Success Letter for ICS 392 (Executive Coaching - Leadership in a VUCA (Volatile, Uncertain, Chaotic & Ambiguous Business Environment)
David Drehmer, PhD, ACC, FAAETS, FIOCPA, CSP
Copyright © 2018 by David E. Drehmer, PhD All Rights Reserved
The challenges of leading in a VUCA (volatile, uncertain,
chaotic & ambiguous) business environment
Powerpoint Day 2 EXECUTIVE COACHING: LEADERSHIP in a VUCA (Volatile, Uncertain, Chaotic & Ambiguous) BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT.
Name __________________________________________________________ If this workbook is found, please return it to the Management Department, DePaul University, Room 7000, One East Jackson Boulevard, Chicago, IL 60604 so that it may be returned to its owner.
Day 2 1/3/2018
1
David Drehmer, PhD, ACC, FAAETS, FIOCPA, CSP Associate Professor of Management & Entrepreneurship, DePaul University Executive Director (emeritus), Performance Enhancement Institute, PC Licensed Clinical Psychologist, Consulting Organizational Psychologist Senior Scientist, Neuroscience Institute Clinical Director (emeritus) & Co‐Founder, Center for Traumatic Stress Founding Fellow, Harvard Institute of Coaching, Harvard Medical School Fellow, Center for Creativity and Innovation, DePaul University Mentor Coach, International Coach Federation Harvard Business Review, Advisory Council
Coaching: Leadership in a VUCA Business Environment
Positive Psychology
David E. Drehmer, PhD
Positive Psychology Scientific Study of Human Flourishing
aka: The Science of Happiness
+
Don’t forget to turn your cell phone on after the presentation
Some people create happiness wherever they go
Some cause happiness whenever they go.
Day 2 1/3/2018
2
Why Science?
It works in practice, but
Will it work in theory?
Happy People Make More Money
Diener, Nickerson,
Lucas, & Sandvik (2002)
College Entry Cheerfulness and Income 19 Years Later
Happy People Live Longer The Nun Study
Most cheerful +7 Years
Most +ive emotion words +9.5 Years
Most variety of +ive words +10.5 Years
Danner, Snowdon, & Friesen, 2001.
Happy People Live Longer
Not Smoking: +12 Years
Being Happy: +10.5 Years
So if you must smoke…
You better enjoy
it!
(S)he who laughs . . . lasts
Day 2 1/3/2018
3
What problem do you want to work on?
We are having a problem!
What’s your chief complaint?
Psychological Research (1967‐2000)
Negative • Anger: 5584 • Anxiety: 41,416
• Depression: 54,040
Positive • Joy: 415 • Happiness 1,710
• Life Satisfaction 2582
Ratio: 1 / 21
Growth “Human systems grow in the direction of what they persistently ask questions about.”
Cooperrider and Whitney
Focus on weaknesses Focus on strengths Overcoming deficiencies Building competencies Avoiding pain Seeking pleasure Running from unhappiness Pursuing happiness Neutral state (0) as ceiling No ceiling Tensionless as ideal Creative tension as ideal
Disease Model Health Model
neurosis, anger, anxiety, wellbeing, satisfaction, joy depression, psychosis excitement, happiness
Happiness isn’t the Negation of Unhappiness
-_______________________ 0 ____________________ +
Day 2 1/3/2018
4
• Positive psychological approach (1980s-) – “What makes some individuals
succeed despite unfavorable circumstances?”
• Traditional psychology (Post-WWII) – “Why do these individuals fail?”
The Power of Positive Psychology: Studying At-Risk Population
Water the flowers, not the weeds.
Three Kinds of Happiness
• Pleasure • Engagement • Purpose, Intention,
Meaning
Coca Cola
Hardiness and Stress (engagement)
Flow
Day 2 1/3/2018
5
Engagement & Flow
Purpose & Intention
Southwest Airlines Purpose
Life Balance
Why Science?
But what works?
And how do we
know?
Uncommon Sense Telling kids they are smart?
