Memorandum
Research Memo B:
Fact Pattern
The legislature in the State of Red enacted a new law requiring rideshare services to treat their drivers as employees and not as independent contractors. This means that for the employee, the company withholds income tax, Social Security, and Medicare from wages paid. For the independent contractor, the company does not withhold taxes. Your client Miss Pretty owns the hair salon and spa, Girls Only. Girls Only is a subchapter S corporation and Miss Pretty is a 52% shareholder. The rest of the stock is owned by two hair stylists in the salon. There are six hair stylists in total in the salon and three manicurists. She received notice from the IRS that she was subject to an audit to determine whether her hair stylists and manicurists are employees or independent contractors.
Miss Pretty has an oral agreement with her hair stylists that each will pay the corporation monthly rent of $650 for their stall. Manicurists pay $250 per month for their stations. As part of the arrangement, Miss Pretty can terminate any stylist not working full time at the salon.
The hairstylists charge varied prices to customers and there is no uniform pricing. Each stylist or manicurist sets their own respective prices. Miss Pretty supplies the equipment such as beauty chairs, special lighting, and manicuring station furniture. Miss Pretty also purchases all inventory for the salon including shampoo, color hair products and nail polish. The cost of the inventory is included in the monthly rental fees. The stylists own their own hair dryers, brushes, and scissors. The manicurists supply their own emery boards and nail equipment. The stylists and manicurists file their own respective tax returns which reflect the profit or loss from their services to clients.
On occasion, Miss Pretty will pay for the stylists to attend beauty shows for training. She also reimburses stylists for special training in hair coloring and cutting.
Your client has heard that California and Florida have passed laws characterizing which service companies are employers and which are not. Also, the common law, followed by the IRS, also provides a test to determine the status of workers.
Prepare a tax memorandum for use in advising your client. State the issue(s) to be resolved and make sure to identify the specific authorities ( code, statutes, case law etc.) that address your client’s tax issues. Make sure to weigh authorities both for and against your client’s position.
The memo should be 2 pages, double spaced, one-inch margins, 12pt. Use the template in your assignment.
Hint: search engine words: hairdresser (or stylist); independent contractor; case law; IRS 20 factor test
Other hint: consider the cases in Florida and California and/or any other states.