Justifications of poets
Lesson 12: Confessional Poetry As we move into the post-World War II era, we’ll start with another lesson on poetry. But don’t worry! Poetry after the 1920s is generally way more accessible and straightforward than The Waste Land or Hugh Selwyn Mauberley. Gone is fragmentation, juxtaposition, and allusion. (Good riddance!). Instead, poetry tends to be confessional, with writers exposing their innermost thoughts and feelings almost as if the reader were a therapist. Before we get into the specific readings, though, let’s define the era we’re entering.
Postmodernism (1950-1990)
CONTENT
Identity politics Games & puzzles Absurdity & coincidence History is a form of narrative and thus indistinct from fiction Media is omnipresent Embraces popular culture
STYLE
Narrative (surface over depth) Reinstitutes authorial presence
metafiction present tense direct addresses
EFFECT
Challenges the authority of aesthetic traditions; insists that values are “local” or “historical”
Texts are part of culture Erodes the distinction between high & low culture; is populist
CONTEXT
post-WWII affluence logic of late capitalism media culture abstraction of values & institutionalization of irony
(A good illustration of postmodernism: on the left is Salvador Dali’s The Persistence of Memory from 1931, a surrealist piece dramatizing the dream-like un-reality of life. On the right is a takeoff on the painting from The Simpsons, in which pop culture images replace the symbols of time)
The main thing we should remember about postmodernism that is it reintroduces those elements of storytelling or communication that the modernists took out. Remember we said that the main function for modernism was to fragment stories, to break down the causality implied in a beginning, middle, and end. While postmodernism doesn’t reinstitute that linearity, it does reestablish contact with the reader, whether through direct addresses (we’ve come full circle!) or through a straightforward presentation. In other words,
postmodernists try to engage the common, everyday reader by giving us a vision of the absurdity and alienation of everyday life in the post WWII era. Often, the literature critiques the prosperity and affluence of our age, claiming that it has spiritually deadened us. For this lesson in particular, here’s a good basic definition of what we mean by “confessional poetry”: The confessional poetry of the mid-twentieth century dealt with subject matter that previously had not been openly discussed in American poetry. Private experiences with and feelings about death, trauma, depression and relationships were addressed in this type of poetry, often in an autobiographical manner. The confessional poets were not merely recording their emotions on paper; craft and construction were extremely important to their work. While their treatment of the poetic self may have been groundbreaking and shocking to some readers, these poets maintained a high level of craftsmanship through their careful attention to and use of prosody. Because our discussion question for this lesson asks you to rank the poets from least to most confessional, I’m going to go over them in alphabetical order: Elizabeth Bishop
Bishop offers an example of what we might call “observational confession.” That is, she gives a scene and asks us to ponder its significance, but her narrator is merely a point of view, not a participant in the poem. Reading her two selections, ask what point is Bishop trying to make by asking us to picture the fish and the moose: “The Fish” is one of those poems that seems simple from the outside but actually contains great depths of meaning. In the text, Bishop engages with themes of nature, humility, and choices. It is her choice, after catching this extremely noteworthy fish to release it back into the water. She had a moment of connection with the creature that spread out into a broader connection with the natural world. She was suddenly more a part of things than she had been in the past, her state of mind was altered. Additionally, it is clear that she was moved by the history of this particular creature, the number of times it had been caught, and how each time it escaped death. This speaks to another less obvious theme–death. As for “The Moose”:
Bishop claimed that it took her around 20 years to finish “The Moose.” Even for a poet as methodical as she was, that seems like an unusually long time to hold on to an idea, to sketch out the first impressions of an actual event and return to them until she was satisfied that her poem was complete. Taking up a theme she explored in poems such as “The Fish” and “The Armadillo,” “The Moose” meditates on the transcendent power of nature, and its often startling intrusion into our modern lives. The poem also maps the physical and psychological terrain of Nova Scotia, where the young Bishop was taken to live with her maternal grandparents after being effectively orphaned by her father’s early death and her mother’s institutionalization for mental illness. Both poems, we should note, are written in free verse, which, as we previously noted, is different from blank verse: free verse is unrhymed poetry whose lines aren’t set within any specific meter (defined by the number of syllables and stress pattern). Allen Ginsberg and the Beat Generation Ginsberg’s Howl offers a good if profane example of the way poets take their personal lives as their subject matter, often self-mythologizing their private histories. The poem uses autobiography to create a generational credo: Ginsberg is telling the story of the infamous Beat Generation of the 1950s—the young men like him and Jack Kerouac who rebelled against the conformity by indulging in drugs, sex, and bebop music.