Day 2 1/3/2018
6
Effort not Ability
Jeffrey Immelt
Ed Deiner
age gender education social class income having children ethnicity intelligence physical attractiveness
Correlations with happiness and life satisfaction (zero and small)
Correlations with happiness and life satisfaction
(moderate) number of friends being married religiousness level of leisure activity physical health conscientiousness extroversion neuroticism (negative) internal locus of control
Correlations with happiness and life satisfaction
(large) gratitude optimism being employed frequency of sexual intercourse percent of time experiencing positive affect test retest reliability of happiness measure happiness of identical twins self‐esteem
Correlations in medical studies
Aspirin and reduced risk of death by heart attack: r = 0.03
Chemotherapy and survival with breast cancer: r = 0.03
Smoking and lung cancer: r = 0.08
Anti‐histamine use and reduced nasal congestion: r = 0.11
College grades and job performance: r = 0.16
Day 2 1/3/2018
7
Interventions to Increase Happiness
Gratitude Visit
Savoring 3 Good Things
You at Your Best
Signature Strengths
Seligman, Steen, Park, & Peterson (2005)
Gratitude
Three Good Things
Signature Strengths
The Evidence‐ I
The Evidence‐ II
Day 2 1/3/2018
8
Four Ways to Savor • Basking – receptive to praise and
congratulations
• Luxuriating – engaging the senses fully
• Thanksgiving – experiencing and engaging gratitude
• Marveling – losing self in the wonder of the experience
Bryant & Verhoff (2007)
Two StrategiesTwo Strategies
Bowling Study Students in college PE class Randomly assigned to 2 groups 1. Coaching Style: What you did wrong
2. Coaching Style: What you did right
Results – 11 pin difference
Avoid what you did wrong
Think about what you did right
Elliot & McGregor (2001)
Approach Goals
• I will be on time for class
• I want to finish my assignments on time
• I want to be more assertive
Avoidance Goals
• I will not be late for class
• I want to stop procrastinating
• I want to stop being so shy
Approach Oriented Students
Higher exam scores with less test stress
More class engagement
Fewer visits to the student health center
Day 2 1/3/2018
9
The Power (and Peril) of Positive Thinking
Imagine Succeeding Easily Imagine Overcoming Obstacles
Search for High Paying Jobs after College
Also: Weight Loss Lasting Romantic Relationships Recovery from Hip Replacement Surgery
Success = Imagine Confidence + Imagine Overcoming Tough Time
Gabriele Oettingen (2000, 2009)
Moving Forward
Halverson (2011)
Be good ‐ performance Proving yourself ‐ validation Drives performance and perfection Failure seen as permanent, pervasive, personal Ability determines success or failure Its about the destination
Get better ‐ mastery Improving yourself ‐ growth Experience fuels improvement and excellence Effort determines success or failure Appreciate and enjoy the journey Buffers depression and anxiety Learning promotes happiness and achievement
Inch Pebbles are as Important as Milestones
. . .But you can’t cross a chasm in two short leaps.
Conquer Goal Saboteurs
It’s about execution Seize the moment Know what to do Put your shields up Know how you are doing
What You Can Do
Halverson (2011)
Day 2 1/3/2018
10
It’s about execution
Most of the time, we know what needs to be done to reach a goal. We just don’t manage to actually do it. Focusing on execution is essential for success
Halverson (2011)
Seize the moment
Given how busy most of us are, and how many goals we are pursuing at once, it’s not surprising that we routinely miss opportunities to act on a goal because we simply fail to notice them. Achieving your goal means grabbing hold of these opportunities before they slip through your fingers.
Halverson (2011)
Know what to do
Once you’ve seized the moment, you’ve got to figure out exactly what you’re going to do with it. When you can’t act swiftly, you risk wasting the opportunity.
Halverson (2011)
Put your shields up
Goals require protection. Distractions, temptations, and competing goals can steal your attention and your energy, and sap your motivation.
Halverson (2011)
Know how you are doing
Achieving a goal also requires careful monitoring. If you don’t know how well you are doing, you can’t adjust your behavior or your strategies accordingly. Check your progress frequently.
Halverson (2011)
Many of life’s failures are people who did not realize how close they were to success when they gave up.
Downside of Performance Goals
Thomas A. Edison
Day 2 1/3/2018
11
Noah Principle
One survives, not by predicting rain, but by building arks.
Science: A Deeper Understanding
It works in practice, but will it work in theory?
Solution Focused Coaching
Find five beige things
Human Flourishing in a Nutshell:
For someone to flourish, it is not enough to fix what’s wrong.
You also need to focus on what’s right!
