Discussion Board
Of the People
McGerr, Lewis, Oakes, Cullather, Summers, Townsend, Dunak
© 2018
Volume II
Since 1865
© 2018
Chapter 17 The Culture and Politics of Industrial America 1870—1892
© 2018
Protestors Outside an Ohio Saloon
Chapter 17 American Portrait: Luna Kellie and the Farmers’ Alliance
Dreamed of life on a farm
Barely scraped by
Farmers’ Alliance was popular with women
Cooperative enterprise
Became state secretary
Populist Party
© 2018
The Elusive Boundaries of Male and Female
© 2018
Anthony Comstock Crediting himself with 4,000 arrests and destroying 400,000 pictures, New York’s most notorious vice crusader showed how active governments could be, in the so-called era of laissez-faire, against views that middle-class moralists found objectionable.
The Victorian Construction of Male and Female
Females were inferior, undeveloped males
After 1750, the idea of “opposite” sexes
Men were active, competitive, providers
Rational, insistent sexual drives
Women were frail, cooperative, needed protecting, lacked sexuality
Role of medical profession in reproduction
© 2018
The Victorian Crusade for Morality
Cities broke down traditional morality
Anthony Comstock, Society for the Suppression of Vice
Pornography, contraception, abortion
Abortion, contraception were illegal but still accessible
Prostitution remained common
© 2018
Urban Culture
Reflected social changes
Culture reflected nostalgia for the past
Buffalo Bill, Uncle Remus
Electricity led to the growth of nightlife
Idealization of sensuality
© 2018
Houses of Prostitution
© 2018
Houses of Prostitution, 1850–1859 and 1900–1909 One measure of the sexual freedom characteristic of city life was the explosive increase in prostitution. As the demand for prostitution rose, so did attempts to suppress it.
Source: Timothy J. Gilfoyle, City of Eros (New York: W. W. Norton, 1992), p. 33.
Growth of the Nonfarm Sector
© 2018
Growth of the Nonfarm Sector Underpinning the rise of urban culture was the emergence of a wage-earning labor force. Concentrated in cities, wage earners had cash at their disposal to spend on the amusements cities had to offer.
A New Cultural Order: New Americans Stir Old Fears
© 2018
Immigrants Immigrants often crowded into “tenements,” a new form of apartment building that actually improved living conditions for many of America’s poor city dwellers.
Josiah Strong Attacks Immigration
Our Country
Anglo Saxon strengths are love of liberty, spiritual Christianity
Immigrants were a threat to Anglo-Saxon America
Peasants, Catholics
Social Gospel
© 2018
Foreign Birth by Region
© 2018
Population of Foreign Birth by Region, 1880
Source: Clifford L. Lord and Elizabeth H. Lord, Lord & Lord Historical Atlas of the United States (New York: Holt,1953).
From Immigrants to Ethnic Americans
Loyalties were local, not national
Immigrants’ regional differences faded into nationalism
Fraternal organizations, mutual aid societies
© 2018
The Catholic Church and Its Limits in Immigrant Culture
Churches eased transition into American life
Sped development of ethnic identities
Full rituals, mass in European languages
Catholic leaders worked to standardize rituals, ceremonies
Parochial school systems
© 2018
Immigrant Cultures
Music, theater adjusted to New World expectations
Families were large
Infant mortality was high
Children’s earnings helped families
© 2018
The Enemy at the Gates
Social transformation was difficult
Diversity
Rise of nativism
Chinese exclusion act, 1882
Fight against Tammany Hall
American Protective Association
Impact of social Darwinism
© 2018
Two Political Styles
© 2018
As the Number of Immigrants to America Swelled, So Did Opposition to Them This 1891 cartoon blames immigration for causing a host of social and political evils.
The Triumph of Party Politics
Party line voting
Intimidation and corruption
Resurrectionists, colonizers, purchase caters
Voter turnout was high
Newspapers were partisan
Campaign spectacle
© 2018
Eligible Voters Casting Ballots
© 2018
Percent of Eligible Voters Casting Ballots Between 1840 and 1896, a huge proportion— often 80 percent—of those eligible to vote did so in presidential elections. In the twentieth century, turnout dropped substantially.
