RUA Group
NR449 Evidence-Based Practice
Matrix Table RUA: Analyzing Published Research
NR449_Matrix_Table_RUA_Analyzing_Published_Research_JUL24 © 2024 Chamberlain University. All Rights Reserved 1
Evidence Matrix Table
ARTICLE
REFERENCES
PURPOSE HYPOTHESIS
STUDY QUESTION(S)
STUDY VARIABLES STUDY DESIGN
SAMPLE SIZE &
SELECTION
DATA COLLECTIO
N METHODS
MAJOR FINDING(S)
1 (SAMPLE ARTICLE)
Smith, L. (2013). What should I eat? A focus for those living with
diabetes. Journal of Nursing Education, 1 (4) 111-112.
How do educational support
groups effect dietary modifications in patients with diabetes?
D-Dietary
modifications I-Education
Qualitative N- 18 Convenience sample-selected
from local support group in Pittsburgh, PA
Focus Groups Support and education
improved compliance with dietary modifications.
1-ABBY Yanke, E., Moriarty, H., Carayon, P., & Safdar, N. (2021). “The Invisible Staff”: A qualitative analysis of environmental service workers’ perceptions of the VA Clostridium difficile prevention bundle using a human factors engineering approach. Journal of Patient Safety, 17(8), e806–e814.
To explore environmental service workers’ perceptions of the barriers and facilitators that influence adherence to the Veterans Affairs C. difficile prevention bundle using the SEIPS human factors model.
Qualitative themes, not variables
Qualitative descriptive study using a focus group; SEIPS human factors engineering framework.
N=7 Convenience sample Recruited from a single VA medical center
60-minute focus groups audio recorded.
-ESWs had strong knowledge of CDI hand hygiene requirements. -Barriers included inadequate space, difficulty enforcing visitor PPE adherence, interruptions while cleaning, and discomfort correcting physicians. -Facilitators included adequate supplies, supportive supervisors, clear cleaning protocols, and strong work ethic.
2-ABBY Banks, M., & Phillips, A. B. (2021). Evaluating the effect of automated hand hygiene technology on compliance and C. difficile rates in a
To evaluate whether implementing automated hand-hygiene monitoring technology increases staff compliance and reduces C. difficile infection rates in a
Independent Variable: Introduction of automated hand-hygiene technology
Non- randomized pre/post interventio n study (12 months pre- implementa
All clinical staff during study 3,778,830 monitor- captured Hand hygiene moments
Automated sensor system results
-Hand Hygiene compliance significantly increased from 89.82% to 97.10% -C. difficile incidence significantly decreased
NR449 Evidence-Based Practice
Matrix Table RUA: Analyzing Published Research
NR449_Matrix_Table_RUA_Analyzing_Published_Research_JUL24 © 2024 Chamberlain University. All Rights Reserved 2
long-term acute care hospital. American Journal of Infection Control, 49, 727–732
long-term acute care hospital.
Dependent Variables: Hand Hygiene compliance, C. Diff infection incidence,
tion vs. 12 months post- implementa tion).
from 9.54 to 3.72 per period -Technology identified far more hand hygiene opportunities than traditional hand-audit observation. -Alcohol-based sanitizer consumption more than doubled.
3 LYDIA- TILACIOU
Comparcini, D.,
Simonetti, V.,
Segala, F. V., Di
Gennaro, F.,
Bavaro, D. F.,
Pompeo, M. A.,
Saracino, A., &
Cicolini, G. (2023).
Nurses’ knowledge,
attitudes and
practices on the
management of
Clostridioides
difficile infection: A
cross-sectional
study. Antibiotics,
12(3), 529.
https://doi.org/10.33
90/antibiotics12030 529
To evaluate nurses’
knowledge, attitudes, and
practices regarding
Clostridioides Difficile
Infection management and prevention.
Higher levels of
Clostridioides Difficile
Infection-related
knowledge among nurses
are associated with better
infection-prevention
practices.
What are nurses’
knowledge levels,
attitudes, and clinical
practices related to
Clostridioides Difficile
Independent
Variable:
Knowledge/atti
tudes.
Dependent Variable:
Infection-
prevention
clinical
practices
(including hand
hygiene and
contact
precautions).
Quantitati
ve cross- sectional
design.
424 registered
nurses
recruited via
convenience
sampling from three
hospitals in
Italy.
Self-
administe
red online
questionn
aire assessing
knowledg
e,
attitudes,
and
practices;
analyzed
using
descriptiv
e and
inferential
statistics.
Nurses demonstrated strong awareness of Clostridioides Difficile Infection risks but insufficient understanding of correct disinfection procedures and optimal hand hygiene timing. Higher knowledge scores were associated with significantly better infection-control practices (p < 0.05). Authors recommended targeted education programs to raise compliance and reduce Clostridioides
NR449 Evidence-Based Practice
Matrix Table RUA: Analyzing Published Research
NR449_Matrix_Table_RUA_Analyzing_Published_Research_JUL24 © 2024 Chamberlain University. All Rights Reserved 3
Infection prevention and
management?
Difficile Infection transmission.
4 LYDIA- TILACIOU
S
Lev, V., Anbarchian, T., Yao, H., Bhat, A., Britt, P., & Shieh, L. (2024). Health care–associated Clostridioides difficile infection: Learning the perspectives of health care workers to build successful strategies. American Journal of Infection Control, 52(3), 284–292. https://doi.org/10.1 016/j.ajic.2023.08.0 08
To explore healthcare
workers’ perspectives,
barriers, and facilitators
associated with
preventing healthcare-
associated C. difficile
infections.
Healthcare worker
insights can guide the
development of more
effective Clostridioides
Difficile Infection
Prevention strategies.
What barriers and facilitators do healthcare workers identify regarding Clostridioides Difficile Infection prevention efforts?
Qualitative study — variables not isolated/quanti fied; themes included communication , environmental cleaning, hand hygiene, and workflow factors.
Qualitative descriptive
study using semi- structured interviews.
45 healthcare workers
(nurses, physicians, EVS, infection preventionists ) recruited through purposive sampling in a large academic medical center.
Audio- recorded interviews transcribe d verbatim; thematic analysis conducte d by two independ ent coders.
Inconsistent hand hygiene, staffing shortages, unclear Clostridioides, Difficile Infection protocols, and insufficient interdepartmental communication were major barriers. Participants noted that reinforcing hand hygiene practices, improving workflow, and providing targeted education can reduce Clostridioides Difficile Infection rates.
5-NICOLE
6-NICOLE
7-OLIVIA 8-OLIVIA
9-
AISSATA
10-
AISSATA
NR449 Evidence-Based Practice
Matrix Table RUA: Analyzing Published Research
NR449_Matrix_Table_RUA_Analyzing_Published_Research_JUL24 © 2024 Chamberlain University. All Rights Reserved 4
11-TRACY
12- TRACY