Research Paper Analysis
PSYC3320 (A11) Research Paper Analysis – Rubric
Pg. 1 of 2
Question 0 pt 1 pt 2 pt 3 pt 4 pt
1 Incorrect or absent Presents a reasonable new title that is declarative (i.e., states the results of the study)
+ Rationale is based on specific findings from the study. Demonstrates some improvement in title.
--- ---
2 Limited description of methods used. Demonstrates minimal understanding of methodology. Writing difficult to understand, lacking organization, and/or excessively technical.
Minor inaccuracies in description of methodology. Evidence of some gaps in understanding of the methodology. Writing is limited by disorganization, excessively technical style and/or jargon.
Describes all aspects of methodology are described. Demonstrates thorough understanding of the paradigm, timeline, etc. Writing is clear and relatable.
--- ---
3 Incorrect or absent Limited description of figure. Demonstrates minimal understanding of result(s). Writing difficult to understand, lacking organization and/or excessively technical.
Missing description of x-axis, y-axis, main result, and/or take- home message. Shows moderate understanding of the result(s). Language lacks clarity or is too technical.
Missing description of x-axis, y-axis, main result, or take- home message. Evidence of some gaps in understanding of the result. Writing shows minor issues with clarity and/or accessibility.
Defines x and y axis. Describes main result clearly and succinctly. “Take-home message” captures the essence of the finding. Writing is clear and appropriate for lay audience.
4 Incorrect or absent Selects an appropriate main finding. Alternative explanation is implausible, inadequately considered, and/or not scientifically-based.
Selects an appropriate main finding. Alternative explanation is plausible, well- considered, and rooted in science.
--- ---
PSYC3320 (A11) Research Paper Analysis – Rubric
Pg. 2 of 2
5 Incorrect or absent Selects an appropriate main finding. Makes a vague or superficial connection to course material. Shows limited understanding of both the paper and related course material.
Selects an appropriate main finding. Makes a thoughtful, well- reasoned connection to course material. Shows strong understanding of both the paper and related course materials.
--- ---
6 Incorrect or absent. Implications are implausible, generic, and/or do not follow from the results.
Demonstrates clear understanding of the overall significance of the findings. Well-considered real-world application or explanation of everyday phenomenon. Strong connection to study results.
Well-considered real- world application or explanation of everyday phenomenon. Strong connection to study results. Demonstrates clear understanding of the overall significance of the findings.
--- ---