Discussion - Module 10
Incremental or Discontinuous Innovation MBA 580
By: Johnathon Blake Davis
Option A and B
Business problem: Connected cars will become of greater demand in the future.
Option A: Incremental Innovation
Option B: Discontinuous Innovation
Option A
Two benefits of option A:
Increase product diversification
Protect the current business model
Two risks of option A:
Lack of coordination
Time risk/reward related to demand
Option B
Two benefits of option B:
- Securing the competitive advantage
Increased market share/profitability
Two risks of option B:
Unknown demand of the new product
Production cost that could potentially outweigh profit
Competitors
BMW: navigation, emergency services, smart house connectivity
Functionality emphasis: vehicle control/safety, IFTTT-customized applications and IoT connectivity, LTE
Toyota: navigation, emergency services, social media
Functionality emphasis: vehicle control, social media, safety, entertainment, navigation, 5G
Volkswagen: navigation, emergency services, consumer orders, maintenance status
Functionality emphasis: vehicle control, maintenance, in-car consumer experience
Competitors
BMW: Projection of fully autonomous vehicles in the next 12 years.
-5-10-year plan: fully integrated information system, semi-autonomous driving, connection to traffic information systems, introduction of fully autonomous driving early 2030s
Toyota: Social media in Japan and expectation of of implementing in US markets with 5G capability.
-5-10-year plan: fully integrated information system; semi-autonomous driving; connection to traffic information systems, expanded social media, and communications; consumer services; maintenance; fully autonomous vehicle early 2030s
Volkswagen: Same forecast as us. They have partnered with Microsoft to try and ease ahead of competition.
-5-10-year plan: fully integrated information system; semi-autonomous driving; connection to traffic information systems; connectivity with smart home; fully autonomous vehicle early 2030s
Partial Gap Analysis
We have some connectivity regarding the technology – driver apps, OnStar, detect accidents, and alert first responders. Most of the technology will need to be purchased to gain market share.
The 10 best automotive technologies of 2021: Advanced driver assistance, emergency braking, mobile app connection, teen driver, exit warnings, wireless charging, 360-degree camera, video rearview mirror, stole vehicle software, blind-spot monitor (https://www.kbb.com/awards/best-car-technologies/)
Partial Gap Analysis
Available for purchase:
Wireless charging
360-degree camera
Video rearview mirror
Navigation
Wireless Bluetooth connectivity
Parking sensors
Push to start button
Vehicle start from remote key
Apple Carplay
Innovation Approach
The Incremental Innovation approach would be the best option for the company moving forward.
Reason 1: Introducing a new product into the automotive industry isn’t a good idea.
Reason 2: The reward outweighs the risk.
Sales forecast/financial snapshot
Sales:
Gross Margin:
Option A - Sales
Sales Traditional 183.29999999999998 188.71249999999998 194.26526789999994 199.95984500569995 205.79753408935821 211.77936279123503 217.90604290767092 224.17792513444687 230.59494878970997 237.15658599184798 244.08999999999997 Sales Connected 3.8 4.1 875999999999998 5.2344999999999997 5.7684189999999997 7.2105237500000001 9.0131546875000002 11.266443359375 14.083054199218751 17.603817749023438 22.004772186279297 27.505965232849121
Option A - Gross Margin
Gross Margin Traditional 27.494999999999997 28.306874999999994 29.139790184999988 29.993976750854991 30.86963011340373 31.766904418685254 32.685906436150638 33.626688770167029 34.589242318456492 35.573487898777195 36.613499999999995 Gross Margin Connected 0.79799999999999993 0.87939599999999996 1.0992449999999998 1.2113679899999998 1.5142099874999999 1.892762484 3749999 2.3659531054687499 2.9574413818359373 3.6968017272949218 4.6210021591186523 5.7762526988983156
References
January 1, 2021. KBB Editors. https://www.kbb.com/awards/best-car-technologies/
Carroll, Andrew. Oct 23, 2019. https://innotechtoday.com/top-10-connected-car-features/
Hard, Andew. Nov 19, 2017. https://www.digitaltrends.com/cars/10-car-technologies-to-be-thankful-for/