week 4 replies

djinvasion16
  • 5 hours ago
  • 1
files (1)

week4replies.docx

100 WORDS EACH REPLY

D1 Reply Matthew

Transformational leadership is an important leadership approach because it focuses on motivating, inspiring, and encouraging individuals to reach their full potential. Transformational leadership involves leaders connecting with followers in ways that increase their motivation and morality. These leaders encourage personal growth and build relationships with their followers (Northouse, 2021, p. 185-187).

An example from my own experience is my first sergeant, Jason Miles. Sgt Miles always encouraged open communication, recognized officer’s accomplishments, and motivated his officers. By setting a positive example and showing genuine concern for his officers, Sgt Miles built trust with his officers and improved overall morale.  Sgt Miles had a strong charismatic aura, exuding self-confidence in his beliefs and values.  Officers under the supervision of Sgt Miles wanted to do better to meet his expectations.  Sgt Miles’ leadership style made it easy for officers to want to follow his directives.  As demonstrated in  Leadership and Followership (2011), leadership isn’t just about the person in charge.  It also involves the followers and how leaders and followers work together to achieve a favorable outcome.  This demonstrates transformational leadership because Sgt Miles motivated his officers through encouragement and support instead of relying solely on hierarchy or authority.

Transformational leadership is important to leadership research because it helps explain how leaders can influence the motivation, accomplishments, attitudes, and relationships of their followers. In the video,  The Puzzle of Motivation (2009), Pink talks about how autonomy, mastery, and purpose can motivate people more than traditional rewards and punishments. People want the opportunity to improve their skills and become better. By doing this, they feel their work has meaning and they are a contributing member. Extensive research has been conducted on transformational leadership because of its effects on improving employee motivation, performance, and relationship between supervisor and employee.

I believe transformational leadership can be taught.  Through training and experience, a leader could build the necessary behaviors and skills for transformational leadership.  Many leaders already have the traits to be transformational leaders. Traits such as being a strong role model, open communication, tolerating opposing views, creating a vision, building trust, and fostering collaboration are all leadership qualities that can be improved upon (Northouse, 2021, p. 201-202).  I don’t believe transformational leadership isn’t always practical based on the situation.  As a police officer, when responding to an active crisis, situational approach would be more beneficial from a supervisor.  This would allow the supervisor to put his officers in the best situations for a safe and successful outcome. 

Chaleff, I. (2011).  Leadership and followership: what tango teaches us about these roles in life [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cswrnc1dggg&t=29s

Northouse, P. G. (2021).  Leadership: Theory and Practice (9th ed.). SAGE Publications, Inc. (US).

Pink, D. (2009m August). The puzzle of motivation [Video]. TED Talks. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rrkrvAUbU9Y

D1 Reply lance

An example of transformational leadership that comes to mind is a supervisor who motivates employees to look beyond their daily responsibilities and focus on improving the overall organization. In my experience working in probation and corrections, leadership can sometimes become focused on policies, procedures, and completing daily tasks. However, a transformational leader encourages employees to take ownership of their work, develop professionally, and recognize how their individual contributions affect the larger mission. This demonstrates transformational leadership because the leader is not simply directing employees but inspiring them to improve themselves and the organization. Transformational leaders create a shared vision, encourage new ideas, and lead by example.

I believe transformational leadership is important to leadership research because it focuses on more than the authority or position a leader holds. It examines how leaders influence motivation, performance, and personal development among their employees. This is especially important in criminal justice organizations, where employee morale, communication, and commitment to the mission can directly affect the quality of services provided to the community. I also believe this leadership style can be taught. Although some individuals may naturally possess stronger leadership qualities, skills such as communication, motivation, emotional intelligence, and leading by example can be developed through training and experience.

However, I do not believe transformational leadership is practical or desirable in every leadership situation. There are situations, particularly in law enforcement and corrections, where employees need clear direction, structure, and immediate decisions. During an emergency or a safety-related incident, a leader may need to take a more directive approach rather than spend time building consensus or encouraging new ideas. In my opinion, effective leaders understand that different situations require different leadership approaches. Transformational leadership is valuable because it can inspire employees and create positive organizational change, but it should be balanced with other leadership styles when circumstances require it.

