Practicum 4

INSTRUCTIONS: Student submits a pdf or a link to the article reviewed and it is scholarly in nature.

ii. Article review includes all required sections per the guidelines of the publisher. Guidelines from publisher are supplied when they are utilized. If the generic review form is used in place of publisher recommendations, the report evaluates all components including the following: Introduction, Background/Literature Support, Methodology, Results, Discussion, Bibliography/References, Problem statement identified, population specified, other key factors noted, Decision, Originality (Contribution To The Field, Technical Quality, Clarity Of Presentation, Depth Of Research/Content), Recommendations

If you chose this option for your assignment, review an article published in a peer reviewed healthcare journal- evaluate the article using criteria in the journal set aside for author submission. Complete the review using the format provided in the template below.

Review form -

Reviewer’s Information

Title:

First Name:

Last Name:

Specialization:

Manuscript Information

Title:

Date Published:

Evaluation Report

Kindly enter evaluation criteria ment in a commentary format for each section below.  If not included in the article, please indicate.  Also specify if information exempt was needed.

Introduction:
Background/Literature Support:
Methodology:
Results:
Discussion:
Bibliography/References:
Problem statement identified, population specified, other key factors noted:
Decision:

Please rate the following: (1 = Excellent) (2 = Good) (3 = Fair) (4 = poor)

Originality:
Contribution To The Field:
Technical Quality:
Clarity Of Presentation :
Depth Of Research/Content:

Recommendation

Please mark with an X below

Accept As Is:
Requires Minor Corrections:
Requires Moderate Revision:
Requires Major Revision:
Submit To Another Publication Such As:
Reject on grounds of (Please be specific)

Additional Comments

Please add any additional comments: