Writing thesis

QRedSox
HowtoDotheDiscussionQuestionsforDrCurnuttFALL2026-1.docx

How to Do the Discussion Questions for Dr Curnutt’s classes

For the past two years, I’ve completely disallowed the use of AI tools like ChatGPT. However, it’s become clear that, much like the calculator, this product is going to change how we approach writing and the making of information. According to one recent survey, nearly 70 percent of employers expect students coming out of college to know how to work AI writing tool. So starting in fall 2024 in my classes I’m incorporating them into how we do our discussion questions. However, I want to be very clear: we can only use AI to create an outline. As we ask our AI to generate ideas for us, we want to be very specific in our query and make sure to use the word outline. Not a draft. Please recognize the difference.

So to start, you should bookmark the website: https://copilot.microsoft.com/# You can log into it with you Troy credentials and it *should * work. If not, you can use https://chatgpt.com/.

You can use any AI writing tool … but you must at the bottom of your file you submit identify which database you used.

Now a few rules about the DQs:

1. You can only write about works on the syllabus. I can’t accept any DQ that’s not about, say, Mark Twain’s “Calavaras County” in Lesson 2 and instead on Autobiography of Huckleberry Finn. I just find it hard to believe that you would read an entire extra work of several hundred pages in addition to all we have to do on the syllabus. So no credit for any DQ that doesn’t address the specific works assigned for that lesson.

2. No secondary sources. I don’t want folks going to websites or fishing around the Net for information. Everything you need to know is in our weekly lessons and in the book (the introduction to each work). If you cite an outside source or provide a link for it, I reserve the right to either deny credit or require you to rewrite to give you any credit. Why? To cut down on the possibilities of plagiarism, very simply.

3. For each discussion question, you will cut and paste your Copilot outline into the textbox after your DQ so other students can read it and comment.

4. Here is what I am specifically looking for in each discussion question:

a. At least 3 if not 5 paragraphs, including an introduction, a body of examples (1-3 paragraphs), and a conclusion. Each paragraph should be 6-7 sentences.

b. Each DQ will open with a thesis statement that states specifically the point you’re going to prove. Our thesis statements will build upon a basic formula: X does Y to accomplish Z. So, for example, In his 1931 short story “Babylon Revisited,” F. Scott Fitzgerald employs the geography of Paris as external symbols to dramatize the moral corruption of the 1920s. That’s the type of thesis we’re gonna work toward.

c. We will be working stylistically toward getting rid of abstract language and passive voice: no There is, There are, It is, or “by.” Instead we’ll be working on action verbs: dramatizes, illustrates, reveals, employs, etc.

d. We will be using verbs that emphasize function instead of presence. That is, instead of calling attention to the fact that devices are in the text, we’ll be focusing on the function of these devices: symbols aren’t just in the text—they’re included in order to accomplish a goal.

e. Each paragraph must include a quote in sentence 5. We’ll be working on the placement of quotations to support your argument: the quote is the proof or corroboration of the point you’re making.

f. We will avoid all use of first and second person: no I, we, us, or you. Why? Because first and second person are no-no’s in professional writing, where the tone is usually objective and impersonal.

g. We’ll be working on taking out all the unnecessary hype-y adjectives and adverbs, which, as we’ll discover, is a lot of what Copilot produces. (According to AI, everything is “brilliant,” “amazing,” “profound,” etc.)

h. Even as we write in an objective and impersonal tone, we’re gonna learn to avoid sounding like automatons. For starters, we’ll never use the phrase “In conclusion”. You’re always gonna sound like a robot using those two words

PLEASE CONSULT THE RUBRIC INCLUDED WITH EACH DQ

Keep in mind the basic goal of these writing assignments: I’m here to improve your writing, and your grade isn’t just for participating: it’s based on the improvement I see in your word choice, grammar, and in your argumentation/analysis skills. I’m gonna give you some basic bits of advice on how to give you a leg up in the job market in terms of communication abilities. And I promise that while you never may write about TS Eliot or Sylvia Plath again, the techniques I offer you are applicable to any type of professional writing you might do.

A few How-To’s:

1. Always access DQs through the weekly module. They will give you the due date.

2. So, first step: Grammar.

I want everyone to write their posts in MSWord and paste them into the entry box in Canvas. This was, first and foremost, if there’s a glitch, you won’t lose your work. But second, you can make use of the MSWord grammar check in the Review column of your file:

The MSWord checker is as basic as it gets, but it’s good for identifying run-on sentences and comma splices, which are the main errors we tend to see in this class.

