Sociology

https://doi.org/10.1177/1090198120922942

Health Education & Behavior 2020, Vol. 47(4) 504 –508 © 2020 Society for Public Health Education

Article reuse guidelines: sagepub.com/journals-permissions DOI: 10.1177/1090198120922942 journals.sagepub.com/home/heb

Perspective

Racial capitalism is a fundamental cause of disease in the world and will be a root cause of the racial and socioeco- nomic inequities in COVID-19 that we will be left to sort out when the dust settles. What is a fundamental cause? In Link and Phelan’s widely cited (1995) theoretical article, they argued that a social condition is a basic, fundamental cause of disease disparities if it (a) influences multiple disease out- comes, (b) affects disease outcomes through multiple risk factors, (c) involves access to flexible resources that can be used to minimize both risks and the consequences of disease, and (d) is reproduced overtime through the continual replace- ment of intervening mechanisms.

Sociological health research has since proven that both socioeconomic and racial social inequities are social condi- tions that fit the formula and contribute to socioeconomic and racial health inequities (i.e., Gee & Ford, 2011; Lutfey & Freese, 2005; Phelan & Link, 2015; Phelan et al., 2010; Sewell, 2016; Williams & Collins, 2001). I extend this conver- sation by arguing that the research is actually capturing how racial capitalism works to have a fundamental impact on health inequities, as Black radical thought traditions suggested as much decades ago. As introduced by Robinson (1983), racial capitalism is the idea that racialized exploitation and capital accumulation are mutually constitutive. Racial capital- ism created the modern world system, through slavery, colo- nialism, and genocide because “the development, organization,

and expansion of capitalist society pursued essentially racial directions, so too did social ideology” (Robinson, 1983, p. 2). Racially minoritized and economically deprived groups face capitalist and racist systems that continue to devalue and harm their lives, even within newer, supposedly deracialized neolib- eral agendas (Clarno, 2017; Johnson, 2017).

We have ample evidence of racial capitalism as a cause of health inequities in the United States though, collec- tively, scholarship has not always connected all the pieces. For instance, Pulido (2016) argues that racial cap- italism is at the very core of the Flint, Michigan lead water crisis:

The people of Flint are so devalued that their lives are subordinated to the goals of municipal fiscal solvency . . . this devaluation is based on both their blackness and their surplus status, with the two being mutually constituted. (p. 1)

Additional research has found that exposure to the Flint water crisis has been linked to both physical (Sadler et al.,

922942HEBXXX10.1177/1090198120922942Health Education & BehaviorLaster Pirtle research-article2020

1University of California Merced, Merced, CA, USA

Corresponding Author: Whitney N. Laster Pirtle, Department of Sociology, University of California Merced, 5200 North Lake Road, Merced, CA 95340, USA. Email: [email protected]

Racial Capitalism: A Fundamental Cause of Novel Coronavirus (COVID-19) Pandemic Inequities in the United States

Whitney N. Laster Pirtle, PhD1

Abstract Racial capitalism is a fundamental cause of the racial and socioeconomic inequities within the novel coronavirus pandemic (COVID-19) in the United States. The overrepresentation of Black death reported in Detroit, Michigan is a case study for this argument. Racism and capitalism mutually construct harmful social conditions that fundamentally shape COVID-19 disease inequities because they (a) shape multiple diseases that interact with COVID-19 to influence poor health outcomes; (b) affect disease outcomes through increasing multiple risk factors for poor, people of color, including racial residential segregation, homelessness, and medical bias; (c) shape access to flexible resources, such as medical knowledge and freedom, which can be used to minimize both risks and the consequences of disease; and (d) replicate historical patterns of inequities within pandemics, despite newer intervening mechanisms thought to ameliorate health consequences. Interventions should address social inequality to achieve health equity across pandemics.

Keywords capitalism, coronavirus, COVID-19, fundamental causes, health inequities, racism

Laster Pirtle 505

2017) and mental (Cuthbertson et al., 2016) health problems for poor and people of color and can be explained through multiple mechanisms, such as disinvested, racially segre- gated neighborhoods (Michigan Civil Rights Commission 2017).