(Left: Ginsberg in the fifties. L: Members of the Beat Generation: including l to r, Ginsberg, Jack Kerouac (who’s looking
pretty hammered), unknown, and Neal Cassady) You can imagine how shocking this poem was when first performed in 1956 at San Francisco’s Gallery Six— the eventual print version was deemed obscene and led to a landmark trial that eventually cleared it of that charge. The point is to shock by its graphic references to sexual activity—both homosexual and heterosexual. But equally important is Ginsberg’s criticism of the materialism of the 1950s, especially with the repeated references to the Hebrew “devil” Moloch, whom Ginsberg viewed as an embodiment of the soullessness of consumerism that was devouring America. Also, note that a common motif of 1950s literature is electroshock therapy, a treatment for depression at the time that—believe it or not—involved shooting jolts of electricity into the brain. The idea was to cure depression by wiping out short-term memory, which was considered the storehouse of neuroses. For Ginsberg (and Plath in her novel The Bell Jar or Ken Kesey in his One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest), electroshock therapy and mental institutions more broadly are houses of socialization—they are the places where people who can’t conform are sent and made to fit in.
The publication of Howl (1956) sounded a cry of rage, and in turn other cries of rage—or downright dismissals—were raised against it. Ginsberg announces himself as speaking for his compatriots, naming their collective condition of disaffection: “I saw the best minds of my generation, starving, hysterical, naked” (the most famous line of the poem). “Howl” explicitly identifies itself as a lamentation for those most promising and most excluded from the “American ideal.” In a long descriptive catalogue Ginsberg makes clear his contention that the finest have been driven, by what a critic called “the overwhelming pressures of conformity, competition, prestige and respectability,” toward madness, dissipation, and the outraged enactments of the denied. Not only is he exiled from the tranquilized suburbs by virtue of ethnicity, sexuality, political philosophy, and intellectual energy; he also cannot locate in the codified possibilities of American society a tenable way of living. Thus the speaker inhabits a sort of psychic inferno, a territory of the lost which underlies the flawless, bourgeois vision of American life.
“‘Howl’ lies,” as Kenneth Rexroth observed, “in one of the oldest traditions, that of Hosea or the other, angry Minor Prophets of the Bible.” The fault for the condition of Ginsberg’s generation—and his own violated psychic state—thus lies with “Moloch,” the embodiment of the State as evil, the demon of this world. But even in the “belly of Moloch” lies the possibility of transcendence. This tension between existential despair at the political and social conditions of the world and the prophetic optimism of vision would continue to inform all of Ginsberg’s work. Transcendence is always possible, even in the shattered universe of Howl—through visionary experience, sex, or chemical transformation of the psyche through drugs: “flower of industry, / tough spiky ugly flower, / flower nonetheless, / with the form of the great yellow / Rose in your brain.”
The form of Howl is Blakean (based on William Blakes Songs of Innocence and Songs of Experience from the early 19th century) and Biblical; Ginsberg relied on parallel constructions and long incantatory lines which, like those of Walt Whitman before him, take the form of the King James Bible as their model. Ginsberg fuses his Whitmanic apostrophes and catalogues with verbal play influenced by the prose of Jack Kerouac. In effect, he’s creating a mashup of the Bible and spoken jazz!
Due in part to the poem’s “obscenity trial” and resultant publicity, Howl became an important indicator of the changing climate in American poetry, an alarm sounding the decline of academic verse (like The Waste Land). If the poem was not taken seriously by many poets and critics—due to its bombastic, sprawling rhetoric, its spontaneous and chantlike form—then it at least offered a signal of a realm of possibility for powerful poetry to be constructed from “unmentionable” realms of experience. The poem would also, by virtue of its visibility and its radical loosening or re-visioning of formal design (which, Ginsberg said, sprang “from a source deeper than the mind, that is to say, it came from the breathing and the belly and the lungs”), serve as a rallying cry and focus to other poets in the loose nexus of artists who came to be known as the “Beats.” Though the coherence of the group was at least in part created by the media (certainly a new phenomenon in American poetry: poets as somewhat scandalous news, interesting as much for their other activities as for their poetry), the group took the label to heart. “The word ‘beat’ originally meant poor, down and out, deadbeat . . . sleeping in subways. Now that the word is belonging officially it is being made to stretch to include people who . . . have a certain new gesture, or attitude, which I can only describe as a new more.”
