worksheet 6

12/18/2014 Ha-Joon Chang: Protectionism... the truth is on a $10 bill - Business Comment - Business - The Independent

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/comment/hajoon-chang-protectionism-the-truth-is-on-a-10-bill-458396.html 1/6

THE INDEPENDENT THURSDAY 18 DECEMBER 2014 Sign in RegisterApps eBooks i Jobs Dating Shop

News  >  Business  >  Business Comment DONATE

NOW

READ ABOUT OUR APPEAL

Advanced search Article archive Topics

Search The Independent

NEWS VIDEO PEOPLE VOICES SPORT TECH LIFE PROPERTY ARTS + ENTS TRAVEL MONEY INDYBEST STUDENT OFFERS

UK World Business P eople Science Env ironment Media Technology Education Images O bituaries Diary Corrections New sletter Appeals

PRINT A A A

I have a six-year-old son. His name is Jin-Gyu. He lives off me, yet he is quite capable of making a living. After all, millions of children of his age already have jobs in poor countries.

Jin-Gyu needs to be exposed to competition if he is to become a more productive person. Thinking about it, the more competition he is exposed to and the sooner this is done, the better it is for his future development. I should make him quit school and get a job.

I can hear you say I must be mad. Myopic. Cruel. If I drive Jin- Gyu into the labour market now, you point out, he may become a savvy shoeshine boy or a prosperous street hawker, but he will never become a brain surgeon or a nuclear physicist. You argue that, even from a purely materialistic viewpoint, I would be wiser to invest in his education and share the returns later than gloat over the money I save by not sending him to school.

Yet this absurd line of argument is in essence how free-trade economists justify rapid, large-scale trade liberalisation in developing countries. They claim that developing country producers need to be exposed to maximum competition, so that they have maximum incentive to raise productivity. The earlier the exposure, the argument goes, the better it is for economic development.

However, just as children need to be nurtured before they can compete in high-productivity jobs, industries in developing countries should be sheltered from superior foreign producers before they "grow up". They need to be given protection, subsidies, and other help while they master advanced technologies and build effective organisations.

This argument is known as the infant industry argument. What is little known is that it was first theorised by none other than the first finance minister (treasury secretary) of the United States - Alexander Hamilton, whose portrait adorns the $10 bill.

Ha-Joon Chang: Protectionism... the truth is on a $10 bill

   Monday 23 July 2007

Shares: 116

Talk to the animals at London Zoo: Bid in our charity auction

Sony hack: Jolie branded 'seriously out of her mind' in further email leak

Natalie Portman blames Star Wars prequels for almost ruining her career

'Everyone thought I was a horrible actress'

When will the majority of

1 China: The world's biggest prison for journalists

2 Transport for London believes this "new device" will save Christmas

3 Even for Bill O'Reilly, this is bad

4 Will we ever get to watch The Interview? Should we care?

5 Why men shouldn't be in charge of tampon adverts

CHARITY APPEAL

PEOPLE

FILM

VOICES

12/18/2014 Ha-Joon Chang: Protectionism... the truth is on a $10 bill - Business Comment - Business - The Independent

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/comment/hajoon-chang-protectionism-the-truth-is-on-a-10-bill-458396.html 2/6

Most Shared Most Viewed Most Commented

Nigel Farage: Me vs Russell Brand on Question Time – he's got the chest hair but where are his ideas?

Harry Potter fans can apply to the Hogwarts-inspired College of Wizardry

Jessica Chambers: 19-year-old woman 'doused with lighter fluid and burned alive' in the US

Russell Brand calls Nigel Farage 'poundshop Enoch Powell' in BBC Question Time debate

Orange Wednesdays are no more

Initially few Americans were convinced by Hamilton's argument. After all, Adam Smith, the father of economics, had already advised Americans against artificially developing manufacturing industries. However, over time people saw sense in Hamilton's argument, and the US shifted to protectionism after the Anglo- American War of 1812. By the 1830s, its industrial tariff rate, at 40-50 per cent, was the highest in the world, and remained so until the Second World War.

The US may have invented the theory of infant industry protection, but the practice had existed long before. The first big success story was, surprisingly, Britain - the supposed birthplace of free trade. In fact, Hamilton's programme was in many ways a copy of Robert Walpole's enormously successful 1721 industrial development programme, based on high (among world's highest) tariffs and subsidies, which had propelled Britain into its economic supremacy.