Travel just 70 miles down I-75 from Flint to Detroit, Michigan, and we are able to witness in real time the way racial capitalism is shaping COVID-19 health inequities. In a report by Michigan’s Health Department, as of April 3, 2020, Detroit City and surrounding counties have the largest num- ber of cases in the state; as Nichols (2020) wrote for the New York Times, Detroit is already mourning. Detroit and its sur- rounding areas have large populations of people of color, most of whom are Black Americans and populations that are poor and working class (Nichols, 2020; Schulz et al., 2002). Even more striking than the incidence rates, however, is sta- tistics that reveal that out of the direct deaths related to COVID-19, 40% of them are of Black residents in a state that has only 14% Black population. The clock is already ticking in Detroit on the racial time bomb in the coronavirus crisis (Blow, 2020), and data replicate these trends in major metros across the United States including Chicago, New Orleans, and New York (McCarthy, 2020). The overrepresentation in mortality among Black Americans, or death gap, is a result of structural violence (Ansell, 2017) as created through a racial capitalist system. In the sections that follow, I detail how racial capitalism acts as a fundamental cause of health ineq- uities and COVID-19.

A. Racial Capitalism Influences Multiple Disease Outcomes

First, the people of Detroit already endure multiple health problems, such as high rates of diabetes (National Medical Association, 2015). An early report from Italy found that a large majority of COVID-19 fatalities occurred in those who had comorbidities, or additional illnesses like diabetes and asthma, that amplified COVID-19’s wear on the body (Ebhardt et al., 2020). To be clear, these racial differences in illnesses are not the result of biological or even behavioral differences in race but a result of racist, capitalist systems that structure people’s lives.

B. Racial Capitalism Increases Multiple Disease Risk Factors

Racism and capitalism have, for example, mutually con- structed racial residential segregation, which refers to the physical separation of groups into residential contexts that are patterned by race (Rothstein, 2017). Racial residential segregation has been

imposed by legislation, supported by major economic institutions, enshrined in the housing policies of the federal government, enforced by the judicial system, and legitimized by the ideology

of white supremacy that was advocated by the church and other cultural institutions. (Williams & Collins, 2001, p. 405)

Residents in deprived neighborhoods have less access to green spaces and healthy, affordable foods; thus, restricting healthy behaviors. Racial residential segregation means poor people of color are also forced to live near manufacturing and other harmful toxins and wastes. People restricted to these areas endure multiple exposures to harmful physical and social environments and increased stressful events, all of which demonstrate how multiple risk factors shape health, including COVID-19.

A 2002 study by health researchers argued that racial and spatial relations were fundamental determinants of health in Detroit (Schulz et al., 2002). Not only is Detroit one of most segregated cities in America, as mapping data shows (Cable, 2013), but Detroit also ranks in the top 20 major cities in the United States with highest rates of homelessness (Frohlich, 2019), and the majority of those persons are Black. Homelessness is another way that racial capitalism puts the poor, older, and families of color at increased risk for conse- quences of COVID-19 (Torres, 2020). How can a person even shelter in place with no shelter?

Given our capitalist, privatized insurance system in the United States, most homeless and unemployed have inade- quate access to quality health care (Ansell, 2017). Though, to be clear, America’s exceptionally unequal, extreme neoliberal health care system puts the entire country at risk (Gaffney, 2020). Health care inequities are another risk factor; the coro- navirus does not have to discriminate across race and class, our health care system does that work on its own. Racial and economic differences in testing and treatment rates (Farmer, 2020) is one mechanism that shapes disparities. In a recent interview on PBS News Hour, Dr. Uché Blackstock shared the implications of racial bias in medical encounters:

when black and brown people interface with the health care system, they often encounter provider bias. So, we know, and it’s well-documented, that their pain is undertreated or their complaints are minimized. So, my concern is that, when these patients present to emergency departments and hospitals in their areas with COVID-19 symptoms, that their symptoms may be downplayed or they may not be taken seriously. And we do already have the data to support that trend continuing to happen. (Blackstock, 2020)