More seems an accurate term: the program of the Beats, like that of the Surrealists before them, was less a set of aesthetic principles than an embodiment of a philosophy of experience, a program of action. From existentialist philosophy, the Beats appropriated the replacement of given social, ethical, and religious codes with an emphasis on individual experience—or, to borrow the name of a magazine of the day, “the unspeakable visions of the individual.” They yoked the existentialist sense of despair with a will to transcendence (thus their idolization of Whitman and Rimbaud and their linkage of the term “beat”
with “beatitude”) that found its vehicles in Oriental religion and meditational practices, in sheer verbal exuberance and in the visionary experiences of drugs, and in the rhythms and improvisations of progressive jazz.
“A Supermarket in California,” meanwhile, offers a good example of why the Beats revolted against 1950s culture. Think about what a brand-new supermarket would be like in the mid-1950s, and how differently it symbolizes Ginsberg’s America than Whitman’s: more impersonal, more commercial, more corporate. Ask too what the classical allusions suggest in the poem’s final lines, the reference to Charon (the ferryman who carries the souls of the newly dead across the Styx [the river, not the 1970s’ band]) and the Lethe (another river in Hades that caused people who drank from it to forget): they seem to suggest that shopping in modern America puts us in a kind of limbo, a spiritual death in life. The poem rejects American consumerism—a way of life that places great importance on buying and owning things, on being a customer with money to spend and endless options to choose from. Feeling that he doesn’t fit in with a world of shiny shopping aisles and identical houses and cars, the speaker (generally treated as Ginsberg himself) finds kinship in the figure of Walt Whitman—one of the founding figures in American poetry. Through his vision of Whitman, the speaker senses an alternative America. And though the poem never defines this alternative vision for the country outright, it mourns the “lost America of love”—what the nation once was, or could have become. The poem takes place in the heart of consumerist culture—in the belly of the beast. California is closely associated with an idea of the American Dream that equates money and happiness: the home of Hollywood and the rich and famous, a place where lives are ostensibly filled with sunshine and joy. The supermarket brimming with food reflects this sense of carefree abundance.
And yet, the poem also implies that none of this is real, that the supposed freedom offered by this way of life is as fake as the movies pumped out by Hollywood. The fruit is “neon,” so bright as to seem garish, and the speaker shops for “images” rather than actual nourishment to satiate his “hungry fatigue.”
Nevertheless, the poem establishes the extent to which this way of life has a hold on people. “Whole families” parade down the supermarket aisles as if in some kind of trance —”wives” are “in” the “avocados,” and there are “babies in the tomatoes.” In other words, they are totally immersed in the consumerist way of life that the supermarket represents. This way of life robs them of their individual humanity, the poem implies, reducing people to the things they buy and instilling a sense of conformity but making people think they all want the same things. This idea is later echoed by the image of “blue automobiles in driveways,” which implies a cookie-cutter vision of success. People think they’ll be happy if only they can buy this car or have that house, but the speaker doesn’t buy in, and that’s why he conjures up a vision of Walt Whitman. For poets of Ginsberg’s generation, Whitman stood for a kind of celebration of the common man, the nobility of labor, and people’s individuality. Whitman’s poetry reflects an idealistic romanticism, which he viewed as inseparable from America itself. Whitman becomes something like the speaker’s guide, which the speaker at one point explicitly asking Whitman which “way” to go.
Ginsberg in the 1980s with his hero, Walt Whitman, in the background.
Robert Lowell Lowell is an example of what we might call “experiential confession,” which means the world around him reflects the inner turmoil of his depression and despair. (Lowell suffered from manic depression, in fact, a major influence on his poetry). Notice how the lover’s lane in “The Skunk Hour” stirs up only feelings of loneliness, not passion. And what does Lowell learn from the proud skunk at the poem’s end? “For the Union Dead” does something a little different: it captures the Northern sense of sacrifice that has been lost amid encroaching modernity, a reflection of American culture’s alienation from its historic past. For Lowell, the idea that this statue is lost amid the traffic of Boston says that we have forgotten the sacrifices it took to make America.
