Scientific Merit Paper Scoring Guide
Evaluates the scientific merit of the article by analyzing how the research advances the scientific knowledge base. Evaluates the scientific merit of the article by analyzing how the research contributes to research theory and the field of study. Evaluates the scientific merit of the article by analyzing the scientific methods. Analyzes the validity and reliability of a selected research study and elaborates on how it contributes to scientific merit. Analyzes the effectiveness of strategies selected for addressing ethical concerns in the design of a research study. Communicates in a manner that is completely scholarly, professional, and consistent with expectations for members of the identified field of study, and uses APA style and formatting with few or no errors.