evaluating essay

Write a 1,000 - 1,300-word evaluative essay in which you challenge these improper evaluations of the chosen work, providing sound reasons and solid evidence as to why these improper evaluations should be challenged.  You will also supply your own evaluation of the work and defend it, clarifying what criteria you used, how it was judged and weighted, and why that criteria makes for a more proper evaluation.

Perhaps you want to look at a classic novel that you believe is overrated, or a movie you enjoyed that has terrible reviews.  

This new evaluation is not to be presented as your opinion; it is a formal argument.  Avoid first person (I think, I believe, etc).  Defend your ranking with argument and research.  Include a Works Cited page with at least four sources.