“Skunk Hour” expresses the turmoil of Lowell’s personal life at this crucial point. It is a poem framed by matriarchal images, and built around an analogy between art and voyeurism. It also dramatizes an inner debate between the demands of formality and discretion on the one hand and, on the other, the longing for an open and candid poetry that would capture the life of a privileged and educated American man in the middle of the 20th century. The structure of the poem, we now realize, is highly symmetrical: two stanzas devoted to a matriarchal figure; two to a society in crisis; two to an individual—the poet—in crisis; and two to a society led by an alternative matriarchal figure who represents a potential resolution to Lowell’s dilemma. The hermit heiress, who would have had him forgo artistic candor and continue to write “prehistoric monsters” all his life, finds her nemesis in the mother skunk. As for “Union Dead”: “For the Union Dead” follows the mind of a person as he interacts with the landscape of modern Boston. What he sees dismays him, especially insofar as he compares it with an older Boston. For it is an historical poem, one which tries to show a relation between the past and the present. It tries to show this relation in many ways, but most obviously in its superimposition of scenes from an earlier Boston upon parallel scenes from what the Chamber of Commerce has been calling “the New Boston.” Some examples. The old South Boston Aquarium, once the centerpiece of a park overlooking the harbor, has been gutted by vandals. The Boston Common, a Colonial grazing pasture, is being exhumed to provide parking places. Thomas Bulfinch’s golden-domed State House must be propped by scaffolding so that “the garage’s earthquake” will not topple it. The Memorial to Colonel Robert Gould Shaw, the young Boston Civil War hero, who, along with most of his Negro regiment, was killed in the assault on Fort Wagner in 1863 is similarly buttressed. These violations of the past are complemented in the poem by today’s monuments—“giant-finned cars” and advertisements exploiting the bombing of Hiroshima. The landscape of the poem then is not so much the city’s as it is the poet’s. It is not photographed, but felt. It is not history, but autobiography. But the poem is not the work of a modern laudator temporis acti (a “praiser of times past”). Though obviously sympathetic to the past, the speaker belongs to the present. His past is an imagined past, the Union soldier is “abstract.” The present, however, is real, and the speaker, as much as anyone else, is part of it. He creates the imagined virtues of the historical past, but shares the downward tendency of the present. His nose “crawls like a snail”; he must “often sigh . . . / for the dark, downward and vegetating kingdom / of the fish and reptile,” and must “press” and “crouch” like a beast.
The memorial in Boston that “For the Union Dead” celebrates.
Sylvia Plath
Plath in the final year of her life, the apartment complex in London where she committed suicide, and her gravesite in Heptonstall, England. Plath is perhaps the most famous example of a confessional poet, because of the legend surrounding her suicide on 11 February 1963, at the age of thirty. She was not famous in her lifetime—she came to prominence in the early 1970s when her novel, The Bell Jar, was posthumously published in the United States. (It had been published in the United Kingdom just a month before her death under the pseudonym Victoria Lucas). A major part of her fame also rests in the final poems she wrote in the fall of 1962, which were published under the title Ariel in 1965. Here is an excerpt from the fiftieth anniversary commemoration of her death back in 2013: It is fifty years since Sylvia Plath killed herself, in her flat in London, near Primrose Hill, in a house where William Butler Yeats once lived. She was thirty. Her two children, Frieda, age three, and Nicholas, barely one, slept in the next room. (Her son committed suicide in 2009, sadly). Plath jammed some rags and towels under the door, then turned the gas on in the oven and laid her head inside. She was separated from her husband, the poet Ted Hughes, who had betrayed her; raising the children was left almost
entirely to her. She wrote several dozen of the most extraordinary poems in the English language within the span of a few months, before the children awoke at dawn.
The care with which she prepared her own death scene, leaving out mugs of milk for the children, is the work of a person whose talent for hospitality never left her, though it took a macabre turn. This care extended to her book. On her writing table, she left a black spring binder that contained a manuscript she had completed some months earlier, “Ariel and Other Poems” (she had scratched out alternate possibilities: “Daddy and Other Poems,” “A Birthday Present,” and “The Rabbit Catcher”) and, beside it, a sheaf of nineteen additional poems that she had written since. Hughes published a book he called “Ariel,” derived from the manuscript, with the newer poems added, in 1965. Robert Lowell, who contributed a forward, is said to have exclaimed, when he opened and read the manuscript, “Something amazing has happened.”
