Case Study

Analyze the assigned ethical dilemma case study in an objective and morally reasoned manner.  Specifically, your analysis should address the following:

1. Clearly identify the central issue in this case (conflicting rights) and, specifically, the party who is primarily faced with the dilemma which requires a decision.
2. Identify all of the relevant facts in this case, avoiding assumptions not supported by the facts.
3. After considering all sides of the issue, identify, discuss and consider all of the viable options available to successfully resolve this professional dilemma.
4. For each viable option, consider and discuss the consequences which would arise in choosing each particular option.
5. Finally, choose the option which you feel best satisfies the dilemma and provide the specific reasons and justifications for your conclusion.