C. Racial Capitalism Restricts Access to Flexible Resources That Buffer Negative Disease Outcomes

Additionally, racial capitalism is a fundamental cause because it shapes access to flexible resources. For example, those with high socioeconomic status secure a superior set of knowledge, power, money, power, prestige, and beneficial social connec- tions, all of which can alleviate the consequences of the disease

506 Health Education & Behavior 47(4)

(Link & Phelan, 1995). Think about who has access to up-to- date reports of COVID-19 that communicate important health education facts on protection. The wealthy can also afford to pay others to do their grocery shopping or order online, mean- while part-time Amazon workers forced to be on the front line write pleas about having no paid time off (Guendelsberger, 2020). And, why don’t employers value and protect the workers doing the essential jobs? Jason Hargrove, a Black bus driver in Detroit, who was exposed to COVID-19 and lacked access to proper safety equipment wondered this himself shortly before passing away from the disease (Witsil, 2020).

Racism also restricts those same crucial flexible resources, in addition to others even more racialized such as freedom. For instance, unfreedoms, or the lack of control Black Americans have over their lives in the United States, whether it be attributed to historical systems of slavery or mass incar- ceration today, puts them at heighted risks for mental and physical health problems (e.g., Alexander, 2020; Phelan & Link, 2018). The vulnerability and unfreedoms of detained populations at the border and in prisons, who are overwhelm- ingly Black and Brown and poor, increases their risk for harsh consequences of COVID-19 (Morse, 2020). Through- out Michigan’s prison system, as reported on April 3 by WXYZ Detroit, 184 incarcerated persons have already tested positive for COVID-19 (R. Jones, 2020).

D. Racial Capitalism Shapes Disease Outcomes Overtime Despite Implementation of Intervening Mechanisms

Finally, intervening mechanisms found to mitigate some health inequities, like increased public sanitation or health education interventions, cannot fully eradicate the relationship between racism, poverty, and health because they are replaced by other mechanisms, like gentrification and rent surges that leads to housing instability and homelessness. In fact, mecha- nisms that sustain racial capitalism present a “fundamental resilience in the face of changing proximate causes” (Seamster & Ray, 2018, p. 330). The resilience can be evidenced in the revert back to previously mitigated mechanisms that are once again contributing to disease disparities, such as poor water sanitization (look again no further than the Flint water crisis).

Undeniably, racism and socioeconomic disadvantage have persistent, significant, multifaceted associations with poor health. Indeed, historical research on smallpox reveals that if access to flexible basic resources, like food, medicine, shelter, and treatment, excluded any subset of the population, the disease will continue to spread and continue to kill (Mitchell, 2020). During the 1918 flu epidemic in Chicago, racist tropes were used to blame the spread of the disease on Black residents, impeding a quality public health response (McDonald, 2020). History tells us that pandemics exacer- bate race and class inequalities.

COVID-19 Is Showing America Who We Are, Again—But What Can We Do?

An interview on Democracy Now with Dr. Abdul El-Sayed, former director of the Detroit Health Department, perfectly summarizes the impact of racial capitalism on COVID-19 inequities in the area, specifically highlighting political and economic decisions about water:

when you look at communities that are suffering the most, they’re communities on which environmental injustice, structural racism, and their implications on poverty, have already softened the space for the incoming of this virus to devastate people [emphasis added]. You know, you think about something like water . . . Detroiters were literally having to pay back the debt that the entire region incurred because Detroit was the single utility purifying water for everybody. And then they just raised rates . . . and then you fast-forward, and you think about the incoming pandemic, and we’re telling people to wash their hands with warm, soapy water for 20 seconds. Well, if you don’t have water in your house, you can’t do that. All of those— all of that is seeded by decisions that have been made, that have been patterned around race and patterned around wealth for a very long time [emphasis added]. (El-Sayed, 2020)

Racialized capitalist pursuits have left behind the poor, people of color in Detroit, devaluing life so much that it is being easily snatched up by the novel coronavirus pandemic.

