Creative Exercises

vspell818

CE #9 and CE#10 

  • 2 years ago
  • 10
files (4)

Module7-CE10-11.docx

CE #10

Simulating Field Research – Playtime, Snacks, and Learning in Kindergarten

The purpose of this creative exercise is to simulate a field research project with a relative immersion in the naturalistic setting. A simulation of the field experience involves observing the video recorded interactions among children during their playtime, snacks, and learning in kindergarten at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GIJh3zCK6Pg [watching the clip before the class is strongly recommended].

1. Formulate a research question that interests you with respect to this setting. It can be very broad. It may pertain to gender differences, learning, and other behavioral interventions, but it doesn’t have to.

2. Based on the chosen research question, watch the video clip again [i.e., conduct observations] and write personal field notes. At first, conduct the observations individually. Consult your notes and the book for the major elements that you need to record [i.e., the setting, the people, individual actions and activities, group behavior, and meanings and perspectives].

3. What observer role did you play? Also, what observer role was the observer/video recorder? Please explain the advantages and disadvantages/ethical issues associated with each role.

4. Someone believes that in order to answer your research question the children should be observed at random intervals throughout the week. Another person argues that the children should be observed for one full morning. What do you think would be the advantages and disadvantages of each approach? Can you think of a better method of time sampling for this situation?

Module7-CE91.docx

CE #9: Quantitative Data Analysis

1. Please indicate whether the following variables are continuous or discrete. (8 points)

Variable Name Discrete or Continuous?

a. Annual income ____________________

b. Time ____________________

c. Number of shoes you own ____________________

d. Human weight ____________________

e. Population of the United States ____________________

f. Distance ____________________

g. Course credit hours you are taking this semester ____________________

h. Car value ____________________

2. Following are data from a camper satisfaction survey conducted by a nationwide campground chain. Use this data to provide answers to posed questions about the relative comparisons. (16 points)

Responses to question

Frequencies (N = 572)

Overall experience was excellent

135

Would definitely return

151

Good value for the price

369

Appealing recreational activities

421

a. What is the rate of people selecting “Overall experience was excellent?” Also, provide an interpretation of your answer.

b. What is the ratio of people selecting “Would definitely return” to “Appealing recreational activities?” Please provide an interpretation of your answer.

c. What percentage of respondents considers the campground to be “Good value for the price?” Please provide an interpretation of your answer.

3. Please look at the table below, which includes a distribution of player’s ages at a midnight basketball program, and answer to proposed questions about the measures of central tendency and variability. (16 points)

Player’s age

Number of players

17

1

18

5

19

1

20

4

21

1

22

1

a. What is the mean age of players who participated in a midnight basketball program?

b. What is the median age of players who participated in a midnight basketball program?

c. What is the modal age of players who participated in a midnight basketball program?

d. Among the three choices (mean, median and mode), which “average” would be the most appropriate to cite in a report? Please provide explanations to support your answer.

e. What is the range of player’s age from highest to lowest?

4. Please look at the two graphs below and interpret how graph A and graph B are different. (hint” which one has larger standard deviation and what does that mean?) (8 points)

5. You are reading the findings from a study on the relationship between the total number of hours a college basketball team practiced and their winning/losing percentage. The result showed that the correlation coefficient (r) value was -0.69 between the number of hours a college basketball team practiced before a game and team losing a game. Please make an interpretation (hint: use the table provided in lecture to determine the strength of the relationship and also use coefficient of determination). (12 points)

image1.JPG

Module7-DataAnalysis_Qualitative2.pptx

Field Research & Qualitative Analysis

Part I

1

Qualitative and Field Research Defined

Qualitative research data come in the form of words, pictures, narratives, and descriptions rather than in numerical form.

Field research (a type of qualitative research) involves observations made of people in their natural settings as they go about their everyday life.

2

2

Characteristics of Qualitative Methods

Contextual approach:

Must understand the full context in which people behave

Offers a deeper and richer understanding of people's lives and behavior

Offers access to subjective experience

Focuses on the meanings, feelings and interpretations that people assign to experience

3

3

Characteristics of Qualitative Methods

Grounded theory methodology:

Develop theory by letting the theory emerge from the data, or be "grounded" in the data.