Britain and the US may have been the most ardent - and most successful - users of tariffs, but most of today's rich countries deployed tariff protection for extended periods in order to promote their infant industries. Many of them also actively used government subsidies and public enterprises to promote new industries. Japan and many European countries have given numerous subsidies to strategic industries. The US has publicly financed the highest share of research and development in the world. Singapore, despite its free-market image, has one of the largest public enterprise sectors in the world, producing around 30 per cent of the national income. Public enterprises were also crucial in France, Finland, Austria, Norway, and Taiwan.

When they needed to protect their nascent producers, most of today's rich countries restricted foreign investment. In the 19th century, the US strictly regulated foreign investment in banking, shipping, mining, and logging. Japan and Korea severely restricted foreign investment in manufacturing. Between the 1930s and the 1980s, Finland officially classified all firms with more than 20 per cent foreign ownership as "dangerous enterprises".

While (exceptionally) practising free trade, the Netherlands and Switzerland refused to protect patents until the early 20th century. In the 19th century, most countries, including Britain, France, and the US, explicitly allowed patenting of imported inventions. The US refused to protect foreigners' copyrights until 1891. Germany mass-produced counterfeit "made in England" goods in the 19th century.

Despite this history, since the 1980s the "Bad Samaritan" rich countries have imposed upon developing countries policies that are almost the exact opposite of what they used in the past. But these countries condemning tariffs, subsidies, public enterprises, regulation of foreign investment, and permissive intellectual property rights is like them "kicking away the ladder" with which they climbed to the top - often against the advice of the then richer countries.

Pakistanis stand up to those who think it is OK to kill 130 children?

Michelle Dockery: Golden Girl

Best known for playing Lady Mary in ITV’s Downton Abbey, Essex- born actor Michelle Dockery is a woman of many talents.

Recommended by

Rescuers communicate with 12 trapped miners (Promoted ­ Independent ­ Video)

NATO joins search for Russian submarine off Scottish coast

HMS Defender returns

Struggling Dortmund and Wolfsburg share points

SPONSORED

PROMOTED VIDEO

12/18/2014 Ha-Joon Chang: Protectionism... the truth is on a $10 bill - Business Comment - Business - The Independent

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/comment/hajoon-chang-protectionism-the-truth-is-on-a-10-bill-458396.html 3/6

PROMOTED STORIES

Recommended by

INDEPENDENT IMAGES

But, the reader may wonder, didn't the developing countries already try protectionism and miserably fail? That is a common myth, but the truth of the matter is that these countries have grown significantly more slowly in the "brave new world" of neo- liberal policies, compared with the "bad old days" of protectionism and regulation in the 1960s and the 1970s (see table). And that's despite the dramatic growth acceleration in the two giants, China and India, which have partially liberalised their economies but refuse to fully embrace neo-liberalism.

Growth has failed particularly badly in Latin America and sub- Saharan Africa, where neo-liberal reforms have been implemented most thoroughly. In the "bad old days", per capita income in Latin America grew at an impressive 3.1 per cent per year. In the "brave new world", it has been growing at a paltry 0.5 per cent. In sub-Saharan Africa, per capita income grew at 1.6 per cent a year during 1960-80, but since then the region has seen a fall in living standards (by 0.3 per cent a year).

Both the history of rich countries and the recent records of developing countries point to the same conclusion. Economic development requires tariffs, regulation of foreign investment, permissive intellectual property laws, and other policies that help their producers accumulate productive capabilities. Given this, the international economic playing field should be tilted in favour of the poorer countries by giving them greater freedom to use these policies.

Tilting the playing field is not just a matter of fairness. It is about helping the developing countries to grow faster. Because faster growth in developing countries means more trade and investment opportunities, it is also in the self-interest of the rich countries.

The author teaches economics at the University of Cambridge. The article is based on his book Bad Samaritans ­ Rich Nations, Poor Policies, and the Threat to the Developing World (Random House).

Promoted stories

This Is What a Real Woman Looks Like (According to Austrian Bigots) (VICE)

Slideshow: 22 Amazing Photobombs & Photo Fails (Wably)

Spring Break in the 90's was a simpler time (21 Photos) (theCHIVE)

What you missed at Vladimir Putin's quite crazy press conference

The glorious moment Russell Brand incurred the anger of a hungry RBS worker with a cold lunch

No, Whitehall hasn't banned use of the word Christmas

Virgin's wristband checks if you've fallen asleep and starts recording your TV

Mario Balotelli banned for one match over offensive Instagram post

The Hobbit and Lord of the Rings

Ridiculously Popular Sweatshirt… (Business Insider)

14 Unsatisfied Women In Western Art… (Refinery29)

Out of the Box: 10 Amazing… (Details.com)

What China's Newest Fighter Jet… (Bloomberg)

TOP 10 CITIES IN THE WORLD

i100

VIDEO

NEWS

TECH

FOOTBALL

FILM