DB8

Criteria Ratings Points

Content 65 to >59.0 pts

Advanced

The student thoroughly addressed the points of the analysis.

59 to >54.0 pts

Proficient

The student sufficiently addressed the points of the analysis.

54 to >0.0 pts

Developing

The student did not accurately address the points of the analysis.

0 pts

Not Present

65 pts

Content

Analysis and Conclusion

40 to >36.0 pts

Advanced

Major points are clearly articulated and sufficiently supported. There is a logical flow of arguments. Contextual factors are considered, complex issues are navigated with precision and nuance.

36 to >33.0 pts

Proficient

Major points are not always clearly analyzed, and/or some aspects of context, terminology, awareness of complexity, the need for nuanced understanding are lacking. AND/OR The paper does not have a logical flow to its arguments.

33 to >0.0 pts

Developing

The major points are largely unclear or presented in a superficial manner that does not deal with the context, terminology, or complexity, related to the subject matter.

0 pts

Not Present

40 pts

Structure

Formatting

25 to >22.0 pts

Advanced

The student meticulously followed strict current Turabian guidelines when writing the paper and had the required page count (3 pages).

22 to >20.0 pts

Proficient

The student mostly followed strict current Turabian guidelines when writing the paper but had an insufficient page count.

20 to >0.0 pts

Developing

The student did not follow strict current Turabian guidelines when writing the paper and/or did not have sufficient page count.

0 pts

Not Present

25 pts

Structure

Spelling and Grammar

20 to >17.0 pts

Advanced

There are few to no spelling and grammar errors.

17 to >16.0 pts

Proficient

There are a several spelling and grammar errors.

16 to >0.0 pts

Developing

There are considerable spelling and grammar errors.

0 pts

Not Present

20 pts

Total Points: 150

Situation Analysis Grading Rubric | PPOG506_B02_202140