Here is a good statement of why these poems are so unsettling: In her late work Plath often appropriates imagery from a startling and, at times, troubling range of sources in order to heighten the emotional intensity and expressionist violence of her poetry. She implicitly justified the various references that these poems make to the Holocaust in a letter of 21 October, again to her mother: ‘What the person out of Belsen – physical or psychological – wants is nobody saying the birdies still go tweet-tweet, but the full knowledge that somebody else has been there and knows the worst, just what it is like’. When, in the second and third stanzas of ‘Lady Lazarus’, she claims her skin is ‘Bright as a Nazi lampshade’, that her face is a ‘fine / Jew linen’, she is provocatively asserting her right to compare her ‘psychological’ Belsen with the experiences of those condemned to real Nazi concentration camps. This has outraged some critics, while others commend her development of a poetic idiom capable of responding to the horrors of 20th-century history. What makes her references to such atrocities so disturbing is their incorporation into a poetic performance that also deploys the language of advertising, mass spectacle and pornographic self-display – the ‘big strip tease’ that the ‘peanut-crunching crowd / Shoves in to see’. The poem figures the crowd’s fascinated eyeing of her body parts and fingering of her blood as part of a debased, commercialized martyrdom. The reader, in a further irony, becomes uncomfortably aware that she or he is also one of the ‘peanut-crunching crowd’ lured into marvelling at the terrible wounds and scars that the poem tauntingly chooses to parade; and that while the narrator apparently derides and parodies the ‘theatrical’ exploitation of suffering, ‘Lady Lazarus’ makes use of the very techniques that it mocks and elicits precisely the curiosity that it condemns, in order to deliver its ‘charged’ narrative of victimization and revenge. To put it another way, both “Lady Lazarus” and “Daddy” explore what we might call “the morality of metaphor,” the propriety of using certain images to dramatize one’s personal experience. In particular, the “Nazi” imagery in them sits right on the border of self-assertion and self-delusion: it invites readers to think the poet is self-involved and self-absorbed. But the point is to say that we always experience the personal before we experience the historical or cultural: we can only know our own feelings. Many of these poems are rightly celebrated because they are acts of women’s self-assertion: they give voice to the rage many women feel at male dominance. You might think of these poems as what the narrator of “The Yellow Wallpaper” might have said had she not been forbidden to write by her husband: in a sense, Plath’s poems rip the wallpaper off society’s insistence that women should be unemotional and inexpressive. “Daddy” is particularly important for the way Plath tries to exorcise the memory of her father, Otto Plath, who died when she was barely eight. It’s a great poem for thinking of the relationship between fathers and daughters: “Daddy” deals with the deification and mythologizing of authority figures. It does this through the lens of the speaker’s individual relationship with her father as well as through the historic lens of the Holocaust.
In order to see her father clearly, for who he really was, the speaker first needs to puncture her godlike image of him. Likewise, Nazi authority is revealed to be vulnerable—dependent on people believing in the propaganda that mythologized it. The poem demonstrates that people are subject to authoritarian power when they believe themselves to be powerless and the authority to be absolute—and that they change this dynamic by puncturing the illusions that sustain it. Having lost her father to illness at a young age, the speaker develops an obsession with him that follows her into adulthood. The speaker’s father “died before [she] had time—” to see him for who he really was, and because of this the speaker has been trapped inside a childlike perception of her father as godlike. Over the years, her memory of him seems only to have grown in its oppressive power, and she realizes she must destroy her godlike image of him in order to be free. She thus confesses to her father that she has had to “kill” him—or rather, the idea of him which has held her in thrall. To do so is difficult, however. The speaker struggles to see her father clearly, saying “I never could tell where you / Put your foot, your root.” This image illustrates both her father’s vague identity in the speaker’s mind and the speaker’s sense of his omnipresence, his godlike ability to be everywhere at once—”I thought every German was you.” This difficulty in pinpointing the man while also being surrounded by the myth of him speaks to her growing understanding that to see him clearly would rob him of his power over her. The speaker goes on to compare her relationship to her father to the relationship between Jewish people and Nazis during the Holocaust. This comparison not only illuminates her own struggle but illustrates the ways in which power and authority are vulnerable to people’s belief in them. The speaker describes being scared of her father’s “Luftwaffe” and “gobbledygoo”—on the one hand, the very real physical force represented by the Luftwaffe (the German air force), and on the other hand, the mythology broadcast by their propaganda system, a mythology that—when