8PM EST---CORRECT ASSIGNMENT

nmonfort
comparative_study_peer_review_template.doc

Comparative Study

Reviewer:______________________ Author of the Study:__________________

Criteria

Feedback

1. Ask A Question

· Is the question clearly stated?

· Is the population clear?

· Are the variables clearly defined?

2. Collect Data

· Do you understand how this data was gathered?

· Does the author state the potential biases?

· Are there any potential problems with how this data was gathered (that have not been addressed by the researcher)?

3. Analyze the data

· Are the analyses appropriate for the data? Support/Explain.

· Are the analyses labeled and explained? Support/Explain.

· Are any of the representations of the data misleading or potentially misleading? Support/Explain.

· Do you have any questions?

4. Interpret the data

· Has the question been answered?

· Is this interpretation clearly supported by the analysis? Explain.

· Do you have any questions?

5. Reflection

· Has the author reflected on both positive and negative experiences?

· Has he/she commented on surprising or unexpected results/experiences?

· Has he/she considered how to improve the study?

image1
image2
image3
image4
image5
image6
image7
image8
image9
image10
image11
image12
image13
image14
image15
image16
image17
image18
image19
image20
image21
image22
image23
image24
image25
image26
image27
image28
image29
image30