Unit 5 IP

1,200-1,500 words

This is a 2-part assignment.

Part 1

Consider the scenario from the perspective of (1) the police, (2) the courts, and (3) corrections. From each perspective, answer the following questions:

• Where would discretion be appropriate?
• Where would discretion not be appropriate?
• Give an example of how discretion (if used in this capacity) could change the outcome of the case.

Part 2

In the context of the United States criminal justice system, select any 2 of the questions listed below. Your response should provide sufficient detail on each of the topics, and you should address the topic of discretion within the criminal justice system.

• What factors influence the exercise of discretion?
• What are some of the methods for controlling discretion?
• What are some ethical considerations for discretion?
• Do you think there is too much discretion in the criminal justice system? Explain.
• Do you think it would be desirable to limit the amount of discretion in the criminal justice system? If so, how would you do it? What might be the effects?