Week 4: Summative Assessment: Innovative Leadership Report
Week 3: Leadership Theories Comparison Chart
LDR/535
2
November 3, 2022
A comparison chart for 3 leadership theories (the focus company is Amazon).
|
Leadership Theories |
||
|
Situational leadership |
Transformational leadership |
Transactional leadership |
|
It is a leadership theory that requires leaders in a company like Amazon to combine both directive and supportive aspects when making decisions in a specific situation. |
It is a leadership theory that requires a leader in a company like Amazon to encourage, inspire, and motivate employees to participate in the transformation process of the organization. |
It is a leadership theory that requires leaders in a company like Amazon to focus on gaining compliance by giving and withholding rewards and benefits. |
|
Situational leadership theory is based on the relation between task behavior, listening, support, and value in a specific company like Amazon. |
Transformational leadership theory is based on how a company like Amazon's leadership inspires its employees to go above and beyond their capabilities. |
Transactional leadership theory is based on control, organization, and short-term planning of a company like Amazon. |
|
Its main argument is that there is no single right way for a company to lead, just like how all Amazon employees are held accountable for their actions each day. |
The main focus is on long-term goals, like how Amazon's main long-term goal is to meet every customer's need and want with a superior experience. |
The main way to motivate followers is believed to be through rewards and punishment. Amazon company motivates employees by offering learning and growth opportunities, as well as a conducive working environment |
|
Its main components are individual and organizational needs. Amazon company main components are employees and customers. |
The four main components are ideal influence, inspiring motivation, mental persuasion, and personal consideration. |
The primary goal of followers is to adhere to leaders’ instructions.
|
|
Leaders applying this theory possess the following traits; a high level of direction, flexibility, encourage participation, delegation, regular coaching, and honesty. |
Characteristics of leaders applying this theory include; openness to new thinking, talent for broadening minds, commitment to active listening, tolerance for intelligent risks, willingness to accept responsibility, trust in team members, and inspire others to participate. |
Characteristics of leaders applying this theory include how they are focused on short-term goals, favor structured policies and procedures, thrive on following rules and doing things correctly, revel in efficiency, are very left-brained, tend to be inflexible, and opposed to change.
|