project management course project
Project Proposal. BBA222. Project Management. 13537. Rubrics Mohamed_Abbas_Aly_Hegazy
MARKS MARKS
OBTAINED FEEDBACK
Knowledge & Understanding 20% 48,75 Business Strategy (Vision, Mission, Values, Goal, Objectives, Challenges)
5% 75 Good level of understanding and knowledge regarding business strategy concepts.
Project Pre-Assessment and Assessment 5% 40 Poor knowledge and understanding of the project assessment process
Project Charter 10% 40 Some of the concepts regarding project definition, triple constraint and project parameters are not clear.
Application 30% 36,5
Identification of the vision, mission and values of the company. What is its goal and objectives? In your opinion, what are the most important challenges that the company will face short- medium term (in the next 3-4 years)?
5 4 Good application of the concepts of business strategy
At least 10 projects ideas that the company could carry out during a short-medium term (in the next 3-4 years) are proposed. The project ideas are aligned with the strategy of the company and their current and possible future challenges.
5 3,5 Some of the described projects are actually business funcional strategies (e.g. Prioritizing on sales and marketing, Attracting and retaining employees…)
A Project Pre-Assessment has been carried out. 5 from the 10 pre-selected projects are chosen
10 5 Only 5 projects have been analyzed using the pre-assessment.
A Project Assessment has been carried out using a Qualitative Analysis. 1 from the 5 project candidates is chosen
10 0 No Qualitative Analysis has been presented.
PROJECT CONTEXT, DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION 12 8 No project context presented. Good project description and justification
PROJECT STRATEGY (Project Goal, Project Objectives and Critical Success Factors)
10 5 Poor definition of goal, objectives and CSF. Objectives are not SMART
TRIPLE CONSTRAINT: PROJECT SCOPE (Requirements and Deliverables), PROJECT TIME and PROJECT COSTS
18 6 Poor definition of requirements and deliverables. Project Time is clear, but without explaining the most important phases of the project. Project cost is not clear
PROJECT PARAMETERS (Assumptions, Constraints, High- level risks, resources and Stakeholders)
30 5 Poor definition of the project parameters
Critical Thinking 30% 47,5 Business Strategy (Vision, Mission, Values, Goal, Objectives, Challenges)
7,5% 60 Good analysis of the business strategy but without any reliable sources to justify the exposed arguments.
Project Pre-Assessment and Assessment 7,5% 70 Good arguments but lack of reliable sources to support them
Project Charter 15% 30 No sources to justify the project definition. Arguments are weak. At the end, is not clear what will be done, how much is going to cost and what are the most important parameters that need to be considered.
Communication 20% 88,5 Clarity in the communication of ideas 14% 90 Ideas are mostly expressed in a
clear way.
Respect of word count, grammar and spellcheck 2% 90 Very good
Format of the document 2% 90 Very good meeting of the formalities (Cover page, table of contents and bibliography)
Use of reliable sources and references in HRS 2% 75 Good use of reliable sources
FINAL GRADE 53
PROJECT GENERATION & SELECTION
THE PROJECT CHARTER