Read & Write an Essay about WEB vs Booker

DOCUMENT-BASED QUESTION RUBRIC    

5  4  3  2  1 

·​ ​Thoroughly  addresses all 

aspects of the task 

by accurately 

analyzing and 

interpreting most 

of the document 

·​ ​Incorporates  relevant outside 

information 

·​ ​Richly supports  essay with relevant 

facts, examples, 

and details 

·​ ​Writes a  well-developed 

essay, consistently 

demonstrating a 

logical and clear 

plan of organization 

·​ ​Uses  information from 

the documents in 

the body of the 

essay 

·​ ​Includes a  strong introduction 

and conclusion 

·​ ​Addresses all  aspects of the task 

by accurately 

analyzing and 

interpreting most 

of the documents 

·​ ​Incorporates  relevant outside 

information 

·​ ​Includes  relevant facts, 

examples, and 

details, but 

discussion may be 

more descriptive 

than analytical 

·​ ​Writes a  well-developed 

essay, 

demonstrating a 

logical and clear 

plan of organization 

·​ ​Includes a  good introduction 

and conclusion 

·​ ​Addresses  most aspects of 

the task or 

addresses all 

aspects in a limited 

way; uses some of 

the documents 

·​ ​Incorporates  limited or no 

relevant outside 

information 

·​ ​Uses some  facts, examples, 

and details, but the 

discussion is more 

descriptive rather 

than analytical 

·​ ​Writes a  satisfactorily 

developed essay, 

demonstrating a 

general plan of 

organization 

·​ ​Restates the  theme in the 

introduction and 

concludes with a 

simple restatement 

of the theme 

·​ ​Attempts to  address some 

aspects of the 

task making 

limited use of 

the documents 

·​ ​No relevant  outside 

information is 

presented 

·​ ​Uses a few  facts, examples 

and details and 

discussion simply 

restates 

contents of the 

documents 

·​ ​Writes a  poorly organized 

essay, lacking 

focus 

·​ ​Has vague or  missing 

introduction 

and/or conclusion 

·​ ​Shows a  limited 

understanding of 

the task with 

vague, unclear 

references to the 

documents 

·​ ​No relevant  outside 

information is 

presented 

·​ ​Attempts to  complete the task 

but essay 

demonstrates a 

major weakness in 

the organization 

·​ ​Uses little or  no accurate or 

relevant facts, 

details, examples 

·​ ​Has no  introduction or 

conclusion 

  

Name___________________________________________ 

   

Score___________________________________________