Project Draft
1
The ATF and the Branch Davidians
Research Paper
The ATF and the Branch Davidians
The US departments of Alcohol, Tobacco, and Firearms (ATF) launched a raid at Mount Carmel in Waco, Texas. The raid was done against a religious cult called the Branch Davidians and its purpose was to investigate any possession of explosions and firearms. When the ATF agents tried to enter the compound, gunfire started, resulting in a prolonged confrontation between the Davidian members and the ATF agents. The confrontation between the two parties resulted in injuries and four federal agents being killed. Following the unsuccessful ATF raid, tear-gas assault on the compound was approved. On April 19th, 1993, the Branch Davidians were asked to surrender. However, the compound was set on fire and more than seventy people died. The operation involved over 100 agents from the ATF and it is one of the largest to be taken by the bureau resulting in the largest number of casualties.
How the Branch Davidians cult started
David Koresh was born in 1959, Texas. Later in 1981, he joined a Branch of the Seventh-day Adventist church that was named the Branch Davidians. The seventh day Adventist was started in 1934 by Victor Houteff, a Bulgarian immigrant. Since Koresh had an exhaustive understanding of the Bible scriptures, he rose rapidly within the hierarchy of the religious organization, and eventually, an influence struggle began between Koresh and the son George Roden (Wright, 2019). Since Koresh was not satisfied with his authority within the organization, he went back together with his followers in eastern Texas. But decided to return in 1987 with armed followers to raid the compound. During the raid, he critically wounded Roden. He and his followers were sent for trial for attempted murder, however, the charges were dropped as the leaders declared his case a ministerial endeavor.
Towards the end of 1990, he became the leader of the Branch Davidians and used legal means to change his name to David Koresh successfully. The name David represented his religious status as the head of a biblical house while Koresh stood for Cyrus (Hebrew name). After taking leadership of the religious organization, Koresh took multiple wives to the compound and fathered over 12 children from each wife. Some wives were as young as 12 years when he made them pregnant (Dawes, 2020). There is also evidence that he punished most of the Branch Davidian members harshly. Members who were punished harshly were his children and believe that was a vital aspect of his religious teachings. Another important assertion of his religious teachings was that the apocalyptic events said in the book of revelation were bound to happen and the Branch Davidian members were supposed to stock explosives and firearms in preparation. The intensity of the cult activities attracted the attention of both media and law enforcers.
The Raid
The operations started when law enforcers started to investigate the activities that took place in the compound. The operation took place between February 28 and April 19, 1993. David Koresh led the Branch Davidians to resist the raid. The purpose of the raid was to investigate the allegations of the stockpiling of firearms illegally. The situation escalated when the ATF tried to serve an arrest and search warrant on the compound. Following the resistance, an intense gunfight started leading to the death of six Branch Davidians and four government officials. When the ATF officials entered the compound and failed to implement the search warrant, the federal bureau of investigation brought the property under siege that lasted for 51 days (Battal, 2016).
The newly appointed attorney general, Janet Reno, approved recommendations from the hostage team that had been surrounding the Branch Davidians compound. The recommendations said that the conditions were getting worse and more children were being mistreated and abused sexually. Reno forwarded the recommendations to President Clinton at that time. She convinced the president that the rescue team was tired of waiting and the standoff was becoming more costly. Additionally, she made him understand that mass suicide and child sexual abuse were imminent. Eventually, the federal bureau of investigations launched an attack coupled with tear gas in an attempt to get the Branch Davidian members out of the property. Following the FBI’s assault, the whole of Mount Carmel center was surrounded by flames. The fire led to the death of more than 70 members of the Branch Davidians including David Koresh.
