article

Article Critique #3 Assignment ENG 501

STILL HONING OUR ARTICLE CRITIQUE SKILLS

For this week’s major assignment, you are going to write another article critique. Again, an article critique is a specific

type of reading response that asks you to read, analyze and discuss the strengths and weaknesses of an academic

article. Critiques are holistic and examine both the content of the article and the ways in which it is written before

rendering an opinion on the validity or worthiness of the article. Ultimately, the purpose of the critique is to determine if

the article meets your (personal and field-specific) standards of topic selection, evidence, logic and writing style.

The article you choose must be one you retrieved through Trine’s Research Hub.

THE ASSIGNMENT

You need to carefully and critically read an article of your choice from one of the journals of the list from the journal

project. You then need to compose a narrative response of two (2) to three (3) pages that

• Explains (one short paragraph) why you chose this article,

• Briefly (one or two paragraphs) summarizes the article,

• Makes a claim about the strength or validity of the author’s claims,

• Supports your claims about the author’s work with specific evidence from the article,

• Makes a supported recommendation about whether someone in your field should use this article in his/her

own research or writing.

FORMAT

Your critique should be in essay format, using complete sentences and paragraphs in double spacing. It should begin

with a paragraph discussing the connection of the topic to your career path, interests, etc. – whatever reason

brought you to choosing this topic. Then write a summary that identifies the article and author. That should be

followed by your evaluation of the research and writing of the article, supported by evidence. Finally, you should

conclude with a one paragraph recommendation, again supported by evidence, about the use of the article.

Your review should contain direct references (quotes, summaries and paraphrases) from the article. You need to

correctly cite your summary at the beginning with a signal phrase and in‐text citation. All other evidence should be

cited in APA format. Include a correctly formatted APA-style Reference entry on its own page.

APA formatting: You need to include a title page, page numbers, a running head, APA citations, section headings,

and a References page.