Speaking even more broadly, capitalist gain has threat- ened the health of millions of Americans within the pan- demic. Volunteer innovators printing important medical technologies report being threatened with litigation from large corporations (Peters, 2020). Individual racketeers have wiped out entire city’s stock of hand sanitizer in seek of profit. Wisconsin Republicans in power reject extensions for returning absentee ballots exploiting the pandemic and increasing voter disenfranchisement of poor, people of color (Bearman, 2020). Xenophobic racism has already affected health outcomes, as governmental officials lacked to enact policies by othering the problem, or later enacting targeted border policies (Goh, 2020). Anti-Asian interpersonal dis- crimination has increased and social distancing may spike rates of White Nationalism (Dickson, 2020). “Each public health issue is a snapshot where we can see the unfolding of the collective processes that define who we are, what we believe, and what we value as a society” (Wallack, 2019, p. 901). COVID-19 is showing us who we are . . . again.

The racist, capitalist frameworks that sustain the modern world is a fundamental cause of COVID-19 within and across countries, but what can we do? As a collective, we must first ask, what would it take to create the change we need to solve this problem (Wallack, 2019)? Public health and health education research, in particular, must look beyond interventions focused to individual and interpersonal characteristics and more to institutions, environments, and

Laster Pirtle 507

ideologies (Golden & Earp, 2012). As Link and Phelan (1995) instruct, “If one wishes to address fundamental social causes, the intervention must address inequality in the resources that fundamental causes entail” (p. 89). C. P. Jones (2014) offers three tangible way to address health equity that combats racial capitalism: “valuing all individuals and popu- lations equally; recognizing and rectifying historical injus- tices; providing resources according to need.” (p. S75).

Acknowledgments

I appreciate early suggestions from Victor Ray and helpful feed- back from the editor, Jesus Ramirez-Valles. Thoughtful conversa- tions with my Graduate Sociology of Health Spring 2020 seminar students inspired this piece.

Declaration of Conflicting Interests

The author declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.

Funding

The author received no financial support for the research, author- ship, and/or publication of this article.

ORCID iD

Whitney N. Laster Pirtle https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5357-8629

References

Alexander, M. (2020). The new Jim Crow: Mass incarceration in the age of colorblindness (10th ed.). The New Press.

Ansell, D. A. (2017). The death gap: How inequality kills. University of Chicago Press. https://doi.org/10.7208/chi- cago/9780226428291.001.0001

Bearman, A. (2020, April 7). How republicans exploited the corona- virus to steal a Wisconsin election. MotherJones. https://www. motherjones.com/politics/2020/04/wisconsin-voting-coronavirus/

Blackstock, U. (2020, April 2). COVID-19 may not discriminate based on race: But U.S. health care does [Interview]. PBS. https://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/covid-19-may-not-dis- criminate-based-on-race-but-u-s-health-care-does

Blow, C. (2020, April 1). The racial time bomb in the Covid-19 crisis. New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/01/opin- ion/coronavirus-black-people.html?referringSource=article Share&fbclid=IwAR1LT_taBmAZ9tBE5ofcu7OjM1AZC- woOroBNtpznEn5AQB0kOV3Mwdgn5r0

Cable, D. A. (2013). Racial dot map. Weldon Cooper Center for Public Service, Rector and Visitors of the University of Virginia. https://demographics.virginia.edu/DotMap/index.html

Clarno, A. (2017). Neoliberal apartheid: Palestine/Israel and South Africa after 1994. University of Chicago Press. https:// doi.org/10.7208/chicago/9780226430126.001.0001

Cuthbertson, C. A., Newkirk, C., Ilardo, J., Loveridge, S., & Skidmore, M. (2016). Angry, scared, and unsure: Mental health consequences of contaminated water in Flint, Michigan. Journal of Urban Health, 93(6), 899–908. https://doi. org/10.1007/s11524-016-0089-y