Miracle Question
Suppose a miracle happens tonight. The problem that brings you here has been solved (to a significant extent), but you are unaware of it because you are asleep. What will be the first thing that you notice tomorrow morning that tells you the miracle has taken place? What else?
Day 2 1/3/2018
12
Basic Solution‐Focused Questions
What are your best hopes? What difference would that make? What is already working in the right direction? What would be the next sign of progress? What would the next step be?
Bannink (2006)
All Coaches: Activity: get your clients to rewrite all their avoidance goals as approach goals.
Corporate Coaches: Ask “What does your organization do well?” rather than “What’s your biggest problem?”
Personal Coaches: Ask “What 3 good things happened since our last coaching session?”
Marcus Buckingham
Go Put Your Strengths To Work
Sir Ken Robinson
Finding Your Passion
Loved it, Loathed, It I Loved It … • I felt strong when …
I Loathed it … • I felt weak (drained, bored) when …
Signs of a Strength
Source: Marcus Buckingham, Go Put Your Strengths to Work
Day 2 1/3/2018
13
VIA Strengths: History
DSM / ICD Classification of
Dis-Ease
Un-DSM Classification of
Ease
Why focus on strengths?
24 VIA Strengths • Creativity • Curiosity • Judgment & Open‐
Mindedness • Love of Learning • Perspective • Bravery • Perseverance • Honesty • Zest • Capacity to Love and Be
Loved • Kindness • Social Intelligence
• Teamwork • Fairness • Leadership • Forgiveness & Mercy • Modesty & Humility • Prudence • Self‐Regulation • Appreciation of Beauty
and Excellence • Gratitude • Hope & Optimism • Humor • Religiousness &
Spirituality
How Low Can You Go?
Strength Spotting in Conversations
Verbal Clues
• Increased clarity in speech • Quicker speech • Stronger voice • Larger vocabulary • More direct—to the point • Speaking to several related
points in the story • Creative word choice
Strength Spotting in Conversations
Non‐Verbal Clues
• Energy • Improved posture • Good eye contact • Eyes light up • More hand gestures • Smiling / laughing more • Positive emotions – excitement, joy, hope
Day 2 1/3/2018
14
Key Assessment Questions
• What are your signature strengths? (Character)
• What do you have a natural ability for? (Talents)
• What are you good at? (Skills)
• What do you like to do? (Interests)
• What do you hope for your future? (Dreams)
• What principles do you hold most dear? (Values)
What the Research Says Most Associated with Wellbeing
Hope Curiosity
Gratitude Zest
Capacity to Love and Be Loved
What the Research Says What about workplace satisfaction?
Of 24 VIA strengths, only TWO are positively correlated with workplace satisfaction!
Zest Hope &
Optimism
“Don’t ask what the world needs. Ask what makes you come alive. Because what the world needs are people who have come alive.”
Harold Whitman
Using Your Strengths
“The task of leadership is to create an alignment of strengths, making a system’s weaknesses irrelevant.”
But my clients want to work on their weaknesses!
Peter Drucker Professor Emeritus, Harvard University
Carol Kaufmann
Day 2 1/3/2018
15
Bridge Building
Bridge Building / Elevator
Identify and practice how we translate our selves to others.
Feature • Here is my strength of ____________
Benefit • And here is what’s in it for you: _______
Exercise
Speaker’s experience and Observer’s experience. One reflection / suggestion from each person at the table.
Coach to your client’s strengths!
• Ask clients to do the VIA survey: www.viame.org
• Practice using signature strengths in a different way each week
• Focus on the “top 5” for well‐ being
• Career coaches: focus on the “top 2” for workplace satisfaction
Character Strengths Alignment Top 5 Strengths Top 5 Work Tasks Alignment
Harzer & Ruch (2016); Littman‐Ovadia & Niemiec (2017)
Affirm Them Spotlight their: – Abilities – Strengths – Efforts – Values – Intentions
Recognition vs. Praise Military Families Network July 19, 2016 By David Christian, Ph.D.
Affirmations • Your commitment really shows by…
• You showed a lot of [strength, courage, determination] by doing that.
• It’s clear that you’re really trying to change your…
• By the way you handled that situation, you showed a lot of [strength, courage, determination].