3. Please don’t upload your final draft as an attachment but, as above, cut and paste it in the dialog box: it’s easier for me to post a reply in the DQs rather than download 40 files. But it’s important to write in MSWord because occasionally you may suffer an Internet blip or a Canvas glitch and lose you work---even though Canvas caches writing in the DQs, it’s better to be safe than sorry. So just write the post in a word file and cut and paste. You will upload your AI draft in the file so I can contrast what AI produces to your final product.

4. Very important: DO NOT PLAGIARIZE. Trust me, I can tell when you’re cutting and pasting something that’s not your words into your post. I also know CourseHero, Shmoop, CliffsNotes, all the resources online on these works. Also, 9 times out of 10 people who plagiarize do so very lazily: often I only need to Google a line or phrase that doesn’t sound like a student in this class would write and lo and behold it’s usually the VERY FIRST link that pops up. So to be very clear: plagiarizing is using any words or ideas that aren’t your own. To avoid even getting near getting into trouble on this, I want you to avoid going to secondary sources. Use the notes to understand the works and the issues we’re discussing. Keep in mind: the use of AI is different from plagiarism. Copilot is only used for generating outlines, not for drafting.

5. Along those line, avoid dictionary definitions---define the terms for yourself. Use a dictionary to understand words, but don’t quote the dictionary.

6. Please remember: the federal government requires for online courses for students to post replies to at least two other student submissions for each DQ and to reply to my comments that I post. The replies need to be substantive: we want to engage the ideas and themes of each work. Doing so will help us study for the exams.

7. After I post comments each Monday and Wednesday, I want you to keep a running list of the issues I direct your attention to: if I say “work on specificity of language,” I want to see you apply the advice I give in your next paragraph: and I’ll be giving you plenty of advice

JUST A REMINDER: No outside sources, and you can only discuss works that are on the syllabus.

These are the basic steps I’d like you to keep in mind so we make these DQs useful. I don’t want you approaching it as just work you have to crank out to get a grade; I want us to look at each post as a self-improvement opportunity for making our writing clearer, more specific and exact, and more convincing (persuasive). I promise: writing is actually easy if you take these steps.

Finally, please note that DQs are graded in groups of five on the following dates: DQs 1-5 (Nov 10), 6-10 (Dec 1), 6-10 (Dec 15). Once those dates past, the DQs are shut down. I just can’t have students trying to crank out 15 posts the night before final grades are due.

Here’s an example of what Copilot produces. I basically fed in the first DQ question into it:

First, I would say if a student simply reproduced this in a DQ, that’s plagiarism. Second, we’re not gonna write in bullet points. The main thing to think here is that copilot will give you ideas or a potential structure, but you need to reorganize and corroborate the info to be accurate. While the first example is correct, the second two are actually characteristics of literary sentimentalism (as Lesson 1 tells us).

Here’s what I get when I feed sentimentalism into the prompt:

These are more correct, but you want to use the terminology in Lesson 1: for example, emotional engagement is made through direct addresses to the reader. Notice Christian love is basically the same characteristic realism came up with.

Another thing to consider: if you cut and paste these, the footnoted sources will pop up, which is a no-no (in your final draft).

Here’s what happens when I ask for a 500 word essay on the two modes in “Life”:

The best way to think of the version that Copilot gives you is it’s information, not a draft. It should corroborate what you get out of the lesson, giving you confidence. But AI right now produces a lot of junk detail to. So some things we are going to avoid:

a) Hype language: AI will always lard on excessive adjectives and adverbs to fill up the 500-word request. Our goal is to learn how to avoid those.

b) Historical context: AI rarely engages with the historical moment of a question, so notice in the opening line it “universalizes” the significance: it’s a story of human hope, blah blah blah. We want to put the story in the context of the 1860s and recognize that the story protests the exploitation of labor at the dawn of American industrialization. This is the kind of specificity that we’re gonna work toward.

c) Subheads: AI will always break an essay up into sections. We’re going to avoid this to work on unifying the overall post with transitions.

d) No quotes: AI won’t cite the text, which is essential to make your analysis persuasive. So keep in mind it’s up to you to include a quote from the text as an example. The quote should come in sentence 5 or 6 of the 7-sentence paragraph.

e) Verbs: One thing we’ll spend a lot of time on is verb choice. Notice the introduction begins “Life” opens… that’s a big no-no too bc “opens” implies we’re summarizing, telling what happens instead of why. Instead, we’ll be using verbs like dramatizes, illustrates, exemplifies, etc. These are action verbs that convey energy and action.

So as we learn how to use AI, we want to recognize it produces ideas and potential information. It’s then up to us to sift through these ideas and sculpt what’s useful into the format I’m requesting.

It’s a journey, so keep in mind our learning will be a process.

image1.png

image2.png

image3.png

image4.png

image5.png

image6.png

image7.png