choose one option and state at least 3 reasons why this candidate should get reward.

Michelle_Michy
L08.docx

Prompt

Traditionally, graduating seniors at Penn State donate to a fund to make a class gift. Past gifts include the Lion Shrine, renovation of historical landmarks, a plaza honoring veterans, and a solar panel array. Within the past decade, gifts have focused more on student services, including a food bank for low income students, an initiative to reduce textbook prices, and funding for more mental health services for students.

Suppose that the next class gift provides for scholarships, including one to be given specifically to a World Campus student. Furthermore, suppose that the recipient is to be selected by a committee of current World Campus students. Your group will be playing the role of that committee.

Read through the candidate descriptions below, and then deliberate with your group about the options for awarding the scholarship. While you should attempt to reach a consensus by the end of the 48 hour period, remember that practicing effective deliberation--the process itself--is more important for this activity than the eventual decision you reach.

Candidate 1

· Name: Candice Donovan

· Age: 37

· Background: From a small town in north-central Pennsylvania. Dropped out of high school at 17 to raise her daughter. Got her GED last year, and wants to go to college now that her daughter has grown up.

· Annual Income: $24,362

· Description: Currently works 60 hours a week at two part-time jobs, but plans to drop down to 50 hours a week to allow time for school. She wants to get an associate’s degree in Human Development and Family Services, in order to become a case manager to help people in her county recovering from opioid addiction.

Candidate 2

· Name: Mike McCall

· Age: 30

· Background: Lives in a suburb of Philadelphia, PA. Has completed an Advanced Certificate in Turfgrass Management, and wants to continue on for a bachelor’s degree in Turfgrass to advance in his field.

· Annual Income: $36,000

· Description: Started out as a golf caddy when he was 16, and has been working at golf courses ever since. Currently is the youngest assistant manager of a golf course in Pennsylvania, and hopes to be the youngest general manager after earning his degree. Was the recipient of a small scholarship from the Philadelphia Association of Golf Course Superintendents, as well as their “Excellence in the Early Career” award.

Candidate 3

· Name: “Sarah” [Real Name Withheld]

· Age: 26

· Background: Lives in a country that discourages education for females. Her name and country are being withheld to protect her identity, but the University confirms that her story is legitimate. Her husband does not know she is taking classes online.

· Annual Income: $0. Her husband is a wealthy business owner, so she sometimes is given spending money and gifts, which she has saved up since he married her at 16. However, this money is intermittent and she doesn’t know whether she’ll have enough to finish a degree without additional assistance.

· Description: She is pursuing a bachelor’s degree in organizational leadership. She likely won’t be allowed to get a job after graduating, but hopes to serve as a role model and to develop

· online support networks for other girls and women in her country interested in seeking education. If her husband finds out, however, she likely would have to stop taking classes.

Candidate 4

· Name: Jamal White

· Age: 32

· Background: Owns and operates a small business in Johnstown, PA.

· Annual Income: $46,000

· Description: Self-taught entrepreneur, who believes he can increase his business significantly with more training. Is pursuing a bachelor’s degree in business with an entrepreneurship focus. Hopes to grow from employing 14 people to employing 40 people once he expands to serving markets outside of the region. The extra jobs would help revitalize the stagnant economy in Johnstown.

Candidate 5

· Name: Rose Gonzalez

· Age: 23

· Background: Taught herself computer programming during high school, and has worked remotely as a part-time programmer while her husband is stationed overseas at the US’s Ramstein Air Force Base in Germany.

· Annual Income: $15,000 ($49,000 when combined with her husband’s salary)

· Description: While she has worked on a variety of programming gigs, she is especially interested in the software side of network security. The daughter of Cuban refugees, she is pursuing a bachelor’s degree in software engineering, with a minor in security and risk analysis, because she wants to help keep people safe online. Resides in Florida when not stationed overseas.