Business & Finance assignment
Rubric - Argumentative Essay (30%)
GSBS6001: Managing Under Uncertainty
|
CRITERIA |
MARKS 30 |
|
Content Understanding of relevant issues. Awareness of relevant ideas and arguments. Wide reading of the literature.
|
6 |
|
Argument Points clearly related to one another. Interpretation and analysis, not just description. Covers multiple sides of argument.
|
8 |
|
Structure Introduction is clear, showing direction of argument. Body is cohesive, with sequence of relevant paragraph-based points. Conclusion follows logically and relevantly from argument.
|
8 |
|
Writing Clear, exact, easily readable, and concise.
|
4 |
|
Referencing Proper use of references as needed. Accurate format using APA 7th.
|
4 |
|
TOTAL MARKS |
30 |
|
CRITERIA |
FAIL Significantly incomplete answer |
PASS Partly complete answer |
CREDIT Mostly complete answer |
DISTINCTION Significantly complete answer |
HIGH DISTINCTION Complete answer |
MARKS 30 |
|
Content
|
Does not consider relevant issues. Misunderstands or ignores ideas. Little or no use of literature.
|
Identifies relevant issues. Acknowledges relevant ideas. Narrow use of literature. |
Understands relevant issues. Aware of relevant ideas. Some variety in use of literature. |
Engages with relevant issues. Uses and connects relevant ideas. Uses literature with fair variety and quality. |
Critically engages with relevant issues. Critically uses relevant ideas. Uses varied, high-quality literature. |
6 |
|
Argument
|
Variety of points but unconnected. Mostly descriptive – no analysis. Deeply partial or biased. |
Points in generally reasonable order, but order not made explicit. Some attempt at analysis. Recognises multiple sides. |
Order of points is clear. Analyses evidence and arguments. Examines multiple sides. |
Order of points clear and logical. Analyses evidence and arguments to develop own insights. Synthesises multiple sides. |
Order of points clear, logical and intuitive. Analyses and synthesises multiple arguments as basis of own insights. |
8 |
|
Structure
|
No introduction/ conclusion. No obvious topic sentences, or paragraphs not clearly making one point each. |
Introduction and conclusion. One point in each paragraph. |
Introduction and conclusion with matching thesis statements. 1 point/paragraph with appropriate topic sentences. |
Introduction and conclusion with matching thesis statements and summary. 1 point/paragraph with effective topic sentences. |
Introduction and conclusion with matching thesis statements and summary. 1 point/paragraph with effective, succinct topic sentences. |
8 |
|
Writing
|
Writing style makes argument hard to follow.
|
Writing can be followed and understood. |
Writing can be followed without effort. |
Writing makes argument clear and recognisable. |
Writing makes argument clear and precise. |
4 |
|
Referencing
|
All inaccurate or very inconsistent.
|
Mostly inaccurate. Often not used when needed. |
Partly inaccurate. Sometimes not used when needed. |
Mostly accurate. All references used when needed. |
Complete and perfectly accurate, both in-text and in reference list. |
4 |
|
TOTAL MARKS |
30 |