You should offer constructive comments for your classmates’ sources. As you address their source, confirm or refute whether the source cited is peer reviewed and assess the currency of the research.

D2 reply chet

An article published in 2021 by Madalina Busuioc in Public Administration Review, "Accountable Artificial Intelligence: Holding Algorithms to Account" discusses some of the problems with the increasing use of AI to inform decisions of great significance to individuals. Such decisions may relate to receipt of benefits and other services, the manner in which one is treated by various authorities, and even one's liberty, for instance in determining police activity, granting of bail and prison sentences. As Busuioc (2021) notes, many such systems will reflect the prejudices and other failings of their human counterparts, albeit less transparently. Furthermore, decision-makers may well find it hard to give a satisfactory explanation for a particular outcome, or indeed to establish who should bear responsibility.

Of course, as discussed above, there will be questions of accountability surrounding the development of an algorithm and the outcomes it produces. However, Busuioc (2021) rightly draws attention to questions arising out of reliance on such outcomes by those taking decisions. To the extent that these decision-makers place great weight on the opinion provided by an algorithm, clearly this will affect their judgement, although ultimately the decision will remain theirs. Accordingly, the interplay between algorithms, individuals and wider organizational structures will all be pertinent, and Busuioc sets out various aspects for each to be considered: for example, what explanations may reasonably be expected and required from public officials; what inquiries can legitimately be put to them by oversight mechanisms; what sanctions may apply in the event of failure to comply.

Clearly this paper will be very useful to my proposed area of study. In particular, it would support the contention that those in leadership positions need to go further than simply introducing an algorithm that may prove beneficial. They will want to be satisfied as to where liability lies, that users appreciate the strengths and weaknesses of any opinion provided and continue to play a significant role in reaching decisions, including challenging and recording reasons for departing from the suggested conclusion. Thus, it brings together many issues arising from introduction of algorithms, many of them moral, which will be faced by public sector decision-makers. For the reasons set out above, it seems clear to me that a substantial degree of scrutiny by humans is warranted, and those leading an organization will wish to encourage this. Therefore, it is useful as a starting point for discussion the leaders should consider.

Reference

Busuioc, M. (2021). Accountable artificial intelligence: Holding algorithms to account. Public Administration Review, 81(5), 825–836. https://doi.org/10.1111/puar.13293 

less

D2 reply Matthew

Author:

Myunghyun Choi, Sohee Kim, and Youngki Woo

Journal:

 Policing:  An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management

Title:

The impact of transformational leadership by chiefs and supervisors on law enforcement turnover intention: an examination of job satisfaction and commitment as mediators.

Date:

May 22, 2025

Substance of article:

This article explores how transformational leadership influences police officers' job satisfaction, organizational commitment, and intentions to leave their department. The study included 13,072 sworn officers from 85 law enforcement agencies across the United States. The study indicated that transformational leadership was associated with higher job satisfaction and lower turnover intentions. Leadership styles exhibited by police chiefs and supervisors influenced officers’ perception of their department. The research found that transformational leadership among police chiefs had a direct relationship with turnover intentions. While Supervisors influence whether officers want to stay with their department and how satisfied and committed those officers feel towards their jobs (Choi et al, 2025).

How it relates to my paper:

This article will be beneficial to my research paper because it provides evidence of how transformational leadership can influence police officers job satisfaction, organizational commitment, and overall morale. Since my research focuses on how different leadership styles affect officer performance, motivation, and morale, the findings from Choi et al. (2025) directly relate to my topic. I believe the study is valuable because it includes a large number of officers from different law enforcement agencies, allowing researchers to examine leadership across various departments. The article helps explain how the leadership behaviors of police chiefs and immediate supervisors can influence officers directly.

Final thoughts:

I believe this research article reaffirms that transformational leadership is an effective leadership styles in law enforcement.  Police officers face stressful situations with demanding responsibilities.  Transformational leaders provide encouragement and motivation to keep officers engaged for their duties.  I will need to find additional articles to further expand on the topic of transformational leadership as well as other leadership styles in law enforcement. 

Choi, M., Kim, S., & Woo, Y. (2025). The impact of transformational leadership by chiefs and supervisors on law enforcement turnover intention: an examination of job satisfaction and commitment as mediators.  Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management. 48(3), 610-629. https://doi.org/10.1108/PIJPSM-09-2024-0146