the ethical dimension/ what if the facts were different?

short paragraph 8 to 10 lines about the  case 6.2

use simple words 

q/ the ethical dimension a number of students work full time for their school to pay  for their education. is it fair to require them to pay FICA taxes when they would not have to do so it they worked only thirty hours per week? explain. I attached copy for the study case please read the study case then answer the question .

 -----------------

the question is / what if the facts were different ( if bad frog had sought to use the offensive label to market toys instead of beer, would the court'a ruling likely have been the same? why or why not 

from the case 5.3 bad frog brewery, 

please I want short answer 8 lines , simple words 

i attached the pic to see the full case