Dickson, E. J. (2020, March 18). How social distancing could lead to a spike in White Nationalism. Rolling Stone. https://www.

rollingstone.com/culture/culture-news/covid-19-coronavirus- pandemic-extremism-white-nationalism-southern-poverty- law-center-969079/?fbclid=IwAR238yjEG2CnFvvZ2UtIgFqb F39CFyQ77q4KqOVjo4diuHPwHV_0NLYk-Xg

Ebhardt, T., Remondini, C., & Bertacche, M. (2020, March 18). 99% of those who died from virus had other illness, Italy says. Bloomberg. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-03- 18/99-of-those-who-died-from-virus-had-other-illness-italy-says

El-Sayed, A. (2020, March 31). Communities enduring racism & poverty will suffer most due to COVID-19 [Interview]. Democracy Now! https://www.democracynow.org/2020/3/31/abul_el_sayed_ epidemic_of_insecurity

Farmer, B. (2020, April 1). The coronavirus doesn’t discriminate, U.S. health care may be a different story. KGOU. https://www. kgou.org/post/coronavirus-doesnt-discriminate-us-health- care-may-be-different-story

Frohlich, T. (2019, October 7). Sheltering the homeless: These 48 major US cities face growing homeless populations. USA TODAY. https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/2019/10/07/ 48-major-us-cities-struggling-to-shelter-growing-homeless- population/40242171/

Gaffney, A. (2020, March 21). America’s extreme neoliberal healthcare system is putting the country at risk. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2020/mar/21/ medicare-for-all-coronavirus-covid-19-single-payer

Gee, G. C., & Ford, C. F. (2011). Structural racism and health inequities: Old issues, new directions. Du Bois Review: Social Science Research on Race, 8(1), 115–132. https://doi .org/10.1017/s1742058x11000130

Goh, J. X. (2020). Perceived vulnerability to disease predicts restric- tive policy supports in response to the 2019-nCoV (“Wuhan Virus”) outbreak. PsyArXiv. https://psyarxiv.com/52bw4/

Golden, S. D., & Earp, J. A. L (2012). Social ecological approaches to individuals and their contexts: Twenty years of health education & behavior health promotion interventions. Health Education & Behavior, 39(3), 364–372. https://doi .org/10.1177/1090198111418634

Guendelsberger, E. (2020, March 18). Coronavirus diaries: I’m an amazon worker handling all those toilet paper shipments. Slate. https://slate.com/technology/2020/03/coronavirus- diaries- amazon-toilet-paper.html

Johnson, W. (Ed.). (2017). Race, capitalism, justice forum 1. Boston Review. https://bostonreview.net/forum-i

Jones, C. P. (2014). Systems of power, axes of inequity: Parallels, intersections, braiding the strands. Medical Care, 52(10 Suppl. 3), S71–S75. https://doi.org/10.1097/MLR.000000000000021

Jones, R. (2020, April 3). Michigan prisons and jails see COVID-19 cases rise. WXYZ. https://www.wxyz.com/news/local-news/ investigations/michigan-prisons-and-jails-see-covid-19-cases- rise

Link, B. G., & Phelan, J. (1995). Social conditions as fundamen- tal causes of disease. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 80–94. https://doi.org/10.2307/2626958

Lutfey, K., & Freese, J. (2005). Toward some fundamentals of fundamental causality: Socioeconomic status and health in the routine clinic visit for diabetes. American Journal of Sociology, 110(5), 1326–1372. https://doi.org/10.1086/428914

McCarthy, N. (2020, April 7). COVID-19’s devastating impact on African Americans. Statista. https://www.statista.com/ chart/21364/african-american-share-of-covid-19-deaths/

508 Health Education & Behavior 47(4)

McDonald, S. N. (2020, April 1). In 1918 and 2020, race colors America’s response to epidemics. Undefeated. https://theunde- feated.com/features/in-1918-and-2020-race-colors-americas- response-to-epidemics/