Day 2 1/3/2018
16
Strengths & AffirmationsStrengths & Affirmations Example: Student continues to miss class and not complete assignments. •Strength: Determination to make his own decisions. •Expression? Resists changing behavior when professor tells him that he must change his school habits or face losing scholarship, flunking out and not graduating. •Helps how? Allows him to maintain some control in a situation that may feel out of control. Provides a sense of integrity. Consistent with values. •Affirmation? You’re not somebody who does something just because somebody says you must. You have to decide if it is right for you, and sometimes this means standing against some pretty formidable pressure.
Affirmations I I know my assignment is late but I have to study for the GREs. Mom died and Dad lost his job. I have to work! There is nothing I can do to pass. It’s hopeless and I’m helpless. I’m going to keep trying for as long as it takes – one day at a time. I have been abstinent all week, but the cravings were REALLY bad! I don’t have a problem with grades – I can study anytime I want.
Affirmations II I feel alone, no one will help me. I’m not smart enough. It comes so easily for others. I resent that my girlfriend gets to go out and party while I have to stay home and study. I don’t need to do bullshit participation in class when there is better stuff on Youtube. I am very disappointed with this class and your attitude. Your lack patriotism, and your support for burning the American flag is disgraceful. It blows my mind how a professor of a prestigious university could behave like that. Frankly, I’m not interested in being told that I should support Islamic terrorists, rapist drug dealing Mexicans and Obamacare.
Phone‐a Friend
What five words describe me when I am at my very best?
Ask this Question?
Marcial Losada
Observed business strategy teams • Counted positive and negative statements
• Counted inquiry and advocacy statements
• Counted self and other statements
Day 2 1/3/2018
17
Inquiry – Advocacy Examples
Inquiry
• How could we improve on these numbers?
• Can you expand on that?
• Tell me more…
Advocacy
• Let’s take this approach…
• I don’t think that’s a good idea
• Can’t we just try out my suggestion?
Positive – Negative Examples
Positive • That’s a great idea!
• Congratulations on that big accomplishment
• Here’s what our customers said they like about our new product…
• We rock!
Negative • You don’t know what
you’re talking about
• Our competition is killing us
• That’s a great idea…
Self – Other Examples
Other
• What do our customers think about this?
• Our competition is killing us
• The new regulations are going to have a huge effect on our industry
Self
• The coffee in the snack room sucks
• That should be the responsibility of our marketing department
• Why can’t I get my own parking space?
60 Teams Later
Inquiry/Advocacy Positive/Negative Other/Self
Strengths, Again
Hope Zest Curiosity Gratitude Love
Positivity Inquiry Other Focus
Increase your team’s inquiry / advocacy ratio!
• Practice Active Constructive Responding
• Managers: Ask, Ask, Ask
• Other “active listening” exercises – use your coach training skills
Day 2 1/3/2018
18
Why Positive Emotions?
Negative emotions restrict options, e.g. “fight or flight”
Positive emotions promote growth, creativity, and exploration
Barb Frederickson “Broaden and Build” theory
Workaholism
Running Hitting the Wall v. Runner’s High
Inside the Brain The Limbic System
Thalamus Amygdala Hippocampus Cingulate Gyrus Hypothalamus Pituitary
Emotional Processing
Information and Stress
Day 2 1/3/2018
19
The “Old Story”
Deliberate Effort
Positive Outcome
Positive Emotions
Broaden and Build Theory Positive Emotions
Increased Psychological Resources Creativity Optimism
Resilience Increased Outcomes
Increased Efforts
Attention to Periphery Control Participant: 15.5% Peripheral Fixation
Positive Emotion Participant: 75.5% Peripheral Fixation
Wadlinger & Isaacowitz (2006). Motivation and Emotion, 30, 87-89.
Green Red Blue Orange Purple
Green Red Blue
Orange Purple
Name the Ink Color
Kraft & Pressman, 2012
Has hopes and aspirations Is trying to avoid suffering Is striving for happiness & fulfillment Has experienced pain & disappointment Wants to feel respected and valued Desires to live in peace and safety May (s)he live life with ease
Just like me, this person . . . Compassion
Repeat for intimate friend, close friend, acquaintance, stranger, enemy
Lifeline in Smile not Palm
Abel, E. L., & Kruger, M. L. (2010). Smile intensity in photographs predicts longevity. Psychological Science, 21, 542-544.
Day 2 1/3/2018
20
Measuring Smiles
Increase Your Face Value
Notice your Reaction?