The activities of the siege have been disputed by various sources. One controversy that surrounded the siege concerns the source of the fire. An investigation carried out by the justice department concluded that the FBI agents used tear gas and the fire was set by Davidian members. The activities of the Branch Davidians came into the spotlight when a publication called the Waco Tribune-Herald published a series of articles called “the sinful messiah.” The articles reported claims that Koresh was physically abusing children in his compound by taking underage girls to be his wives. The articles also claimed that Koresh advocated for polygamy by declaring himself a man married to multiple wives. Additionally, the article claimed that Koresh has said that he is entitled to over 140 wives. The investigations became more serious when a package was reported to have broken open on its delivery to the compound revealing grenade casings, firearms, and black powder.
How the ATF and FBI Changed after the Waco Siege Event
Some of the ways the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives (ATF) and the Federal Bureau of Investigations (FBI) changed after the Waco siege event include; the two agencies became better equipped in terms of resources needed for such events. During the Waco siege, agents did not have enough helmets and gun belts. That is why most of them did not fire any shots during the raid. Therefore, this brought the agency better equipped to avoid a crisis in the future. Besides, the Waco event called for proper training of ATF and FBI agents to ensure efficiency in the next raid. After Waco, the ATF invested in tactical equipment and improved weapons systems, along with training on using tear gas and automatic weapons.
The agency also standardized training across the board (Wilson, 2018). Besides, there was an improvement in communication for the FBI. A Critical Response Group was implemented to ensure prompt communication when it came to negotiations and collaboration between teams in critical situations like the Waco siege. The agents were not on the same page when it came to communication during the siege and this is one of the things that contributed to the failure of the operation which claimed the lives of 76 Branch Davidians and four agents. The various agents should work to understand one another’s roles and capabilities so they can function alongside each other during complex and time-sensitive responses to critical incidents (Wilson, 2018). There were also new policies that were put in place to ensure that what happened during the Waco siege would not happen again. These policies included, agents having the correct intelligence before a raid and when the use of military-style tactics should be applied.
Conclusion
Based on the several evaluations on what could have really happened between the ATF and the Branch Davidians, under the circumstances, considering how David Koresh was being uncooperative, the FBI handled the raid with really outstanding professionalism. His hunger for power is what led to the killing of some of his followers. Had he been cooperative the loss of the many lives could have been avoided. Thus, if the ATF and the FBI had not applied military-style tactics in the operation such as using tear gas which is believed to have been the cause of the fire, David Koresh and his followers could have overpowered the ATF and more lives could have been lost. Nevertheless, the influence of David Koresh over his followers was unbreakable and this forced the FBI and ATF to react violently. It is possible that the raid taking up to 51 days could have been David Koresh’s plan. However, he could have been charged for the attempted murder of his partner and marrying minors. Such actions show the impact religion has on people when it comes to justice. Religion scholars argued that the FBI’s impatience at Waco grew out of theological ignorance and unquestioned assumptions.
References
Battal, E. (2016). Dying and/or Killing for the Faith: New Religious Movements and Violence. Insan ve Toplum, 6(1).
David Koresh | Waco - The Inside Story | FRONTLINE | PBS. (2014). Pbs.org. https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/waco/davidkoresh.html
Dawes, J. (2020). Revisiting Waco and the Branch Davidiansidiansidian Tragedy. In Dark Tourism in the American West (pp. 41-65). Palgrave Macmillan, Cham.
History.com Editors. (2010, February 9). ATF raids Branch Davidian compound. HISTORY. https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/atf-raids-branch-davidian-compound
Remembering Waco | Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives. (2019). Atf.Gov. https://www.atf.gov/our-history/remembering-waco
Wilson, M. (n.d.). How failures during the Waco siege changed everything for the FBI, ATF. Austin American-Statesman. https://www.statesman.com/news/20180419/how-failures-during-the-waco-siege-changed-everything-for-the-fbi-atf
Wright, S. A. (2019). Media Review Waco after Twenty-five Years: Media Reconstructions of the Federal Siege of the Branch Davidians. Nova Religio: The Journal of Alternative and Emergent Religions, 22(3), 108-120.