American Government

sherie12
  • an hour ago
  • 15
files (1)

JudicialInterpretationWorksheet20221.doc

Directions: Read Chapter 10, read the Scalia v. Breyer PDF and watch their debate ( http://www.annenbergclassroom.org/page/a-conversation-on-the-constitution-judicial-interpretation ), then complete this worksheet. Also, research the current justices online to see if they are known to be liberal or conservative in their decision making.

TASKS

Judicial Restraint

(Strict Constructionism/ Textualism/ Original Intention)

Judicial Activism

(Active Liberty / Living Constitution)

· Explain logic and approach to the 2 interpretation

SAMPLE ANSWER: Conservative approach to interpretation where judges practice stare decisis or “let the decisions stand” of legislators or past judges unless the standard clearly violates the Constitution.

· Tools/resources used to assist in making interpretation (Hint: Construction worker uses a hammer, saw, nails, etc. to build. What tools do Justices use to interpret the law? What are the tools of the law or those implied by each approach? What hierarchical order is there for the tools for each approach?)

1)

2)

3)

1) SAMPLE ANSWER: Constitution

2)

3)

· Judicial Leanings (Yes, do the research!)

· Chief Justice Roberts

· Justice Gorsuch

· Justice Kagan

· Justice Brown Jackson

· Justice Barrett

· Justice Kavanaugh

· Justice Thomas

· Justice Sotomayor

· Justice Alito

Conservative leaning Justices

SAMPLE ANSWER: Chief Justice John Roberts

Liberal leaning Justices