Ron Gutman
Smile
Happy Marriages
Couples Lab
5 : 1 (P:N) Ratio John & Julie Gottman
University of Washington
Positivity Ratio Positive Emotion
Negative Emotion = 3:1 5:1
(Individuals) (teams)
How can you increase this ratio in your life?
Teams: How can you improve your positivity ratio?
www.positivityratio.com
Day 2 1/3/2018
21
Example Use my favorite body lotion in the morning, take time for lunch, take a 15 minute coffee break with my husband, take a 15 minute walk with the dog, listen to my favorite song on youtube and dance in my office, meditate…
Stop watching the depressing Oprahs, stop watching the news, stop getting upset about traffic, wake up 20 minutes earlier to avoid fights with the children…
-N
+P
Gottman: Bids and Turns
Toward
Against
Away
Currency of the Emotional Bank Account
Name These Fruits
Prevent Truth Decay
Use Mental Floss
Learned Optimism Martin Seligman (2006)
“We have found over the years that positive statements you make to yourself have little if any effect. What is crucial is what you think when you fail, using the power of nonnegative thinking. Changing the destructive things you say to yourself when you experience the setbacks that life deals all of us is the central skill of optimism.”
Learned Optimism Explanatory Style
We are more optimistic when we can see the bad things that happen to us as…
1. Temporary vs. Permanent 2. Specific vs. Pervasive 3. Not Personal vs. Personal
Day 2 1/3/2018
22
Adversity Belief or negative Self- Talk
Consequence Disputation
This is the bad event that occurs.
Automatic Negative Thoughts or beliefs about yourself when the bad event occurs.
How do you feel as a result?
Dispute the belief with a more realistic response.
During my interview I think I gave a very stupid answer to an important question.
“I’m such an idiot!” (permanent) “They’ll never hire me now” (permanent) “I’m so bad at interviews” (pervasive)
I feel embarrassed, like I’m going to fail. What’s the point of sending a thank you note, they won’t hire me anyway. I don’t want to go on any more interviews!
I know I didn’t give the best answer I could have, but I’m not an idiot. I just gave a bad answer that time (temporary). I don’t actually know if they won’t hire me;
That is just me mind-reading and fortune telling. I did well on my other interviews so I’ll do better next time (specific).
Two Wolves
Increase your team’s positivity!
• Measure positivity ratios: www.positivityratio.com
• Measure Optimism scores: www.authentichappiness.org
• Team activity: Brainstorm ways to increase positivity and decrease negativity in the team
• Individual activity: Thought disputation and reframing (DML, ABCD, etc.)
Appreciative Inquiry DISCOVERY Appreciating
“The Best of What Is”
DESTINY Sustaining
“What Will Be”
DREAM Envisioning
“What Could Be”
DESIGN Co-Constructing
“What Should Be”
Positive Topic
Increase your team’s other / self ratio!
• Corporate volunteering programs
• Meet your customers / suppliers / other stakeholders
• Appreciative Inquiry: www.appreciativeinquiry.case.edu
Exercise Pick a TV show Count events and calculate ratios
• Positive / Negative • Inquiry / Advocacy • Other / Self
Day 2 1/3/2018
23
Love, Support, Nurturance
Social Support Who do I turn to . . .
For close friendship To share problems with To play with For expert advice To energize me When I am hurting For acceptance and approval To help me discover and try new things For professional contacts As teachers, mentors, helpers For good social times When I want to be with someone who knows me well
Winners
Reframe
Up until now
Success Charts First Third
Middle Third
Recent Third
Future
Day 2 1/3/2018
24
Imagine . . .
FEAR Fantasized Evidence Appearing Real
…but what if we could FLY?
Stress and the Common Cold
Sheldon Cohen, Carnegie‐Mellon
Who gets sick? How sick to they get?
Mind‐Body Pioneers
Jon Kabat‐Zinn, PhD Mindfulness Stress Reduction
Lydia Temoshok, PhD Type‐C Personality Style Price of Being Nice
Herbert Benson, MD The Relaxation Response
Winnie‐the‐Pooh on Success
• Select a Dream • Use your dreams to set a Goal • Create a Plan • Consider Resources • Enhance Skills and Abilities • Spend time Wisely • Start! Get Organized and Go
Allen & Allen, 1997
Day 2 1/3/2018
25