Continual interplay between data collection, data analysis and theory development.

4

4

Theory Testing vs. Theory Building/ Grounded Approach

5

Theory

Hypotheses

Data Collection

Data Analysis

Theory Development

Operational Definition

Data collection

5

Grounded approach: Example

6

6

Observation

7

7

Participant Observation

Participant observation:

Observation of people in natural environment

Researcher is a part of the activities of the people, group, or situation being studied

Enables researcher to approximate understanding

Select when research problem is exploratory in nature

Two kinds of observations:

Participation—Researcher personally experiences the world of the observed

Observation—Noting and recording the behavior of others in the social setting

8

8

Researcher Roles and Intervention

Will the observer's identity be known to those being observed?

Will the observer intervene in and possibly change the setting that is being observed?

Emphasis on participation or on observation?

Participation as unnatural intrusion

Informed Consent

9

9

Observer Roles

Complete participant

Valuable to study of closed groups

Participant-as-observer

High level of participation

Observer-as-participant

Brief and limited participation

Complete observer role

No direct contact with those observed

10

10

Unobtrusive Observation

Complete observer role

Unobtrusive or nonreactive observation:

Those under study are not aware of being studied

Investigated people do not change their behavior

Hidden observation: observation from a vantage point obscured from the participants

Ensuring that the observations are in fact hidden and truly unobtrusive

Disguised observation: conducted in natural settings but without revealing that observers are researcher

11

11

Steps and Issues in Field Research

Problem formulation

Selecting the field setting

Entering the field

Developing rapport

Becoming invisible

Attitude of the researcher

Observing and recording in the field

Going native

Exiting the field

12

12

Recording Field Notes

Running description

Accounts of previous episodes that were forgotten or went unnoticed

Analytical ideas and inferences

Personal impressions and feelings

Notes for further observation

Methodological notes

These detailed notes allow the possibility of assessing bias

13

13

How to Record? When to record?

Carry notepad at all times

Audio or videotapes

Challenge of recording during disguised observation

The ‘when’ question is a question of time sampling

Periodicity effect

14

14

Field Notes: What to Record?

The setting

The people

Individual actions and activities

Group behavior and relationships

Meaning and perspectives

Be aware of selective perception

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xAFfYLR_IRY

15

15

In-Depth Interviewing

In-depth or ethnographic interviewing:

Informal, unstructured interviews

Explore wide range of subjects

Last long period of time

Source of data for participant observation

More interactive and collaborative and less directive than survey interviewing

Goal is to explore how the world appears to the respondent without imposing structure

16

16

Ethnographic Interview

17

17

Issues in Field Research

Validity

Be thorough

Assess own potential for bias

Compare conclusions with independent observers and other research methodologies

Consider influence of observer condition

Make a video or audio recording of the scene

Reliability

May not be able to assess with lone researcher

Can be assessed through tests of inter-coder reliability

18

18

Assessment of Field Research and Qualitative Methods

Deep and insightful data

Includes actual behavior and statements

Group behavior

Researcher direct involvement

Observer bias (big man bias)

Observer over-identification

Lack of structure

Difficult to quantify

Ethics

Restricted samples

19

19

Key Ideas

Observational techniques

Direct visual or auditory experience of behavior

Qualitative research

Contextual in nature

Grounded theory approach

Participant observation

Participation – empathic understanding

Observation – deep appreciation of the context

Unobtrusive observation to minimize reactivity

Hidden observation and disguised observation

Field notes and ethnographic interviews

20

20

image1.jpeg

image2.png

image3.png

image4.jpg

image5.png

image6.png

image7.jpeg

image8.jpeg

image9.gif

image10.png

image11.jpeg

image12.jpeg

image13.jpeg

image14.jpeg

image15.png

image16.png

image17.jpeg

image18.jpg

image19.jpg

Module7-DataAnalysis_Quantitative1.pptx
This file is too large to display.View in new window