Research Critique

Breeee3
ResearchCritiqueinstructions1.docx

Research report critique essay (100 points). In the last week, you need to use LU library or Google Scholar to find an article from a journal in communication or a related area that interests you. The article must be about a study or studies that collect and analyze data, either qualitative or quantitative (review or commentary articles does not fall in this category). Alternatively you can critique any one of the articles provided by the instructor (see articles in separate folder)

Read the article carefully, and write a 2-3 page critique essay (double-spaced, with 12-point times new roman and 1-inch margins all around) about the article. While this article critique is due in the last week, it is highly recommended to start working on it early on. Your critical essay should address the following questions:

1. Provide a complete APA citation of the article (Title, authors, journal, volume, year, and pages)

2. What are the questions(hypotheses) that the study(s) in the article try(s) to test?

3. Is the significance of those questions/hypotheses solidly elaborated in the review of the literature?

4. What are the major theories/concepts that it examines (be sure to briefly explain the theory)

5. What research method(s) is(are) used to collect data and test the questions/hypotheses? Are those research methods appropriate for those questions/hypotheses? Can you think of better or other equally good methods to collect data and test those questions/hypotheses?

6. What are the strengths and weakness of the research methods used in the study? Are those methods applied appropriately? Any place can be improved?

7. Anything interesting covered in the discussion part? What does the author say is the major contribution of the study?

8. Methodologically, what are the three takeaways you learned from this article? What are the three things you would improve if you were the author(s)?