for Natural Science Guru M6D1

M6D1: Alcoholism and Accountability

The "disease versus non-disease" model of alcoholism continues to be an ongoing, controversial debate. In the Criminal Justice field, the question is: is the alcoholic "not guilty" for a crime committed while under the influence because he or she has this disease? Briefly explain these two models, highlighting their major points. Then discuss which model you personally favor. Explain your rationale. How should the Criminal Justice System respond?