: (1) the manifestation of compassion fatigue in law enforcement officers' professional and personal lives and (2) the perceived impact on their job performance.

Framework (Conceptual or Theoretical)

What theory(ies) and/or concept(s) support (frame) your study and who are the original authors? Provide an in-text citation with your response, and the complete APA reference entry with summary in the Supporting Literature section.

The theories and/or concepts that ground this study include the Compassion Fatigue Resilience Model (CFRM) developed by Figley and Figley (2017), which provides a comprehensive framework for understanding the development, progression, and mitigation of compassion fatigue in helping professionals, including law enforcement officers. The CFRM consists of eight interconnected components: exposure to suffering, empathic ability, empathic concern, empathic response, residual compassion stress, traumatic memories, other life demands, and compassion fatigue resilience. These components collectively address the degree of contact with traumatized individuals, the helper's capacity to recognize and respond to others' pain, the stress resulting from such exposure, the impact of traumatic memories, external stressors, and the ability to cope with the challenges of helping without succumbing to compassion fatigue (Figley & Figley, 2017)

How do these theories and/or concepts relate to your research problem, purpose, and the nature of your study?

The logical connections between the framework presented and the nature of my study include the following:

Rubric Standard | Grounded > Is the problem framed to enable the researcher to either build upon or counter the previously published findings on the topic? For most fields, grounding involves articulating the problem within the context of a theoretical base or conceptual framework. Although many approaches can ground a study in the scientific literature, the essential requirement is that the problem is framed such that the new findings will have implications for the previous findings.

Research Question(s) and Hypotheses (if applicable)

List the question(s) that you plan to use to address the research problem. Your question(s) must align with your study purpose and include the variables and/or concepts and how they will be examined.

1. What is the lived experience of compassion fatigue among law enforcement first responders?

2. What is the essence of how compassion fatigue manifests in the lived experience of law enforcement officers' daily work?

3. How do law enforcement officers deal with compassion fatigue?

Nature of the Study

What systematic approach/method and research design do you plan to use to address your research question(s)?

To address the research questions in this Qualitative study, the specific research design will include a phenomenological approach.

Reference entry for the work on which this research design is based:

Johnson, A. (2023). The lived experiences of 911 dispatchers with compassion fatigue: An interpretive phenomenology [Doctoral dissertation, Old Dominion University]. ProQuest Dissertations & Theses Global. https://doi.org/10.25777/5m83-pm64

For your planned research design, what type of data will you need and what data collection instruments will provide it?

For my planned research design, I will need qualitative data in the form of detailed narratives and personal accounts from law enforcement officers about their experiences with compassion fatigue and its perceived impact on their job performance. The data collection instruments include semi-structured interviews and focus groups.

What data sources and analysis do you plan to use to answer your research question(s)?

The primary data source will be active-duty law enforcement officers from various agencies, backgrounds, and experience levels. This will include both male and female officers, as well as individuals from diverse racial and ethnic groups to ensure a comprehensive representation of experiences. Participants will be selected using purposive sampling to ensure they have experienced the phenomenon of compassion fatigue and can provide rich, relevant information. The analysis will entail various steps including transcription, phenomenological analysis, coding, peer review, and member checking.

What limitations, challenges, and/or barriers might you need to address while conducting this study (e.g., access to participants, access to data, requirements for storing data, separation of roles or other ethical considerations, instrumentation fees, etc.)?

1. Access to participants: Obtaining permission from law enforcement agencies to interview their officers may be challenging due to the sensitive nature of the topic and potential concerns about organizational reputation.

2. Participant willingness: Officers may be hesitant to discuss personal experiences related to compassion fatigue due to stigma, fear of professional consequences, or concerns about appearing vulnerable.

3. Confidentiality and data storage: Ensuring the privacy and confidentiality of participants' responses will be crucial. This will require secure data storage methods, including encrypted digital files and locked physical storage for any paper documents. Anonymization procedures will be necessary to protect participants' identities.

4. Ethical considerations: The study will need to address potential psychological risks to participants when discussing potentially traumatic experiences. This may require having mental health resources available for participants if needed.

5. Time constraints: Coordinating interviews and focus groups with officers who often work irregular shifts may present scheduling challenges, potentially extending the data collection phase.

6. Potential for data saturation issues: If the experiences shared are too similar, it may be challenging to reach true data saturation, potentially limiting the depth of insights.

7. Resource limitations: Conducting in-depth interviews and focus groups, along with their subsequent transcription and analysis, can be time-consuming and potentially costly.

Rubric Standard | Feasible > Can a systematic method of inquiry be used to address the problem; and does the approach have the potential to address the problem while considering potential risks and burdens placed on research participants? The tentative methodology demonstrates that the researcher has considered the options for inquiry and has selected an approach that has potential to address the problem.

Significance

How will your study address the meaningful, discipline-specific issue that you identified and therefore contribute to your field, discipline, professional practice, etc. contributing to positive social change?

This study is significant in that it will contribute to understanding the lived experiences of law enforcement first responders dealing with compassion fatigue, which can inform both individual and organizational interventions. By exploring officers' personal narratives and coping strategies, the findings can help develop more effective support systems and training programs to mitigate the impact of compassion fatigue. This research has practical implications for law enforcement agencies seeking to improve officer wellbeing and job performance while reducing turnover and burnout. The study can drive positive social change by promoting better mental health support for law enforcement professionals, which in turn may lead to improved police-community relations. When officers are better equipped to manage compassion fatigue, they are more likely to maintain empathy and professional effectiveness in their interactions with the public. Additionally, insights from this research could inform policy changes regarding mental health resources and organizational support systems in law enforcement agencies.

Rubric Standard | Impact > Does this project have potential to affect positive social change? As described in the Significance section, the anticipated findings have potential to support the mission of Walden University to promote positive social change.

Rubric Standard | Objective > Is the topic approached in an objective manner? The framing of the problem should not reveal bias or present a foregone conclusion. Even if the researcher has a strong opinion on the expected findings, the researcher must maximize scholarly objectivity by framing the problem in the context of a systematic inquiry that permits multiple possible conclusions.

Partner Site Masking Self-Check

Walden capstones typically mask the identity of the partner organization. The methodological and ethical reasons for this practice as well as criteria for exceptions are outlined here (link to posted guidance).

☒ Check here to confirm that you will mask the identity of the organization in the final capstone that you publish in ProQuest.

☐ If you perceive that your partner organization’s identity would be impossible to mask or if there is a strong rationale for naming the organization in your capstone, please check this box so that your Program Director can review your request for an exception. If granted, that exception must be confirmed by the IRB during the ethics review process. The IRB will also ensure that your consent form(s) and/or site agreement(s) permit naming the organization.