are you an English teacher ??? can you analyze text ???

you will read two text, each text is 10 pages or less. after reading them, you need to compare the first text with the second major text. find their rhetorechal effectivness of each text and then write three pages on which text do you find more effective and persuasive and why ??  and specefy their rhetorichal moves. 

the firsttext is ( schools kill creativity ) by ken robinson.

the second text is ( this is water ) by david foster walace