Michigan Civil Rights Commission. (2017). The Flint water cri- sis: Systemic racism through the lens of Flint. https://www. michigan.gov/documents/mdcr/VFlintCrisisRep-F-Edited 3-13-17_554317_7.pdf

Mitchell, E. (2020, March 11). The shortages may be worse than the disease. The Atlantic. https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/ archive/2020/03/humanitys-long-history-of-making-epidem- ics-worse/607780/

Morse, I. (2020, March 19). Thousands of ICE detainees at high risk amid coronavirus pandemic. Al Jazeera. https://www. aljazeera.com/news/2020/03/thousands-ice-detainees-high- risk-coronavirus-pandemic-200319202703607.html

National Medical Association. (2015, August 3). Detroit diabetes [Conference session]. National Medical Association 113th Annual Convention and Scientific Assembly, Family Medicine Section, Detroit, MI, United States.

Nichols, D. A. (2020, April 2). Detroit is mourning. New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/02/opinion/corona- virus-detroit.html

Peters, J. (2020, March 17). Volunteers produce 3D-printed valves for life-saving coronavirus treatments. The Verge. https:// www.theverge.com/2020/3/17/21184308/coronavirus-italy- medical-3d-print-valves-treatments

Phelan, J. C., & Link, B. G. (2015). Is racism a fundamental cause of inequalities in health? Annual Review of Sociology, 41, 311– 330. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-soc-073014-112305

Phelan, J. C., Link, B. G., & Tehranifar, P. (2010). Social conditions as fundamental causes of health inequalities: Theory, evidence, and policy implications. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 51(1 Suppl.), S28–S40. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022146510383498

Pulido, L. (2016). Flint, environmental racism, and racial capital- ism. Capitalism Nature Socialism, 27(3), 1–16. https://doi.org/ 10.1080/10455752.2016.1213013

Robinson, C. (1983). Black Marxism: The making of the black radi- cal tradition. University of North Carolina Press.

Rothstein, R. (2017). The color of law: A forgotten history of how our government segregated America. Liveright.

Sadler, R. C., LaChance, J., & Hanna-Attisha, M. (2017). Social and built environmental correlates of predicted blood lead levels in the Flint water crisis. American Journal of Public Health, 107, 763–769. https://doi.org/10.2105/ajph.2017 .303692

Schulz, A. J., Williams, D. R., Israel, B. A., & Lempert, L. B. (2002). Racial and spatial relations as fundamental determi- nants of health in Detroit. Milbank Quarterly, 80(4), 677–707. https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-0009.00028

Sewell, A. A. (2016). The racism-race reification process: A meso- level political economic framework for understanding racial health disparities. Sociology of Race and Ethnicity, 2(4), 402–432. https://doi.org/10.1177/2332649215626936

Seamster, L., & Ray, V. (2018). Against teleology in the study of race: Toward the abolition of the progress paradigm. Sociological Theory, 36(4), 315–342. https://doi.org/10.1177/ 0735275118813614

Torres, S. (2020, March 20). Closed community spaces due to coro- navirus will leave the homeless out in the cold: It’s a disgrace. CalMatters. https://calmatters.org/commentary/as-community- spaces-close-due-to-the-coronavirus-the-homeless-have-almost- nowhere-to-go/

Wallack, L. (2019). Building a social justice narrative for public health. Health Education & Behavior, 46(6), 901–904. https:// doi.org/10.1177/1090198119867123

Williams, D. R., & Collins, C. (2001). Racial residential segrega- tion: A fundamental cause of racial disparities in health. Public Health Reports, 116(5), 404–416. https://doi.org/10.1016/ s0033-3549(04)50068-7

Witsil, F. (2020, April 2). Driver who said woman coughed on his bus has died of coronavirus. Detroit Free Press. https://www. freep.com/story/news/local/michigan/detroit/2020/04/02/ detroit-bus-drivers-dead-covid-19/5115450002/