looked at closely—was nothing but gobbledygoo (nonsense). She also fears her father’s “Aryan eye, bright blue.” The singular use of “eye” refers more to a watchful, authoritarian presence than to a literal pair of eyes. Likewise, during WWII people were paralyzed by the thought of attracting Nazi attention, behaving every moment as if they were being watched, thus reinforcing Nazi control. Recognizing the fallacy of her father’s power—”Not God,” an actual deity, “but a swastika,” an empty symbol—the speaker invokes the symbol of the Nazi regime, underlining the fact that in order for a symbol of authority to work, it has to be “So black no sky could squeak through.” In other words, it must block out all light, hope, and truth. The moment one begins to see through the illusion, to the truth of what’s behind it, the symbol loses its power. Thus only when the speaker is finally able to see her father for who he is, to puncture her illusion of him as a godlike authority, does she free herself of his power. The speaker describes a picture she has of her father in which he stands at a blackboard, apparently teaching a class, a picture which points to his supposed authority. The speaker, however, finally recognizes that he is “No less a devil” just because the image conceals his true nature. The poem ends with the speaker asserting her freedom—”Daddy, daddy, you bastard I’m through”—an assertion she can make because she no longer buys into the myth of him. Finally.… Plath’s intensely personal poetry raises questions about the role of suffering in art, and the voyeurism that draws audiences to “enjoy” or consume other people’s suffering: The speaker sardonically declares that “dying is an art, like everything else,” and repeatedly presents her suffering as a performance for an audience that is eager to watch the show. To put it bluntly: the poem is
deeply critical of society’s twisted fascination with others’ suffering. The speaker describes her death and resurrection as being “theatrical,” and describes how “the peanut- crunching crowd”—you’d probably say “popcorn munching” today—push and shove in order to get a glimpse of Lady Lazarus, wrapped like a mummy in death, being resurrected. “The big strip tease,” the speaker ironically calls this show, suggesting that people view pain and suffering in much the same way they do sexual gratification: it’s all just fodder for their amusement. The speaker even charges audience for access to her: “There is a charge // For the eyeing of my scars” and “For the hearing of my heart” and even larger charges “for a word or a touch / Or a bit of blood / Or a piece of my hair or my clothes.” Not only are people able to watch the speaker suffer, but they are also able to actively participate in her suffering. People’s fascination with others’ pain, and lack of empathy, seemingly know no bounds. At the same time, the speaker herself does seem to find some sense of empowerment from this spectacle, complicating the notion of it as purely exploitative or degrading. The speaker clearly feels oppressed by a society that objectifies her, and, in a way, decides to use that objectification to her advantage by charging for access to her pain. The speaker, in the lines immediately following, addresses her enemies: “So, so Herr Doktor. / So, Herr Enemy. // I am your opus, / I am your valuable.” The use of the word “opus” here implies that the speaker’s “work” or “art” of death and resurrection is not her work, per se, but rather is the artistic work of her enemies. This makes sense: all the speaker wants to do is die. The spectacle is created when she is continually forced to recover, to be resurrected, such that society can then look at and gossip about why she wanted to kill herself. The speaker suggests that the performance is being forced on her, that she is being forced to star in it. Of course, this isn’t a real show—the speaker is using an extended metaphor to relate how much society craves sensationalism and gossip, and to condemn those who use other people’s pain for macabre entertainment. The performance could also be seen as a metaphor that represents the complicated dynamic between the artist and their art. The speaker describes the repetitiveness of the performance as exhausting, telling the reader that it’s easy enough to die by herself, but it’s the “theatrical comeback” to the “same place, the same face, the same brute / Amused shout” that truly “knocks her out.” Although the speaker’s performance is both authentic to her experience, and a way in which she can derive a sense of empowerment from her suffering, she is also wearied by having to repeat her suffering over and over. This could reflect the struggle many artists have when they represent their suffering in their work, and come to believe that, perhaps, the performance of suffering is what makes their work popular or valuable to others, not what they have to say about it. By the way, there are some pretty good movies about at least two these poets you might check out: Howl (2010): the story behind the poem. Here’s the trailer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C4h4ZY8whbg
Sylvia (2003) is a biopic of Plath starring Gwyneth Paltrow. Here’s its trailer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6_-X8t1kvYs
Reaching for the Moon (2013) is a story about Bishop’s love affair with a Brazilian architect. Here’s the trailer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=654X8V2bwA0
Sadly, no Robert Lowell movies yet!