Masculine Partisanship and Feminine Voluntarism
Voting was part of man’s sphere, public
Women belonged in the private sphere
Decorated meeting halls, prepared foods, participated in parades
Moral reform movements gave women a political outlet
Education and lobbying
© 2018
The Women’s Christian Temperance Union
Frances Willard
Rallies, speeches, articles, books
Endorsed women’s suffrage, allied with labor unions
Drunkenness as public health issue
Middle class movement
© 2018
The Critics of Popular Politics
Liberals challenged the party-run state
Gov’t by professionals, independent agencies
Nonpartisan secret ballot
Civil Service Commission
© 2018
Struggles for Democracy
The “Crusade” Against Alcohol
Women pushed to end liquor sales
Temperance saloons
YMCA
Sunday schools
Change took political action
© 2018
© 2018
Economic Issues Dominate National Politics
© 2018
Greenbacks and Greenbackers
Gold standard
Greenbackers wanted to issue paper money backed by gov’t, not gold
Coinage Act of 1873 shifted to gold
Inflation benefited bankers, hurt farmers
Greenback-Labor Party
Resumption
© 2018
Weak Presidents Oversee a Stronger Federal Government
Questions about election of Hayes
Assassination of Garfield led to civil service reform
Arthur, Pendleton Civil Service Act
Grover Cleveland, fight over the tariff
Benjamin Harrison, protectionism
Sherman Anti-Trust Act, 1890
© 2018
The Election of 1888
© 2018
The Election of 1888 With the Solid South locked up, Democrats only needed two of the biggest northern states to win. They failed this year—just barely. But for Republicans, it was a wake-up call: either they must admit enough new states to pack the Electoral College their way or they must pass a law protecting a free, fair vote down South.
America and the World
Foreign Policy: The Limited Significance of Commercial Expansion
Seward, expansion of American commerce
Growth in exports
Investment abroad—Mexico
Reciprocity
Mix of economic interest, mission to spread democracy created more assertiveness
American overthrow of Hawaiian gov’t
© 2018
© 2018
Government Activism and Its Limits
© 2018
Kansas Farm Families on the Road to a People’s Party Gathering In a state usually locked up for the GOP, the farmer’s revolt revived political competition and an evangelical passion about issues absent since the Civil War.
States Discover Activism
Power of corporate lobbyists
Gov’t power expanded
Corporate taxes went up, public school systems expanded
Food safety laws
National holidays
Protectionist legislation
© 2018
Cities: Boss Rule and New Responsibilities
Political machines expanded services, jobs
Traded them for votes
Money came from shakedowns and graft
Scandals and abuse
Authority was taken from elected officials, given to experts and specialists
Reformers
© 2018
Challenging the New Industrial Order
© 2018
John F. Weir’s 1877 Painting Forging the Shaft: A Welding Heat This painting graphically depicts the forms of industrial wage labor that Henry George feared. He advocated tax policies that would restore a Jeffersonian economy of small, independent producers.
Henry George and the Limits of Producers’ Ideology
Progress and Poverty
Only human labor creates legitimate wealth
Money made from money is illegitimate
Producers and predators
Tax on rents to discourage landowning classes
Challenged socialism, social Darwinism
© 2018
Edward Bellamy and the Nationalist Clubs
Looking Backward
Progress came through cooperation
Overcoming excessive individualism
Imagined a high tech future
Centralized planning that avoided the whims of the market
© 2018
Agrarian Revolt
Global economy produced competition
Debt for agricultural equipment, railroad shipping
The Grange, collective storage
Farmers’ Alliance
Concentrated in the South and West
Ocala Platform: free silver, lower tariffs, subtreasuries, direct election of senators, publicly owned infrastructure
© 2018
The Rise of the Populists
Formed by a coalition of reform organizations
Omaha Platform
Inflationary currency policy, subtreasury system, graduated income tax, national ownership of infrastructure
Secret ballot, popular election of senators
Working class coalition lacked industrial workers
Racial split in the South
© 2018